Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£14 an hour for a doctor ?!

161 replies

gardenlife · 15/04/2023 07:26

Junior doctor says she can't afford to start family www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lancashire-65275409

Wait hang on - the article shows the payslip and this doctor is only on £14 an hour. Having to lay in excess of £1600 for their own exams.

That's not much more than minimum wage is it? Yes she has £80k plus debt from studies.

I agree with minimum wage being increased but this is closing the gap between non professional jobs and professionals

Surely they deserve more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
missmollygreen · 15/04/2023 14:43

ladykale · 15/04/2023 13:08

No offence but why are we comparing an HGV driver (which I think you can do without having GCSEs) and highly skilled doctors who need to be top of their class grades wise to even make it to medical school, train for 5 years at university, many more years of training and a level of skill that most of us can't even imagine (particularly surgeons!)

This thread shows that people fundamentally don't understand that some jobs require significantly more skill, training and intelligence than others!

If THAT is what what you took from that post then you are a proper cunt

bumblebusy · 15/04/2023 14:33

@ajenniejonesworld no I am in a career job that required me to be in less pay to obtain further training and experience that equated to better pay in the long term though.

Where will the money come from to pay these higher salaries especially given that once junior doctors get paid more anyone above them will thereafter expect to be paid more.

Rainbowshit · 15/04/2023 14:26

@BungleandGeorge

"What is so amazing about the pension?"

Are you.. are you joking?! 🤔

It's a hugely valuable benefit that those of us with DC pensions will get nowhere near replicating.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 13:40

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 12:41

Are you one of the trainee Dr's claiming you're working for £14 an hour in F1?

You're not so I'm not sure what your point is?

The BMA put out a marketing piece about how junior Dr's only earn £14 an hour which was less than a barista Which had a lot of backlash even from BMA members about how it was not equitable in any way.

That is the point of this post.

The idea that ALL junior Dr's as in non-consultants only earn £14 an hour. When that only applies to F1 Drs in the foundation programme.

You're not earning that are you?

If you're not a consultant but a Dr who has passed the foundation years then you should be in your chosen field and earning 50 to 80k a year basic as a speciality Dr.

As a speciality grade Dr you can earn
80k to 100k.

As a consultant it will rise over 100k a year. Which is wh6

So what? I can empathise. Noonesaid every dr is on that. I'm on £24ph. I was trying to find a cleaner last week as my life is a mess and couldn't find any asking less than £19ph

No registrar is on 100k that's delusional.

Speciality Dr is a totally different pay scheme as they are neither trainees nor consultants

A consultant starts on 88k. They don't breech 100k until 9 years as a consultant (ie a bare minimum of 18yrs as a Dr, in most cases far more as most don't stick to the 7y speciality training as have enforced gap years to meet registrar entry points

www.bma.org.uk/pay-and-contracts/pay/consultants-pay-scales/pay-scales-for-consultants-in-england

Weedoormatnomore · 15/04/2023 13:37

ladykale · 15/04/2023 13:08

No offence but why are we comparing an HGV driver (which I think you can do without having GCSEs) and highly skilled doctors who need to be top of their class grades wise to even make it to medical school, train for 5 years at university, many more years of training and a level of skill that most of us can't even imagine (particularly surgeons!)

This thread shows that people fundamentally don't understand that some jobs require significantly more skill, training and intelligence than others!

She was comparing the rules of having a break so you did not endanger lives. HGV drivers by law has to have breaks so he is not driving while tired. All employed staff are legally meant to have breaks. Management should be making sure that breaks are being taken by doctors.

surreygoldfish · 15/04/2023 13:35

Coffeewinecake · 15/04/2023 08:34

£58k is an unacceptable salary for someone role just before becoming a consultant.

This - £58k IS a low salary for the skill and expertise. The vast majority of the population couldn’t do the job of a doctor. It should be a role that is seen as prestigious and something to be proud of. The NHS is no longer fit for purpose.

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 15/04/2023 13:19

ladykale · 15/04/2023 13:08

No offence but why are we comparing an HGV driver (which I think you can do without having GCSEs) and highly skilled doctors who need to be top of their class grades wise to even make it to medical school, train for 5 years at university, many more years of training and a level of skill that most of us can't even imagine (particularly surgeons!)

This thread shows that people fundamentally don't understand that some jobs require significantly more skill, training and intelligence than others!

Because if you read my post you would see I was talking about working conditions and agreeing that it was crazy that doctors are expected to work such long shifts when there are other jobs that have a cap on hours due to the dangers of working when tired and lacking concentration.
unless you think that by being sooo highly skilled, intelligent and important means you can concentrate for 12hrs+ cos you is so brilliant.

wow, way to loose the little sympathy that people have 🙄

Exaspa · 15/04/2023 13:18

So when it comes to CEOS, bankers and other such vital members of humanity, "you get what you pay for" and "if you don't pay fabulous wages you won't get the best" but it's a different story when you come to people in professions that actually contribute directly to society it's a different story?? I sometimes wonder about people in this country and how their brains work...

