Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

IKEA injured my child

136 replies

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 08:44

A shelving unit fell on my 3yo child at IKEA through no fault of his own, (confirmed by them with CCTV) it hit him in the head and pinned him against a wire basket by his neck. I was with him so it was mere seconds he was pinned. The shelving unit grazed & bruised his cheek, and the wire basket bruised his shoulder blade. He cried at first, then went into shock for a good 6hrs, then slept for a very long time due to the stress I think. He received first aid at the store, in the form of an ice pack. They also gave him cola moose sweets. An accident form was filled in, I asked for a copy, this was denied. I was polite but firm that I was understandably unhappy and wanted a full investigation into why this happened. I was told they would ring me the following day to check on my child’s well-being. They didn’t. Finding no way of contacting the individual store, I started a case with Resolver, said I wasn’t happy, no one had checked on my child’s well-being, etc. I then received a phone call a few days later from the same staff member who did the first aid. He asked after my child, agreed that he had suffered bruises & was clearly in shock. This was also when he told me CCTV had been reviewed & that it confirmed my son had not caused the shelving unit to fall. I asked why it had fallen, his answer “we don’t know” so I asked that they find out and give me an answer because how is it safe to go there for anyone!? It’s been a month & I’ve not heard anything. I’ve escalated the case with Resolver, but if nothing happens, or I just get an apology, should I just leave it? Is duty of care not a basic thing, or AIBU? His injuries were superficial but It could have been so much worse, it was so close to his eye. Witnesses were very distressed at the time. It was a horrible experience. We’ve not been back since.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Eleganz · 15/04/2023 18:03

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 13:49

Well said. I think the previous poster was just trying to derail your thread. It is entirely reasonable to expect shops to put together thier displays in such a way that they do not fall on people.

They have a legal duty of care under section 3 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. It's back and white and that other poster really needs to refresh themselves on what those duties of care are as well as the difference between recording accidents and incidents and reporting them to the HSE.

Crazykatie · 15/04/2023 17:52

This incident happened in a shop, the child was able to pull the shelves over, no lasting injury but could have been a broken arm or head injury.
Clearly the display was not safe, the remedy either prevent access or secure safely, liability is clear. I would walk the manager round the store and point out every unsafe display, whoever is responsible for doing risk assessments is not doing their job.

Mischance · 15/04/2023 15:35

It is not just an accident - IKEA shelf units have warnings about being secured to the wall to prevent them falling over and injuring someone - they should follow their own guidelines.

My DD once tried to climb into a wardrobe with 2 bottom drawers - she opened one of the drawers and climbed in and at the same moment pulled it over on herself - luckily there was a bed nearby which prevented the wardrobe falling completely onto her - she was trapped in the space beneath. We then bracketed the wardrobe to the wall for safety.

This is no small matter - flag it up with them; and maybe also on their social media pages.

TheRealShatParp · 15/04/2023 14:06

IKEA really needs to take this seriously, these kinds of accidents can cost lives. At the very least I would want an apology from the manager and reassurance that it is being investigated and managed accordingly.

DogInATent · 15/04/2023 13:56

No, they do not have a duty to report the incident in an accident book. They are not in breech of any HsE regulations by not doing so.
This is probably confusing to laypeople reading this the way you've phrased it.

  • There is a duty to record it in the accident book.
  • There is not a duty to report the incident to the HSE on a form F2508 under the circumstances described.
There is a duty to provide a copy of the accident book entry to the subject (or the OP in this case as the subject is a child). If Ikea aren't forthcoming the mechanism for getting this is to make a Subject Access Request - by default the entry must include sufficient personally identifying information to meet the SAR requirements if it meets the H&S requirements.

And will everyone else stop saying it should be reported to the HSE. That is wrong. They are not the responsible authority for accidents on retail premises.

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 13:49

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 13:37

I meant duty of care as in keeping people from being injured on their premises, not the first aid. I’d be appalled though if somewhere didn’t offer first aid when a customer had been injured on site through no fault of their own.

Well said. I think the previous poster was just trying to derail your thread. It is entirely reasonable to expect shops to put together thier displays in such a way that they do not fall on people.

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 13:47

SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 13:33

OP said “do they not have a duty of care?”

No, they do not have to administer first aid, which was my original point, and also that any investigations that take place as a result of her feedback do not have to be fed back to her.

Their own internal system will have a process regarding H&S but they have done no wrong in law.

”Medical attention” in this case was the GP. HsE is very clear it needs to be hospital treatment so that point is not relevant.

I think you are being intentionally obtuse. They do have a duty of care in so kuch as ensuring their displays do not fall on top of people.

londonrach · 15/04/2023 13:39

Report to HSE. Let them deal with it.

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 13:37

I meant duty of care as in keeping people from being injured on their premises, not the first aid. I’d be appalled though if somewhere didn’t offer first aid when a customer had been injured on site through no fault of their own.

OP posts:
SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 13:33

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 13:14

So what exactly was the point of your first reply? Do you think furniture falling on small children is perfectly ok? The OP also did seek medical attention for her child.

