Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think most European countries don't have an Education class system or a class system at all?

297 replies

Stellanotbud · 15/04/2023 10:24

Aibu to think that most European countries especially former communist countries don't have a class system or educational class system like the UK.. Most kids all go to state school & muddle along? Snobbery isn't a prevelant in most European countries & educational standards are high & mostly state run.

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 15/04/2023 18:35

postapesto · 15/04/2023 18:24

Except I did. I went from the poorest section of society to middle class. Through education and hard work.
It wasn't a luxury, it was a huge effort. But I and many many many others did it.
So yet again, you are wrong.

You moving from being being poor to middle class (while good for you) is not really relevant to what we are talking about. It's like you're kind of saying to people "well it's your fault your poor, just work your way out if it". Instead of us addressing the abuse aimed at the most vulnerable in society.

We are talking about class based discrimination. Children cant move themselves from one class to a higher class can they. As adults we can work our way up. But what about the children.

I also moved from poverty to being "middle class" (I hate that term) in Ireland.

I still see people in council estates being abused and sneered at and looked down on. I see children being left out.

My friend works in a primary school in Ireland. She told me that all the popular kids are the wealthy kids. All the unpopular kids are the poor kids.

JazbayGrapes · 15/04/2023 18:33

You wouldn't speak to someone who works a certain job? That is pathetic.

Speak to and socialize are completely different things. Everyone chooses who to hang out with according to their own preference.

Isiteveningyet · 15/04/2023 18:29

Do you admit that it does happen in Ireland now?

I guess you can ask the poster to admit that, when you admit England isn’t cold and cruel where rhe middle classes refuse to speak to the working classes, as many many posters have told you

so I suggest you go first with the admitting

feellikeanalien · 15/04/2023 18:25

I think every country has it's own form of "class" system, whether that is what your family name is, where you went to school or uni or even if you have money or not.

Human nature is such that some people like to think that their situation in life is better than others because it makes them feel that they have something which others do not.

I think it is more easily identified in the UK because of the monarchy and the aristocracy and the fact that there are are still elite public schools which many in government have attended. As other pps have pointed out in communist countries it may be if you are part of the ruling elite.

When I lived in Spain for a couple of years I acquired an extensive knowledge of members of the aristocracy by reading Hola magazine.😁

postapesto · 15/04/2023 18:24

CrotchetyCrocheting · 15/04/2023 18:04

In your reality. Not ours, yours. In mine and other posters it very much is. It's lovely that you can move on but for poorer people unfortunately they don't have that luxury.

Except I did. I went from the poorest section of society to middle class. Through education and hard work.
It wasn't a luxury, it was a huge effort. But I and many many many others did it.
So yet again, you are wrong.

GrumpyPanda · 15/04/2023 18:18

Mumoftwoinprimary · 15/04/2023 14:17

My niece is German. She is 9. A decision has already been made as to which level of secondary school she goes to - from what I can tell the decision was based on her teacher’s opinion rather than anything objective.

That's very misleading. What in your opinion would be an objective measure? One-off testing? That mainly recognizes students who are good test-takers. In any case. What you are talking about is not a decision, it's a recommendation by the main primary school teacher, based on the child's overall record. Parents are free to disregard the recommendation and enroll yheir child in a different school track.

There are two principal objections to the system. One, it's documented that children with an immigrant background often get lower recommendations than warranted by their overall record. Schools are working on addressing this - often it's due to a mixture of subconscious bias and a skepticism over how much students' families will be able to support them in a more academic setting.

Two, the system doesn't cater well to late developers. Again, true, but it's a tradeoff. My mother taught grammar school in Germany, and many many of her students including from non-academic families thrived with the special opportunities especially in the early years, age 10-13, after which you'd get a general slacking off with the onset of puberty. As to late developers, it's important to note that tracking isn't impermeable - especially in the more demanding regional systems, there are plenty of ways to move laterally in a more academic direction at later ages.

NoKnit · 15/04/2023 18:16

JazbayGrapes · 15/04/2023 12:42

The thing that is wrong with the middle class, and you and I both know it, is that they look down on the working class, and won't even talk to people from the working class a lot of the time.

Utter nonsense. If "looking down" means i wouldn't want to work certain jobs myself, and i wouldn't wish it on my kids; or i don't talk to them because we have nothing in common and not much to talk about - then yes. But then, class also means having manners and respect.

Oh what nonsense. I have found the most well mannered and polite people to have not very much and extremely well behaved children. You wouldn't speak to someone who works a certain job? That is pathetic. The middle class you are talking of are probably the ones with kids who run riot.

TodayInahurry · 15/04/2023 18:15

I knew someone who worked for a well know fashion company, she said there was nothing as snobby as wealthy French people!

Mooshamoo · 15/04/2023 18:13

@postapesto when I said that I saw a lot of snobbery bullying and class abuse in Ireland , you said that I was stuck in the 1950s and I was talking rubbish.

Now that two other Irish women have come on here saying that they have witnessed a lot of class abuse and discrimination in Ireland, and their children also have experienced that class based abuse.

Do you admit that it does happen in Ireland now?

whumpthereitis · 15/04/2023 18:13

Stellanotbud · 15/04/2023 17:48

@whumpthereitis but it was open to everyone yes? And there were no fees attached due to the communist era? They wanted their brightest & best in academia the same way they wanted the most talented sportspeople, musicians, ballerinas etc..

No, not at all open to everyone. It was open to those approved of by those in charge. Those approved of being the children of those in power, the children of their friends, and the children of parents who paid enough in the way of bribes.

JimmyDurham · 15/04/2023 18:11

JimmyDurham · 15/04/2023 17:55

There is most certainly a class system in the Czech Republic. I once worked with a woman married to a Czech (not of the upper classes) who had lived there and described it in some detail.

Forgot to add, including being told to her face in a Prague restaurant that when speaking Czech "she had an accent like a peasant".

JazbayGrapes · 15/04/2023 18:08

@whumpthereitis but it was open to everyone yes? And there were no fees attached due to the communist era?

No they were not. They were pretty much reserved for the children of the elites of that time, like senior party members or regime functionaries - those groomed for future leadership. There were no fees, but often huge bribes to be paid.

Mooshamoo · 15/04/2023 18:06

postapesto · 15/04/2023 18:01

It's not a class free utopia. Nobody said it was. The issue was you took your personal ideas and extrapolated it to the whole country, the whole people. It's not true for the whole country, not even close. IT's not true for most people.

It's an observation you made, that is not reflected in our realities. We have moved on. We have new issues to contend with!

I have seen a lot of class based discrimination in Ireland.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 15/04/2023 18:04

postapesto · 15/04/2023 18:01

It's not a class free utopia. Nobody said it was. The issue was you took your personal ideas and extrapolated it to the whole country, the whole people. It's not true for the whole country, not even close. IT's not true for most people.

It's an observation you made, that is not reflected in our realities. We have moved on. We have new issues to contend with!

In your reality. Not ours, yours. In mine and other posters it very much is. It's lovely that you can move on but for poorer people unfortunately they don't have that luxury.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 18:01

CrotchetyCrocheting · 15/04/2023 17:52

I really don't understand why you are being so aggressive and defensive over this? You said 'you are making us look bad', is that it? You are so concerned with appearances that you want people who don't agree that Ireland is a class free utopia to stfu?

It isn't my experience that it is and it isn't my children's experience either. I'm not slagging wealthier people by saying that they stick to their own, it's just an observation.

It's not a class free utopia. Nobody said it was. The issue was you took your personal ideas and extrapolated it to the whole country, the whole people. It's not true for the whole country, not even close. IT's not true for most people.

It's an observation you made, that is not reflected in our realities. We have moved on. We have new issues to contend with!

Fluffymule · 15/04/2023 17:56

Mooshamoo · 15/04/2023 17:43

You are so bizarre.

So you are saying your one personal experience means everybody else's experience in the whole country is wrong?

Wow. So you talk for all five million people in ireland then? Youre crazy.

I can see that your experience - whrte you see children playing together is probably true. I can see that the other Irish woman's experience where she sees rich children play with other rich children is also true.

Why. Because people have different experiences. I can't believe that you would think that everyone would have the EXACT same experience as you. Grow up

Feels a little hypocritical calling other posters;

'bizarre';

or complaining 'you are saying your one personal experience means everybody else's experience in the whole country is wrong';

or stating 'Why. Because people have different experiences. I can't believe that you would think that everyone would have the EXACT same experience as you. Grow up';..

when that was your exact stance coming into this thread insisting that all of England was absolutely a 'cold and cruel' place with 'cold and cruel' people, because that was yours and your family experience.

You extrapolate a 'cold and cruel' experience to insist all English people are like this, but turn around and accuse others of doing the exact same thing with a "Grow up" thrown in for good measure.

