Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU-In-laws make no effort

32 replies

lyfopas · 15/04/2023 14:12

DH and I have been together for 7 years, married for 4 of those.
In that time my relationship with my in-laws has never really improved- we’re civil but they clearly have no interest in me, my work or my interests (which are broadly the same as DH!).

This really became noticeable to me a couple of Christmas’s ago, the first one after lockdown, and after our first kid was born, we went all the way up north to see them (we live in London) and with all the stress of having a 6 month old. I hadn’t really noticed before but that Christmas DH got loads of presents (their tradition is a stocking with several small bits and then one larger present). DS got the same and I got a card attached to DH main present that was addressed to both of us, implying the present was for us both - except it was some gardening tools and I hate gardening.

Anyway, this got me thinking and I realised it has always been like this, every Christmas and at birthdays he’ll get a pretty expensive gift and I’ll get a box of chocolates or sometimes just a card.

My family, on the other hand, DH gets his own separate gift from my mum, and all my siblings up to and sometimes higher in value to whatever they get me.

It’s the same at Easter, every year they will send one fancy Easter egg, always dark chocolate as DH prefers dark when I prefer milk.

I explained to DH that I thought it was odd they treated me as an extension of him, and not like an individual the way my family do for him and especially now DS is here and they spoil him like crazy. It’s not about the monetary value in any way, more I feel they haven’t really accepted me as a daughter in law. (My SIL gets spoilt by them and I have no vision we’ll ever get treated equally but it would be nice to be seen as an equal) DH agrees and has tried talking to his parents about it but nothing has changed or they’ll passive aggressively point out when they have done something; for example this Easter they sent a milk chocolate egg and both MIL and FIL felt it necessary to tell me multiple times “it’s milk chocolate this time”.

Curious to hear how others are treated by their in laws and whether I might be being irrational/unreasonable

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brokendownclotheshorse · 15/04/2023 17:05

They sound annoying but people have such strange family rules about gift giving.

The only people who ever actually buy me presents I like are my DH and my sister. This is because they thankfully take an interest in who I am.

Both my parents and in laws have always bought presents that are things they like. They are both the kind of people who think they have great taste and that everyone likes the same stuff as them! I would rather not get anything.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 15/04/2023 16:51

I barely speak to any of my in laws. I tried to make so much effort, only to get rebuffed so now I don't bother. They may be family, but they come as a package deal with your partner who you chose. You don't choose them.
The only time it pisses me off is like this month, three birthdays in the family, one of my nephews, my DD and then another nephew.
Guess which one had a significant birthday and was not said happy birthday to? And which two were mentioned across social media with bragging photos about wonderful nephew this and wonderful nephew that?
Yep, DD was the one ignored. But she doesn't care anymore, she's used to it and they've already lost her respect.

I would keep contact to a minimum. If they don't make effort, why should you? And it's up to your partner to say something as well.

CheeseLouisePlease · 15/04/2023 16:47

I would PIL would have just bought me a small token I liked rather than what they did buy me.
Tiny sized clothing (size 6), old lady nighties and knickers and clothes, perfume (I’m allergic), chocolate my MIL liked but I didn’t etc. all such a lot of waste. This was all done to make me go on a perpetual diet and dress/be like her. Didn’t work!
Whereas she would ask SIL and get her what she liked so she didn’t offend her!

ArcticSkewer · 15/04/2023 16:27

ElfAndSafetyBored · 15/04/2023 16:15

I luckily married a lovely principled man who dotes on his own children, why would he not leave them money?
If he had more kids then they would be my kids half-siblings. Why would they resent them their share?
I love my husband. If he has kids after I’m gone then I’d want them to be provided for too.

The minute he marries, any previous will is null and void and the spouse automatically inherits. He would need to write another will setting out his intentions. Oftentimes that either doesn't happen, or the new wife inherits under a 'mirror will'. You only have to read a few threads here to see that many times that spouse then does not leave the money to his children.

Him being lovely doesn't make his next wife lovely.

Poor Lynda Bellingham, who seemed a very lovely person, is one example where the new not-lovely spouse disinherited her kids.

Anyway, up to your parents who they leave their money to but I'd be horrified by that clause. It's not a typical clause in a will - for that very reason!

Xjshdvf · 15/04/2023 16:22

My in laws treat me and DH broadly the same whereas my mum gives DH a present for about £30 and me about £80; my DH isn’t really bothered and accepts this.
I think it’s crappy they don’t give you your own present but equally I don’t think they have to treat you the same as your DH as essentially you’re not their child.

ElfAndSafetyBored · 15/04/2023 16:15

I luckily married a lovely principled man who dotes on his own children, why would he not leave them money?
If he had more kids then they would be my kids half-siblings. Why would they resent them their share?
I love my husband. If he has kids after I’m gone then I’d want them to be provided for too.

UnsureSchool32 · 15/04/2023 15:27

If my DDs choose to get married I vouch to treat their wives/husbands as I would treat them. My MIL is not quite like yours but she’ll always spend more on DH. All the in-laws get the same but DH and his siblings get more.

ArcticSkewer · 15/04/2023 15:27

ElfAndSafetyBored · 15/04/2023 15:11

My parents treat my husband and my brother’s wife exactly the same they do me and my brother. We each get the same value gift at birthdays and Christmas. They are also in the will, ie if I died first my husband would get my share.

My in laws are lovely but the same isn’t true there. I benefit massively from having them in my life though and they are generous to a fault (offered to pay our mortgage for a year when I was under threat of redundancy).

I expect if my husband goes first, my children would get his share. I guess it’s up to them but I think my parents are much nicer people.

Why are your parents disinheriting their grandchildren if you die before them? Your husband remarries and that's it ... no money for your kids. I'd be really unhappy about that!

thing47 · 15/04/2023 15:24

Some of my family are a bit like this, but DH has never seemed that bothered. The only aspect of it that annoyed him was that he was just as likely as me to be the one buying cards/presents for them. He said a couple of years ago that he wasn't prepared to keep doing this if they couldn't be bothered to make even a minimum effort. Which seemed fair enough.

NurseCranesRolodex · 15/04/2023 15:18

This is rubbish!
I'm sorry, OP. This could be a gift for you though. I'd just lower and lower the effort and contact you have completely. After a while you will not need to be involved atall. When it comes to PIL being v elderly there will be no expectations on you. DH will have done the visits and you don't need involved. Use it as time to spend any way you choose!

ElfAndSafetyBored · 15/04/2023 15:11

My parents treat my husband and my brother’s wife exactly the same they do me and my brother. We each get the same value gift at birthdays and Christmas. They are also in the will, ie if I died first my husband would get my share.

My in laws are lovely but the same isn’t true there. I benefit massively from having them in my life though and they are generous to a fault (offered to pay our mortgage for a year when I was under threat of redundancy).

I expect if my husband goes first, my children would get his share. I guess it’s up to them but I think my parents are much nicer people.

CastlesinSpain · 15/04/2023 15:08

Do you collect something? It's so much easier to find a personal gift for someone if they are crazy about china pigs, or cacti, Pandora beads, nail varnish....
My late MIL loved badgers - so anything badger themed was well received - mugs, teatowels ( I tried to steer away from ornaments, her shelves were overflowing) 😁

Ktime · 15/04/2023 15:07

SparklyBlackKitten · 15/04/2023 14:49

Yanbu
Id be petty and start treating them the same way.
It would be petty but i also know it wod make me feel better :)

Not petty at all, you reap what you sow.

whynotwhatknot · 15/04/2023 15:01

yanbu-to not get you a sperate present is rude-like you say just an extension of your dh

i do think hes a bit old for stockings

SparklyBlackKitten · 15/04/2023 14:49

Yanbu
Id be petty and start treating them the same way.
It would be petty but i also know it wod make me feel better :)

Whitewolf2 · 15/04/2023 14:45

Im very fortunate, my MIL is always getting me kind little gifts when she sees things and for Christmas / birthdays I get similar level of gift to what they get my husband and SIL. They’re kind and generous people though - I’m sure not all are the same. I think if they’re kind to your child I’d try to ignore it (and leave DH to buy their gifts)!

Probz · 15/04/2023 14:35

My in laws treat me exactly the same as my DH. We get similar gifts, definitely the same value spent. My Mum is the same with my DH.

ArcticSkewer · 15/04/2023 14:32

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 15/04/2023 14:27

I'm lucky with my in laws, but my MIL told me the old saying "a daughter is your daughter for life; your son is only as good as his wife", which is probably why they made a huge effort from the start. They have always treated me like a daughter and my parents have always treated my dh like a son.
It must hurt to be a non person in your in law's eyes, but effectively ignoring you they have given your permission not to care a fig about them either. Perhaps my MIL's saying is relevant still after all.

It's usually 'a son is a son til he gets a wife' ... which has a fair bit of truth to it I think, at least in Western cultures. That's it then, off they go!

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 15/04/2023 14:32

It is a bit crap- suspect its ghe feeling of just being a non person...

I don't think there's anything you can do.. Apart from stopping putting any effort into gift giving.

Ktime · 15/04/2023 14:30

It is odd but all you can do is minimise your exposure to them and step back from doing things for them i.e. if not already, DH sorts their presents/cards and let them facilitate meet ups or seeing their grandchildren directly with DH.

RampantIvy · 15/04/2023 14:27

My late MIL was lovely, and at Christmas she used to spoil me as much as DH and SIL. So I used to do the same for her.

In your shoes I wouldn't bother present buying for them.

Supertayto · 15/04/2023 14:27

Not all in-laws are created equal. YANBU but I don’t think it’ll ever change and trying to address it will probably just cause friction. As long as they treat your kids and DH well I’d just leave it be and not go the extra mile for them.

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 15/04/2023 14:27

I'm lucky with my in laws, but my MIL told me the old saying "a daughter is your daughter for life; your son is only as good as his wife", which is probably why they made a huge effort from the start. They have always treated me like a daughter and my parents have always treated my dh like a son.
It must hurt to be a non person in your in law's eyes, but effectively ignoring you they have given your permission not to care a fig about them either. Perhaps my MIL's saying is relevant still after all.

bussteward · 15/04/2023 14:24

I’d love my in-laws to not give me things! One year, between MIL and SIL across birthday and Christmas I got 11 hand creams. I don’t even use hand cream. It’s just “here’s a gift for the sake of a gift”.

Your family does things one way, his another. The Easter egg is for him – complaining you can’t eat his gift because you don’t like the flavour is really weird, especially when you can just go to the shop and buy an Easter egg yourself.

Saniflo · 15/04/2023 14:23

My MIL doesn't even know when my birthday is. My family get my DH stuff on his birthday and at Xmas which is equal to what I get in terms of money and thought put in to it. I don't care tbh. Just different families do things differently.

Swipe left for the next trending thread