OP said “do they not have a duty of care?”

No, they do not have to administer first aid, which was my original point, and also that any investigations that take place as a result of her feedback do not have to be fed back to her.

Their own internal system will have a process regarding H&S but they have done no wrong in law.

”Medical attention” in this case was the GP. HsE is very clear it needs to be hospital treatment so that point is not relevant.

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 13:14

SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 10:45

There’s no nonsense. You didn’t read what I said.

Yes, IKEA does have a duty to make sure their shop is secure. That’s as standard.

No, they do not have a duty to perform first aid on a customer. Employees who are first aid trained are trained for the welfare of their staff. If they give first aid to a customer it is as a courtesy and not as a necessity.

No, they do not have a duty to report the incident in an accident book. They are not in breech of any HsE regulations by not doing so. See here:

“Accidents to members of the public or others who are not at work must be reported if they result in an injury and the person is taken directly from the scene of the accident to hospital for treatment to that injury. Examinations and diagnostic tests do not constitute 'treatment' in such circumstances.

There is no need to report incidents where people are taken to hospital purely as a precaution when no injury is apparent.”

https://www.hse.gov.uk/riddor/reportable-incidents.htm

So what exactly was the point of your first reply? Do you think furniture falling on small children is perfectly ok? The OP also did seek medical attention for her child.

DogInATent · 15/04/2023 13:08

HarlanPepper · 15/04/2023 12:19

You don't report it to the LA, you report it to the HSE, using the link several people have posted. You will not get any further with IKEA via 'resolver'.

It's a retail premises. You report it to the Local Authority. The HSE isn't responsible for this premises.

alyceflowers · 15/04/2023 12:30

So bizarre that people think furniture falling on you/your child is just a normal risk of going into a shop, and huge multinational corporations have no responsibility to prevent 'freak accidents'.

HarlanPepper · 15/04/2023 12:19

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 10:04

I didn’t mention compensation. I don’t think my language in my OP is dramatic, I’ve stated what happened & tried not to drip feed. Thanks for all the advice. As I said I’ve escalated it with resolver & I’ll see if I get a response. I’m genuinely worried about it happening to anyone else in the future. I will look into how to report it to the LA.

You don't report it to the LA, you report it to the HSE, using the link several people have posted. You will not get any further with IKEA via 'resolver'.

BerryPieandCustard · 15/04/2023 11:59

A few years back a Mirror fell on a young child in a store close to me (not an IKEA) and the child subsequently died from the injuries caused.

please push this with them to investigate why this happened and understand the importance of securing their items so this doesn’t happen again

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 11:42

Nearlyneverready · 15/04/2023 10:40

@Bretonbabe Years ago, we had a very similar incident happen at IKEA.

DS was in a high chair in the IKEA restaurant and a freestanding dividing wall fell towards him. Luckily, DS was not hurt. It’s hard to explain, but the wall hit the high chair and the angle was such that DS was underneath it, but it didn’t make contact with him, just the high chair which was trapped between the wall and the booth seating.

It was terrifying at the time. DS was silent initially and we couldn’t immediately see if he was okay. Then he started screaming and I eventually managed to get him out of the chair. I remember shaking while I was holding him.

I was not happy with the way IKEA handled it and I complained. The duty manager and staff came and cleared away the wall, but nobody asked if DS was okay (apart from other customers) and I just left, wanting to get him home. I couldn’t think straight and couldn’t stop thinking about the “what ifs”

I reported the incident to the local council (I think) and also emailed a complaint to IKEA HQ.

From there, I had a series of very apologetic phone calls. They offered to meet either in store or at my home. They told me that all IKEA stores followed the same plan, so following the incident, the same dividing walls had been checked at the other stores. They had found that the other walls were okay, but that this particular wall had fallen because it had not been secured to the floor correctly.

You must have been very scared and I’m sorry your DC was hurt. Please do report it. x

That’s horrible, glad your child was ok, but clearly affected as mine was. I was shaking too & just wanted to leave. Worrying to hear a similar story. I will definitely report it.

OP posts:
NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 15/04/2023 10:53

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 10:04

I didn’t mention compensation. I don’t think my language in my OP is dramatic, I’ve stated what happened & tried not to drip feed. Thanks for all the advice. As I said I’ve escalated it with resolver & I’ll see if I get a response. I’m genuinely worried about it happening to anyone else in the future. I will look into how to report it to the LA.

The fact you've now stated you did have the child seen by medical professionals at the time means you do have a paper trail.

SunnySaturdayMorning · 15/04/2023 10:45

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/04/2023 09:14

What nonesense are you spouting!? They have a duty to make sure their displays are put together and secured in such a way as they do not fall onto children. If an incident occurs, they are legally obliged to note it in an incident report/ accident book. If they do not, they are in breach of the Health and Safety Act, which is why people are saying OP should contact the HSE who investigate breaches.

There’s no nonsense. You didn’t read what I said.

Yes, IKEA does have a duty to make sure their shop is secure. That’s as standard.

No, they do not have a duty to perform first aid on a customer. Employees who are first aid trained are trained for the welfare of their staff. If they give first aid to a customer it is as a courtesy and not as a necessity.

No, they do not have a duty to report the incident in an accident book. They are not in breech of any HsE regulations by not doing so. See here:

“Accidents to members of the public or others who are not at work must be reported if they result in an injury and the person is taken directly from the scene of the accident to hospital for treatment to that injury. Examinations and diagnostic tests do not constitute 'treatment' in such circumstances.

There is no need to report incidents where people are taken to hospital purely as a precaution when no injury is apparent.”

https://www.hse.gov.uk/riddor/reportable-incidents.htm

Reportable incidents - RIDDOR - HSE

This page explains the types of incidents that are reportable under RIDDOR.

https://www.hse.gov.uk/riddor/reportable-incidents.htm

Nearlyneverready · 15/04/2023 10:40

@Bretonbabe Years ago, we had a very similar incident happen at IKEA.

DS was in a high chair in the IKEA restaurant and a freestanding dividing wall fell towards him. Luckily, DS was not hurt. It’s hard to explain, but the wall hit the high chair and the angle was such that DS was underneath it, but it didn’t make contact with him, just the high chair which was trapped between the wall and the booth seating.

It was terrifying at the time. DS was silent initially and we couldn’t immediately see if he was okay. Then he started screaming and I eventually managed to get him out of the chair. I remember shaking while I was holding him.

I was not happy with the way IKEA handled it and I complained. The duty manager and staff came and cleared away the wall, but nobody asked if DS was okay (apart from other customers) and I just left, wanting to get him home. I couldn’t think straight and couldn’t stop thinking about the “what ifs”

I reported the incident to the local council (I think) and also emailed a complaint to IKEA HQ.

From there, I had a series of very apologetic phone calls. They offered to meet either in store or at my home. They told me that all IKEA stores followed the same plan, so following the incident, the same dividing walls had been checked at the other stores. They had found that the other walls were okay, but that this particular wall had fallen because it had not been secured to the floor correctly.

You must have been very scared and I’m sorry your DC was hurt. Please do report it. x

ExasperatedbyJanuary · 15/04/2023 10:34

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 15/04/2023 10:24

Honestly some of these replies!

Some posters REALLY hate other humans. Or are just wholly self deprecating. Or they’re just so bloody British they spend their lives apologising even when other people are at fault.

Businesses actually DO have a duty of Health and Safety to their customers. Children have the right to go in a shop and not be injured. And when it DOES happen, even if it’s no one’s fault, the victim deserves an explanation as to what they did to fully investigate and what they will change going forward.

Exactly.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 15/04/2023 10:24

Honestly some of these replies!

Some posters REALLY hate other humans. Or are just wholly self deprecating. Or they’re just so bloody British they spend their lives apologising even when other people are at fault.

Businesses actually DO have a duty of Health and Safety to their customers. Children have the right to go in a shop and not be injured. And when it DOES happen, even if it’s no one’s fault, the victim deserves an explanation as to what they did to fully investigate and what they will change going forward.

Hibernating80 · 15/04/2023 10:16

Yep exactly I was keeping an eye on her thankfully. Accidents happen in split seconds and I was on the ball, but would have been easy to be off the ball for a split second as well, that's why it's important once risks become incidents to act on them and stop them happening again.

DuesExMachina · 15/04/2023 10:07

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 10:04

I didn’t mention compensation. I don’t think my language in my OP is dramatic, I’ve stated what happened & tried not to drip feed. Thanks for all the advice. As I said I’ve escalated it with resolver & I’ll see if I get a response. I’m genuinely worried about it happening to anyone else in the future. I will look into how to report it to the LA.

Good for you!

Next child might not be ok but hopefully thanks to you, there won't be a next time

FloatingRodger · 15/04/2023 10:05

Glassfullofdreams · 15/04/2023 09:45

It was a freak accident. It's unfortunate that it happened to your child, but accidents happen. Maybe IKEA did look into the incident and there is honestly no explanation for what happened, hence it being an accident.

Your child clearly wasn't seriously harmed otherwise I'm sure you would have mentioned a trip to A&E in your post.

There's no need to take it any further. It's time to move on. You won't make any money out of it, which is what it sounds like you're hoping for. You don't have to sue someone over every minor incident these days.

So if they conclude that "furniture can fall onto children with no explanation or obvious cause", what changes do you think they need to make in their stores?

Honestly, are people really this hard of thinking?

If it happened again: "oh yes it did happen before but our investigation showed it was a freak accident so we didn't need to do anything about it". Would that cut it with you? I guess they're banking on it.

Bretonbabe · 15/04/2023 10:04

I didn’t mention compensation. I don’t think my language in my OP is dramatic, I’ve stated what happened & tried not to drip feed. Thanks for all the advice. As I said I’ve escalated it with resolver & I’ll see if I get a response. I’m genuinely worried about it happening to anyone else in the future. I will look into how to report it to the LA.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread