Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think co parent should continue punishment

241 replies

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 09:31

I genuinely don't know if iabu or not my just turned 10 year old dd got gobby and swore at me so iv grounded her for a week but she was at her dad's yesterday and he let her out with her mates. Just to add he's an amazing dad and we co parent really well. I'm just curious how others deal with this when co parenting

Yabu: when she's with him its his rules
Yanbu: he should back you and follow through punishments

OP posts:
SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 11:53

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:48

But I would rather take insignificant stuff from her or not allow her to do things she enjoys rather then ignoring her or not allowing her to spend time with me or be in my space. I want her to have the security im always there, she can always talk to me and I will never push her away. That feeling an adult is mad with you and you questioning their love or them leaving is a lot more severe and traumatising then someone taking your ipad for a few days

You don’t need to be mad at her, and she isn’t going to question if you love her because you wouldn’t feed her tantrum.

You are enabling her behaviour and allowing her to behave badly because your past is clouding your judgement, so you are unable to make appropriate decisions.

Enko · 15/04/2023 11:52

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:48

But I would rather take insignificant stuff from her or not allow her to do things she enjoys rather then ignoring her or not allowing her to spend time with me or be in my space. I want her to have the security im always there, she can always talk to me and I will never push her away. That feeling an adult is mad with you and you questioning their love or them leaving is a lot more severe and traumatising then someone taking your ipad for a few days

You can teach her to have security with you without you teaching her its ok to be disrespectful. Allowing her to see her words have consequences if she can't talk politely she doesn't get to spend time with you for a short period (for me it was 15 mins when it started) is showing her that you value yourself. You won't be spoken to impolitely. She makes the choice to speak to you poorly she KNOWS calling you a bitch is not ok so she does it for attention and she got it. You want to teach her to value herself too. So show her you have value and she will learn how to model this. Don't teach her she can get away with bad-talking you and you will hand out punishments that are not going to work long-term as she doesn't care. If she cared she would not have smirked and edged you on for further punishment. THis was all done on her terms. Stop that or you will allow her to grow up not understanding respect for others she is in a close relationship in.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/04/2023 11:52

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:30

I'm still waiting for a response to what are the natural consequences of a child calling their mum a stupid bitch because everyone has gone very quiet

The natural consequence of calling your mum a stupid bitch is that your mum will feel hurt and/or angry. And if you generally have a good relationship with your mum, and she explains how you have actually made her feel, you are likely to feel quite guilty and realise that what you said wasn't very nice.

You might also realise that you are much less likely to have your point of view listened to if you express yourself in that kind of language because your mum makes it clear that nobody is going to engage with an opinion that is expressed in an aggressive or abusive manner, and that you will do better to put across your point across in a different way next time.

If instead your parent grounds you, then your attention is more likely to turn away from the natural consequences of your own actions to your feelings about the punishment itself, which you will probably regard as an injustice. You decide that your parent is unfair/power-crazed or whatever, and all your energy is focused on pushing back against them that rather than reflecting on your own behaviour.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:52

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/04/2023 11:49

Well reading this thread its obvious why there are so many badly behaved entitled children.

OP you were correct to discipline your daughter. I think I would have ignored the smirk and the will see because she would have seen when you carried through the original punishment.

Thankyou yes I agree with you on that, I should of let that bit go. That is something I need to work on

OP posts:
SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 11:51

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/04/2023 11:49

Well reading this thread its obvious why there are so many badly behaved entitled children.

OP you were correct to discipline your daughter. I think I would have ignored the smirk and the will see because she would have seen when you carried through the original punishment.

She hasn’t disciplined her. She attempted (and failed) to punish her, which fed her daughter’s attention seeking bad behaviour.

Her daughter will continue to behave badly because OP is allowing her to.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/04/2023 11:49

Well reading this thread its obvious why there are so many badly behaved entitled children.

OP you were correct to discipline your daughter. I think I would have ignored the smirk and the will see because she would have seen when you carried through the original punishment.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:48

MuffinToSeeHere · 15/04/2023 11:42

But that's the consequence of her actions you probably would still be cross a few hours later and not want to do what she wanted because her words hurt you. How is that logical consequence worse than you swore so for a whole day you can't have the TV or iPad or see your friends etc none of which relates to the actual situation and then extending it to an arbitrary 7 days because she answered back?

But I would rather take insignificant stuff from her or not allow her to do things she enjoys rather then ignoring her or not allowing her to spend time with me or be in my space. I want her to have the security im always there, she can always talk to me and I will never push her away. That feeling an adult is mad with you and you questioning their love or them leaving is a lot more severe and traumatising then someone taking your ipad for a few days

OP posts:
Zonder · 15/04/2023 11:44

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:30

I'm still waiting for a response to what are the natural consequences of a child calling their mum a stupid bitch because everyone has gone very quiet

People answered you but you didn't like it

The natural consequence is that it upsets you and makes you les likely to give in to demands.

What do you want her to learn out of this?

I'd guess:

  1. Not to call you rude names
  2. Not to nag when you have said no

So I would discuss this with her from the point of view of being family and a team. Punishment divides and stops this. This is how we did it with ours. They're never rude to us now, at 16 and 17, and they don't nag.

I would sit down with her and say firstly calling me a stupid bitch is really rude. I don't call you names.
Secondly, you wanted more but I've already given you x and y. Let's look at what you have already spent on. Is there a way you could earn some extra cash? Can we think of a job you could do if you really want more cash than I'm giving you?

Thirdly instead of asking for x and y is there something at home you could have had instead.

I would keep all discussion as calm as possible and listen to her replies. Show her how to treat people with respect and how you want to be treated, and give her life skills.

Enko · 15/04/2023 11:44

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:40

But I don't think its fair to randomly punish for an unset time. I'd feel like I was throwing it in her face if she wanted to play a game and I said I'm not going to because you called me a bad name 7 hrs ago

Do you think it's fair she calls you a bitch? So why is she allowed to be unfair and you are not? That is a conversation to have with her when she is calmer. Not a suggestion you continue to be unfair.

However, as I said in my earlier response to me natural consequence of someone being disrespectful to me is they don't get to spend time with me for a period. This can be done without it damages the relationship. It's about clear boundaries. If you can't speak politely and pleasantly to me right now I am not spending time with you..

MuffinToSeeHere · 15/04/2023 11:42

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:40

But I don't think its fair to randomly punish for an unset time. I'd feel like I was throwing it in her face if she wanted to play a game and I said I'm not going to because you called me a bad name 7 hrs ago

But that's the consequence of her actions you probably would still be cross a few hours later and not want to do what she wanted because her words hurt you. How is that logical consequence worse than you swore so for a whole day you can't have the TV or iPad or see your friends etc none of which relates to the actual situation and then extending it to an arbitrary 7 days because she answered back?

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:42

Velvian · 15/04/2023 11:38

@Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy , I think you need to relate the consequences to the situation.

The consequence is that you are far less amenable to helping your DD work out how she can get the thing she wants (extra cash) than you would have been had she not sworn at you.

I would explain to DD that the next time she wants extra money or whatever, she should ask me if there are any jobs she can do to earn some extra money. I would tell her that now she has done X, I won't be helping her to figure that out today.

Consequences are within the child's control and a result of their actions, punishment is abitary and imposed on them.

She has to do jobs to earn her weekly pocket money when it's gone its gone, she needs to learn to budget so it lasts the week

OP posts:
Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:40

MuffinToSeeHere · 15/04/2023 11:36

A natural consequence would be when she asks you to later play a game, to go to the park, for money etc you say no and when she says why you explain that earlier she made the choice to be disrespectful towards you by using bad language and now you're making a choice to not do what she would like because her choice led to you feeling upset.

You use the opportunity to discuss how the words made you feel and how others won't want to be kind and respectful to her if she chooses to use such words to them.

All grounding her did was give her the attention she wanted and allow her to answer back which then got her more of a reaction.

But I don't think its fair to randomly punish for an unset time. I'd feel like I was throwing it in her face if she wanted to play a game and I said I'm not going to because you called me a bad name 7 hrs ago

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/04/2023 11:39

aSofaNearYou · 15/04/2023 11:26

I wouldn't bother engaging with people trying to tell you your method of discipline is wrong. That's up to you. The question was about carrying it on at a coparents house.

Of course the OP doesn't have to listen or engage if she doesn't want to. But people are genuinely trying to help. She can ignore it if she chooses.

Velvian · 15/04/2023 11:38

@Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy , I think you need to relate the consequences to the situation.

The consequence is that you are far less amenable to helping your DD work out how she can get the thing she wants (extra cash) than you would have been had she not sworn at you.

I would explain to DD that the next time she wants extra money or whatever, she should ask me if there are any jobs she can do to earn some extra money. I would tell her that now she has done X, I won't be helping her to figure that out today.

Consequences are within the child's control and a result of their actions, punishment is abitary and imposed on them.

MuffinToSeeHere · 15/04/2023 11:36

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:30

I'm still waiting for a response to what are the natural consequences of a child calling their mum a stupid bitch because everyone has gone very quiet

A natural consequence would be when she asks you to later play a game, to go to the park, for money etc you say no and when she says why you explain that earlier she made the choice to be disrespectful towards you by using bad language and now you're making a choice to not do what she would like because her choice led to you feeling upset.

You use the opportunity to discuss how the words made you feel and how others won't want to be kind and respectful to her if she chooses to use such words to them.

All grounding her did was give her the attention she wanted and allow her to answer back which then got her more of a reaction.

Enko · 15/04/2023 11:35

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:30

I'm still waiting for a response to what are the natural consequences of a child calling their mum a stupid bitch because everyone has gone very quiet

Takes a bit of time to type a reply :)

SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 11:33

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:21

So what would the natural consequences of this decision be?

“If you cannot talk to me in an appropriate manner than we cannot converse at all.”

And leave it there. Ignore the tantrum.

She’s getting louder and louder because you’re entering into a discussion with her - there isn’t a discussion to be had. You’ve made your point and she needs to accept it, so move on.

You are feeding her behaviour so she will continue to attention seek.

Enko · 15/04/2023 11:33

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:21

So what would the natural consequences of this decision be?

For me
If someone talked to me like dirt like your dd did 1 they would get a sharp " Do not talk to me like that" If they continued I would state I didn't wish to spend time in their company right now. I would remove myself . The natural consequence is if you cant treat others like shit and expect them to accept it.

Going forward if she throws a tantrum, remove yourself. When she is done request she picks up any mess made. repeat as needed by removing yourself if she doesn't continue.

Grounding doesn't work to the extend she felt so convinced she didn't have to do so she was continuously rude to you " we will see about this" So you handed out a punishment you didn't have any control over. Take the control back. If she follows you then outright say " I don't wish to spend time with you right now due to how you behave. we can talk once you have reconsidered your manner of talking to me".

I also would argue her dad did nothing wrong he did back you up in stating she can't speak to her mother like that.

I have 4 children I have had some attempts of back talk a sharp " excuse me" and my kids knows they overstepped. I have not needed to remove myself from them for years.

I would suggest you read up on how to communicate with teenagers and also something about boundaries Its hard when you have a damaged childhood yourself to find the comfortable norm for yourself as a parent.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:30

aSofaNearYou · 15/04/2023 11:26

I wouldn't bother engaging with people trying to tell you your method of discipline is wrong. That's up to you. The question was about carrying it on at a coparents house.

I'm still waiting for a response to what are the natural consequences of a child calling their mum a stupid bitch because everyone has gone very quiet

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 15/04/2023 11:26

I wouldn't bother engaging with people trying to tell you your method of discipline is wrong. That's up to you. The question was about carrying it on at a coparents house.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:21

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:21

So what would the natural consequences of this decision be?

Situation sorry not decision

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/04/2023 11:21

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:03

No it wouldn't be extended however if at the end of the week or at a later date she called me a stupid bitch again a whole new punishment would start until she realises its not worth it and behaving a certain way means you don't get nice things or do the stuff you want to do.

Creating a punishment starts you off on an escalating path - and the inventiveness of a ten year old beginning to have hormonal surges, brain development and physically getting bigger and stronger to push your buttons is almost infinite.

But showing calm, controlled responses that demonstrate behaviour like that doesn't get her what she wants, whilst behaving in the opposite manner is far more likely to succeed.

It sounds as though you've been on the receiving end of the compliance through fear of punishment method - and it didn't work for you practically or emotionally, did it? It can be triggering to find yourself in a similar dynamic as an adult, as it puts you emotionally back in the 'fight/defend/attack/run' position, but as the parent, the win at all costs drive just doesn't work.

It's like war - the only way to win is not to play.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:21

SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 11:19

YABU. Punishment doesn’t teach anything. Grounding or taking away things doesn’t teach anything.

It’s a control and power thing on your part so you can feel as though you’ve done something and then be apparently confused when it doesn’t work and the behaviour continues.

You need to learn the difference between punishment (power and control) and discipline (a teaching moment), and you need to enable natural consequences too.

So what would the natural consequences of this decision be?

OP posts:
SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 11:19

YABU. Punishment doesn’t teach anything. Grounding or taking away things doesn’t teach anything.

It’s a control and power thing on your part so you can feel as though you’ve done something and then be apparently confused when it doesn’t work and the behaviour continues.

You need to learn the difference between punishment (power and control) and discipline (a teaching moment), and you need to enable natural consequences too.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 15/04/2023 11:18

Thankyou for everyone who answered my actual question I appreciate it.

OP posts: