Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU-In-laws make no effort

32 replies

lyfopas · 15/04/2023 14:12

DH and I have been together for 7 years, married for 4 of those.
In that time my relationship with my in-laws has never really improved- we’re civil but they clearly have no interest in me, my work or my interests (which are broadly the same as DH!).

This really became noticeable to me a couple of Christmas’s ago, the first one after lockdown, and after our first kid was born, we went all the way up north to see them (we live in London) and with all the stress of having a 6 month old. I hadn’t really noticed before but that Christmas DH got loads of presents (their tradition is a stocking with several small bits and then one larger present). DS got the same and I got a card attached to DH main present that was addressed to both of us, implying the present was for us both - except it was some gardening tools and I hate gardening.

Anyway, this got me thinking and I realised it has always been like this, every Christmas and at birthdays he’ll get a pretty expensive gift and I’ll get a box of chocolates or sometimes just a card.

My family, on the other hand, DH gets his own separate gift from my mum, and all my siblings up to and sometimes higher in value to whatever they get me.

It’s the same at Easter, every year they will send one fancy Easter egg, always dark chocolate as DH prefers dark when I prefer milk.

I explained to DH that I thought it was odd they treated me as an extension of him, and not like an individual the way my family do for him and especially now DS is here and they spoil him like crazy. It’s not about the monetary value in any way, more I feel they haven’t really accepted me as a daughter in law. (My SIL gets spoilt by them and I have no vision we’ll ever get treated equally but it would be nice to be seen as an equal) DH agrees and has tried talking to his parents about it but nothing has changed or they’ll passive aggressively point out when they have done something; for example this Easter they sent a milk chocolate egg and both MIL and FIL felt it necessary to tell me multiple times “it’s milk chocolate this time”.

Curious to hear how others are treated by their in laws and whether I might be being irrational/unreasonable

OP posts:
ArcticSkewer · 15/04/2023 14:22

Are you one of those where you expect in laws to become your parents? Some families seem to run like that, while for others you are never their actual daughter, just the daughter in law?

Different ways of seeing family.

I can't imagine ever spending anywhere near as much money on any daughter in law as I would my son and grandkids. It isn't the norm in my family so I would just find it weird. Hopefully I'll end up with a dil who doesn't expect it either. I imagine I can feign an interest and flash the cash if required but I would rather not.

So for my family, you would be a bit of an oddbod asking for a milk chocolate easter egg and expensive personalised gifts.

Why is your mum buying your husband a more expensive gift than she gets for you? Does your family prioritise the men?

girlfriend44 · 15/04/2023 14:22

That's the way it is you aren't going to change them.

If you keep on world war 3 will break out is it worth it over bday presents.

Oysterbabe · 15/04/2023 14:21

I like my inlaws but I wouldn't expect them to treat me the same as their own child.

YouveGotAFastCar · 15/04/2023 14:20

It occurred to me two years ago that I always get the exact same gift from MIL - A photo frame from the White Company, and a specific Hotel Chocolate little gift set. There's nothing wrong with it. It's perfectly tame. I don't really use photo frames, so they're all in a pile in the loft, and DH tends to eat the chocolate.

DH started to joke about me not needing another photo frame early last year, whenever MIL asked for gift ideas. Originally she laughed it off, then she took offence, then I got nothing for Christmas 😅 DS got a puzzle with bizarrely sharp corners (he was one), DH got bags full of random stuff, underwear; shoes, books, teabags, etc.

In-laws are bizarre things.

If they're usually good people, I'd try and frame it that they're trying, at least - they sent a milk egg this year, for example, which is an improvement!

Dilemma19 · 15/04/2023 14:18

Yanbu, is SIL dh sister ?
Hopefully you treat them the same, don't put in any extra effort.

ShirleyPhallus · 15/04/2023 14:17

I think it’s just how different families operate isn’t it. I wouldn’t expect anything from my in laws but importantly I don’t want anything from them. I find the endless present giving a bit pointless sometimes and am happy to buy my own stuff.

Being sent an Easter egg as an adult is honestly a bit weird. Being offended that your PIL didn’t buy you an Easter egg as an adult is really weird.

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 14:14

YANBU. But this seems to be how some families are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread