Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Whalesong · 18/04/2023 01:17

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 00:32

Americans have an unfortunate habit of trying to explain to everyone else though.

I haven't seen any Americans on this thread though? Only some people trying to ridicule them. And believe me, I'd be the first to point out the faults of Americans (or at least American society in general) but in this case I feel it's totally undeserved.

Whalesong · 18/04/2023 01:14

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 01:06

Petal is pretty ignorant. Not having that. I'm Irish and proud of it. I've english relatives and i'm proud of them too.

Thank you. I was ignoring that as there was so much else that was ignorant in her posts. But yes, "petal" is the height of ignorance unless used by someone where it's part of the dialect. And I've never actually been called that by an Irish person before. I don't mind so much when it's someone from the North of England as it's normal there, but otherwise it feels glued on.
Good for you for being proud of all your ancestry. That's how we're raising our children as well, who have several. And they are way more clued in to the history of their various heritages than some, it seems.

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 01:10

postapesto · 18/04/2023 00:37

Calm down petal. Who hasn't met Michael D? Ive drunk his wine at the Aras, its not a claim to fame here!!

I couldn't care less how many people you know in Ireland. You weren't here for Bidens visit, you haven't a notion. Stop trying to claim you do, and that you know better than people who live here. ffs.

It's not a British only site, its open to all.

I live in Ireland

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 01:06

Petal is pretty ignorant. Not having that. I'm Irish and proud of it. I've english relatives and i'm proud of them too.

WhoWhatWhenWhereWhyHow · 18/04/2023 01:03

Another thread complaining about those awful Americans.

Whalesong · 18/04/2023 01:03

postapesto · 18/04/2023 00:59

Scarlet for you. Anyone can have an opinion...anyone that was here and actually understood what we were talking about, that is. So not you.

Did you seriously call all foreigners on MN "wannabee Brits"? You absolute spanner.

It was only right back at you since you keep saying on a BRITISH site that nobody other than those with Irish nationality who live in Ireland and were there last week have any right to express an opinion.
The barefaced cheek of you.
I assume you don't ever express an opinion on ANYTHING relating to something that happens in the UK (or anywhere else in the world), since you don't live here, so clearly can't have the first clue? And I'll hold you to that...

postapesto · 18/04/2023 00:59

Scarlet for you. Anyone can have an opinion...anyone that was here and actually understood what we were talking about, that is. So not you.

Did you seriously call all foreigners on MN "wannabee Brits"? You absolute spanner.

Whalesong · 18/04/2023 00:52

postapesto · 18/04/2023 00:37

Calm down petal. Who hasn't met Michael D? Ive drunk his wine at the Aras, its not a claim to fame here!!

I couldn't care less how many people you know in Ireland. You weren't here for Bidens visit, you haven't a notion. Stop trying to claim you do, and that you know better than people who live here. ffs.

It's not a British only site, its open to all.

I never said I knew better than you or anyone else - on the contrary, I've repeatedly said that people clearly have different experiences. And I never said meeting Michael D is a claim to fame (and note that I didn't just say "meeting" but being a guest of honour at a number of events, not just swigging wine as one of the crowd, FFS). Was just trying to reply to your dismissing my Irish husband's right to have any opinion. But oh well, you live in Ireland and (clearly) drink down the local pub, so you must know best.
You're the only one who has tried to diminish my right to an opinion, or rather that of my Irish relatives or friends, because it doesn't happen to match your own. While you're busy being a wannabe Brit on Mumsnet, which I actually find quite hilarious.
None of my Irish mum friends would dream of posting on here. I do because although not a Brit I live here, so discussions of every day life in the UK affect my family. Not sure what you're doing here, since you only accept opinions of Irish people living in Ireland, but whatever floats yer boat.
You seem a bit insecure in your national identity. But whatever.
Going to stop this discussion now. We've both told each other to feck off (you first, I responded) so let's leave it at that.
Meanwhile, lots of valuable contributions from others on this thread, British and Irish :)
Very good thread, OP (before it got derailed).

postapesto · 18/04/2023 00:37

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 21:06

Reading comprehension isn't your strong side, is it? Once again, my full sentence which you keep choosing to quote selectively was "According to my Irish husband, his family and our friends over there, as well as Irish media" , NOT "my husband said". There is a BIG difference. I have spoken first-hand about the subject to a number of "Irish people living in Ireland" which according to you are the only ones allowed an opinion. And I read Irish media extensively.

Again I ask, even if you disqualify my husband (who incidentally was a guest of honour at a number of events commemorating the independence centenary, due to being the direct descendent of someone who was involved, including a garden party at President Michael Higgins' private residence - lovely man!) and my Irish children, on what basis do you disqualify our many Irish relatives and friends who still live in Ireland?

This is a thread on a BRITISH site, about something that happened in Ireland. You claim sole rights to express an opinion. So why are you even discussing it on a BRITISH site if only those who are Irish and live in Ireland are allowed an opinion?

Calm down petal. Who hasn't met Michael D? Ive drunk his wine at the Aras, its not a claim to fame here!!

I couldn't care less how many people you know in Ireland. You weren't here for Bidens visit, you haven't a notion. Stop trying to claim you do, and that you know better than people who live here. ffs.

It's not a British only site, its open to all.

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 00:32

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 18/04/2023 00:25

Hahahaha nothing gets Mumsnet going that topics that relate to the US.

And it’s so funny they way everyone tries to philosophically explain Americans lol

Americans have an unfortunate habit of trying to explain to everyone else though.

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 00:26

What's he like? I was in college with his son.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 18/04/2023 00:25

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 15:55

This thread is getting ridiculous.
Biden came to Ireland, he has Irish heritage which he is proud about, he talked about it.
Most Irish people were delighted to see him and happy he considers himself Irish (we understand what it means when an American says they are Irish, this is a part of American culture which we are very familiar with and understand).
He went home to America.

Hahahaha nothing gets Mumsnet going that topics that relate to the US.

And it’s so funny they way everyone tries to philosophically explain Americans lol

Whalesong · 18/04/2023 00:17

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 00:04

It's Michael D. Or miggeldy. No need to be rude.

Yes I know. I've met him several times. The "D" somehow fell off when editing. But indeed, my husband would never refer to him as anything other than Michael D. But I'm on less familiar terms with him and also didn't think anyone on here would know who I was referring to unless I added the surname. But I do apologise for the "D" having fallen off, that was a mistake.

Chickenkeev · 18/04/2023 00:04

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 21:06

Reading comprehension isn't your strong side, is it? Once again, my full sentence which you keep choosing to quote selectively was "According to my Irish husband, his family and our friends over there, as well as Irish media" , NOT "my husband said". There is a BIG difference. I have spoken first-hand about the subject to a number of "Irish people living in Ireland" which according to you are the only ones allowed an opinion. And I read Irish media extensively.

Again I ask, even if you disqualify my husband (who incidentally was a guest of honour at a number of events commemorating the independence centenary, due to being the direct descendent of someone who was involved, including a garden party at President Michael Higgins' private residence - lovely man!) and my Irish children, on what basis do you disqualify our many Irish relatives and friends who still live in Ireland?

This is a thread on a BRITISH site, about something that happened in Ireland. You claim sole rights to express an opinion. So why are you even discussing it on a BRITISH site if only those who are Irish and live in Ireland are allowed an opinion?

It's Michael D. Or miggeldy. No need to be rude.

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 21:06

postapesto · 17/04/2023 20:17

According to my Irish husband and my husband said literally mean the same thing.

Reading comprehension isn't your strong side, is it? Once again, my full sentence which you keep choosing to quote selectively was "According to my Irish husband, his family and our friends over there, as well as Irish media" , NOT "my husband said". There is a BIG difference. I have spoken first-hand about the subject to a number of "Irish people living in Ireland" which according to you are the only ones allowed an opinion. And I read Irish media extensively.

Again I ask, even if you disqualify my husband (who incidentally was a guest of honour at a number of events commemorating the independence centenary, due to being the direct descendent of someone who was involved, including a garden party at President Michael Higgins' private residence - lovely man!) and my Irish children, on what basis do you disqualify our many Irish relatives and friends who still live in Ireland?

This is a thread on a BRITISH site, about something that happened in Ireland. You claim sole rights to express an opinion. So why are you even discussing it on a BRITISH site if only those who are Irish and live in Ireland are allowed an opinion?

StephanieSuperpowers · 17/04/2023 20:42

Xenia · 17/04/2023 18:25

Best never to ask people where they are from. It is too dangerous a question.
The US/ Irish thing is just for political gain. No one takes it too seriously although US money to the IRA to bomb us back in the day was very serious and very wrong.

I wish anybody could guess why they would mysteriously and for no known reason, do such a thing.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 17/04/2023 20:34

@GarlicGrace I don't disagree with you. If someone refers to themselves as "Italian-American" and someone else says "That does not meet my definition of Italian", I don't actually see what the big deal is.

It's not necessary to try to win someone over to your point of view. Respectful disagreement is perfectly valid.

postapesto · 17/04/2023 20:17

According to my Irish husband and my husband said literally mean the same thing.

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 20:15

postapesto · 17/04/2023 19:06

You literally started your "correction" to me with "according my Irish husband". Do keep up (with yourself, if no-one else).

You totally Britsplained Ireland to me. Just own it. You actually thought you knew better than me what has been going on in Ireland the last week and how people feel about it, because you know a few Irish people. Classic.

How about reading what I actually wrote? I said "According to my Irish husband, his family and our friends over there, as well as Irish media". Not "my husband said" (which I agree would have been a bit pathetic, but it's not what I wrote).

