Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Whalesong · 17/04/2023 18:09

postapesto · 17/04/2023 16:39

Thank you for explaining to an Irish person, living in Ireland, how Irish people felt about what happened in Ireland this week.

No seriously, we really do need non Irish people who are not in Ireland to do that for us. You're so kind. go raibh maith agat

I'm sure not everyone in Ireland had the same reaction, and no, I'm not Irish. But a lot of my in-laws, our cousins, other relatives and friends, of all generations, who are also Irish people living in Ireland, reported very differently. You clearly had a different experience to them - doesn't make their views any less valid than yours (or vice versa of course).
Our family and friends range from farmers to a professional rugby player, students, teachers and hospital consultants, so an eclectic social mix. They are in Dublin, Sligo, Mayo, Galway, Cork and Waterford btw, so not a regional thing either.

DdraigGoch · 17/04/2023 17:49

13Bastards · 16/04/2023 17:24

I saw a brilliant Tripadvisor review of an English pub LampLamp where an American tourist had marked it down because it was playing 'modern pop music' as opposed to 'traditional English or Irish folk music'

Firstly, WTF is that and secondly, why would a typical British pub play that kind of music? It's absolutely like they want a theme park, not a country. And that's just the uk I feel for Ireland as I am sure they get it a whole lot worse.

That reminds me of the airport in the US which was piping bagpipe music through the PA "because everyone's Irish on St Patrick's Day!"

The tune? Scotland the Brave.

Chickenkeev · 17/04/2023 17:38

postapesto · 17/04/2023 17:22

We're not really. You and I can discuss whether we liked the visit, and what the mood of the country was. Mrs "My husband said that the whole country was dancing a jig" can feck off for herself though. That's the point.

Ah yeah, fair enough. I did enjoy it (but can't dance a jig alas).

postapesto · 17/04/2023 17:22

We're not really. You and I can discuss whether we liked the visit, and what the mood of the country was. Mrs "My husband said that the whole country was dancing a jig" can feck off for herself though. That's the point.

Chickenkeev · 17/04/2023 17:16

postapesto · 17/04/2023 16:56

Of course we can, but we really don't need someone who wasn't here and isn't Irish telling us that we are wrong, do we? Telling us how the whole country felt? No, thanks.

We're going around in circles here a bit. We don't need anyone to tell us what to think or to patronise us. Equally we're free to enjoy the visit. Or not enjoy it. Free society and all that. I liked it tho.

postapesto · 17/04/2023 16:56

Chickenkeev · 17/04/2023 16:50

I'm Irish living in Ireland. I enjoyed the visit. We can have different perspectives.

Of course we can, but we really don't need someone who wasn't here and isn't Irish telling us that we are wrong, do we? Telling us how the whole country felt? No, thanks.

Chickenkeev · 17/04/2023 16:50

postapesto · 17/04/2023 16:39

Thank you for explaining to an Irish person, living in Ireland, how Irish people felt about what happened in Ireland this week.

No seriously, we really do need non Irish people who are not in Ireland to do that for us. You're so kind. go raibh maith agat

I'm Irish living in Ireland. I enjoyed the visit. We can have different perspectives.

postapesto · 17/04/2023 16:39

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 16:37

According to my Irish husband, his family and our friends over there, as well as Irish media, they very much cared. Lots of lovely reports of him meeting various people, including requesting to meet a now retired priest, who formerly acted as a chaplain in the US army, and actually gave Biden's son his last rites. There were many emotional accounts about that and other encounters. All reduced by British media to "dressing up as a leprechaun, dancing and drinking Guinness" - none of which he did (Biden is a teetotaller, for starters).

But mostly, Ireland understands the value of the outspoken support it gets from the US and many other countries, in the face of the UK's bonkers behaviour over the NI protocol. Most Brits don't realise that the whole of the UK is held completely to ransom by a very small minority of Unionists in NI. This is one important reason why Brexit is such a mess - as those who understood the implications warned would happen (but it was dismissed as Project Fear). The EU stands fully behind Ireland, and both the EU and Ireland have a much closer relationship with the US, despite the so-called "Special Relationship" that the UK claims to have with the US.

Thank you for explaining to an Irish person, living in Ireland, how Irish people felt about what happened in Ireland this week.

No seriously, we really do need non Irish people who are not in Ireland to do that for us. You're so kind. go raibh maith agat

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 16:37

postapesto · 17/04/2023 15:07

To be fair, most of Ireland just didn't care. Not proud, not offended. Just vaguely bemused and wondering why someone taped black bin bags over the bins in part of Dublin for the arrival of Joe.

According to my Irish husband, his family and our friends over there, as well as Irish media, they very much cared. Lots of lovely reports of him meeting various people, including requesting to meet a now retired priest, who formerly acted as a chaplain in the US army, and actually gave Biden's son his last rites. There were many emotional accounts about that and other encounters. All reduced by British media to "dressing up as a leprechaun, dancing and drinking Guinness" - none of which he did (Biden is a teetotaller, for starters).

But mostly, Ireland understands the value of the outspoken support it gets from the US and many other countries, in the face of the UK's bonkers behaviour over the NI protocol. Most Brits don't realise that the whole of the UK is held completely to ransom by a very small minority of Unionists in NI. This is one important reason why Brexit is such a mess - as those who understood the implications warned would happen (but it was dismissed as Project Fear). The EU stands fully behind Ireland, and both the EU and Ireland have a much closer relationship with the US, despite the so-called "Special Relationship" that the UK claims to have with the US.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 17/04/2023 15:48

@BrBa In America someone saying "we are from Poland" or"we are Polish" would be widely understood to mean anything from the person having been born in Poland to that person being of Polish descent.

The poster you quoted is taking it more literally; saying "we are from Poland" means that that was your place of birth; you are literally "from" there.

I didn't interpret anything in that post to mean that your ethnicity could only be determined by country of birth though.

BrBa · 17/04/2023 15:13

IcedPurple · 17/04/2023 15:04

I don't see anything wrong with the poster's comment.

You seem to be trying to superimpose American norms on other countries, which kind of validates some of the arguments made above.

I’m merely trying to understand a sensitive and often complex subject.

OP posts:
postapesto · 17/04/2023 15:07

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 13:56

The Irish aren't sneering at Biden at all. They're proud of his identification with his Irish heritage, and how keen he is to acknowledge it and to show support to Ireland. They were equally happy when Obama did the same thing, and the same with any other Irish Americans who come to visit Ireland - they're welcomed with open arms.
The only ones who are sneering are British media, who are upset that the American President so clearly snubbed the UK. It has even been written that he "owes" it to the UK to make as big a deal of his UK heritage - why, that's his choice, tough!
Biden met Rishi Sunak in Belfast for an uncomfortable hour, then spent several days in Ireland, meeting Irish politicians and many local people. During his trip, as he has all along, he made his support of Ireland over the NI Protocol very clear, and he warned Sunak that there is no question of any UK/US trade deal as long as the UK threatens peace in NI. And he has turned down an invitation to Charles' coronation.
British media portray it as being all about leprechauns, thereby trivialising the issue. They still haven't grasped the seriousness how how badly the UK is damaging its own international standing and reputation. The Western world is firmly on Ireland's side - regardless of heritage. I'm not Irish btw, but I read newspapers in a number of languages and what's being portrayed elsewhere is very different from how it's represented to the UK public.

To be fair, most of Ireland just didn't care. Not proud, not offended. Just vaguely bemused and wondering why someone taped black bin bags over the bins in part of Dublin for the arrival of Joe.

IcedPurple · 17/04/2023 15:04

BrBa · 17/04/2023 15:01

Is this considered polite? I’m attaching the post in question, where a poster has decided that the child of another poster is not Pakistani, despite the parent explaining their ethnicity as an inescapable fact of their existence. It read like whitewashing or cultural incompetence at best.

I understand that national citizenship can be a part of how people identify but it’s not the whole, especially if you are not white.

I don't see anything wrong with the poster's comment.

You seem to be trying to superimpose American norms on other countries, which kind of validates some of the arguments made above.

BrBa · 17/04/2023 15:01

Is this considered polite? I’m attaching the post in question, where a poster has decided that the child of another poster is not Pakistani, despite the parent explaining their ethnicity as an inescapable fact of their existence. It read like whitewashing or cultural incompetence at best.

I understand that national citizenship can be a part of how people identify but it’s not the whole, especially if you are not white.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?
OP posts:
IcedPurple · 17/04/2023 14:46

Surely by definition people born in Britain are native Brits whether or not they have additional Pakistani (or Malay or Romanian) heritage and identities?

That's why I put 'native' in scare quotes.

There is a certain sector of society who consider British people of recent foreign origin not to be 'really' British. Thankfully, these idiots have dwindled in numbers recently, but a few of them still exist. That's why it might be considered insulting to refer to a British person of, for example, Nigerian origin as being 'Nigerian'. It would be much more polite, and accurate, to refer to them simply as British. That's not the same as denying their Nigerian heritage.

BrBa · 17/04/2023 14:38

Surely by definition people born in Britain are native Brits whether or not they have additional Pakistani (or Malay or Romanian) heritage and identities? I will try to find the specific post I am referring to.

Of course I don’t assume these views are representative of the UK as a whole but the same or a similar sentiment was repeated throughout the thread by a number of posters.

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 17/04/2023 14:30

BrBa · 17/04/2023 14:25

I’m thinking of the responses to this thread, there were some very firm ‘no you are not Pakistani and neither are your children if you and they were born in Britain’ type of comments.

That's because it might be considered derogatory to say that someone born in Britain is not British. The implication might be that only 'native' Brits can call themselves British. That's not the same as denying someone's heritage.

BrBa · 17/04/2023 14:25

IcedPurple · 17/04/2023 14:23

What a fascinating discussion. It seems the answer to my question is partly due to a British emphasis on nationality, the legal framework by which one becomes a citizen of a nation state with one’s ethnic background and heritage being almost entirely erased from questions of identity. I wasn’t expecting that.

Probably because it's incorrect.

The British government does not 'erase' ethnicity. It measures and collects data on race and ethnicity, for example when carrying out a census. Perhaps you were thinking of France?

I’m thinking of the responses to this thread, there were some very firm ‘no you are not Pakistani and neither are your children if you and they were born in Britain’ type of comments.

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 17/04/2023 14:23

What a fascinating discussion. It seems the answer to my question is partly due to a British emphasis on nationality, the legal framework by which one becomes a citizen of a nation state with one’s ethnic background and heritage being almost entirely erased from questions of identity. I wasn’t expecting that.

Probably because it's incorrect.

The British government does not 'erase' ethnicity. It measures and collects data on race and ethnicity, for example when carrying out a census. Perhaps you were thinking of France?

poetryandwine · 17/04/2023 14:20

Interesting thread, OP.

My sense of the international media, particular EU media, agrees with that of @Whalesong I really fear that the UK does not realise how isolated it is becoming.

@Florenz I am another who wonders why the US would be better off in the Commonwealth? Philosophically they obviously prefer otherwise, in the strongest of terms. Culturally, the US does not particularly identify with the UK anymore, although it appreciates much of what is best about the UK. Economically, we have

2021 US GDP over $21T
2021 Commonwealth GDP over $13T

so Commonwealth membership is hardly an economic advantage. What am I missing?

DdraigGoch · 17/04/2023 14:12

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 13:49

No, just referring to your last paragraph in that quote:

Incidentally, many African-Americans who have moved to Europe have said how they appreciated being treated as "just Americans", with no one caring about the colour of their skin or crossing the street to avoid them.

You were still disingenuously trying to put words in my mouth. At no point did I say "there is no racism in Europe".

Who are you to contradict their lived experience? They moved to Europe (not just the UK) and found a step-change in how they were treated by others compared with the US. No one crossing the street, no sideways glances, no one pulling their bags closer. They found themselves treated like human beings in shops. Obviously they weren't unfortunate enough to encounter some of the pond life that does exist in the UK, but that it is so rare that they didn't experience it points to how much less overt racism there is in Europe, in contrast to their daily experience in the US.

BrBa · 17/04/2023 14:08

What a fascinating discussion. It seems the answer to my question is partly due to a British emphasis on nationality, the legal framework by which one becomes a citizen of a nation state with one’s ethnic background and heritage being almost entirely erased from questions of identity. I wasn’t expecting that.

For us the very plurality of our ethnicities and religions and continents of origin, all living side by side, is the success story of our national identity today. It makes perfect sense to me to develop a personal identity based as much upon your family’s cultural history as your country of birth or current residence. Other posters have explained these aspects of American history far more eloquently than I ever could.

OP posts:
Whalesong · 17/04/2023 13:56

Inthesamesinkingboat · 14/04/2023 15:54

@VickyEadieofThigh Id imagine this is in relation to Biden and his claiming of his Irish heritage. As I understand it he had a set of great grandparents who came from Ireland over 170 years ago but has really been playing up his links.

The Irish aren't sneering at Biden at all. They're proud of his identification with his Irish heritage, and how keen he is to acknowledge it and to show support to Ireland. They were equally happy when Obama did the same thing, and the same with any other Irish Americans who come to visit Ireland - they're welcomed with open arms.
The only ones who are sneering are British media, who are upset that the American President so clearly snubbed the UK. It has even been written that he "owes" it to the UK to make as big a deal of his UK heritage - why, that's his choice, tough!
Biden met Rishi Sunak in Belfast for an uncomfortable hour, then spent several days in Ireland, meeting Irish politicians and many local people. During his trip, as he has all along, he made his support of Ireland over the NI Protocol very clear, and he warned Sunak that there is no question of any UK/US trade deal as long as the UK threatens peace in NI. And he has turned down an invitation to Charles' coronation.
British media portray it as being all about leprechauns, thereby trivialising the issue. They still haven't grasped the seriousness how how badly the UK is damaging its own international standing and reputation. The Western world is firmly on Ireland's side - regardless of heritage. I'm not Irish btw, but I read newspapers in a number of languages and what's being portrayed elsewhere is very different from how it's represented to the UK public.

DdraigGoch · 17/04/2023 13:41

Jemandthehologramsunite · 16/04/2023 12:30

The prejudice and hate on this thread is vile, it's not surprising to see why exiled people may have formed bonds when they moved to other countries if this is the attitude 100s of years later. Not very inclusive at all. I don't think Chinese/Vietnamese/Jamaican/Pakistani etc would have the same attitude if a person with a great grandparent came to visit their country, they'd probably be warm and welcoming. That in itself is quite telling.

Has "hate" been redefined as "anything I disagree with"? Did I miss the memo? Because that's where Internet discussions seem to be heading over the last couple of years.