Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should we let DD2 come to meal?

288 replies

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2023 17:23

DD2 (14) accidentally left the key in the front door when she came in today. OH noticed when he came in the house not long after but she is frequently careless (leaving windows open when she goes out etc). She refused to take responsibility or apologise, reasoning that nobody took the key, nothing bad happened, so it's all fine. We explained that someone could have easily taken the key. He's now saying she can't come out for a meal with us tonight, also with DD1 (19). She's v upset but still refusing to apologise but I don't like going out for a nice meal and leaving her at home miserable. Wwyd?

OP posts:
Magenta82 · 15/04/2023 20:41

Seems messed up to me.
How is missing a meal connected to forgetting a key?
Would the rest of the family even enjoy the meal without her?
What are you actually trying to achieve?
In what way will this approach achieve it?

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 15/04/2023 20:41

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2023 17:54

I agree that it was an accident but she's being completely defiant and refusing to take responsibility or apologise. As I said before, that is the issue here

I don't think you understand the concept of a mistake or accident. Poor kid.

Witchofearthsea · 15/04/2023 20:40

Of course it was an innocent mistake but the dismissive attitude is not okay.
Yes she should come for the meal but there needs to be a proper discussion about why you are so disappointed in her not taking responsibility, not taking it seriously, and how serious the consequences could have been for the whole family. She may not apologise - teens can stubborn and not want to admit being wrong, but hopefully she will take on board your feelings and respond more maturely to your concerns in the future. I think explain your position clearly then de-escalate, I really wouldn't try to force an apology, but hopefully you will get one next time!

Redandyellowelephant · 15/04/2023 20:33

I'm almost 30 and I left the key in the lock the other day so I think it's a little harsh yes. I gave myself a little telling off and that's it. She's 14 she probably knows it was silly

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 20:31

Melj123 - Consequences, privileges, you use those words alot

SoShallINever · 15/04/2023 20:31

Melj123, my DC were never really punished but they managed to avoid behaving in an "entitled" way. They've grown up to be pretty amazing people that have professional roles in public services and give back to their communities.

When they were young we accepted that they were human and would make mistakes. We accepted that as teenagers we would have small spats as they asserted themselves. We never demanded forced (fake) apologies or imposed ridiculous sanctions esp over a non event.
Your behaviour is bordering on controlling and I think the evening out is ruined anyway.

Inastatus · 15/04/2023 20:28

I hope you decided to let her join you OP.

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 20:27

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 20:10

But you're acting like the DD was badly behaved and left the key in the door on purpose - she didn't - it was a mistake, and I don't believe in punishing children for mistakes.

Mistakes come with natural consequences, they shouldn't come with punishment.

So in this case - she loses her key for a couple of weeks and has to wait until her parents come home to let her in, or the key gets attached to her bag so that she can't leave it in the door anymore.

If I knew I had to apologise to my parents before getting x, y or z - then of course I'd apologise - but I wouldn't mean it and it wouldn't really teach me anything except to just apologise to get what I want, lol.

But the removal of privilege is not because of the mistake, it's for not the behaviour after the mistake was made. Most parents can tell when a child is being sincere so a flippant "Sorry" is not going to cut it.

If my DD left her key in the door, I found it and asked her to be more careful then her automatic response would be words to the effect of "Sorry, I'll be more careful/I'll try and remember" and that would be perfectly acceptable as an acceptance that she has personal responsibility for her actions and I would not apply any other consequence for the "first offence". If this was the 3rd time in two weeks it had happened then the natural consequence would be for me to remove the key for a period of time until I could trust her to be more responsible, or let her keep the key on condition we sit down together and figure out ways to reduce it happening again.

If my DD left her key in the door, I found it and asked her to be more careful and her response was "Whatever" or "it's no big deal, I just forgot, get over it!" then that is not acceptable and I would expect an apology for her attitude. Any consequence in removal of privileges would be in response to her behaviour and attitude after the fact, not for the initial accident of leaving the key in the door.

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 20:26

I guess op is at the meal now, will we ever find out if her dh relented!

IronicElf · 15/04/2023 20:26

I've done this. DH left the door open and was halfway to Germany before he had a bad feeling and had to get the police to go round and shut the door. I left my back door open in London while I went away for a weekend.

Neither of us are neurotypical. Neither of us get too upset (or if he starts snarking me due to his HFA I remind him of the Germany thing and he backs off).

Natural consequences for not accepting her fault would be taking the key off her, while the family accepts forgetfulness is a real thing that everyone has to some extent. Take the child out - that level of excluding from family life is not warranted.

Have you ever tried asking a child to come back to you with what they think the consequence should be? I find my teenagers have mini-epiphanies when I do this. Make them responsible for their own punishments and they have a good think about things.

