Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
FurAndFeathers · 17/04/2023 05:31

Florenz · 16/04/2023 23:56

America would be better off if they hadn't fought the war of independence, if they'd gained independence through peaceful means like Canada and Australia and other countries did, and were still part of the British commonwealth.

Better off in what way?

FurAndFeathers · 17/04/2023 05:29

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 23:35

Ok: Great Britain snd Ireland. We ruled you. Happy now? As we ruled America. It’s still odd to me that an American is desperate to be seen as Irish when America fought to be free of Great Britain and Ireland and its king and its taxes. I guess they 100% managed it though.

Grim

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 17/04/2023 01:01

Florenz · 16/04/2023 23:56

America would be better off if they hadn't fought the war of independence, if they'd gained independence through peaceful means like Canada and Australia and other countries did, and were still part of the British commonwealth.

😬

The whole point was not being part of the Commonwealth though!

Itsanewnameeveryday · 17/04/2023 00:58

Swiftbushome · 14/04/2023 15:56

Biden calling himself Irish is bloody ridiculous. He's 4th generation American with 1 side of his family having Irish heritagem he's not bloody Irish. It's nonsense. By the same token I'm either Welsh or Caribean

I’ve found some Australians & Americans prejudiced against Catholics and / or Irish people.
I’m 50 now and this was particularly notable with people of older generations.
I have an Irish surname even through my family are a mix of French Hugenots, Scottish, English and German.
When I started my first job in a private hospital it was extremely common for older people to pass comment like some sort of gotcha moment.
I see Biden saying I’m Irish as actually politely saying “yes I’m Catholic, what’s it to you”. It was the same with the Kennedy’s.

MissConductUS · 17/04/2023 00:58

Florenz · 16/04/2023 23:56

America would be better off if they hadn't fought the war of independence, if they'd gained independence through peaceful means like Canada and Australia and other countries did, and were still part of the British commonwealth.

Are you basing this dubious conclusion on the assumption that the revolutionary war was so costly that America would have been better off enduring another century or so of British taxes and exploitation?

There would have been a much better chance of this happening if George III hadn't been such a nutter.

belleager · 17/04/2023 00:02

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 23:35

Ok: Great Britain snd Ireland. We ruled you. Happy now? As we ruled America. It’s still odd to me that an American is desperate to be seen as Irish when America fought to be free of Great Britain and Ireland and its king and its taxes. I guess they 100% managed it though.

To understand this, you need to know that both Ireland and America rebelled against British rule in the 1700s - some ideas shared with the French Revolution. It took longer for Ireland to gain independence than America, but these 18th century rebellions were still a reference point for the founders of the Irish state and their American supporters.

That's why there's no contradiction in embracing the values of the American Revolution and valuing an Irish heritage.

That is one of the facts Biden was referencing with his discussion of shared values. Most Irish people would have understood that - and he went through some of the history briefly anyway.

Florenz · 16/04/2023 23:56

America would be better off if they hadn't fought the war of independence, if they'd gained independence through peaceful means like Canada and Australia and other countries did, and were still part of the British commonwealth.

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 23:44

State of you.

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 23:43

You didn't 'rule' us we don't accept that and we never will. Urgh.

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 23:39

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 23:35

Ok: Great Britain snd Ireland. We ruled you. Happy now? As we ruled America. It’s still odd to me that an American is desperate to be seen as Irish when America fought to be free of Great Britain and Ireland and its king and its taxes. I guess they 100% managed it though.

Argh. You ruled us? Ffs.

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 23:35

Ok: Great Britain snd Ireland. We ruled you. Happy now? As we ruled America. It’s still odd to me that an American is desperate to be seen as Irish when America fought to be free of Great Britain and Ireland and its king and its taxes. I guess they 100% managed it though.

belleager · 16/04/2023 20:57

I couldn't see why you'd consider Americans any more or less parochial than anyone else.

FurAndFeathers · 16/04/2023 20:50

belleager · 16/04/2023 20:08

I can't think of a nation this doesn't apply to - the parochial perspective, that is.

I don’t really understand your point?

FurAndFeathers · 16/04/2023 20:48

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 20:04

That's really snooty.

Snooty - synonyms include disapproving.
Am I disapproving of parochial attitudes and an inability to see perspectives other than your own? Yes very likely I am.

I’m also pretty comfortable with that position

belleager · 16/04/2023 20:22

I'm Irish but if I moved to America I'd be delighted to have the social and cultural support of Irish-America. I would enjoy mixing with my new Irish friends there, as well as with other Americans.

belleager · 16/04/2023 20:14

I haven't seen any Americans on this thread insisting theirs is the only proper perspective. Only anecdotes about particular Americans.

It's not Americans who are posting here to say they can't understand other people having their own descriptors around culture and identity; or that even if they accept these differences, that we should remember that the Irish / Americans are wrong / naive in other ways. It all seems quite intolerant.

belleager · 16/04/2023 20:08

IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 20:05

I find it interesting that people from a nation that clings so desperately to its global heritage often have such a parochial perspective

I agree with this.

I can't think of a nation this doesn't apply to - the parochial perspective, that is.

IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 20:05

I find it interesting that people from a nation that clings so desperately to its global heritage often have such a parochial perspective

I agree with this.

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 20:04

FurAndFeathers · 16/04/2023 20:02

Thanks, yes I am aware of this. It’s why I raised the point Confused

It still stands though that there are a proportion of Americans whose identity is so enmeshed in their historical heritage that they’re unable to fathom a different perspective e.g that Irish is not equivalent to Irish -American globally, or that African-American isn’t a global term for any black person.

I find it interesting that people from a nation that clings so desperately to its global heritage often have such a parochial perspective

That's really snooty.

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 20:02

I'm Irish. Just plain boring Irish. I wouldn't ever choose to be anything else. Equally i don't diss americans or brits who are 'irish'. Why would I? They love us we welcome them. We can all get along.

FurAndFeathers · 16/04/2023 20:02

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/04/2023 14:20

There's a cultural difference between the UK and US on this, obviously.
In the UK, anyone with citizenship is considered British and it's bad form to ask where someone is from. If you ask a black person in Britain where they are from, they are probably going to say "London" and get annoyed with any further probing, even if their parents were born elsewhere. The idea of a black British person being called African, unless they were actually born there and have current citizenship there, is laughable and has racist undertones. Yet in America, even black people who were imported as slaves 200 years ago and have no link with Africa whatsoever are called African American.
For white British people with a British accent, if someone asks where you're from, they mean what town did you grow up in. They'd be surprised if you came out with any family history.

Thanks, yes I am aware of this. It’s why I raised the point Confused

It still stands though that there are a proportion of Americans whose identity is so enmeshed in their historical heritage that they’re unable to fathom a different perspective e.g that Irish is not equivalent to Irish -American globally, or that African-American isn’t a global term for any black person.

I find it interesting that people from a nation that clings so desperately to its global heritage often have such a parochial perspective

Goldenbear · 16/04/2023 19:48

Insistent not insist.

Goldenbear · 16/04/2023 19:46

Sandinmyknickers · 16/04/2023 18:53

Yeah and do I find it hard to understand that "I'm irish" is shorthand for Irish American, when they say the full "African American" all the bloody time. So much so in fact that when in the states wih my ex, they kept referring to him as "African american" and he had to keep saying that he was neither, he was British with a Caribbean heritage and family, and they could just call him Black if easier...but they'd still insist on calling him "African american" as if they couldn't contemplate black people living outside of those identities. Facepalm.

Other Posters have mentioned this now so not exactly a one off and yet some of us are being told how intolerant we are of American culture that dictates the, 'I am Irish' being a cultural norm that the British (Aka English, with that being the English persona of 50 years ago, aka the quintessential English man because of course nobody who is English has anything other than an anglo Saxon heritage 🙄) in their imperialist fashion insists doesn't exist and yet Americans are also insist their references are the only ones - funny that!

Sandinmyknickers · 16/04/2023 18:53

MasterBeth · 14/04/2023 16:29

To the rest of the world, saying "I'm Irish" means "I'm Irish".

It can often feel to the rest of the world that Americans are talking to us as if we are all American.

Yeah and do I find it hard to understand that "I'm irish" is shorthand for Irish American, when they say the full "African American" all the bloody time. So much so in fact that when in the states wih my ex, they kept referring to him as "African american" and he had to keep saying that he was neither, he was British with a Caribbean heritage and family, and they could just call him Black if easier...but they'd still insist on calling him "African american" as if they couldn't contemplate black people living outside of those identities. Facepalm.

Swiftbushome · 16/04/2023 18:42

Chinese/Vietnamese/Jamaican/Pakistani etc would have the same attitude if a person with a great grandparent came to visit their country, they'd probably be warm and welcoming. That in itself is quite telling.

This is not my experience actually. I am 2nd generation British with heritage from one of these. Lived there (ancestral home country) with family for a while as a youngster and was not accepted at all. 100% treated as an outsider with a lot of racist aggression. Just saying.