FortyFacedFuckers · 15/04/2023 13:10

Farmerama1 · 15/04/2023 08:02

In a free market for Labour, the demand for these skills is international and post covid, there are shortages of of medical professionals. If we want a functioning health service, pay and conditions must be globally competitive.

I work for the NHS & fully support the junior doctors (& nurses) but no matter what your opinion this is the crux of the matter, in order to retain doctors & nurses the pay & conditions need to be good enough to make the UK an enticing place to work which at the moment it is no where near that!

ladykale · 15/04/2023 13:08

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 15/04/2023 08:50

Yeah I’m sorry, I just can’t get worked up about doctors being underpaid. Working conditions? One hindered percent, but pay? Nah, you guys are doing alright.
Dh has just completed HGV training. By law he is only allowed to drive for a maximum 9hrs a day and by law he must take a 45minute break after 4.5hrs driving, because otherwise he could endanger lives. I find it crazy that driving for 5hours is considered so dangerous but doctors can work for 12hrs with barely any break. That does need to change, the conditions are terrible and, quite frankly, dangerous

No offence but why are we comparing an HGV driver (which I think you can do without having GCSEs) and highly skilled doctors who need to be top of their class grades wise to even make it to medical school, train for 5 years at university, many more years of training and a level of skill that most of us can't even imagine (particularly surgeons!)

This thread shows that people fundamentally don't understand that some jobs require significantly more skill, training and intelligence than others!

HostessTrolley · 15/04/2023 13:07

I'm sure that landlords who rent flats to junior doctors say 'ah it's ok, pay what you can now, because your salary will be high in a few years'. Not.

ladykale · 15/04/2023 13:04

@Soontobe60 but if you are a teacher then you don't work particular unsociable hours...

Your "overtime" is what many professional works and you don't work chunks of school holidays presumably??

WeAreBorg · 15/04/2023 13:03

I fully support the junior docs…however that lass who’s complaining because she’s done two degrees and has only just started regular employment at the age of 31…c’mon love
I do worry that they’re starting to undermine their cause by focusing on rubbish like this

ladykale · 15/04/2023 13:01

thesmee · 15/04/2023 07:33

An F1 doctor posted their payslip on TikTok from covid to show how low it was. It was about £1900 net a month, which is my take-home pay as on something like £36,000 (have lost track). I don't disagree they're underpaid, and there is a recruitment and retention crisis so clearly something needs to be done, but I think the £14 an hour is disingenuous. They get more for unsociable hours etc. A year or two after they graduated, all my doctor friends and family were earning in 3 days what I did in 5, in another professional job. It's not anywhere near enough, but it's hardly NMW.

But it's ridiculous that we are even sitting here comparing them with NMW or someone doing a random job when they are typically much cleverer, have to have the best academics and have to study much longer. Their wage should be compared with other jobs you can get with those sort of grades and study etc.

ajenniejonesworld · 15/04/2023 12:59

Lincslady53 · 15/04/2023 12:20

And yet we are told doctors are retiring early as they have paid the maximum into their pension funds. There is a lot of malicious spin being spouted at the moment.

This is happening. Because they ended up with huge tax bills due to pension contributions that they had no way of stopping other than reducing their hours or giving up work.

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 12:41

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:19

Sorry don't understand your point? We are still trainees

The government just likes to keep the trainee title as it infantalises us and makes the public associate us with being medical students not fully qualified professionals

Are you one of the trainee Dr's claiming you're working for £14 an hour in F1?

You're not so I'm not sure what your point is?

The BMA put out a marketing piece about how junior Dr's only earn £14 an hour which was less than a barista Which had a lot of backlash even from BMA members about how it was not equitable in any way.

That is the point of this post.

The idea that ALL junior Dr's as in non-consultants only earn £14 an hour. When that only applies to F1 Drs in the foundation programme.

You're not earning that are you?

If you're not a consultant but a Dr who has passed the foundation years then you should be in your chosen field and earning 50 to 80k a year basic as a speciality Dr.

As a speciality grade Dr you can earn
80k to 100k.

As a consultant it will rise over 100k a year. Which is wh6

Weedoormatnomore · 15/04/2023 12:39

When questioned on TV they admitted it was only between 7 and 10 percent that are on £14 an hour. I presume they are training in their first years like any other professional so reduced pay at start that increases. There was a post on here for someone else but 2 years old. Reading her post it mentioned her take home pay had increased by about 30 percent now but she would not show the newer payslip or mention her new hourly wage. No idea who could start a career do one or two years of work and then take time of to have a family !

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 12:30

KnittedCardi · 15/04/2023 12:12

PP's. And that's the point. They are complaining of low pay and then having to work o/t. But they get paid enhanced rates for o/t. It's the usual cyclical argument.

And it is just not a bill for the expected 35% on standard salary. Then o/t rate cards will increase, as they have with consultants, and the extra value % on pensions. It's a big bill to cover. All the extra billions being pumped into healthcare will just disappear into existing salaries, no extra staff, no extra treatments. Just the status quo, unless everyone, and I mean even medium and low paid workers put more into the tax pot.

You don't really get how our hours work.

Working nights evenings weekends is not overtime it's mandatory and part of our standard salary.

Locum shifts are additional work that we do ontop of our 48-62h weeks on days off, the only reason these shifts exist are because we are haemorrhaging drs abroad and into non medical jobs like pharmaceuticals ... funnily enough you can't just leave an emergency theatre or obstetric shift uncovered else people will die. If these are rota vacancies then they have to be filled. Locum pay has to be better than our normal rate else noone would give up their days off to do it (they're not exactly popular given I get about 10 requests most days). You see in London where they have pit caps on rates only 10ish £ above normal day rate they are constantly begging and begging for cover as funnily enough the little free time we have is deemed worth more than that to us

Our out of hours/nights oncall pay is not pensionable so that has zero to do with anything. Our pension is based on 40h day time pay and that's it

The pay restoration has nothing to do with locum pay to cover vacant shifts

If you don't sort the current crisis you won't keep these staff let alone buy additional staff from God knows where, as all my European Dr mates have had enough and are off

Ariela · 15/04/2023 12:26

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 15/04/2023 07:44

So in the first year of employment they are paid a minimum base of £30,000 plus overtime available?

I know they work hard, train hard, but is that really such a bad starting rate? Many of us have degrees and PhDs and are only earning that after 10 years in other sectors and are providing for families. Junior doctors are on a course to earn significantly more than that.

And they get a good pension.

Sodthebloodypicnic · 15/04/2023 12:21

Hbh17 · 15/04/2023 11:55

This is not new, because a junior doctor is in a training grade. So they are getting massive amounts of free training and experience, which will enable them to move on to a well-paid consultancy or GP role in later life. Not to mention generous pension provision.
My OH earned less per hour than a porter when he was a houseman. It was annoying, but he knew that it was a means to an end. He also knew that he would have to pay big sums for exam costs, courses etc. It is all about investment in the future, and I don't understand how junior doctors now fail to understand this. They work hard but are also are very fortunate people.

I'd like to see this massive amount of free training and experience Foundation trainees are getting? What do you think this is? As far as I can see we are service provision and our consultants prefer to train permanent staff but excited to hear your point of view

The houseman experience your OH had is a thing of the past.
Pay was better compared to the cost of living and cost of housing.
Housemen had free accommodation in their first year.
There were no student loans, let alone nearly 100k.
Pension schemes were amazing value compared to what have now.
Choice of where to train? None of the costs of having to move/commute across country every year.

If you can't recognise what a different situation FY1s are in now you need to give your head a wobble.

All of these changes happened during the working life of current seniors who watched it happen.

We very much understand the 'investing in the future' argument. Just a shame the best investment in my future is the USMLE licensing exams for the states or a flight ticket to Aus - unless we see pay restoration.

00deed1988 · 15/04/2023 12:20

I am mid band 6 on NHS May scale and even though my payslip says I get £18.19 an hour. Last month, by the time my unsociable hours pay and outer London weighting is added it averages out at £26.15 an hour (although I do a lot of nights so varies from person to person) Bank shifts are even more for nights and weekends. Because of my unsociable hours I earn more than my bank 7 manager.

It isn't quite black and white. I'm not saying they don't deserve more. But not clear cut with the figures!

Lincslady53 · 15/04/2023 12:20

And yet we are told doctors are retiring early as they have paid the maximum into their pension funds. There is a lot of malicious spin being spouted at the moment.

KnittedCardi · 15/04/2023 12:12

Botw1 · 15/04/2023 10:14

@KnittedCardi

Who said it was unfair they had to work unsocial hours?

It is part of the job. Its also why they are paid more for working those unsocial hours

PP's. And that's the point. They are complaining of low pay and then having to work o/t. But they get paid enhanced rates for o/t. It's the usual cyclical argument.

And it is just not a bill for the expected 35% on standard salary. Then o/t rate cards will increase, as they have with consultants, and the extra value % on pensions. It's a big bill to cover. All the extra billions being pumped into healthcare will just disappear into existing salaries, no extra staff, no extra treatments. Just the status quo, unless everyone, and I mean even medium and low paid workers put more into the tax pot.

Hbh17 · 15/04/2023 11:55

This is not new, because a junior doctor is in a training grade. So they are getting massive amounts of free training and experience, which will enable them to move on to a well-paid consultancy or GP role in later life. Not to mention generous pension provision.
My OH earned less per hour than a porter when he was a houseman. It was annoying, but he knew that it was a means to an end. He also knew that he would have to pay big sums for exam costs, courses etc. It is all about investment in the future, and I don't understand how junior doctors now fail to understand this. They work hard but are also are very fortunate people.