And I couldn't "Britsplain" anything if I tried, being that I'm not British. On the contrary, what I wrote was directed at those Brits (not all, but many) who have zero idea of Irish History and who DO Britsplain and reduce the Irish to dancing Leprechauns with shamrocks. And who ask my husband "So are you from Northern or Southern Ireland" - um no, the country is called "Ireland". Which is internationally recognised as the official name of the country that only Brits ever refer to as "the Republic". Only Brits stuck in colonial times can't accept "Ireland" on its own.

You have NO idea how deep my connections to Ireland are (or not as it's none of your business either way). You're just making assumptions. You don't know how much time I've spent there over the last 30 years, whether I've lived there or for how long, or how many people I know there, or who they are.

I have Irish children - are they allowed to have an opinion? Is my husband, born and bred in Ireland? Are his siblings and other relatives (and there aren't just "a few" - this being Ireland, he has ca 40 cousins, all with children at various stages of growing up; we are also close to a number of his second cousins)? Are our friends, also Irish people living in Ireland? Or do you have a monopoly?

Funnily enough you seem to be taking the general view that has been reported in British right-wing media, ie that Biden's visit was all for show. Maybe you've spent too much time on Mumsnet?

FYI I've just come off the phone from a long conversation with my SIL who has lived in Ireland all her life. And who is very happy about the clear message of support that Biden gave by his visit.

Again, I'm not saying that EVERYONE in Ireland feels the same way - clearly many descendants of wealthy Protestants don't, for example, and I'm sure there are others who like yourself don't care. But you simply can't claim to be the sole owner of the truth. As shown by the other poster in this thread who said that she enjoyed the visit.

GarlicGrace · 17/04/2023 19:39

You know, I'm so over the cult of personal "identity". It's a modern curse! Sure, everybody has a personal identity and also a group identity (often several), a national identity, a cultural identity and so forth. what pisses me off is the idea that you and only you determine your "identity" - you choose it, basically - and then everyone should damn well respect you for what you say you are. To question or disagree is insulting and is "hate".

Our real identities are shape-shifting concepts made up of an individual's core personality and physical features, then overlaid with our roles in various situations and things like our economic & social situations, where we live, our legal status, what we mean to other people and how they see us. To slap an "identity" label on yourself and demand acceptance feels controlling to me. Narcissistic, almost.

Many of the angrier comments in this thread reflect the tug-of-war going on around "trans identities". The same phrases are popping up, including challenges like "who are you to question my identity?" I'd say everyone has that right if they believe they've got cause to. Your identity isn't something you can unilaterally declare, it's a compound of multiple factors including other people's responses to you.

It's clear enough where I stand on this, I just find it an interesting and somewhat exasperating feature of 21st century life.

postapesto · 17/04/2023 19:06

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 18:14

Where did I say the whole country was "off dancing a jig"? And where did I say "my husband said"? I do speak regularly myself with our friends and family over there, and I read Irish newspapers.
You can feck off yourself with your attitude of "only I know what's happening in my country". You clearly don't.

You literally started your "correction" to me with "according my Irish husband". Do keep up (with yourself, if no-one else).

You totally Britsplained Ireland to me. Just own it. You actually thought you knew better than me what has been going on in Ireland the last week and how people feel about it, because you know a few Irish people. Classic.

Xenia · 17/04/2023 18:25

Best never to ask people where they are from. It is too dangerous a question.
The US/ Irish thing is just for political gain. No one takes it too seriously although US money to the IRA to bomb us back in the day was very serious and very wrong.

FurAndFeathers · 17/04/2023 18:19

DdraigGoch · 17/04/2023 17:49

That reminds me of the airport in the US which was piping bagpipe music through the PA "because everyone's Irish on St Patrick's Day!"

The tune? Scotland the Brave.

😂

Bobcat246 · 17/04/2023 18:15

I don't sneer but I do find it strange. Joe Biden is absolutely of Irish descent but your great great grandfather does not make you "Irish". My husband has an Irish grandmother and is therefore a quarter "Irish" and legally entitled to an Irish passport but he would never refer to himself as "Irish", despite being raised by her and knowing lots of his Irish family. It seems to be a uniquely American cultural affectation, like the posh East Coast Americans who trumpet their ancestry back to the Pilgrim Fathers. They don't have the same depth of history we do, American Indians aside, which I think gives them more of a curiosity about their (generally) European roots.

Whalesong · 17/04/2023 18:14

postapesto · 17/04/2023 17:22

We're not really. You and I can discuss whether we liked the visit, and what the mood of the country was. Mrs "My husband said that the whole country was dancing a jig" can feck off for herself though. That's the point.

Where did I say the whole country was "off dancing a jig"? And where did I say "my husband said"? I do speak regularly myself with our friends and family over there, and I read Irish newspapers.
You can feck off yourself with your attitude of "only I know what's happening in my country". You clearly don't.