Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Damage by tenant

137 replies

Babysister · 15/04/2023 16:30

Am I being unreasonable to feel the way the tenant has left my house is unreasonable?

Two years ago I was offered a job in France through a teacher exchange and decided to rent out my house while I was living there. I was not sure of my future plans so put all my belongings and furniture into storage to let my house unfurnished. My dream was to move elsewhere when I retired but my personal circumstances have changed so I decided to move back to my house when the tenant gave notice.

I arrived in the UK last week to collect the keys to my now empty house having got a new job here. I fully expected to need to decorate after a two year let and clean carpets etc but was hoping that would be all. Maybe I was being unrealistic!

All the carpets are stained, there are lots of picture hooks on the walls as well as damage where the tenant has used poly filler to fill in a large hole but not sanded it down, there are sticky hooks on the fireplace which I cannot get off and the blinds ( new two years ago) are badly damaged in two rooms - will need replacing.

However, the main issue is that they have removed fitted wardrobes in the box room and left a real mess behind - missing skirting board, bare walls with uneven plaster and large holes in walls where screws were. I did find the wardrobe and drawers in pieces in the garage, along with some other rubbish like old carpets, only fit for the tip! The carpets were not from my house!

The property agents are going to come and look at the house on Monday to give their opinion but I thought I would ask here if I would be wrong to hold back some of the £1000 deposit to replace the wardrobes and blinds, as well as repair the worst of the damage caused by holes in the walls. I’m not sure some of the carpet stains can be cleaned but I’ll be replacing them soon so am not bothered too much about them.

My plans were to get my things out of storage in a couple of weeks after the decorators have been in but I think it will take longer than that now so I’ll be staying longer in my hotel room than I thought.

I’ve attached a couple of photos to try to show the damage.

Damage by tenant
Damage by tenant
Damage by tenant
Damage by tenant
Damage by tenant
OP posts:
Thelittleweasel · 15/04/2023 18:14

@Babysister

I would go the whole hog here. Bill for damage and advise deposit holding company to get money from them. If needed summons through County Court for any balance unpaid. [What used to be small claims court]. Above all an honest reference for any one foolish enough to wish to rent to them again!

L3ThirtySeven · 15/04/2023 18:13

lipstickwoman · 15/04/2023 18:04

Spilling things on a carpet (and not cleaning it) and knocking sockets out of the wall is not usual wear and tear in my house.

You are familiar with the concept of a stain? This is a mark that remains no matter how much you clean it. So stains do not mean no cleaning has happened.

Secondly, carpets in rental properties are usually replaced every five years. So, that is why I said the carpet could be fair wear and tear depending on how old the carpet was when the OP leased their home. If they were brand new for the tenant, yes probably damage. But if the carpets were a few years old already, a few new stains are probably going to be fair wear and tear.

xxooxx · 15/04/2023 18:13

Lindy2 · 15/04/2023 16:51

Yes. It comes from their deposit to put right. Normal wear and tear doesn't count so just repainting wouldn't be deductible. The wall damage and replacing the fitted wardrobe should be paid for though. Also desposing of the old carpets that aren't yours.

You have to itemise and price the deductions you want to make.

The tenant then has to agree. Hopefully they will or it triggers a dispute process.

Your agents will advice and the deposit protection scheme has set processes you need to do.

Sometimes agents will try and be lenient because they don't want to risk the dispute process. I'd suggest keep it fair and hold your ground.

£1,000 is hopefully enough to cover it all. You're unlikely to get them to contribute any more than the deposit though so unfortunately any extra costs are usually covered by the landlord.

It's just one of those things that experienced landlords get used to and incorporate into their budgets.

Mumsnet like to call landlords the money grabbing villans but in reality getting good tenants that are careful and respectful of the property is a rare and valuable thing. Most tenants cause more damage than homeowners would to where they live.

That's such a generalisation! I'm a tenant and when my LL (rented their property to move abroad for a few years for work) came back to inspect he said it looked better than when he lived in it.
It's a mentality, not a tenant thing. I want to live in a house that looks like mine. So I keep it looking nice, as I would if I owned it.