Kennykenkencat · 15/04/2023 20:25

Trouble with going nuclear and laying down punishments that outweigh the over sight is that if you on this case leave her behind she might find that she enjoys having the house to herself and won’t want to come out again with you all I mean even if she did apologise the meal bid a waste of money as there is so much bad feelings

SweetSakura · 15/04/2023 20:23

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 20:17

Melj123, I'm not sure so many children are so entitled, cut them some slack, they've just come out of a pandemic

Most children i meet are lovely. But maybe that's because they have lovely parents who treat them with empathy (I tend to back away from friends who are controlling parents and I think less of them when I see how they treat their children)

katepilar · 15/04/2023 20:22

What would a forced apology be good for?

I would try working out why is she behaving like that rather then keep punishing her.

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 20:19

I've never 'withheld privileges', from any of my kids, they're all OK so far

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 20:17

Melj123, I'm not sure so many children are so entitled, cut them some slack, they've just come out of a pandemic

Kennykenkencat · 15/04/2023 20:12

My key lives in my front door even when I am out.

Never thought that an insurance company would refuse to pay if there is an unlocked door and someone is at home.

In summer do people really lock their doors when they are out in the garden or inside on a hot day.

Surely people leave their doors open

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 20:10

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 20:02

No wonder so many children are so entitled if it is seen as a bad thing to withhold rewards when someone has done something wrong and refuses to accept any responsibility!

If my DD refuses to apologise for her actions when an apology is warranted then of course I am going to withhold privileges, why is that a bad thing?

Withholding privileges is not the same as punishment - going out for dinner, getting treats, going for days out, being bought new things etc are all privileges that are earned they are not a right and it is not a punishment to stop buying/doing those things until DD apologises or cones to me to have a mature discussion about what happened - even if she doesn't apologise, as long as she takes responsibility then that is enough. I am not going to deprive my DD of things she needs but equally I am not going to reward her behaviour either.

If DD chooses not to apologize for her actions then why can't I choose not to spend money on nice things that aren't essential?

But you're acting like the DD was badly behaved and left the key in the door on purpose - she didn't - it was a mistake, and I don't believe in punishing children for mistakes.

Mistakes come with natural consequences, they shouldn't come with punishment.

So in this case - she loses her key for a couple of weeks and has to wait until her parents come home to let her in, or the key gets attached to her bag so that she can't leave it in the door anymore.

If I knew I had to apologise to my parents before getting x, y or z - then of course I'd apologise - but I wouldn't mean it and it wouldn't really teach me anything except to just apologise to get what I want, lol.

flutterbyebaby · 15/04/2023 20:09

Your daughter will one day walk away from you and never look back if this is the ott way you react to things

IsItThough · 15/04/2023 20:09

She's upset and defiant because the punishment for her mistake is totally disproportionate and unrelated.

It is you who are escalating the situation, not her.

Jagoda · 15/04/2023 20:09

I think that would be incredibly mean.

Is “OH” your DD father?

DahliaRose3 · 15/04/2023 20:09

I’ve got ADHD and used to do this quite frequently. I don’t see the point in apologising for accidents; it’s just shaming IMO.

Perhaps a checklist near the door for when she gets in or a prompt from a parent asking if she has her key; so that it becomes part of her daily routine. She could even set an alarm on her phone to check she took the key out.

AnonymousA1 · 15/04/2023 20:05

is your husband usually this highly strung ?

pollykitty · 15/04/2023 20:03

JFC I do that on a semi regular basis. Yes something bad could happen but I think your reaction is exaggerated. The other week I left the car unlocked and the keys in it because DD was late for a volleyball match. Afters I was convinced I’d dropped my keys but then realized they were probably still in the car due to the rush. No harm done.

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 20:02

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 19:44

What you describe is forcing an apology out of her, though, because you say she won't get any treats or rewards until she apologises!

No wonder so many children are so entitled if it is seen as a bad thing to withhold rewards when someone has done something wrong and refuses to accept any responsibility!

If my DD refuses to apologise for her actions when an apology is warranted then of course I am going to withhold privileges, why is that a bad thing?

Withholding privileges is not the same as punishment - going out for dinner, getting treats, going for days out, being bought new things etc are all privileges that are earned they are not a right and it is not a punishment to stop buying/doing those things until DD apologises or cones to me to have a mature discussion about what happened - even if she doesn't apologise, as long as she takes responsibility then that is enough. I am not going to deprive my DD of things she needs but equally I am not going to reward her behaviour either.

If DD chooses not to apologize for her actions then why can't I choose not to spend money on nice things that aren't essential?

SweetSakura · 15/04/2023 20:00

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 19:53

Exactly.

I dog walk for a family with an 11yo boy - there's a note on the inside of the door saying "X, please remember to lock the door behind you and take the key out when you come in!"

It always makes me smile.

Oh that's lovely Smile