Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be bothered that DH expects me to pay him back?

432 replies

Tuatara22 · 15/04/2023 15:22

I recently started a new job after being out of work for some time and I haven't yet received my first paycheck. DH has always been funny about money, for lack of a better word. We have completely separate finances (his preference) and he pays some bills and I pay others, and for some bills I transfer my portion to him and he pays it from his account. He has a spreadsheet that calculates the bills and how we split them, and I pay about a third of everything, since he earns 3x what I earn. Personally I find this strict and precise division of finances odd and pointless, but he gets his back up whenever I raise the matter, so I've let it be for the most part. He grew up working class and his parents struggled at times, and I think that's lead to him having some anxiety around money and seems to always feel a bit insecure about finances even though he earns a good salary. Drives an old car, never buys clothes for himself, purchases require long deliberation etc. I grew up financially comfortable and don't have the same anxiety about money. We don't have kids.

He loaned me some money this month (a few hundred) to buy new clothes and shoes for work and other bits and bobs like hair products, and he said he'll keep a tab to track what I owe him and I can pay him back over the course of a few months. That's fine. I don't expect him to buy everything for me like a sugar daddy.

I have very little left in my bank account and today I asked him if he could transfer me some money to buy a few plants for the garden and mentioned I won't have enough left to buy lunches for work so I'll have packed lunches until the end of the month. He sent me £50 and told me he'll add it to the tab.

I didn't think much of this in the moment, but a few hours later I'm sitting here feeling a bit off. I wouldn't expect or ask him to pay me back for lunch money or household/garden items, and I'm sure my father wouldn't make my mum pay him back for little bits either. I feel like he doesn't fully see our marriage as a complete partnership and sees his money as entirely his. Like there is no marital or household money. If I were to raise this it would probably lead to a fight and me being told I'm entitled. Am I?

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 15/04/2023 20:58

Are you the O{'s husband @Zone2NorthLondon?

Zone2NorthLondon · 15/04/2023 20:57

I’ll let the op explain what does or doesn’t work for her,it’s her thread after all

Clymene · 15/04/2023 20:56

In what way is this working for the OP @Zone2NorthLondon? You seem very defensive.

Zone2NorthLondon · 15/04/2023 20:54

DannyZukosSmile · 15/04/2023 20:17

I must admit I could not live like this. Separate finances when you are MARRIED is wrong, shitty, and weird, because one person ALWAYS earns more than the other - usually the man earns more. (Cue a bunch of posters saying they out-earn their DH by 300%. Don't bother posting coz I don't believe you and I don't care, as even if it IS true, you are in a tiny minority.)

I know a few couples who have been together 10+ years, (some over 20 years,) and they have never shared a bank account, and he earns more. He makes sure SHE pays every last penny she 'owes' him, and splits meals out down to the last penny. Not 50% each... nope... If she eats a bit more, she pays for it/pays more!

I even know a couple married for 15 years, where she gets (for example) £12.26 worth of food from Aldi, and says 'HE owes me £6.13 now, and I am bloody getting it.' And she messages him to tell him to send the money to her account.

I would be binning your DH off @Tuatara22 You will never be happy with him He sounds mean and tight fisted. Miserly, 'mean with money' men are always shit in bed too. AND they usually do fuck-all in the house.

Well what a pointless bombastic post. Just because you find seperate finances intolerable doesn’t make it weird,shitty, wrong. It simply means you’re myopic and cannot countenance another way of doing things. If a couple chose separate finances and it works for them, crack on! It really is interesting you have such a visceral response to someone else separate finances.

Mari9999 · 15/04/2023 20:52

@0P
Everyone is speaking from their personal preference. If your husband were to be responding to this thread his response would be in support of his position.

There is no right or wrong way to handle finances. The right way is the way in which the couple agrees to handle the funds. What your father would have done is irrelevant because he was not party to the agreement that you and your husband reached.

There is no universal or absolute way that finances should be handled within a marriage. There ate no absolute or universal percentage shares that flow with a marriage.

There however is a right to discuss renegotiation or the right to leave the marriage if this is a deal breaker for you.

Many people will say that marriage is a partnership, but there are many types of partnerships all of which can and do have varied terms.

How do you normally handle purchases for your home? This can't be the first small but spontaneous purchase that one or the other of you have made.

LadyEloise1 · 15/04/2023 20:26

Isiteveningyet · 15/04/2023 15:40

But you knew this. You still chose to be with him. You wrote He’s always been like this. Separate finances were the deal. Why did you marry him and accept it.

it wouldn’t be for me, but I’d not have married him. You did.

This. 💯
I couldn't bear to be with a mean man

  • I'd much rather be single.
DannyZukosSmile · 15/04/2023 20:17

I must admit I could not live like this. Separate finances when you are MARRIED is wrong, shitty, and weird, because one person ALWAYS earns more than the other - usually the man earns more. (Cue a bunch of posters saying they out-earn their DH by 300%. Don't bother posting coz I don't believe you and I don't care, as even if it IS true, you are in a tiny minority.)

I know a few couples who have been together 10+ years, (some over 20 years,) and they have never shared a bank account, and he earns more. He makes sure SHE pays every last penny she 'owes' him, and splits meals out down to the last penny. Not 50% each... nope... If she eats a bit more, she pays for it/pays more!

I even know a couple married for 15 years, where she gets (for example) £12.26 worth of food from Aldi, and says 'HE owes me £6.13 now, and I am bloody getting it.' And she messages him to tell him to send the money to her account.

I would be binning your DH off @Tuatara22 You will never be happy with him He sounds mean and tight fisted. Miserly, 'mean with money' men are always shit in bed too. AND they usually do fuck-all in the house.

DannyZukosSmile · 15/04/2023 20:16

LTB

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 20:13

SchoolTripDrama · 15/04/2023 18:38

Do you not realise that medical treatment is free here!?!?

The OP has posted that he begrudgingly paid for her emergency dental treatment and hasn't let her forget it.

So medical/dental....is there a big difference?

Mary46 · 15/04/2023 20:04

Jesus op this is awful. Im not sure I could live like that. But ours is joint. I guess if huge debits he might ask whats this payment. He sounds quite secretive about it.

Kennykenkencat · 15/04/2023 20:01

Sorry meant to say dental care is not free

purpledalmation · 15/04/2023 20:01

Fuck that for a game of soldiers. End it before you have kids.

DrPrunesqualler · 15/04/2023 20:01

MasterBeth · 15/04/2023 18:43

I just don’t get separate finances in a marriage. This is the result.

Agree
The whole idea is bizarre
You're married
If you need secrecy, if u need to hide things from each other, if you can’t share why decide to share your life.

Kennykenkencat · 15/04/2023 20:00

SchoolTripDrama · 15/04/2023 18:38

Do you not realise that medical treatment is free here!?!?

He's not a bad person at all. He's not scheming and hiding things from me

After you have just said you don’t know about any of the financial stuff because he keeps it hidden

Also if you are paying 1/3 of the bills and only earning 31% of the money it’s just another 2.3% extra he is getting.

Take home pay is masking other things like how much he is paying into his pension.
You should get the same amount as well.

If you want to be scrupulously fair you don’t even have to have a joint account.
You add up how much you need to pay all the bills each month (annual bills you divide by 12) you allocate an amount for food, petrol, commuting costs, going out together holidays etc Each person gets the same amount to spend and then the rest is divided by 2 and each person can invest/save that amount each month in their own name.

What happens if you have children. Who would pay for the nappies, clothes childcare, baby swim lessons. Or would all that fall to you whilst he goes to work and stacks the cash whilst you are running around trying to be able to make your inflated share of the bills.

BonnieEye · 15/04/2023 19:58

Sorry I misread the plants as costing £50 but see he just sent £50 and they were less.

I agree it’s not how I would do a financial partnership but hopefully he is trying to be a good steward of your savings.

I would be more concerned if he was spending lots of money on himself.

FWIW we did have a “frugal mindset” for the first 10 years or so. The next 8 were not so much (still savings and living in our means). This has put us in a much more stable housing situation, greater equity/lower interest rates. However the difference is it was a joint decision.

Nagado · 15/04/2023 19:55

SchoolTripDrama · 15/04/2023 18:57

As a disabled widowed parent on disability benefits and (obviously) no child maintenance, I read this like 😧😧😧

I had to search the house for coins to buy a single pint of milk today and had to use the remaining £1.80 on my debit card for bread! Having a safety net like yours, is the stuff of dreams to someone like me!

Well done!

It’s more of a safety handkerchief than a safety net; he’s on minimum wage, I’m not on much more and we’re not big spenders. But he budgets down to the last few pence and is incredibly organised with our money, so we can usually have a lunch out if we fancy it, or treat ourselves now and then. Before he came along, I’d been known to borrow a couple of slices of bread from my pensioner mum in the week before payday, so it’s not anything I’ve achieved!

eyerollwiththepunches · 15/04/2023 19:54

I earn 31% of our after tax income. What should the split for the bills be?

Everything should be 100% shared. There shouldn't be split finances for bills. Marriage is not a romantic whim - it's a legal thing which means that everything you and he have is owned equally. If he didn't want this, he shouldn't have married you.

MysteryBelle · 15/04/2023 19:53

Do you want to solve this problem you’ve got, or don’t you? You can solve this in five minutes. Take advice from those of us who have been married for decades and don’t have these problems because we know how to do these things. You ask for help, we’re giving it. Take it and try it out. You might be surprised. Take charge. He’s not fit to be in charge of you.