Some people have no alternative but to rent, doesn't mean they want to live in a shithole and destroy someone else's property. We really need to change the mindset in this country. Renting is a thing, and it's not going away anytime soon.

Bad renters like yours OP are horrible, and I'm sorry this happened to you. But the trope "shit renters" has to stop before it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 15/04/2023 18:12

We have those blinds, honestly they are shit. You try and clean them and they bend, so you try and bend them back and they sort of go, but not the same. Then next time you dust them, they fold themselves up again. That’s before you’ve tried to pull them up so you can clean the windows and the whole fucking thing falls down.
Whoever invented them needs shooting.
we rent and when we move I know we are going to have to replace them, despite the fact they are shit and uncleanable, and not particularly user friendly. .

Inyournightgarden · 15/04/2023 18:12

They should def loose the deposit, but you should also give them some form of financial compensation for having to live with those hideous blinds

Rewis · 15/04/2023 18:08

Who gets rid of a closet in a rented house? I've always rented and I would never say that's wear and tear. Maybe if the blinds were the only thing or the stains were the only thing etc. But all of it?! Get your money back through the deposit. That's not normal.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 15/04/2023 18:06

Withhold the deposit until you get a quote for the repairs!
Totally disrespectful and unnecessary to damage your property x

lipstickwoman · 15/04/2023 18:04

Spilling things on a carpet (and not cleaning it) and knocking sockets out of the wall is not usual wear and tear in my house.

L3ThirtySeven · 15/04/2023 18:02

lipstickwoman · 15/04/2023 17:58

Are tenants not expected to repair things they damage?

That’s too vague a question. Generally yes, but there is fair wear and tear which is a normal level of damage expected based on length of tenancy, and age of the item/condition it was in when the tenancy started vs it’s expected life span.

LIZS · 15/04/2023 17:59

No definitely inspections as well as I have photos from two previous ones. They asked for 12% initially but I bargained with them as my sister uses them for three houses she rents out! I8

Dod they also do a Non Resident Landlord tax deduction?

lipstickwoman · 15/04/2023 17:58

Are tenants not expected to repair things they damage?

L3ThirtySeven · 15/04/2023 17:58

You have to itemise the damages you are deducting and have quotes to back them up. You can’t say this, that and so I’m keeping all of it without itemising.

lipstickwoman · 15/04/2023 17:58

No way would I accept things hanging out of the wall, stained carpets and damaged blinds as normal wear and tear.

People who appreciate and care for things don't end up with that.

L3ThirtySeven · 15/04/2023 17:57

JustFrustrated · 15/04/2023 17:50

Blinds look fair wear and tear? What? How is snapped slats fair wear and tear? Maybe a bit bent and bashed....
Outlet hanging out the wall? Not in anyway wear and tear. Why were they even removing it?

They’re old, cheap and in a sunny window. The sun damage will have made them brittle. The OP was going to redecorate anyway and TDS will view charging for blinds as old as that as trying to get a redecorate on the back of the tenant.

If you look at the outlet it looks like it was bumped and the plaster board just tore. It’s not been deliberately removed. It looks like it wasn’t installed securely in the first place or perhaps Chinese plasterboard has been used which isn’t the fault of the tenant.

JustFrustrated · 15/04/2023 17:50

L3ThirtySeven · 15/04/2023 17:27

Your agent should be advising you.
However, unless the carpets were new, a few stains could be fair wear and tear. The blinds look fair wear and tear to me. The outlet thingy sagging out the wall, fair wear and tear.

BUT the built in wardrobes they should have put back, so that is damage you can get a quote to put back into your home to take off their deposit.

It’s better to be conservative on what you charge as damage because the deposit service are very much on the side of tenants and any whiff of a landlord charging damages for fair wear and tear and they dismiss and refund the whole deposit to the tenant.

Blinds look fair wear and tear? What? How is snapped slats fair wear and tear? Maybe a bit bent and bashed....
Outlet hanging out the wall? Not in anyway wear and tear. Why were they even removing it?

HappiestSleeping · 15/04/2023 17:48

Presumably , you had their deposit in an approved scheme? If so then you will be fine to retain some. Make sure you have detailed photos from the check in, and check out to be able to compare the two and show the difference, and expect a row. I can't recall the process offhand, but the tenants will likely argue (hence the check in / check out comparison). You'll need the tenancy agreement too.

