Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone regrets having number 3?

111 replies

everlastinghope · 14/04/2023 18:33

We have 2 dc 5 and 7 obviously things have got easier now they are in school.
We've been thinking a lot about having a 3rd for a while but I'm really undecided.
Is it much harder?
How does your body cope with a 3rd pregnancy?

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 15/04/2023 09:18

everlastinghope · 14/04/2023 18:33

We have 2 dc 5 and 7 obviously things have got easier now they are in school.
We've been thinking a lot about having a 3rd for a while but I'm really undecided.
Is it much harder?
How does your body cope with a 3rd pregnancy?

If you're undecided I personally wouldn't.

KinderCat · 15/04/2023 09:15

Like others a different take as I don't think many parents who have 3 will say they regret it. So coming at this speaking a one of three with nearly identical age differences to yours (please disregard if too far removed to feel relevant to you!) I love my brothers but wish my mum had not had all 3 of us. My little brother is great, but was poorly as a baby/child and that ate into my parents time a lot. Even as a child I could pick up that we saw much less of them and that created unfair resentment that children can't really grasp. Likewise, time was spread very thin and as one sibling did GCSEs the other was being investigated for SEN needs in primary which meant lots of little things for the the third slipping through the cracks as both parents also had to work as well. I just wanted to give a little balance to this.

Copasetic · 15/04/2023 09:03

Definitely not planned but def no regrets. My eldest two are DD28 and DD20 (at uni) and not living at home and our lives are so much more full and fun having DS12 at home and totally different to how our lives would have been without him.

QueenOfDuisburg · 15/04/2023 08:58

Everyone will have a different experience. My third really was the perfect final piece to our family. Easiest pregnancy and birth, older two siblings adored her from day 1 (only a 5 and 3 year age gap but they have always instinctively thought it their role to help look after and protect her).

Things are pricier but there are often ways around this. Holidays, we avoid packages and book flights and accommodation separately and always find much cheaper options. Hotels are hard but rooms for 5 do exist, or we book two cheap rooms and split up for the night. More bedrooms needed but we rearranged the layout of our existing house to make that work.

If we hadn't had a third we would definitely have spent the rest of our lives regretting it - I'm not sure the urge would have gone away!

mistermagpie · 15/04/2023 08:54

I have three and no regrets!

Mine are 3, 6 and 7 and to be honest we wouldn't have gone for a third of the gap was going to be much bigger. I just wouldn't have wanted to revisit the baby stage once the oldest two were at school. None of mine were at school when the youngest was born (and it was lockdown) so that bit was tough, but I'm glad we went for it.

I didn't find age was a factor, I was 39 when my third was born, but health and fitness probably is. I'm a lot fitter than I was in my 20s, so running around after three children is fine for me whereas I have friends in their 40s who find young children a struggle.

The major downside is holidays. We don't go abroad anyway, but even in the uk so many places are set up for families of four and it can be quite costly to get a balance big enough for five. Honestly, that's my only complaint though!

MyFaceIsAnAONB · 15/04/2023 08:52

Mine are 5, nearly 8 and 1, so similar to you.

Never ever regret our 3rd, she is heaven and a delight and the older ones utterly adore her. So nice having the whole week with just her while the boys are at school.

School holidays have been mad and it’s a conscious priority to make sure everyone gets enough attention.

And ‘all’ feels much more than ‘both’. All the kids are ill, all the kids are grumpy, all the kids need to be in different places, for example.

I found 2 kids very easy and fun and calm but I had that visceral NEED for a 3rd. So I’d say don’t do it unless you have that need.

The ‘complete’ feeling is lovely and the vasectomy is booked in!

tvbed · 15/04/2023 08:49

I wouldn't say regret because I absolutely adore no3.
However I know if I knew what life was going to be like I wouldn't have had a third. It turns out all 3 are very high maintenance. Life is much harder than it would have been with 2. I have less time and energy to devote to them. I have less money and less earning potential. There's more washing, more worry and more expense. I love my family and obviously wouldn't ever want to be without no3 but I wouldn't recommend 3 to someone else. When/if my children have babies I hope they don't decide to have 3!

teacakesforbreakfast · 15/04/2023 08:34

"Regrets" isn't quite the right word, but DH sees some serious downsides to his parents having decided to have a third. He is 7 years older than that sibling and found it really changed the family dynamic/relationships and still affects them now.

SylvanianFrenemies · 15/04/2023 08:30

I regret trying for a third. 4 losses in a row including a tfmr and a missed miscarriage was hard going. We left it too late - I was 40 when we started trying. I would consider potential impact of age.

We are happy with our 2 now.

GetYourActTogether1 · 15/04/2023 08:21

I think a big factor is the age you were you had your last DC, I had my 3rd when I was 31 and didn’t find it at all difficult. By the time I was late 40’s I had 2 DC at uni and one DC had permanently left home and was working. Now I’m mid 50’s and there’s nothing I enjoy more than having my whole ‘gang’ over for Sunday lunch.

safetyfreak · 15/04/2023 08:13

We have decided to stop at 2 but yes, I still think what if...but I know we would struggle mentally and financially with a third extra mouth to feed etc. They get more expensive as they get older!

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 08:10

Number three is a blessing. Good tempered, kind, thoughtful, lovable, clever, sporty. No regrets here.

What’s right for me might not be right for you though.

SmallGoddess · 15/04/2023 08:08

Not exactly regret but my life would be very different without number 3 who has autism and serious mental health problems. I fear that he will be a burden on his siblings when I am gone. 😥

Hopper123 · 15/04/2023 07:59

I have three, all my pregnancies were rubbish not just the third so to me it was normal, third labour was horrible and the most painful........But I don't regret a single moment or thing I couldn't imagine life without him and things are getting easier now he's 2 and beginning to understand and be understood much more. It is tough and there are days when I long for two minutes to myself. Things definitely cost more, for example most hotels won't let you book just 1 room (although sometimes we can get away with just sneaking him in but another couple years and we prob won't get away with that so it's double. We had to buy a 7 seater because of the blooming massive car seats and wanting everyone to be comfortable on long journeys as they get older. So there are financial mplications and friends who have just one baby at the moment don't always understand that a trip out where their just paying for two adults and a one year old costs us waaaay more but I'm not trying to be negative just honest. At the end of the day if you have a third they will be your baby and you will cherish and love them just as much as the first. In my experience the difficulties and stresses are worth it and somehow you muddle through and just make it work adapting to your new situation.

Doingmybest12 · 15/04/2023 07:58

No regret but did feel I was a bit stuck when friends with 2 moved on to the next stage, like I was still trudging to primary school for another couple of years . That sort of thing, bit of a twinge that things could have been easier. But no no regrets.

Beseen22 · 15/04/2023 07:54

I have 6 and 3 yo and wanted a 3rd and after a long while had a miscarriage. Feel a lot of resentment that it's never happened for us and a lot of sadness about that loss but as the kids get older and easier starting to think it might just be better to stick with the two. We can afford them comfortably, they are best friends, manage childcare well, I can move on with my career. Most of it comes from my entire 20s spent TTC and being so miserable at how unsuccessful that was most of the time, not sure I can put myself through that in my 30s. I'm very lucky to have the two I have and we are so happy with them.

BHRK · 15/04/2023 07:53

Zero regrets here (and this is an honest opinion!). The early days are hard but my god, when I see the 3 of them playing together or cuddling up on the sofa, my heart could burst. I love having a large family, wouldn’t have wanted just 2

CalpolDependant · 15/04/2023 07:48

My third was an excruciating 120 hour labour that ended in a crash C. But I don’t regret it for the world!

My elder two are 8 and 10 so it was a massive step back to the nappy stage. You don’t really ruminate on it, you just get on. Ours was a surprise baby after I lost a coil. Heaven knows where it ended up. The water treatment facility I suppose. Anyway, husband is paying for the snip in June. 😂

JeepersCreeperrs · 15/04/2023 07:45

My friend does. She had the same age gap as you and she said she should have left well alone. Things were getting easier and now it’s so hard. Youngest doesn’t sleep, doesn’t have anyone to play with as the older two have eachother and aren’t interested in baby games. She said it’s so on her. She’s also older now and found the pregnancy really tough and finds the busyness of it all now harder.

ginlovingqueen · 15/04/2023 07:44

How can you regret your own child?

Silly question really

Sceptre86 · 15/04/2023 07:42

How old you are and how your general health is will likely impact on whether your body can cope. Do I regret it? Nope. I was 34 when she was born and it was my 3 emcs. The recovery was rougher but dh was entitled to 6 weeks paternity and had carried over 2 weeks leave which really helped. He did all nights with her for that time. I had batch cooked for those early weeks and when my mum came to visit she stocked my freezer with meals for us too.

I have dd1 who is 7, ds 5 (nearly 6) and dd2 19 months. She's a dream, I adapted really well because she slept through from 3 months. I'm so much more relaxed this time around and enjoy her. Ds was in his final year of preschool when she was born which meant I got one on one time with her whilst he was there. She would usually be napping when he came home so he got one on one time with me and then I got that time with dd1 when the other two were in bed. It worked out really well. I'm still in the early stages, appreciate that things may well get harder when they are all teenagers etc.

PatChaunceysFruitCake · 15/04/2023 07:41

TwistofFate · 15/04/2023 03:48

Slightly different take, I don't know any parents who regret having a third child but I can think of several adults (all unrelated) with 2 siblings who all stopped at 2 children (or less) for a variety of reasons from financial circumstances, housing and cars, worrying they wouldn't be able to give each child enough attention or that siblings would be too competitive.

It's such a personal decision, ultimately I think you have to decide what you'd regret most.

I'm one of three and my siblings and I are all perfectly happy with two DC (albeit one sister has a stepson).

I can give you my perspective as you've said you want things to think about....

There's a big gap as my sister and I were 10 and 8 when baby sister was born. It was hard as my mum was ill with the pregnancy and then the baby needed a lot of attention. I'm giving you the perspective of a child here but we struggled with attention being diverted and there were some things we enjoyed doing that either didn't happen or happened very infrequently once my sister had to be factored in.

Ultimately my parents divorced and I found that really tough so some of my memories are biased as they are bound up with the separation.

We are definitely the vision of a three child family as adults though. The big gap between sister3 and I has closed as we had our first DC at the same time. We are all close and the cousins are a dream together. It was hard when we were younger though which is why none of us would contemplate a third / big gap.

Daffodilwoman · 15/04/2023 07:38

No regrets from me. However mine were much closer in age and would have been much closer if I had got pregnant straight away. I’m not sure if I would have like such a big age gap as you have.
It is expensive but we did without things, that’s how life is.
From people I know who’s siblings are 7 year plus age gap they are not close, none of them, so that’s something to consider. Labour was no harder or easier. I ended up having an epidural and was told after hours of labouring to prepare for a c section.
I don’t regret having 3 but there again I really, really wanted a third so that makes a difference. I was also under 35.

SmallbutMighty1 · 15/04/2023 07:35

I'll let you know 😅 DSs 3 and 21m and number 3 arriving in Aug ❤️

TheaBrandt · 15/04/2023 07:32

And the young child stage wears off now I’m late 40s I want to be doing my own thing which coincides nicely with teens wanting independence. Personally I would hate it if I were still hanging round the primary school doing crafts and play dates etc But some parents love that and I used to but moved on.