Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should we let DD2 come to meal?

288 replies

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2023 17:23

DD2 (14) accidentally left the key in the front door when she came in today. OH noticed when he came in the house not long after but she is frequently careless (leaving windows open when she goes out etc). She refused to take responsibility or apologise, reasoning that nobody took the key, nothing bad happened, so it's all fine. We explained that someone could have easily taken the key. He's now saying she can't come out for a meal with us tonight, also with DD1 (19). She's v upset but still refusing to apologise but I don't like going out for a nice meal and leaving her at home miserable. Wwyd?

OP posts:
postapesto · 15/04/2023 19:24

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2023 17:54

I agree that it was an accident but she's being completely defiant and refusing to take responsibility or apologise. As I said before, that is the issue here

Well yeah, she's 14.

Sailingaround · 15/04/2023 19:22

And just to add my absent mindedness is linked to being ND but (as an adult) I don’t think that gives me a pass to put the lives of others in danger. I lived with someone constantly leaving the door unlocked and we lived in a high crime area. She had ADHD but I made very clear that she better take whatever measures she needs to ensure she doesn’t forget or I’d be moving out and things immediately improved.

OPs daughter is a teen so slightly different but in a few years time she will be a young adult and will need to take more responsibility. I wouldn’t have been best pleased as an 18 year old if my student flatshare was burgled because a flatmate forgot to remove her. Whatever diagnosis they have wouldn’t have replaced my possessions or made me feel safe at home again after such an incident.

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 15/04/2023 19:18

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2023 17:54

I agree that it was an accident but she's being completely defiant and refusing to take responsibility or apologise. As I said before, that is the issue here

So does she have to beg?

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 19:18

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 19:13

Or maybe it will make no difference whatsoever, because she's a teenager and teenagers are forgetful and careless.

If you dropped something on the floor by accident, would being punished really make you less likely to do it again?

But that's not the same thing ... The same thing would be if you frequently dropped things, had been asked to be more careful and then went on to drop someone's birthday cake through carelessness and then refused to apologise.

Punishment is not going to stop an accident happening again in future, but it might make the DD more mindful of her decisions and mean an accident is less likely to happen in the first place.

Twisting · 15/04/2023 19:17

Dh does this. Does my head in. Especially when it's our fault he can't find his keys.

I never do it, nor ds, in spite of us being chaotic and forgetful everywhere else.

Being bollocked for being careless as a child resonates though. And I really, really tried not to be.
Your dh is a dick. I still feel the injustice decades later.

Emerald95 · 15/04/2023 19:17

Your DD sounds like me at her age. I am frustratingly clumsy and appear careless but on the inside I was just overwhelmed at my attention deficit. Punishing her won't do anything but make her resent you. HELP her come up with ways to manage these issues. Get a hook for her keys and have a post it on the back of the door to remind her to check for keys and check the windows are closed.

SweetSakura · 15/04/2023 19:17

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 19:14

My friend's kid was 'frequently careless', turns out they had adhd. Don't be so quick to punish people who have different ways of thinking. It's not always their fault. Just be nice.

Exactly. I was frequently clumsy and my ex h used to yell and shout at me when I dropped things.

Turns out I have a rare neurological condition that makes me clumsy when I am stressed, unwell or tired (among other things)

My lovely Dh(even before my diagnosis)just helps me tidy up the mess and gives me a hug.

Funnily enough I drop less living with him than I did with exH.

iaapap · 15/04/2023 19:16

Personally, I’d let it go if she accepts that it is something to be careful of in future. If she can’t accept that, the key should be confiscated.

I wouldn’t stop her coming to the meal though

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 19:16

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 19:13

And the natural consequence for refusing to take responsibility for your actions is to be given the time to consider your actions and why it was wrong. If the rest of the family are going out to dinner then you don't get to join them until you can be responsible enough to take responsibility for your actions.

I would not be "treating" my DD to a meal out if she was being defiant and refusing to accept the consequence of her actions, she would be staying at home until she was ready to discuss it maturely, and if that meant she missed a family meal out in the meantime, well that's her prerogative as she knows what she has to do in order to join us.

There's something really unpleasant about backing someone into a corner and punishing them until they say what you want them to say.

A forced apology is meaningless.

Wombatbum · 15/04/2023 19:15

OTT. I’ve done it before. Imagine if my husband told me I couldn’t go for a meal until I apologised 👀

Sailingaround · 15/04/2023 19:15

I don’t know if she should be going to dinner or not but I wonder if she feels some kind of shame around being so absent-minded and that’s why she is refusing to back down? She’s only 14 but if it persists into adulthood it can become a problem. I’ve lived with the kind of people who are constantly doing things like that, and it does make the house feel less safe. I am naturally absent minded , but I worked really hard not to do things like that so as not to compromise anyone’s safety. Interestingly when I lived with people I managed but since I now live solo i do occasionally forget to lock doors etc. basically when I was in flatshares or living with family my consideration for others managed to keep my carelessness in check.

She’s still young but hopefully she develops that consideration for others very soon. I don’t think the mistake is the main issue but her attitude towards it is. If she can’t acknowledge things it’s more difficult to change.

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 19:14

My friend's kid was 'frequently careless', turns out they had adhd. Don't be so quick to punish people who have different ways of thinking. It's not always their fault. Just be nice.

