Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£14 an hour for a doctor ?!

161 replies

gardenlife · 15/04/2023 07:26

Junior doctor says she can't afford to start family www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lancashire-65275409

Wait hang on - the article shows the payslip and this doctor is only on £14 an hour. Having to lay in excess of £1600 for their own exams.

That's not much more than minimum wage is it? Yes she has £80k plus debt from studies.

I agree with minimum wage being increased but this is closing the gap between non professional jobs and professionals

Surely they deserve more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sodthebloodypicnic · 15/04/2023 08:51

I don't think the argument 'an FY1 salary (£14ph) is a good starting salary with quick progression' is going to fly unfortunately.

FY1 equivalents make twice my pay in Aus/NZ/HK/Canada and their progression is rewarded fairly with yearly pay increases for accumulated experience and fair OOH remuneration.

My monthly take home is 2138.
Based on 40hrs/wk base salary (at £14ph)+ mandatory additional average 8hrs/week(at £14ph) + 1 in 4 weekends (146.00pm for 2x12.5hr weekend shifts) + 37% increase on night hours (after 9pm before 6pm).
My rota is very heavy on OOH work due to the specialty.

I have >80k in student debt.

I hear a lot 'the NHS paid for your training'. It objectively didn't, I did in loans and working as an HCA and my parents sacrifice.
The 'pay jump' when you become a reg isn't enough to justify staying in the UK when I can have a better deal and ultimately quality of life abroad.

If you want doctors to stay in the UK you have to pay a fair competitive wage for doctors skills.

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 15/04/2023 08:50

Yeah I’m sorry, I just can’t get worked up about doctors being underpaid. Working conditions? One hindered percent, but pay? Nah, you guys are doing alright.
Dh has just completed HGV training. By law he is only allowed to drive for a maximum 9hrs a day and by law he must take a 45minute break after 4.5hrs driving, because otherwise he could endanger lives. I find it crazy that driving for 5hours is considered so dangerous but doctors can work for 12hrs with barely any break. That does need to change, the conditions are terrible and, quite frankly, dangerous

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/04/2023 08:49

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 08:43

F1 Drs are still in training, fresh out of medical school, can only perform certain tasks, have fewer responsibilities and they're not fully registered with the GMC during the 1st year.

The first 2 years are foundation years which are officially called foundation programme internships.

According to a recent thread on this subject from an op, who posted a payslip from 2021, they were paid £14 an hour as an f1. They said they were therefore an f1 during lockdown, resuscitating patients several times a night, prescribing medication and often left alone.

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 08:43

F1 Drs are still in training, fresh out of medical school, can only perform certain tasks, have fewer responsibilities and they're not fully registered with the GMC during the 1st year.

The first 2 years are foundation years which are officially called foundation programme internships.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 08:43

x2boys · 15/04/2023 08:36

Granted its been 8 years since i waa a mental health nurse ,but we always had on call junior Drs ,that covered both the wards and A&E .

Depends on the hospital but it's actual psych trainees that cover the out of hours oncalls rather than f1/2 making the decisions (some hospitals band the f1/f2 psych juniors if they need more numbers on the ground to help

Reallybadidea · 15/04/2023 08:40

Trina1234 · 15/04/2023 08:34

I love the fact that these striking junior doctors seem to be an average age of 25 ? But they want backpay for their proffesion being underpaid from 15 years ago !!! Ffs they were probably not even doing a paper round and want a pay rise backdated to their 11th birthday ..wake up and smell the roses doctor ..your suffering from a severe case of STUPIDITY ..and they seem to be struggling with basic maths because that £14 an hour figure that they keep spouting about just doesnt add up

Just a thought, but have you considered that you might have misunderstood this?

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 08:39

Trina1234 · 15/04/2023 08:34

I love the fact that these striking junior doctors seem to be an average age of 25 ? But they want backpay for their proffesion being underpaid from 15 years ago !!! Ffs they were probably not even doing a paper round and want a pay rise backdated to their 11th birthday ..wake up and smell the roses doctor ..your suffering from a severe case of STUPIDITY ..and they seem to be struggling with basic maths because that £14 an hour figure that they keep spouting about just doesnt add up

I'm 32 and was on day 1 pickets, the rest of the days I spent writing my masters degree essay, and doing the trillion pages of admin and sign off so I can pass my end of year review in 2 weeks. Most of my colleagues my age were revising for their exams to continue training, so you will see more juniors there as they haven't yet got the joys of exams on their plates.

(And to be honest I just got ID'd to buy a lighter for my candles yesterday so of you saw me you probably also would assume I was a 24yo lol

x2boys · 15/04/2023 08:36

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 08:29

Depending on the old banding. I had 2 jobs (gp and anaesthetics/icu) but there's loads like sexual health psych etc that dont have oncalls so the pay drop is dramatic on those rotas (also nice to not work weekends/nights and feel slightly human again) but I had to work extra shifts to cover expenses during them

Granted its been 8 years since i waa a mental health nurse ,but we always had on call junior Drs ,that covered both the wards and A&E .

Gingernaut · 15/04/2023 08:36

I'm a shift working admin body in a hospital

I have nothing like the responsibility of any doctor

I work long shifts, sometimes up to 16 hours, but nothing like the 'on call' hours a doctor works

If I'm paid correctly, I net more than junior doctors, sometimes up to £1k more

My overtime and antisocial hours are all far more generous than those for junior doctors

HisOliveTree · 15/04/2023 08:36

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 08:29

Depending on the old banding. I had 2 jobs (gp and anaesthetics/icu) but there's loads like sexual health psych etc that dont have oncalls so the pay drop is dramatic on those rotas (also nice to not work weekends/nights and feel slightly human again) but I had to work extra shifts to cover expenses during them

True, but most rotations will have an out of hours component for 8 months of the first 12 at least.

IhearyouClemFandango · 15/04/2023 08:35

*This suggests that the average full-time doctor in one of the BMA’s four junior doctor pay grades earned about £43,000 per year in basic pay—and significantly more if you include non-basic pay.

There are many different ways of using these figures to calculate an average hourly rate, and there is some uncertainty in the data, but in general it suggests a range of roughly £20-30 per hour.

These rates may be higher now, as they include pay from 2021/22, when salaries were lower than they are in the current financial year (not accounting for inflation).

None of these figures necessarily represent the pay of the junior doctors who are on strike, as BMA members may not be representative of junior doctors as a whole.

A BMA spokesperson told us: “Of course, our campaign is not suggesting £14.09 is the hourly basic rate for all junior doctors, as this title covers everyone from newly-graduated medics to people who have been working for 8-to-10 years or more as doctors.”

What about Pret’s figure?
We also contacted Pret a Manger, which confirmed that pay for a “team member” in one of its shops would increase on 1 April to £10.60-11.90 per hour, depending on location and experience (or £11.85-13.15 per hour with a performance-related bonus), and for a “barista” to £11.20-12.85, or £12.45-14.10 with the bonus.*

From the Full Fact article. Also worth noting that they divided the total over 365 days of the year to get to £14, which obviously is an 'unusual' was of doing it.

The pay isn't ridiculous for a new starter, especially given pension 3tc. Paying for your own training and quals, insurance etc isn't unusual either. However they would have an argument that working conditions within the NHS should be improved. Being paid more doesn't solve that.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 08:35

HollyBerri · 15/04/2023 08:17

I think the point most people are missing is that most people don’t make life or death decisions on every shift. Regardless of whether £14 is increased by a shift allowance its still woefully inadequate. My daughter is a nurse and tells me first hand what the junior doctors do for there money. I completely support them. The billions wasted on faulty PPE could have fine towards this.

Kinda depends on your speciality. Obviously when you start your generally well supported but can guarantee as an anaesthetist/ icu doctor patients can very easily die on the end of my syringe of drugs and yes every patient requires multiple life and death decisions as we artificially prevent them breathing and take it over alongside controlling other organ systems

(similarly surgeons with a knife in their hand, medics needing to defib abnormal rhythms, fixing potentially fatal electrolyte conditions, most decisions we make hags a degree of life and death but we get slightly desensitised to it as it's all we do/know

Coffeewinecake · 15/04/2023 08:34

gogohmm · 15/04/2023 08:31

That is literally her first payslip after medical school. It increases annually with experience and there's extra for anti social shifts. It's in line with other stem graduates including those with PhDs. Doctors start on £29k I believe outside of london, a salary higher than many people in very responsible jobs with years of experience.

Read full fact for full information, that figure was misrepresented.

I asked a friend what he earned (he's just become a consultant) prior to promotion and he said £58k not a low salary

£58k is an unacceptable salary for someone role just before becoming a consultant.

Trina1234 · 15/04/2023 08:34

I love the fact that these striking junior doctors seem to be an average age of 25 ? But they want backpay for their proffesion being underpaid from 15 years ago !!! Ffs they were probably not even doing a paper round and want a pay rise backdated to their 11th birthday ..wake up and smell the roses doctor ..your suffering from a severe case of STUPIDITY ..and they seem to be struggling with basic maths because that £14 an hour figure that they keep spouting about just doesnt add up

wejammin · 15/04/2023 08:33

I don't want to make this a race to the bottom, but as a legal aid lawyer I was making £15k as a first year trainee and £18k as a second year trainee, and then in the first 8 years of practice I was earning maximum of £28k. No I wasn't doing resuscitation but I was trying to stop social services removing children for adoption, forever. The social workers on these cases were also on low wages for very high stress jobs. Based on the emails I sent and received lots of us were working into the night unpaid.

The problem is that the government doesn't appreciate any of us, doctors, teachers, lawyers, nurses, social workers, who spend a long time qualifying and get into debt to try and give back to society. I would happily pay more tax for better paid public sector workers.

I do think though that there has been a naivety in the PR the doctors have put out, we all know that consultants are well paid (as they should be) and regularly tweeting F1 payslips is making people start to eyeroll and say 'yes but in 10 years you'll be loaded'... The focus needs to be on global comparators of salary, brain drain and working conditions.

Pippa12 · 15/04/2023 08:33

My husband earns circa £50k for running a restaurant???

Orangeoil · 15/04/2023 08:33

There is just this gradual attrition of all our wages. I guess doctors and nurses are wanting not to put up with it.

None of us should be. ‘They’ (governments, capitalist class, the 2640 billionaires & suporters, the financial system decision makers) are pushing our incomes and quality of life lower and lower. They are making us spend more of our salaries on fuel and essentials.

Where is this going? How long are we going to put up with it? A lot of people on MN are probably doing ok. But how representative is this?

Summerhillsquare · 15/04/2023 08:32

I more concerned about their working conditions. That would be a fine salary for a 37 hour week with good support, a well managed environment, modest case load etc. But they appear to be working under impossibly stressful conditions that no amount of money would make ok. And that's before we mention the impact on patients.

gogohmm · 15/04/2023 08:31

That is literally her first payslip after medical school. It increases annually with experience and there's extra for anti social shifts. It's in line with other stem graduates including those with PhDs. Doctors start on £29k I believe outside of london, a salary higher than many people in very responsible jobs with years of experience.

Read full fact for full information, that figure was misrepresented.

I asked a friend what he earned (he's just become a consultant) prior to promotion and he said £58k not a low salary

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 08:29

HisOliveTree · 15/04/2023 08:21

I'd say that's an unusual payslip for an FY1. Most will be receiving an enhanced hours and weekend supplement on top.

Depending on the old banding. I had 2 jobs (gp and anaesthetics/icu) but there's loads like sexual health psych etc that dont have oncalls so the pay drop is dramatic on those rotas (also nice to not work weekends/nights and feel slightly human again) but I had to work extra shifts to cover expenses during them

Coffeewinecake · 15/04/2023 08:28

Basildeleaf · 15/04/2023 07:47

...and their progression is very fast. From what I read, after three years to four years, they could be on £70k - not bad in your mid 20s.

This makes no sense, given that they graduate at age 24.

HisOliveTree · 15/04/2023 08:28

Pippa12 · 15/04/2023 08:22

So it’s acceptable for these doctors to have to work weekends and nights to make ends meet?

Where did I say that? What I said, which is true (see the full facts link someone posted) was that that FY1 payslip is unusual.

Just about all junior doctors work evenings and weekends, it's part of the role, it's not something done to make ends meet.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 08:26

Basildeleaf · 15/04/2023 07:47

...and their progression is very fast. From what I read, after three years to four years, they could be on £70k - not bad in your mid 20s.

Not sure where you've got that from. I'm 10 years in and not on that

Coffeewinecake · 15/04/2023 08:26

And don’t confuse unpaid overtime and paid overtime. Paid overtime is not actually overtime, it’s contractual.
There are hours and hours and hours of unpaid overtime that NHS staff do (doctors, nurses, AHPs etc). The whole thing would have folder decades ago otherwise.

x2boys · 15/04/2023 08:25

Going off on a tangent ,my son was recently in critical care ,the vast majority of the nurse,s working in criticsl care are only paid at band five ,i saw what they do and they really have to have an awful lot of knowledge and expertise,as part of their contract they have to do a masters ,and their is no gurantee of promotion to band six ,imo,all the nurses working on critical care should be paid at least a band six.

Swipe left for the next trending thread