Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should we let DD2 come to meal?

288 replies

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2023 17:23

DD2 (14) accidentally left the key in the front door when she came in today. OH noticed when he came in the house not long after but she is frequently careless (leaving windows open when she goes out etc). She refused to take responsibility or apologise, reasoning that nobody took the key, nothing bad happened, so it's all fine. We explained that someone could have easily taken the key. He's now saying she can't come out for a meal with us tonight, also with DD1 (19). She's v upset but still refusing to apologise but I don't like going out for a nice meal and leaving her at home miserable. Wwyd?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mrsmaggie27 · 17/04/2023 09:02

It was an accident!!! I do it all the time some people are careless no matter how hard they try! The punishment seems very ott! I would t leave her at home!

OkImListening · 17/04/2023 08:24

Please say that you DID let DD go to the meal last night, OP?

Doone21 · 17/04/2023 06:26

I expect your OH overreacted and you are now at a Mexican standoff. I guess I'd try talking to her again saying you understand it was an oversight that turned out harmless but she needs to be able to accept it was her that did it and say sorry. Saying sorry when you don't want to is an important life skill.
If she agrees to prep your OH to accept it with literally no comment except thank you and never mention it again.
Hope it works

Swimminginthelake · 17/04/2023 01:29

What's the point in forcing her to apologise just for the sake of it? It's like some kind of overbearing power battle. And she'll clearly only be saying it because you're trying to make her not because she means it or because she's taking responsibility. Responsibility for what though? Nothing happened. It was an accident. I've done it a few times, especially when younger. Cut her some slack especially if this is the first time. She's 14 not 19. Not taking her out for a meal is actually quite mean and will just build resentment.

karenjkayjay · 17/04/2023 00:47

It’s all seems very over the top for just leaving a key in the door, we all have accidents. I’ve done it myself with my car keys attached as well.

2bazookas · 17/04/2023 00:02

I'd take her key off her and tell her it's because she 's repeatedly shown she's too immature and childish to have that much responsibility.

Crackingoldjob · 16/04/2023 23:30

I just think this has descended into a battle of the wills you know, and when you lock horns and noone is backing down, where do you go next? It just escalates beyond all reason. If someone was demanding an apology off me, you can be absolutely bloody sure they wouldn't get one. Is it a hill to die on? Sometimes taking a step back and trying to de-escalate is the better option, accidents do happen, repeatedly sometimes. I'm forever doing stuff like this and I drive myself mad!

Gcsunnyside23 · 16/04/2023 17:31

I think the point is that she's done this repeatedly and been asked to be more careful, she knows this is a point if worry for her parents and she still acts like it's no big deal. I would find that disrespectful.
Just because some think it's no big deal doesn't mean others don't. I personally do as I worry about the house being locked up etc.
But also the point too is as adults if you make this mistake and it results in needing new locks on the house or house burgled then the financial onus is on you but if it's the daughters fault it's still the parents responsibility and she doesnt understand having a key is a privilege.

I would take her key away and she will quickly learn to pay attention to where her key is

DemelzaandRoss · 16/04/2023 16:40

It’s your DH I would be worried about. Such an overreaction. I do stuff like this frequently & don’t like being called out on it either, makes you feel daft.
Go out on your own meal with DC & leave your miserable DH to his own devices.
Far worse things to get mad about.

pauline987 · 16/04/2023 16:28

Do you or your husband never accidentally leave the key in the door or leave a window open?

This seems like a massive overreaction. People leave windows open and leave keys in doors all the time. I would never expect an apology for it. It's such an easy thing to do

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 16/04/2023 14:50

I don't think the OP is coming back.

Prettybutdumb · 16/04/2023 14:17

Funkyslippers · 15/04/2023 17:27

It's more the refusing to apologise. No need to vote, sorry

What value is there in an apology that was forced out of a person through blackmail? I don’t get people who absolutely insist in receiving an apology. You get one or you don’t, if it’s not voluntary and sincere there’s no point.

annonymousmouseinyourhouse · 16/04/2023 14:14

Take the key off her but take her to dinner.

crossstitchingnana · 16/04/2023 14:03

She probably felt ashamed and then went on the defensive. You can't force an apology, it's not a true one is it if forced?

A calm conversation is best, sharing how she put herself and the house at risk. How would she feel if you all went out and one of you left the house unlocked and she lost her mobile? Would she feel she needed an apology?

MultipleVeganPies · 16/04/2023 13:58

Exactly what @GOW56 and @coffeecupsandwaxmelts said

IMO teens need clear boundaries, and guidance, but there is no need for silly punishments and weird battles of will

so badly handled

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 16/04/2023 13:02

However, the subsequent disrespectful and/or rude behaviour stemming from the initial incident also requires a consequence and in this case it would be loss of the treat of going out for a meal.

But none of that behaviour would have happened if the original incident hadn't been blown out of proportion.

All they needed to say to her was "please remember to take your key out of the door when you come in - if it keeps happening we'll have to take it off you" - there's no need for anyone to apologise or drag it out into something it's not.

GOW56 · 16/04/2023 12:58

However, the subsequent disrespectful and/or rude behaviour stemming from the initial incident also requires a consequence and in this case it would be loss of the treat of going out for a meal.
But didn't that happen because the situation was blown up out of all proportion and turned into a battle if wills? She was probably embarrassed and upset.
I have never understood the need for forced apologies use what is the point? And I've never been a fan of punishments either I don't think they are necessary. You can teach a child to take responsibility for their actions and think through the implications of their behaviour without bringing punishment into the equation.
Fyi my children are now grown up, and they are very kind, thoughtful successful people. And also very good parents.

melj1213 · 16/04/2023 11:10

Yes, and the consequence would be that she can no longer be trusted with a key. There doesn't need to be further consequences (or punishments) on top of that. The loss of the key is enough.

Yes the loss of the key is enough for the initial accident of forgetting the key.

However, the subsequent disrespectful and/or rude behaviour stemming from the initial incident also requires a consequence and in this case it would be loss of the treat of going out for a meal.

I'm not banishing DD to her room without dinner, but if she has been rude or disrespectful to me then I am not going to spend money to take her out for dinner, especially if she has proven to me that she doesn't know how to behave appropriately at the moment. When she can show me she can behave appropriately then I will gladly take her out to dinner on a future occasion.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/04/2023 10:14

HaveSomeIntrospect · 15/04/2023 19:30

She is 14, she will make mistakes. Who is he to say she can’t enjoy a family meal out?
Tell him to f-off

@HaveSomeIntrospect

who is he to say?
well he’s her dad and presumably the one paying for the meal (along with op) so yeah he does have some say lol

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 21:03

It's not the error that is the issue it's the attitude that follows.

But she probably wouldn't have an attitude if she wasn't being forced to apologise for a simple mistake in the first place.

it shows disrespect to me and shows she doesn't take responsibility for her actions. I do not stand for that behaviour in my DD.

But apologising doesn't mean you're taking responsibility - it just means you're saying sorry because you know it will get you out of a sticky situation. So in your DD's case, she knows you would withdraw privileges so she'd apologise to keep her privileges, not necessarily because she was genuinely taking responsibility.

If she is old enough to have a key then she is old enough to take responsibility for it, if she can't or won't take responsibility then there needs to be a consequence for that.

Yes, and the consequence would be that she can no longer be trusted with a key. There doesn't need to be further consequences (or punishments) on top of that. The loss of the key is enough.

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 21:03

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 15/04/2023 20:41

I don't think you understand the concept of a mistake or accident. Poor kid.

You can make a mistake and acknowledge that you have done something wrong and you can have an accident and acknowledge that your actions contributed to the outcome.

It's not unreasonable to expect someone to take responsibility for the actions that lead to the accident/mistake and acknowledge they could have done better.

Kids will make mistakes but they should be taught that part of making a mistake is taking responsibility for it.

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 20:57

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 20:45

If my DD left her key in the door, I found it and asked her to be more careful and her response was "Whatever" or "it's no big deal, I just forgot, get over it!" then that is not acceptable and I would expect an apology for her attitude. Any consequence in removal of privileges would be in response to her behaviour and attitude after the fact, not for the initial accident of leaving the key in the door.

Whereas to me, that's just a huge overreaction. I can't imagine ever withdrawing privileges for such a minor error in judgement which shouldn't necessitate an apology in the first place.

I've left my keys in the door before - DH came home a few hours later and gave them to me - my only response was "Oh, that's where I left them!". Similarly, DH forgot to lock up once - he didn't feel the need to apologise either. Because in both cases, it was just a mistake. It's nothing that needs to be apologised for.

It's not the error that is the issue it's the attitude that follows.

DD losing items is not an issue except from the inconvenience side but if she starts being flippant or rude when I ask her to be more careful, especially if I am then going to have to bear a cost to replace the item or her loss/forgetfulness has a potential consequence for more than just her (eg if she had left the key in the door and it had lead to the house being burgled and our insurance not covering it) then it shows disrespect to me and shows she doesn't take responsibility for her actions. I do not stand for that behaviour in my DD.

As an adult, if I leave my keys somewhere then the consequence that comes from that - having to call out a locksmith, being inconvenienced because I can't get in, potentially being burgled etc - are all on me and I have no choice but to take responsibility for that. I would not expect DD to take on the full responsibility as an adult, but it is not unreasonable to expect age appropriate responsibility from her. If she is old enough to have a key then she is old enough to take responsibility for it, if she can't or won't take responsibility then there needs to be a consequence for that.

Kennykenkencat · 15/04/2023 20:56

Funkyslippers

I agree that it was an accident but she's being completely defiant and refusing to take responsibility or apologise. As I said before, that is the issue here

But did she refuse to apologise before or after the punishment of not taking her for a meal was given out.

That is the issue

melj1213 · 15/04/2023 20:47

Devoutspoken · 15/04/2023 20:31

Melj123 - Consequences, privileges, you use those words alot

Because we are discussing the topic of consequences of actions and I am highlighting the difference between privilege and rights, treats are a privilege that are earned, but can also be removed, based on behaviour. DD has a right to eat dinner, but it is a privilege to go out for dinner ... what language should I be using to differentiate between things that are basic essentials and things that are nice to have but are not necessities?

Why is it a bad thing for children to have consequences? There are consequences to DDs actions, some consequences are positive and others are negative but they are entirely shaped by DDs choices and decisions.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 15/04/2023 20:45

If my DD left her key in the door, I found it and asked her to be more careful and her response was "Whatever" or "it's no big deal, I just forgot, get over it!" then that is not acceptable and I would expect an apology for her attitude. Any consequence in removal of privileges would be in response to her behaviour and attitude after the fact, not for the initial accident of leaving the key in the door.

Whereas to me, that's just a huge overreaction. I can't imagine ever withdrawing privileges for such a minor error in judgement which shouldn't necessitate an apology in the first place.

I've left my keys in the door before - DH came home a few hours later and gave them to me - my only response was "Oh, that's where I left them!". Similarly, DH forgot to lock up once - he didn't feel the need to apologise either. Because in both cases, it was just a mistake. It's nothing that needs to be apologised for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread