Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
StephanieSuperpowers · 16/04/2023 17:51

postapesto · 16/04/2023 15:59

Great Britain has never at any time included Ireland.

Or been especially interested in making sure Ireland benefits in any situation. Although it's gently amusing that the poster imagines there's a nurturing instinct in the UK towards Ireland.

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 17:45

13Bastards · 16/04/2023 17:24

I saw a brilliant Tripadvisor review of an English pub LampLamp where an American tourist had marked it down because it was playing 'modern pop music' as opposed to 'traditional English or Irish folk music'

Firstly, WTF is that and secondly, why would a typical British pub play that kind of music? It's absolutely like they want a theme park, not a country. And that's just the uk I feel for Ireland as I am sure they get it a whole lot worse.

Ireland gets it a lot worse but we monetise the f*ck out of it!

13Bastards · 16/04/2023 17:24

I saw a brilliant Tripadvisor review of an English pub LampLamp where an American tourist had marked it down because it was playing 'modern pop music' as opposed to 'traditional English or Irish folk music'

Firstly, WTF is that and secondly, why would a typical British pub play that kind of music? It's absolutely like they want a theme park, not a country. And that's just the uk I feel for Ireland as I am sure they get it a whole lot worse.

belleager · 16/04/2023 16:42

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 16:29

Does anyone drink Harp anymore 🤣

It's still popular in the North I thought?

Not the same for the rest of us without Vicki Michelle, non

Sally O'Brien Harp Lager TV Ad

And Sally O'Brien... and the way she might look at ya..

https://youtu.be/kbzFy8CGqcU

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 16:29

LampLamp · 15/04/2023 17:27

Yes they are racists (and I agree re Facebook - I’m no longer on it), plain and simple.

A long with that example goes the others I’ve mentioned where Irish Americans want to keep what they see as Irish traditions alive in their American communities but begrudge actual Irish people moving forward and modernising.

I was in Cavan last week having a drink with a few friends and family friends came across an “Irish American” group who were astonished that none of us were drinking Guinness or Harp. FFS.

They want to keep us as a quaint wee theme park.

Does anyone drink Harp anymore 🤣

belleager · 16/04/2023 16:27

postapesto · 16/04/2023 16:14

I think the vast majority of us couldn't give a shiny shit and a small minority were merely a bit pissed off about the road closures.
I'm sure some people were delighted/annoyed/homicidal about it all, but I wouldn't know why.

Sorry - the end of my reply was to TizerorFizz, on UK thinking Ireland didn't get much from the visit. I wondered what they had in mind. But agree for most private individuals it wasn't a major event, or meant to be.

I was just agreeing with your response to re Ireland not part of Great Britain, ever. It is funny that a thread with so much discussion of what Irish Americans can call themselves throws up the usual confusion about what Great Britain means anyway.

postapesto · 16/04/2023 16:14

I think the vast majority of us couldn't give a shiny shit and a small minority were merely a bit pissed off about the road closures.
I'm sure some people were delighted/annoyed/homicidal about it all, but I wouldn't know why.

belleager · 16/04/2023 16:09

postapesto · 16/04/2023 15:59

Great Britain has never at any time included Ireland.

Quite.

It's also very reasonable to see Irish and American independence movements as intertwined.

I haven't seen any analysis in British media of what Ireland got or expected from Biden's visit, but if you have any facts or thoughts to share, feel free. You'd need to know what Irish participants wanted, to start with.

belleager · 16/04/2023 16:03

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 15:55

This thread is getting ridiculous.
Biden came to Ireland, he has Irish heritage which he is proud about, he talked about it.
Most Irish people were delighted to see him and happy he considers himself Irish (we understand what it means when an American says they are Irish, this is a part of American culture which we are very familiar with and understand).
He went home to America.

(Fortunately, none of the determined literalists on this thread popped up as border guards, demanded to see his ID, and detained him for questioning. How did airport security manage such complex thinking? It's a mystery. Wrapped up in an enigma, no doubt).

postapesto · 16/04/2023 15:59

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 15:54

I guess when you are a young country, your original identity means more? Feels a bit clingy though for a country that fought a war of independence to get away from Great Britain which, at the time, included Ireland.

Not sure many of us in the uk truly believe Ireland got much out of Biden.

Great Britain has never at any time included Ireland.

belleager · 16/04/2023 15:58

ilikepinknblue · 16/04/2023 15:55

You are expecting rest of the world to understand American lingo Irish = American Irish. Why not Americans talk to rest of the world in the language they understand, Irish = from Ireland. American with Irish roots = exactly that.

Seems fair for Americans to speak to other Americans in terms they understand, and for Irish Americans to speak to Irish people in terms they understand.

What has this got to do with the rest of the world? I don't switch on French TV and get cross that they're not explaining things to me in English!

ilikepinknblue · 16/04/2023 15:55

Anonymous48 · 14/04/2023 16:29

What I'm saying is that they don't understand (or refuse to acknowledge) that saying "I'm Irish" (or whatever) is shorthand for "I'm Irish American" or "I have Irish ancestry". That is not claiming to be "from Ireland".

You are expecting rest of the world to understand American lingo Irish = American Irish. Why not Americans talk to rest of the world in the language they understand, Irish = from Ireland. American with Irish roots = exactly that.

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 15:55

This thread is getting ridiculous.
Biden came to Ireland, he has Irish heritage which he is proud about, he talked about it.
Most Irish people were delighted to see him and happy he considers himself Irish (we understand what it means when an American says they are Irish, this is a part of American culture which we are very familiar with and understand).
He went home to America.

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 15:54

I guess when you are a young country, your original identity means more? Feels a bit clingy though for a country that fought a war of independence to get away from Great Britain which, at the time, included Ireland.

Not sure many of us in the uk truly believe Ireland got much out of Biden.

belleager · 16/04/2023 15:49

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 15:47

Once we put in the effort to understanding each other, instead of banging on about people being strange or wrong (because obviously we are Right), that's a great thing.

@belleager And it makes life much more interesting and pleasant as well!

There is obviously a lot of anti-American sentiment on MN, which is fine (it is a UK-centric site after all). My only objection is that so many posters have deeply entrenched views about Americans based on something they saw on Facebook or YouTube, etc. Or if they want to back-up a claim they'll (rather conveniently) come up with an anecdote about an American who didn't know Spanish was spoken in Spain🙄

You just can't make sweeping generalizations about 350 Million+ people based on social media posts or anecdotal encounters.

As to the matter at hand....

UK posters: If an American tells you they're Italian and you're curious, ask them if they were born and raised in Italy. Mystery solved!

American Posters: Don't go to Poland and complain that they're not making the pierogi the way your Babci in Chicopee, MA does. They will laugh at you😀

Now that we've smoothed out international relations, I'm going to head out to the beach as it's a glorious day here and there's a beach chair calling my name!

Hope everyone enjoys their day (not being facetious!)

Yes, that about covers it. Enjoy your day!

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 15:48

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 15:47

Once we put in the effort to understanding each other, instead of banging on about people being strange or wrong (because obviously we are Right), that's a great thing.

@belleager And it makes life much more interesting and pleasant as well!

There is obviously a lot of anti-American sentiment on MN, which is fine (it is a UK-centric site after all). My only objection is that so many posters have deeply entrenched views about Americans based on something they saw on Facebook or YouTube, etc. Or if they want to back-up a claim they'll (rather conveniently) come up with an anecdote about an American who didn't know Spanish was spoken in Spain🙄

You just can't make sweeping generalizations about 350 Million+ people based on social media posts or anecdotal encounters.

As to the matter at hand....

UK posters: If an American tells you they're Italian and you're curious, ask them if they were born and raised in Italy. Mystery solved!

American Posters: Don't go to Poland and complain that they're not making the pierogi the way your Babci in Chicopee, MA does. They will laugh at you😀

Now that we've smoothed out international relations, I'm going to head out to the beach as it's a glorious day here and there's a beach chair calling my name!

Hope everyone enjoys their day (not being facetious!)

Sanity!

I will grab my towel! 😂

belleager · 16/04/2023 15:47

IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 15:44

Understanding that some Americans describe themselves as 'Irish' while only having distant links with Ireland is not at all the same thing as that practice being part of 'Irish culture', any more than the fact that many Italians understand the similarly tenuous use of the word 'Italian' by some Americans means that the practice is part of 'Italian culture'. I understand lots of cultural practices from other parts of the world, but that certainly doesn't mean I share them.

Your claim that this practice is part of 'Irish culture' is just not true.

You're misquoting me there - I've said what I mean on this point

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 15:47

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 11:15

Who said he hates the UK?

The jist of what people are talking about is Biden having some Irish Great-Great Grandparents who emigrated to the US in the 19th century and he's claiming to be/feel Irish and that visiting Co. Mayo feels like "coming home" and the Taoiseach describing him as the "most Irish of all the American presidents" which is factually incorrect as just an example, President Andrew Jackson was born in the US to Irish parents who migrated to the US from Ireland a few years before he was born. It's a hell of a stretch to suggest anyone who has Irish Great-Great Grandparents is Irish in any way. Biden is an American with Irish ancestry almost 200 years back.

JFK did the same thing in 1963 eulogising about his Irishness when he had closer Irish ancestry than Biden but still Great-Grandparents so not that close. It's PR and the American sentimentality shared by descendants of Irish migrants which influences voting. To the point Bill Clinton even claimed to have Irish ancestry despite there being no evidence of it. Though Clinton did play a great role in the Good Friday Agreement and was inducted into the Irish-American hall of fame. Despite no evidence he has Irish ancestry.

This feels to me that you have little understanding of American culture.

Americans identify themselves this way.

There are 300 million or so of them! We need to acceot it.

We don't have to like it but we need to accept it.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 15:47

Once we put in the effort to understanding each other, instead of banging on about people being strange or wrong (because obviously we are Right), that's a great thing.

@belleager And it makes life much more interesting and pleasant as well!

There is obviously a lot of anti-American sentiment on MN, which is fine (it is a UK-centric site after all). My only objection is that so many posters have deeply entrenched views about Americans based on something they saw on Facebook or YouTube, etc. Or if they want to back-up a claim they'll (rather conveniently) come up with an anecdote about an American who didn't know Spanish was spoken in Spain🙄

You just can't make sweeping generalizations about 350 Million+ people based on social media posts or anecdotal encounters.

As to the matter at hand....

UK posters: If an American tells you they're Italian and you're curious, ask them if they were born and raised in Italy. Mystery solved!

American Posters: Don't go to Poland and complain that they're not making the pierogi the way your Babci in Chicopee, MA does. They will laugh at you😀

Now that we've smoothed out international relations, I'm going to head out to the beach as it's a glorious day here and there's a beach chair calling my name!

Hope everyone enjoys their day (not being facetious!)

belleager · 16/04/2023 15:46

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 15:35

@4plusthehound The Irish people are not the “useful idiots”. It’s the heirarchy who think it’s ok to be used for American purposes. Biden spent ages in Ireland doing nothing useful at all. Mainly because he’s a lightweight.

I can assure you that the Irish politicians involved got plenty out of this for their own agendas - looking at you, Michael Ring! - even before considering what other benefits Biden's visit may bring them.

One small example. There's been a surge in American tourist bookings coinciding with Biden's visit. And Irish tourism is set up to offer them what he got - genealogical enquiries, reflection on emigrant experience.

You think all that's happening at these events is speeches for the cameras? Ireland is a small open economy, gateway to the EU. Great stuff for us to have a US president, whether he'll be re-elected or not, happy to run an ad for the place. Irish politicians are professionals at this stuff.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 15:44

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 15:35

@4plusthehound The Irish people are not the “useful idiots”. It’s the heirarchy who think it’s ok to be used for American purposes. Biden spent ages in Ireland doing nothing useful at all. Mainly because he’s a lightweight.

Of COURSE the Irish are not "useful idiots".

I started my post by pointing out (to a different poster) that the implication they made that Biden is using the Irish as useful idiots" is deprecating.

IHas I used quotes as you did my meaning would have been clearer - I get into a lot of trouble with my bad grammar and spelling!

IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 15:44

belleager · 16/04/2023 15:37

No, that's not my point. Irish people would not normally describe themselves in this way in relation to their descent from another nationality.

But they would understand - often from ties of kinship - what Irish-Americans would mean when they describe themselves as Irish in this sense. Because the Irish-American culture is formed from a long shared history between the two nations.

Understanding that some Americans describe themselves as 'Irish' while only having distant links with Ireland is not at all the same thing as that practice being part of 'Irish culture', any more than the fact that many Italians understand the similarly tenuous use of the word 'Italian' by some Americans means that the practice is part of 'Italian culture'. I understand lots of cultural practices from other parts of the world, but that certainly doesn't mean I share them.

Your claim that this practice is part of 'Irish culture' is just not true.

belleager · 16/04/2023 15:37

IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 15:26

It is not in Irish culture.

A person from Dublin who had some great grandparents from, for example, Germany, would never describe themselves as German. They would describe themselves as Irish. Which is what they are.

No, that's not my point. Irish people would not normally describe themselves in this way in relation to their descent from another nationality.

But they would understand - often from ties of kinship - what Irish-Americans would mean when they describe themselves as Irish in this sense. Because the Irish-American culture is formed from a long shared history between the two nations.

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 15:35

@4plusthehound The Irish people are not the “useful idiots”. It’s the heirarchy who think it’s ok to be used for American purposes. Biden spent ages in Ireland doing nothing useful at all. Mainly because he’s a lightweight.

belleager · 16/04/2023 15:33

postapesto · 16/04/2023 15:08

If he has an Italian parent, he can call hinself Italian. His grandchildren can't though.

Would his grandchildren not be entitled to Italian citizenship? I thought Italy had no generational limit on dual citizenship, so long as births registered appropriately?

This sort of law obviously encourages continued identification with an international heritage.