Time to take your own advice.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 17:56

I used to live in Italy. The monarchy and aristocracy were abolished in 1949 but there is still definitely a class system. Coming from una buona famiglia is still very much a 'thing'.

The class system is more 'in your face' in Britain, but just about every country has its own version, even the supposedly egalitarian and classless America.

JimmyDurham · 15/04/2023 17:55

There is most certainly a class system in the Czech Republic. I once worked with a woman married to a Czech (not of the upper classes) who had lived there and described it in some detail.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 15/04/2023 17:52

postapesto · 15/04/2023 17:30

It's not just Britain, we've plenty of those in Ireland too. See above!!

I really don't understand why you are being so aggressive and defensive over this? You said 'you are making us look bad', is that it? You are so concerned with appearances that you want people who don't agree that Ireland is a class free utopia to stfu?

It isn't my experience that it is and it isn't my children's experience either. I'm not slagging wealthier people by saying that they stick to their own, it's just an observation.

Stellanotbud · 15/04/2023 17:48

whumpthereitis · 15/04/2023 15:46

Oh, and there were elite universities in the Soviet Union. An education at Lomonosov or Shevchenko university was more highly regarded than an education gained at a regional one.

@whumpthereitis but it was open to everyone yes? And there were no fees attached due to the communist era? They wanted their brightest & best in academia the same way they wanted the most talented sportspeople, musicians, ballerinas etc..

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 15/04/2023 17:47

Stellanotbud · 15/04/2023 17:20

I agree with this wholeheartedly. I've had it with playdates & party invites, Irish parents (dads are as bad as the mams) catagorise kids into "people like us" boxes.. Grew up in rural Ireland, secondary school was the real eyeopener. From the first day of 1st year the solicitors, doctors, accountants, teachers & big business people of the towns children all got placed in a class together 1A1, "lesser kids 1A2 & children from council estates & terraces 1A3.. The 1A1 class did not mix at all, stuck together, got the best teachers & grades. I'm still very resentful over it. 1A3 through no fault of our own were an afterthought,judged as disruptive & got the worst teachers.

@postapesto are you still going to say that I live in 1950's Ireland now, when yet MORE Irish people are coming on here saying the exact same thing as me.

In my experience and in this womans experience, there is extreme snobbery, class division and bullying in Ireland. Rich people in Ireland only mix with other rich people .

Here is yet another Irish woman confirming what I said

TrueScrumptious · 15/04/2023 17:46

A friend of mine grew up in Soviet-era East Germany in a poor single-mother family. But academic prowess siphoned her off age 11 to a specialist boarding school -the education was free for everyone. That was an attempt at a meritocracy, I suppose.

Mooshamoo · 15/04/2023 17:43

postapesto · 15/04/2023 17:19

I can yes. The argument was "rich kids only play with other rich kids" and my refutation is that I'm looking out of the window into my garden which has 6-7 year olds in it from a wide range of backgrounds.
I can tell you it is simply not true because IT IS NOT TRUE.

You are so bizarre.

So you are saying your one personal experience means everybody else's experience in the whole country is wrong?

Wow. So you talk for all five million people in ireland then? Youre crazy.

I can see that your experience - whrte you see children playing together is probably true. I can see that the other Irish woman's experience where she sees rich children play with other rich children is also true.

Why. Because people have different experiences. I can't believe that you would think that everyone would have the EXACT same experience as you. Grow up

whumpthereitis · 15/04/2023 17:30

Minutewaltz · 15/04/2023 17:01

Thank you whump - that was fascinating. Also so many countries having a special phrase or slang for it.

You’re welcome. The Soviet Union was, and is, complex. I never experienced it directly as I was born in Yugoslavia in the dying years of both, so my insight on day to day life there is second hand and comes via my father who did grow up in the Soviet Union (Russian SFSR). I think the best context in which to consider it is by looking at what came before it, rather than by comparing it to Western European countries.

Such a dramatic change happened in such a short time, but how the Soviet Union operated is very much informed by the Tsarist regime it was born from, and was a reaction to. Before the Cheka there was the Okhrana, and exile to Siberia predated the Gulags, for example. In the case of the latter the gulags were of course much, much bigger and far more industrialized, but the Soviets built on what they already knew as a form of punishment.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 17:30

sst1234 · 15/04/2023 17:29

It’s the Little Britain mentality. Small thinking, insular mindedness, resentment of success and talking down those with money.

It's not just Britain, we've plenty of those in Ireland too. See above!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread