Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
UrsulaBelle · 14/04/2023 18:51

My parents were Welsh, born in Wales. They moved to England and had me and my siblings. We are English. 🤷🏼‍♀️ Yes, we could play for Wales, but we’re still English. Many of my cousins are Welsh, born and brought up in Wales. They have moved all over the place but consider themselves Welsh and their DC English/Australian/Welsh etc depending on where their children were born or brought up. The non Welsh ones may have a hankering for bara brith and can say Llanfairpwchgwyngyllgogerychwyndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch but that’s as Welsh as they get!

Theluggage15 · 14/04/2023 18:51

Nope @belleager My dad is English, my mum was Welsh. I don’t say I’m Welsh as I was born and brought up in England and have an English accent. I would look a complete twat if I told a Welsh person born and bred that I was Welsh. You don’t pick the bit of your ancestry that you fancy.

greenlychee · 14/04/2023 18:50

i feel like American modern history isn't really that old and so they want to feel like they come from somewhere with more history and roots.

belleager · 14/04/2023 18:48

ProudToBeANorthener · 14/04/2023 18:42

This ☹️

That is reasonable. As an Irish person I would feel the same way.

Of course, many of my countrypeople also supported this terrorism from a distance.

I don't see this as a reflection on the majority of Irish (or Irish-American) people though, any more than I see British war crimes in the North as a reflection on the majority of British people.

suburbophobe · 14/04/2023 18:48

But America is a child in terms of global history and identity.

The ancestors of Native Americans may have lived on and around the Bering Strait for about 10,000 years before streaming into the Americas

There, fixed that for you.

You do know don't you that what we are taught in school as children only relates to one country's history?

Non stop Henry VIII anyone? "Divorced, beheaded, died, divorced, beheaded, survived"....

belleager · 14/04/2023 18:45

Theluggage15 · 14/04/2023 18:40

I have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about @belleager You don’t just pick your identity.

People very very often do.

I accept that some people have connections only to one race, state, nation, ethnicity. I suppose when you are Irish that is an unusual way to view the world, when so many emigrate and when we have such widespread connections.

People identify with different aspects of their heritage. In this way, they choose their identities. Sometimes that's a match for legal citizenship. Sometimes not.

ProudToBeANorthener · 14/04/2023 18:42

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/04/2023 15:52

I'm not aware of any sneering.

I was (and probably still am) very angry at the American supporters of the IRA though. They were not living in the midst of a serious terrorist bombing campaign that claimed many innocent lives.

This ☹️

Labraradabrador · 14/04/2023 18:42

pikkumyy77 · 14/04/2023 18:21

I’m baffled—not really—by all the surprise on this thread that Americans have a different way of thinking and talking about their national identity, their ethnic identity, or their family identity to that offered by an idealized British person. I mean: of course Americans who emigrated from other countries, and who were absorbed into American society at different rates depending on ever changing laws defining desirable and undesirable, white and non white, citizen and non citizen, might have a different way of thinking about family, culture, identity, and homeland than the mumsnetters who have their panties in a twist over Biden identifying as Irish culturally.

American hyphenated identities reflect the painful experience of immigrants who were first asked to assimilate and forget their culture and languages, often punished for their differences, and then sometimes fought back to resurrect or craft novel, hybrid, or fantasy versions of these identities. In the UK this happens too with various sub state nationalisms sometimes valorized (cornish, welsh, scots) and sometimes squelched. The victorian manufacturer of romanticized scots identity also comes to mind.

All this moaning about how other people choose to understand themselves and their personal family histories? The yardstick for measuring what is normal, or silly, or presumptuous doesn’t lie in the UK like Greenwich Mean Time or a universal measure. It is specific to each country and the history of the communities in that country.

The US has quite a complex history because of race based immigration snd marriage laws that, for example, defined Sikh male immigrants as non white and left them free to marry only non white women. This produced a hybrid Sikh-Mexican community that was not accepted as truly South Asian by later immigrants from the subcontinent. My point here is that what this thread sees as bumptious/presumptuous or hyperbolic American style is really just an interesting American historically derived way some communities have chosen to understand the complex forces that brought them to the US, got them citizenship, and nurtured or repressed them.

Thank you, well articulated

CoalTit · 14/04/2023 18:41

Anonymous48 · 14/04/2023 16:31

"To the rest of the world, saying "I'm Irish" means "I'm Irish"."

Absolutely! I totally get that. That is what I am trying to explain. It has a different meaning in the US

This has irritated me so much that I haven't read the rest of the thread.
Obviously, "I'm Irish" means "I'm American, with Irish ancestors" to other north Americans. The trouble is that Americans will say it on the world wide web, or worse still, say it to actual Irish people, as if they're unaware that not everybody is American, that there are actual Irish people, born and raised in Ireland, whose ancestors didn't emigrate to America. The self-absorption is beyond belief.
It's a form of dishonesty that impedes communication. For example, when the actress in Blade Runner 2 is described as Dutch, I don't know if she's Dutch or just pretentious American.

belleager · 14/04/2023 18:40

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 14/04/2023 18:38

What civil war did we have in checks calendar 2013??

25 years. Same point. American intervention in the North mattered.

Theluggage15 · 14/04/2023 18:40

I have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about @belleager You don’t just pick your identity.

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 18:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RudsyFarmer · 14/04/2023 18:39

Isn’t it just more identity politics? The more you can put in your sack the more interesting you are perceived to be so the more points you earn societally.

belleager · 14/04/2023 18:38

Qbish · 14/04/2023 18:33

Yes, not being Welsh stops me from being Welsh.

That wasn't the question, though.

WhiplashGirlchild · 14/04/2023 18:38

MooseBreath · 14/04/2023 18:25

I am Canadian with Irish and Russian ancestry. I grew up with traditions and culture from both of those cultures along with the Canadian "melting pot". My household was culturally very different than my friend's who has English and German ancestry, yet we were raised in the same neighbourhood by Canadians.

Ancestry is very relevant in a place where there are so many cultures meshed together.

As a side note, nobody would bat an eye at an American acknowledging and celebrating their Indian, Chinese, Jamaican, Mexican, or Nigerian heritage. But for those with white European ancestry, it's apparently tacky.

I wonder why Americans never seem to go around claiming "I'm Chinese", "I'm Nigerian"? It turns out that not all nationalities and cultures are fair game for people to claim. They'll say "I'm part Chinese" or "I have Nigerian heritage" like the rest of the English speaking world. The wholesale hijack of European identities is somewhere between cringe and plain rude.

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 14/04/2023 18:38

Pallisers · 14/04/2023 16:39

America is a country of immigrants. There is a lot of pain in that fact. It wasn't all "america looks nice, lets move there and be americans" For many many people in the past they left family, friends, traditions, cultures and never saw them again. They were economic immigrants or fleeing pogroms or famines or war etc. It is any surprise that those immigrants would try to remember and honour their traditions?

Yeah, americans say "I'm italian" they don't actually mean they are Italian. They mean "we follow some Italian traditions, do the seven fishes on xmas eve, have pasta at every big occasion, will some day plan a trip to Italy to see where our great grandparents came from' They know they are american. They don't need brits to tell them that (despite apparently being just teenagers trying to keep up with the big older real adult countries in the world ffs)

I think Joe Biden gave the perfect opportunity for people to sneer at the Irish and at Americans - win/win. usually they have to chose.

And all that Irish americanism in politics has had a real benefit for Ireland - and for the UK. Thanks in part to american and irish american intervention, 10 years ago a civil war in the UK - that the UK seemed unable to stop and that caused untold suffering to UK subjects - ended

What civil war did we have in checks calendar 2013??

Doingtheboxerbeat · 14/04/2023 18:38

All I know is that I saw a tiktok about an Irish woman who worked in a pub popular with American tourists who insisted she wasn't Irish because she was black 🫣. Nothing she or her colleagues would convince them otherwise.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 14/04/2023 18:37

Biden managed to mix up the Black & Tans with the All Blacks ruby team. He’s about as Irish as the Great Wall of fecking China though he does seem to be enjoying his family spring break trip to the homeland.

KnittingNeedles · 14/04/2023 18:35

Biden also has 10 out of 16 great grandparents who were Irish. He's more Irish than he is anything else.

https://www.itv.com/news/2023-04-11/is-joe-biden-the-most-irish-us-president-in-history

elp30 · 14/04/2023 18:35

I thought I'd add to my previous comments about being Mexican-American.

I am married to an Englishman and we have two English-born children but mainly raised in the US.

They call themselves Americans in England but English-American or Anglo-American in the US. I suppose the oldest does because he speaks with an accent that Americans recognize as English/British. My daughter speaks like a Texan. Like me, they don't fit in with Americans because their cultural references are more English but English people in England and the US do not accept them as English because they're seen as too American. Then they speak a bit of Spanish and it's more of a confusion.

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 14/04/2023 18:34

Horizons83 · 14/04/2023 16:44

Last time I checked Belfast was part of the UK...

Through force and colonisation.....

Qbish · 14/04/2023 18:33

belleager · 14/04/2023 18:29

And would any one or more of these things stop you from being Welsh?

Yes, not being Welsh stops me from being Welsh.

RaininginDarling · 14/04/2023 18:31

I veer between finding it quite endearing to finding it a bit eye-rolly.

It's obviously a cultural thing. A lot of Americans like to look back and be defined, in the present, by (quite often) distant ancestry. New world preoccupation. We all want to feel we belong but it always surprises me that that belonging is rarely to America for Americans.

It only gets annoying if they start to school you about 'their' culture 🙄 - when that culture is one you are considerably more familiar with. I lived in the States for a while and whilst it certainly wasn't everybody acting like that, it was common enough. I used to experience quite a bit of grief from Irish Americans for being British when I lived in Boston. These interactions rarely came from a place of knowledge.

I think this fascination with historical ties and an American education system and a media that can't see beyond its own borders (partly for practical reasons) probably compounds the issue.

The US has never been much of a melting pot, it's more a casserole dish. A fascinating, interesting casserole nonetheless!

AgnesX · 14/04/2023 18:30

Identifying..... you mean knowing their family history? No objections whatsoever.

History however is all it is especially if it's trotted out for political or social purposes. The whole Irish-american (for example) thing especially when its so many generations ago is just excruciating.

belleager · 14/04/2023 18:29

Qbish · 14/04/2023 18:26

Being born in England. Living in England. Having English parents. One or all of these.

And would any one or more of these things stop you from being Welsh?