Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£14 an hour for a doctor ?!

161 replies

gardenlife · 15/04/2023 07:26

Junior doctor says she can't afford to start family www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lancashire-65275409

Wait hang on - the article shows the payslip and this doctor is only on £14 an hour. Having to lay in excess of £1600 for their own exams.

That's not much more than minimum wage is it? Yes she has £80k plus debt from studies.

I agree with minimum wage being increased but this is closing the gap between non professional jobs and professionals

Surely they deserve more?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Botw1 · 15/04/2023 18:49

@Samphiredragonfly

Enough for it to be irrelevant to your point

Samphiredragonfly · 15/04/2023 18:47

@Botw1 generally but not always.

JulieHoney · 15/04/2023 18:26

I fully support the junior doctors and the nurses in their strikes. Their conditions C are ridiculous and their pay far too low to retain them in the U.K.

Botw1 · 15/04/2023 18:21

@Samphiredragonfly

Nurses in most areas are generally very experienced and knowledgeable

Mischance · 15/04/2023 18:16

If you factor in all the unpaid overtime and missed breaks and unsocial hours, then their pay is far too low. My OH worked massively over his contracted hours for no extra pay.

ReplGirl · 15/04/2023 18:14

Samphiredragonfly · 15/04/2023 17:54

Tbf it doesn't really matter if we think they are paid their worth or not. Few of us on here are doctors and have no idea what their job is like. They obviously think they aren't paid enough (despite the two flashy cars on the drive or whatever cited in a post up thread) and they will leave in their droves if the government fails to listen. In fact they already are leaving in reality. Just don't whinge when things get even worse and the 2 week cancer wait gets extended to a 3 and 4 week one or your child can't see a specialist until next year...
@Destiny123 in my experience ICU juniors are supported really well by senior staff.
They don't make life or death decisions and are able to check most things with senior medics. I think it's one of the better areas to work as the nursing staff are generally very experienced and knowledgeable.

Exactly I'm not sure why people can't see the correlation between this and NHS wait times!
Or maybe it's just easier to blame the greedy doctors

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 18:07

Lol I had an 03 plate fiesta until 2y ago. Now a 2015 KA

Yep we are super supported in icu. The bosses are fantastic when I wake them hourly for every referral and come instantly when we are swamped/out of our depth But at the end of the day at 2am putting the sickest patients to sleep/managing cardiac arrests it's just you and a colleague and the boss is 30min drive away (so yes if they arrest from their physiology when you put them to sleep - which isn't that rare the 30min drive after they've woken and dressed can feel like forever

Crazykatie · 15/04/2023 18:06

Basic starting pay is around £28k then depending on unsocial hours worked, extra training, experience, it goes up, so it could be £14 an hour or so. As for the OP saying she couldn’t afford to start a family, does she expect to work for 6 months then take maternity leave, because that’s not really a good way to start your career.

Samphiredragonfly · 15/04/2023 17:54

Tbf it doesn't really matter if we think they are paid their worth or not. Few of us on here are doctors and have no idea what their job is like. They obviously think they aren't paid enough (despite the two flashy cars on the drive or whatever cited in a post up thread) and they will leave in their droves if the government fails to listen. In fact they already are leaving in reality. Just don't whinge when things get even worse and the 2 week cancer wait gets extended to a 3 and 4 week one or your child can't see a specialist until next year...
@Destiny123 in my experience ICU juniors are supported really well by senior staff.
They don't make life or death decisions and are able to check most things with senior medics. I think it's one of the better areas to work as the nursing staff are generally very experienced and knowledgeable.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 17:53

And psych salary (as gp) comes with a 10k salary supplement during training as noone wants to do it as a career, so that'll v much sway the salaries you hear of

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 17:46

Psychiatrists used to be able to retire 10y earlier than any other Dr due to the nature of their job. They now can't.

I didnt want sympathy re tax bills, I'm too junior to be affected. More highlighting another issue meaning we are haemorrhaging drs at both ends of their career now

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 17:13

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 16:51

I didnt at any point say consultant salary was a poor. Purely that the figures you quoted are incorrect.

8835 graduated last year and are on that salary. That's not a few
https://www.statista.com/statistics/473206/medical-graduates-in-the-united-kingdom-uk/

If you went through every year of training with no time out or extensions or breaks the earliest you can hit 100k is 40yo

Can't say I know any retiring at 50 cos it would have to be totally self funded given you can't claim your NHS pension that young. Thos retiring early do so because the tax system is not designed for medics and they're getting tens of thousands in tax bills, many I know have had to remortgage to pay them. And funnily enough they don't want to have to pay to work

I didn’t say you said it was poor, I said you said as if it was and that you'd have to work 9+ years as a consultant to earn over 100k when your previous posts were saying lots of colleagues you know are still training and not near consultant wage in their 40s let alone 100k.

So I said I know consultants in their 30s earning at least 88k and rising rapidly. Which allows them to retire in their 50s.

Which many do. If you're earning 80-100k + in your late 30s and then 40s, you have enough savings to put away to enable you to retite even before the fantastic pension kicks in.

I'm not going to feel sorry for Dr's retiring 10-15 years plus before the general population because they have tax bills. Like I said, they come back to do a few shifts locum making 100s of pounds a day to cover that.

I work in psychiatry by the wayl Dr's but the career progression is usually quicker and the retirement ages on savings probably different.

Which is why the view of Dr's salarys like any other role in the NHS, shouldn't be based on the absolute worst of salaries or roles.

Because they apply to the very few.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 16:51

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 15:55

Again. Not seeing what your point is?

You're saying "no-one said every Dr is on that?

This thread is in response to the propaganda put out by the BMA seeking sympathy for their unreasonable pay demand of a 35% increase because 'Dr's are paid £14 an hour which is less than a barista"

That was the marketing strategy which led to this thread. Which had a huge backlash even from BMA members.

I said that was the starting point for F1 Drs in their foundation year in training.

You keep coming back saying virtually all non-consultant Dr's are in training and so are you and you're making £24 an hour.

So you're not a Dr making £14 an hour? Very few are. That was the point of the thread.

That it's propaganda to say "Drs are making £14 an hour" when that means the few Drs not registered with the GMC who just came out of medical school.

And even if you're making £14 or £24 an hour, you are paid extra for unsociable hours like everyone else.

In my hospital trust, anyone working for the NHS for 10 years like you said you almost had, gets 6+ weeks annual leave plus bank holidays in lieu and six months full sick pay, six months half and a pension with 20% employers contributions.

So your hourly rate is in no way comparable to someone in the public sector earning the same.

So it should never be judged on hourly rates.

You're saying consultant starting rates of 88k as if it's something terrible when I know consultants in their mid 30s earning that. They go up to 100k annum quickly and retire at 50/55 on million plus pensions. And come back as locums a day or so a week making hundreds of £ a day.

GP partners often earn similar.

I didnt at any point say consultant salary was a poor. Purely that the figures you quoted are incorrect.

8835 graduated last year and are on that salary. That's not a few
https://www.statista.com/statistics/473206/medical-graduates-in-the-united-kingdom-uk/

If you went through every year of training with no time out or extensions or breaks the earliest you can hit 100k is 40yo

Can't say I know any retiring at 50 cos it would have to be totally self funded given you can't claim your NHS pension that young. Thos retiring early do so because the tax system is not designed for medics and they're getting tens of thousands in tax bills, many I know have had to remortgage to pay them. And funnily enough they don't want to have to pay to work

Medical graduates in the UK 2002-2021 | Statista

In 2021, the number of medical graduates in the United Kingdom remained nearly unchanged at around 8,835 graduates.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/473206/medical-graduates-in-the-united-kingdom-uk

Skybluepinky · 15/04/2023 16:51

It’s obvious they don’t get paid enough nor do nurses hence why lots are leaving to go abroad for double the wages, who could blame them, when Covid hit they took the brunt of the work, annual leave etc was cancelled and they just got on with it.
You can’t compare teachers as they get 13 weeks holiday, don’t spend their days saving lives, and don’t have to do shift work.

ReplGirl · 15/04/2023 16:21

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 09:31

I mean part of me wonders why we fight it so much. Privatisation of the nhs would be a trillion times in drs favour, the pay would soar like in America and your employer gives you free private healthcare.

We fight because we are passionate for free healthcare at the point of delivery and don't want a system like America where people die or are bankrupt from ill health

I mean none of us do this job for the money, if it wasn't my absolute passion to get people through really difficult times of their life, life changing surgery and a good recovery afterwards I'd be long gone as the system treats us like nothing more than a number on a spreadsheet

Well it doesn't have to be either extreme - you could have public health insurance like France.

Passion doesn't pay the bills. And as you can see on this thread, the public just don't get it. Comparing them to cleaners, HGV drivers, social workers, blah2.

The people who have even managed to get into medical school are highly driven, motivated individuals. They have plenty of options for leaving the profession, that pay significantly higher salaries. Consultancy firms, pharma, tech etc it's very possible to be on 80K with pension contributions + bonus by the age of 30. Why would any other professions' salary be relevant to them?

Perhaps 'salary' is not the right lever, maybe open more medical schools, training places etc who think that what they get paid is a huge amount and increase the supply. I think the defining factor of how bad the UK is though, for doctors is that even those from less developed countries who traditionally choose to migrate to the UK are going elsewhere. They don't want to put up with it either, and they are usually more compliant. Source - my family and friends/

SleeplessWB · 15/04/2023 16:00

Pyui · 15/04/2023 10:02

I’m sorry but I hate these races to the bottom. You are not routinely expected to work 9pm-9am!?

Absolutely agree. I am also a teacher and it is hard work, but not comparable in level of study needed or working hours/responsibility to be a doctor.

SadandFed · 15/04/2023 15:55

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 13:40

So what? I can empathise. Noonesaid every dr is on that. I'm on £24ph. I was trying to find a cleaner last week as my life is a mess and couldn't find any asking less than £19ph

No registrar is on 100k that's delusional.

Speciality Dr is a totally different pay scheme as they are neither trainees nor consultants

A consultant starts on 88k. They don't breech 100k until 9 years as a consultant (ie a bare minimum of 18yrs as a Dr, in most cases far more as most don't stick to the 7y speciality training as have enforced gap years to meet registrar entry points

www.bma.org.uk/pay-and-contracts/pay/consultants-pay-scales/pay-scales-for-consultants-in-england

Again. Not seeing what your point is?

You're saying "no-one said every Dr is on that?

This thread is in response to the propaganda put out by the BMA seeking sympathy for their unreasonable pay demand of a 35% increase because 'Dr's are paid £14 an hour which is less than a barista"

That was the marketing strategy which led to this thread. Which had a huge backlash even from BMA members.

I said that was the starting point for F1 Drs in their foundation year in training.

You keep coming back saying virtually all non-consultant Dr's are in training and so are you and you're making £24 an hour.

So you're not a Dr making £14 an hour? Very few are. That was the point of the thread.

That it's propaganda to say "Drs are making £14 an hour" when that means the few Drs not registered with the GMC who just came out of medical school.

And even if you're making £14 or £24 an hour, you are paid extra for unsociable hours like everyone else.

In my hospital trust, anyone working for the NHS for 10 years like you said you almost had, gets 6+ weeks annual leave plus bank holidays in lieu and six months full sick pay, six months half and a pension with 20% employers contributions.

So your hourly rate is in no way comparable to someone in the public sector earning the same.

So it should never be judged on hourly rates.

You're saying consultant starting rates of 88k as if it's something terrible when I know consultants in their mid 30s earning that. They go up to 100k annum quickly and retire at 50/55 on million plus pensions. And come back as locums a day or so a week making hundreds of £ a day.

GP partners often earn similar.

sst1234 · 15/04/2023 15:44

So most people agree. Doctors are highly qualified and probably should be paid more.

Now what? The UK has the weakest economic growth in the G20. Q1 showed economic stagnation. The country is producing less than it did. We just raised corporation and person tax to the point where the tax burden is at a 70 year high.

How are these pay rises going to be paid for?

Ausdoc · 15/04/2023 15:41

Regardless of what outsiders to the profession think, the pay and conditions are clearly insufficient to retain doctors in the country. They can easily leave for places where they're treated better, and will do so in increasing numbers.

I am a junior doctor in Australia, and about 1 in 5 of my colleagues are now from the UK or Ireland. Almost none of them plan to return. We are delighted to have them, and it compensates for some of our own problems with doctor training, but I can't help thinking there must be an utter disaster on the horizon for the UK, with this level of brain drain.

IsGoodIsDon · 15/04/2023 15:35

My DH is a Dr. It took over 10 years to get to 70k and so much stress and constant training for those 10 years and the exams really do cost a lot. Not just exams but also medical insurance and constant membership and registration fees which are not cheap and they have to continue to pay these for the rest of their careers. In addition to the 5 year student loans.
I don’t think you can compare the level of responsibility these Drs have. The stress my DH had of being the only Dr on site covering the premature neonatal unit and having to intubate these babies in the middle of the night or they die. I really don’t feel their requests are unreasonable and it’s scary when I think of the state of the NHS at the moment.

ProfessorLayton1 · 15/04/2023 15:25

NHS has a monopoly in doctors employment. Most professions have a choice in who they work for, if they don't like the terms and conditions they can choose a different employer.

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 15:20

wherethecityis · 15/04/2023 15:03

But so have lots of other professions.
Surely no one expects to be able to afford to start a family the year after graduating? I certainly wouldn't have been able to and I had 8 years of University education.
I also have nowhere near the earning potential of a junior doctor.
Work conditions are awful and I don't blame people for leaving the profession but I think it's that aspect that we should be focusing on. I suspect a lot of doctors would rather keep the same salary and much safer and fairer working conditions, than earn more in their current conditions.

They kinda come together. Need to retain staff and make it appealing for people to join in order to staff the rota adequately to not work crap hours with under 20min break per 12.5h

Destiny123 · 15/04/2023 15:19

MyrrAgain · 15/04/2023 14:51

All spin. They want 35% increase which is a piss take. Doctors used their power to get out of agenda for change payscales that the other nhs oiks have to deal with. Their pay and conditions will progress astronomically compared to all other nhs professions very quickly, so i have no sympathy for sucking up a few years of hardship just like everyone else training to do a profession has to.

As for the payslip comparison from 10-20 years ago and APPARENT little change in pay....please look at the details. The old payslip was from working more than twice the hours. So yes there's little difference to today's payslip but because it's for half the hours!!! All selective "evidence" they are using.

Eh? I work no different hours from 2014 to now. My pay has gone up 13ph since then

Working hours haven't changed since I started as European working time directive has always been in force

wherethecityis · 15/04/2023 15:03

ajenniejonesworld · 15/04/2023 11:44

What do you mean "until their career kicked off"? Are you still struggling to understand that a junior doctor is has had years of education, and that junior doctors include everyone under consultant?

But so have lots of other professions.
Surely no one expects to be able to afford to start a family the year after graduating? I certainly wouldn't have been able to and I had 8 years of University education.
I also have nowhere near the earning potential of a junior doctor.
Work conditions are awful and I don't blame people for leaving the profession but I think it's that aspect that we should be focusing on. I suspect a lot of doctors would rather keep the same salary and much safer and fairer working conditions, than earn more in their current conditions.

MyrrAgain · 15/04/2023 14:51

All spin. They want 35% increase which is a piss take. Doctors used their power to get out of agenda for change payscales that the other nhs oiks have to deal with. Their pay and conditions will progress astronomically compared to all other nhs professions very quickly, so i have no sympathy for sucking up a few years of hardship just like everyone else training to do a profession has to.

As for the payslip comparison from 10-20 years ago and APPARENT little change in pay....please look at the details. The old payslip was from working more than twice the hours. So yes there's little difference to today's payslip but because it's for half the hours!!! All selective "evidence" they are using.