I truly do not understand these threads, the women act like they can’t walk up to their husbands or boyfriends or partners and look them in the eyeballs when there’s an important issue to resolve. Clearly, he is disrespecting you. I mean, that is so obvious to any thinking person. Is he telling you all these things about your status? How do you know they’re true? Maybe you need to find expertise elsewhere.

Your name should be on the mortgage. You should have access to every single one of his accounts. You should have a shared account. So what if his credit score goes down a few points? That’s not the end of the world. I’ve been handling our finances for almost 30 years, and my own for 12 years before that. We paid off our 30 year mortgage in 9 years thanks to my noggin. You’ve already got the mortgage, that’s the biggest thing you needed the credit for. Now your name needs to be on it asap. You have your own bank account in your name, right? He’s talking a bunch of garbage.

MargotBamborough · 15/04/2023 19:49

Your husband is an addict, OP.

He's not addicted to alcohol or drugs or gambling, he's addicted to seeing his bank balance increase each month. Admittedly that's a healthier thing to be addicted to, but it is still causing and will continue to cause issues for you.

What is his savings target based on? Is it an arbitrary figure or is he saving for something in particular? Because I suspect that if it's the former, once he hits that figure he'll get a different, bigger figure in his head, and if it's the latter, as soon as he's got what he was saving for he'll want to save for the next thing.

Being frugal isn't a bad thing, and indeed in some cases it is necessary because it's the only way to make ends meet. Having a financial safety net is also a good thing, and I can see why that would be important to him if he grew up without financial security.

But he's in danger of throwing away other things that are important - his relationship with you and his enjoyment of life in general - by being so rigid.

I am also living in my husband's home country, having moved here to marry him. But in our case, I am the higher earner and he has actually been unemployed for 8 months, although he has still has an income due to a long period of severance pay which has only just ended. For this reason he hasn't needed me to financially support him so far, and he's just received a job offer. But if he had not got another job before his severance pay ran out, I would obviously have funded him because that's what you do when you're married, isn't it? For better, for worse, for richer, for poorer and all that.

Your setup does sound a bit miserable. If he won't even contemplate fixing the roof I doubt you do anything as frivolous as go on holiday, do you?

That said, if he was paying all the joint bills during your period of unemployment but you have nothing left in your bank account, how has that happened? I get that you only have half as much disposable income as he does once your respective contributions to the family finances are paid, but it sounds like he's building a huge rainy day fund for himself, but you don't have one. When you're employed, what are your spending habits like? Do you spend everything you've got once bills are paid, or do you save some? If you spend it all and don't save, you don't sound very financially compatible.

AlwaysGinPlease · 15/04/2023 19:46

Do you have sex with him?

MysteryBelle · 15/04/2023 19:41

@Tuatara22, ok thanks for clarifying. Well, it is very easy for him to give you the various banks, his account numbers, and online passwords. This mythical paperwork that is in a filing cabinet somewhere…no, he can access this info in minutes and give it all to you right now. I jump on the computer and get on the bank website and access my acct in 15 seconds.

Just try it my way. Go up to him and tell him to show you right now. Why can’t he show you right now? There is no excuse.

Zone2NorthLondon · 15/04/2023 19:38

@Tuatara22 i cannot fathom why you’re together,it seems very sad & incompatible. I’m not sure you like him,you tolerate his idiosyncrasies but they vex you.

shimmeringspice · 15/04/2023 19:38

Massive, massive turn off.

Tuatara22 · 15/04/2023 19:36

MysteryBelle · 15/04/2023 18:53

If he keeps his finances a secret from you, changes banks often so that you don’t even know where he does his banking, reminds you often of emergency dental work he had to pay for you, and bills you for a plant,

Then why do you believe him when he says as soon as he reaches a mystery savings goal, savings held in a mystery account of which you have and will presumably never have any knowledge or access in case of emergencies, he will be freer with you and will think about considering not billing you for a pair of socks?

I do know the name of the banks, it's not a secret, and he likes to tell me the ins and outs of the deal he's getting and the new account bonus or interest rate or whatever it may be. I just don't know how to access the money if he was incapacitated. I'm sure the paperwork is in a filing cabinet somewhere.

That's the thing - I don't think he attitude will suddenly change once he meets his target. I think it's ingrained and he will keep worrying about money no matter what. His mindset is that he's saving as much as possible for our security, but he never seems to feel secure. For example, he's always worried that he's about to lose his job when there is no reason to think that.

OP posts:
DotAndCarryOne2 · 15/04/2023 19:31

ComtesseDeSpair · 15/04/2023 15:30

Bills and essentials, no. Plants for the garden and bought lunches, yes. They’re things you want but shouldn’t be buying if you have no money, so I can see why he’d object to finding them.

Plants in the garden ? So he doesn’t live there ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread