Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£14 an hour for a doctor ?!

161 replies

gardenlife · 15/04/2023 07:26

Junior doctor says she can't afford to start family www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lancashire-65275409

Wait hang on - the article shows the payslip and this doctor is only on £14 an hour. Having to lay in excess of £1600 for their own exams.

That's not much more than minimum wage is it? Yes she has £80k plus debt from studies.

I agree with minimum wage being increased but this is closing the gap between non professional jobs and professionals

Surely they deserve more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Pyui · 15/04/2023 10:02

Soontobe60 · 15/04/2023 08:04

Junior doctors get additional pay for working overtime and unsocial hours. I’m a teacher, I’ve never been paid extra for working overtime or unsociable hours.

I’m sorry but I hate these races to the bottom. You are not routinely expected to work 9pm-9am!?

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:57

itsgettingweird · 15/04/2023 09:46

So in the first year of employment they are paid a minimum base of £30,000 plus overtime available?

They work 40 hour weeks.

They also have to study and write papers as part of their career progression.

And you think it's acceptable to earn a decent wage after 6 years already if uni and the debts they've accrued that they have to work overtime for more income?

We work 48h averaged over an 8 week rolling rota. Can be up to 62.5 during our grotty week of 2 nights, 1 day rest, 3x weekend long days

Won't complain though before the 2016 contract change we did Monday of one week to Friday of the week after (the middle fri-sun as 13h days), during which I was basically a nonfunctioning vegetable after work

Sendouttheclowns · 15/04/2023 09:55

sst1234 · 15/04/2023 09:47

Don’t forget that they they upto a third of their salary paid into their pension. Also the taxpayer had funded upto £200k to train them. This is not as simple as the soundbite.

This issue ultimately boils down benchmarking vs other countries. Junior doctors are not badly paid if you compare vs public sector pay or pay generally in the country. The problem is that our stagnant economy is poor that wages in this country have generally fallen behind other countries.

Nothing is going to change until we have economic growth. But we don’t like that in this country. We like the March to net 0 despite being responsible for less than 1% of global emissions. We like bashing our financial services - talk about the hand that feeds you. We like taxing the private sector to death and then wondering why they set up shop elsewhere. We like protesting against all new development and being nimbys in little Britain. We like locking ourselves up at home and printing half a trillion pound to pay for it because watching Netflix on furlough is fun, innit.

So shut up and put up. You asked for this.

👏👏

Sendouttheclowns · 15/04/2023 09:53

@Singapore4 The responsibility is one of the highest too it's someone's life if anything goes wrong the public would be quick to sue the doctor for their mistake.

This is actually correct.

Legal action would be taken against the employer, usually the NHS. In 2021/22 only just over 54% of the clinical claims were successful in winning compensation.

itsgettingweird · 15/04/2023 09:48

But that's not her actual hourly wage, is it? That needs to cover driving between clients so all vehicle costs, petrol, time travelling etc, insurance, equipment and replacing disposable items, income when she's off sick, on holiday etc.

And junior doctors need to cover their professional body membership, exams, study material and also commute to and from their place of work.

sst1234 · 15/04/2023 09:47

Don’t forget that they they upto a third of their salary paid into their pension. Also the taxpayer had funded upto £200k to train them. This is not as simple as the soundbite.

This issue ultimately boils down benchmarking vs other countries. Junior doctors are not badly paid if you compare vs public sector pay or pay generally in the country. The problem is that our stagnant economy is poor that wages in this country have generally fallen behind other countries.

Nothing is going to change until we have economic growth. But we don’t like that in this country. We like the March to net 0 despite being responsible for less than 1% of global emissions. We like bashing our financial services - talk about the hand that feeds you. We like taxing the private sector to death and then wondering why they set up shop elsewhere. We like protesting against all new development and being nimbys in little Britain. We like locking ourselves up at home and printing half a trillion pound to pay for it because watching Netflix on furlough is fun, innit.

So shut up and put up. You asked for this.

itsgettingweird · 15/04/2023 09:46

So in the first year of employment they are paid a minimum base of £30,000 plus overtime available?

They work 40 hour weeks.

They also have to study and write papers as part of their career progression.

And you think it's acceptable to earn a decent wage after 6 years already if uni and the debts they've accrued that they have to work overtime for more income?

Sendouttheclowns · 15/04/2023 09:39

For comparison -

Train drivers start at £30,000 - can earn £65,000 (plus extras for London)

Pilots - Salaries depend on the airline, the type of aircraft you're flying and your experience.

  • Starting salaries for newly qualified second/first officers, working for a small operation, may be around £24,000. In larger companies, starting salaries can reach £28,000.
  • Once you've built up your experience, salaries as a second officer tend to peak at around £58,000 while first officer salaries can reach £75,000. Once you progress on to a senior first officer role, salaries of up to £85,000 can be achieved.
  • The starting salary for a captain with a medium-sized airline may range from £54,000 to £75,000. Those employed by major operators can earn £97,000 to more than £140,000.

Dentists - Salaried dentists employed by the NHS, working mainly with community dental services, earn a basic salary of between £44,955 and £96,154.
In private practice this can be considerably more.

Vet £47,907 basic - can rise to £86,000. If you have a speciality, such as zoo animals or racehorses it can be even more.

Underwriter (Insurance) A trainee underwriter can start to earn anywhere between £24-30k, depending on location and the individual company. Qualified and experienced underwriters can make between £25-40k. Senior and lead underwriters can start at £40k and reach up to £90k depending on the location and type of insurance.

Singapore4 · 15/04/2023 09:34

thesmee · 15/04/2023 07:33

An F1 doctor posted their payslip on TikTok from covid to show how low it was. It was about £1900 net a month, which is my take-home pay as on something like £36,000 (have lost track). I don't disagree they're underpaid, and there is a recruitment and retention crisis so clearly something needs to be done, but I think the £14 an hour is disingenuous. They get more for unsociable hours etc. A year or two after they graduated, all my doctor friends and family were earning in 3 days what I did in 5, in another professional job. It's not anywhere near enough, but it's hardly NMW.

You need to consider how many hours a week a F1 works? How many hours an SHO works?

It's the work balance that is the worst part. The responsibility is one of the highest too it's someone's life if anything goes wrong the public would be quick to sue the doctor for their mistake.

Botw1 · 15/04/2023 09:33

Soontobe60 · 15/04/2023 08:04

Junior doctors get additional pay for working overtime and unsocial hours. I’m a teacher, I’ve never been paid extra for working overtime or unsociable hours.

Have you ever been responsible for someone living or dying?

Have you ever had to tell someone that they are dying and there is nothing you can do for them?

As a teacher you don't have to work unsociable hours

So whilst I agree with some of the arguments for saying doctors are better paid than most and will have better earning potential overall, there is a reason for that in comparison to other roles

Doctors should be better paid than most.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:31

TheMarzipanDildo · 15/04/2023 09:04

They are leaving in their droves. Limited supply + increased demand = a more expensive commodity. It’s not even a moral issue (well it is) it’s just the market economy.

I mean part of me wonders why we fight it so much. Privatisation of the nhs would be a trillion times in drs favour, the pay would soar like in America and your employer gives you free private healthcare.

We fight because we are passionate for free healthcare at the point of delivery and don't want a system like America where people die or are bankrupt from ill health

I mean none of us do this job for the money, if it wasn't my absolute passion to get people through really difficult times of their life, life changing surgery and a good recovery afterwards I'd be long gone as the system treats us like nothing more than a number on a spreadsheet

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:27

thesmee · 15/04/2023 07:33

An F1 doctor posted their payslip on TikTok from covid to show how low it was. It was about £1900 net a month, which is my take-home pay as on something like £36,000 (have lost track). I don't disagree they're underpaid, and there is a recruitment and retention crisis so clearly something needs to be done, but I think the £14 an hour is disingenuous. They get more for unsociable hours etc. A year or two after they graduated, all my doctor friends and family were earning in 3 days what I did in 5, in another professional job. It's not anywhere near enough, but it's hardly NMW.

We get zero additional pay for working saturdays (no idea why that was accepted by the last contract change)

We get zero additional salary for working a bank holiday (I've somehow been rostered the last 9!) We work a 12.5-13h day on a bank hol and get a 8h day shift in lieu, that's it

I've worked every single Christmas apart from 2 since I graduated in 2014, that being 13h days 24th-27th Dec as we run rolling rotas so if you are due oncall then it's tough luck (you can't argue I worked last year as you're since in a new hospital).

Again, no extra pay as its a BH (that's where the signs come from that a Dr is often the lowest paid when working a BH as all others on A4C will get significant uplifts for working such shifts, I've lost count how many times I've been asked 'are you working this for the extra' as the nurses forget we don't get BH uplift

Bobbybobbins · 15/04/2023 09:23

It's all very well lots of people who aren't doctors saying 'the pay and progression are fine as other professions get paid less' Clearly it's not fine as so many are leaving the profession!!!!

Reallybadidea · 15/04/2023 09:19

TheMarzipanDildo · 15/04/2023 09:04

They are leaving in their droves. Limited supply + increased demand = a more expensive commodity. It’s not even a moral issue (well it is) it’s just the market economy.

This.

The traditional Tory argument against higher taxes for high earners is that they end up relocating to countries where they will pay less tax and the country as a whole loses out. This is exactly the reason why doctors need to be paid more - because otherwise they go elsewhere.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:19

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 09:05

Yes. Not in the foundation programme, without full GMC registration and earning £14 an hour basic though are you?

Sorry don't understand your point? We are still trainees

The government just likes to keep the trainee title as it infantalises us and makes the public associate us with being medical students not fully qualified professionals

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:17

marshmallowsforbreakfast · 15/04/2023 08:53

It isn't correct and the payslip posted is very misleading. This is for an F1 who is fresh out of uni, and doesn't taken into considering any additional that they all get. Don't be fooled.

That's my last payslip of f1. We got paid slightly differently as I'm old (haha) but banding is basically a block payment for every one of your evening, nights, weekend shifts as a lump sum, probably not in our favour as rate says 4.34)

10.85ph

£14 an hour for a doctor ?!
Throwncrumbs · 15/04/2023 09:06

thesmee · 15/04/2023 07:33

An F1 doctor posted their payslip on TikTok from covid to show how low it was. It was about £1900 net a month, which is my take-home pay as on something like £36,000 (have lost track). I don't disagree they're underpaid, and there is a recruitment and retention crisis so clearly something needs to be done, but I think the £14 an hour is disingenuous. They get more for unsociable hours etc. A year or two after they graduated, all my doctor friends and family were earning in 3 days what I did in 5, in another professional job. It's not anywhere near enough, but it's hardly NMW.

Yes they get more for unsocial hours. Have you ever worked nights?, Christmas Day? weekends? People who say ‘ they get more for unsocial hours’ clearly have never worked unsocial hours. Boils my pi££!

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 09:05

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:03

I'm still in training at 32. I still have 2.5 y left of training, have been full time since 2014. If you dare have children or go part time or dual train like itu or head/neck surgery, many are still in training in their 40s

Yes. Not in the foundation programme, without full GMC registration and earning £14 an hour basic though are you?

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:04

sashagabadon · 15/04/2023 08:57

we also hear about 50 year old consultants adding so much to their pensions in the previous 25 years that they go over the limit of 1 million pension pot ( now removed) that they no longer want to work.
so I think junior doctors will be ok

Anyone beyond 2015 have a totally different pension scheme that's far worse than such consultants as no longer final salary (we still have a good pension but nothing like said pensions

TheMarzipanDildo · 15/04/2023 09:04

They are leaving in their droves. Limited supply + increased demand = a more expensive commodity. It’s not even a moral issue (well it is) it’s just the market economy.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:03

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 08:43

F1 Drs are still in training, fresh out of medical school, can only perform certain tasks, have fewer responsibilities and they're not fully registered with the GMC during the 1st year.

The first 2 years are foundation years which are officially called foundation programme internships.

I'm still in training at 32. I still have 2.5 y left of training, have been full time since 2014. If you dare have children or go part time or dual train like itu or head/neck surgery, many are still in training in their 40s

sashagabadon · 15/04/2023 08:57

we also hear about 50 year old consultants adding so much to their pensions in the previous 25 years that they go over the limit of 1 million pension pot ( now removed) that they no longer want to work.
so I think junior doctors will be ok

Grumpsy · 15/04/2023 08:56

marshmallowsforbreakfast · 15/04/2023 08:53

It isn't correct and the payslip posted is very misleading. This is for an F1 who is fresh out of uni, and doesn't taken into considering any additional that they all get. Don't be fooled.

Are you actually expecting people to stay up all night, work anti social hrs at all hours of the night with people’s lives in their hands for no enhancement in their pay?

sounds like you do from your post.

marshmallowsforbreakfast · 15/04/2023 08:53

It isn't correct and the payslip posted is very misleading. This is for an F1 who is fresh out of uni, and doesn't taken into considering any additional that they all get. Don't be fooled.

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 08:51

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/04/2023 08:49

According to a recent thread on this subject from an op, who posted a payslip from 2021, they were paid £14 an hour as an f1. They said they were therefore an f1 during lockdown, resuscitating patients several times a night, prescribing medication and often left alone.

Which they shouldn't have been. Lots of things happened during the pandemic which shouldn't have.