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 19:13

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 19:09

She made a mistake - since when does that mean she's choosing not to be a part of the family? Hmm

The natural consequence to leaving your key in the door is losing your key for a while and having to wait for your parents to get home to let you in/out, surely?

And the natural consequence for refusing to take responsibility for your actions is to be given the time to consider your actions and why it was wrong. If the rest of the family are going out to dinner then you don't get to join them until you can be responsible enough to take responsibility for your actions.

I would not be "treating" my DD to a meal out if she was being defiant and refusing to accept the consequence of her actions, she would be staying at home until she was ready to discuss it maturely, and if that meant she missed a family meal out in the meantime, well that's her prerogative as she knows what she has to do in order to join us.

Ladysaurus · 15/04/2023 19:13

Omg. If I had to forgo dinner every time I left my key in the door (as an adult) I'd have starved to death.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 19:13

MinervaSaidThar · 15/04/2023 19:04

OP says she is frequently careless, so clearly repeated requests are clearly not working.

Missing out on a meal out may get through.

Or maybe it will make no difference whatsoever, because she's a teenager and teenagers are forgetful and careless.

If you dropped something on the floor by accident, would being punished really make you less likely to do it again?

Lavenderlaze · 15/04/2023 19:11

Personally I prefer consequences to be relevant so her not having a key for a while or something else related to what she's done would be ok.

Stopping her from going out with the family would be a dick move. You're far more likely to get the apology you clearly want if you treat her like part of the family and don't ostracize her.

PollyPeptide · 15/04/2023 19:10

Lovemusic33 · 15/04/2023 18:47

I’m 41 and I still often leave the key in the door, luckily I am a single adult and not living with my parents so there’s no one to punish me 😬

Why would you apologise or be punished? If you get robbed and can't claim any insurance, how does it impact on anyone else?

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 19:09

MinervaSaidThar · 15/04/2023 19:01

Because she seems to be choosing when she wants to be part of the family. If she thinks the rule is everyone goes out for a family meal then it should also be everyone acknowledges they keep the family home safe as far as possible.

Yes, I’ve made plenty of mistakes but in my parents’ home I acknowledged them.

She made a mistake - since when does that mean she's choosing not to be a part of the family? Hmm

The natural consequence to leaving your key in the door is losing your key for a while and having to wait for your parents to get home to let you in/out, surely?

Hesma · 15/04/2023 19:08

She’s 14, it was an accident! Just don’t let her have a key. Banning her from dinner is well OTT

SweetSakura · 15/04/2023 19:08

MinervaSaidThar · 15/04/2023 19:04

OP says she is frequently careless, so clearly repeated requests are clearly not working.

Missing out on a meal out may get through.

Or, she might just be someone who is naturally absent minded and no amount of "punishment" will correct that. All it will do is worsen her relationship with her parents and make her feel crap about herself.

GooglyEyeballs · 15/04/2023 19:08

I don't think her missing the meal is the end of the world, but not sure how effective it might be as a lesson. Im shocked she hasn't shown any remorse, I would find that more infuriating than the mistake of leaving the key in the door. Not sure how I would handle it to be honest. I think confiscating the key until she shows some willingness to accept responsibility or apologize is the route I'd go for. With teenagers though, there's often no right answer.

thequeenoftarts · 15/04/2023 19:07

So she gets to be locked out a few times after school, coming home during the day, having to wait on the door step until someone comes home to allow her inside. I'd make it my business to head out for an hour or two each time and make her wait outside, but without letting her know much in advance, so she cant plan to go to friends etc,
A huge inconvenience, esp if wifi is turned off inside so she has to sit outside bored lol, is there a shed she can sit in? Not for many times 3 - 4 should engage her brain esp if its cold outside. Allow her go for the meal tho, the punishment should fit the crime

SweetSakura · 15/04/2023 19:06

Ihatepainting · 15/04/2023 19:03

This is so Ott. She’s now choosing not to be part of the family. Good god. 🙄

This thread is making me grateful over and over that I had decent, understanding parents.

Interestingly all four of us (their children) remained close to them throughout our teenage years and are still close with them as adults. And we have all done incredibly well educationally and in our professional careers. So I would say their approach works well.

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 19:06

YANBU - I wouldn't say not taking DD for a meal is a punishment, just a consequence of her action.

She isn't being excluded for making a mistake - though having said that I think I have left my key in the door maybe once in the thirty years I've been responsible for a house key so I don't understand how people are doing it regularly or excusing it as a minor issue when it isn't - she is being excluded because she is refusing to take responsibility for her actions.

If my DD did something wrong then of course I would want her to apologise as an acknowledgement that she knew her behaviour/action was not acceptable and to show she was regretful of it happening. If she actively refused to do so, or just shrugged me off then of course I am not going to treat her so if I had a nice meal out booked for some reason then I'd either cancel it or go without DD, as I would not be wanting to give someone a treat who cannot show me the basic decency and courtesy of acknowledging their behaviour was unacceptable. In this case, where there are other people who would be affected if the meal was cancelled outright, I would say that unless her attitude improves she cannot join everyone else, and until she apologises her attitude has not changed.

MinervaSaidThar · 15/04/2023 19:05

Time for dinner (sadly not out). BRB.