If you did all this through an agent, then they will help you.

I doubt you'll get additional money, but you may well be able to keep the whole deposit.

Good luck

Moraxella · 15/04/2023 17:46

Def pull up the management company/agent as the havent performed contracted duties too

whynotwhatknot · 15/04/2023 17:45

i think youre main compaint should be with the agency why didn they check it at all and do an inventory on check out

they need to shoulder some of the blame and give you compensation

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/04/2023 17:45

Babysister · 15/04/2023 17:43

Ahh, didn’t think the posters might be hiding something! I’ll remove them tomorrow and look.

Don’t remove them until photos have been taken!

Your agent should have taken photos before you went back in - the tenant could turn around and say “that wasn’t like that when I left”.

You’re going to be claiming quite a chunk of deposit so you need to be super careful and get everything done completely properly to protect yourself

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/04/2023 17:44

You’ve definitely got cause to hold some deposit back.

you’ll have to work out the costs involved and the calculate their share in a way that doesn’t show you seeking betterment.

The carpets you’ll have to work out if they need replaced or professional cleaning.

The blinds you might not win on - those thin metal blinds just don’t last unfortunately.

Your agents don’t seem very on the ball - they should have been in taking photos right away and it doesn’t sound like they took in move in photos?

Babysister · 15/04/2023 17:43

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 15/04/2023 17:33

Have you looked behind the posters?

We privately rent and wouldn’t dream of letting our home get in that state.

Ahh, didn’t think the posters might be hiding something! I’ll remove them tomorrow and look.

OP posts:
EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 17:42

You will be able to successfully (get quotes for replacing/ repairing) hold back money for the big hole that has been badly poly-filed and the ripped out fitted wardrobes and skirting board (but you do need to log all of this, and have 2 to 3 quotes for repair/ replacement).

The carpets and blinds, it depends on how bad they are. Is the wear and tear beyond reasonable use? Can the carpets be made good with a professional clean (in which case you can hold back the cost of that). If not, you should be able to claim for those costs from the deposit. Again, photos, quotes and any evidence you can gather.

You are unlikely to be able to claim for picture hooks in the walls.

Quite frankly, the costs you can claim are likely to exceed the deposit. Which is really frustrating. Have been in the same boat before, and it is utterly disheartening.

Babysister · 15/04/2023 17:42

LIZS · 15/04/2023 17:37

8% is pretty low, might it only be tenant finding and rent rather than full management service.

No definitely inspections as well as I have photos from two previous ones. They asked for 12% initially but I bargained with them as my sister uses them for three houses she rents out! I8

OP posts:
Babysister · 15/04/2023 17:40

L3ThirtySeven · 15/04/2023 17:27

Your agent should be advising you.
However, unless the carpets were new, a few stains could be fair wear and tear. The blinds look fair wear and tear to me. The outlet thingy sagging out the wall, fair wear and tear.

BUT the built in wardrobes they should have put back, so that is damage you can get a quote to put back into your home to take off their deposit.

It’s better to be conservative on what you charge as damage because the deposit service are very much on the side of tenants and any whiff of a landlord charging damages for fair wear and tear and they dismiss and refund the whole deposit to the tenant.

Thanks for your comments about the deposit service being on the side of the tenants. Unfortunately the wardrobes cannot be refitted as they were damaged when being dismantled and the some of the doors are in pieces. They were old and flat packed though so wouldn’t expect as new replacement, just a portion of the cost of buying a new unit. Would it be reasonable to get a quote for repairing the damage to the skirting boards and making the wall good enough to paint as I was thinking of putting a desk in there instead - although the room will need a new carpet as there was none underneath the wardrobe.

I’m struggling to work out why she removed the wardrobes, they were definitely there in Feb 2022 in an inspection photo when there was a bed there as well. The room looks such a mess that I cannot imagine anyone sleeping in there recently!

OP posts:
PinkiOcelot · 15/04/2023 17:40

I would be keeping the whole deposit. How can people think this is ok?!