Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
belleager · 14/04/2023 19:32

suburbophobe · 14/04/2023 19:31

The territory now known as the USA was populated long before Columbus set sail but it wasn't the USA then but a series of nations (how many, who was in charge and to what extent the concept of nationhood applied is hotly debated).

I don't disagree with you but a link would be helpful to back up your statement.

I would really be interested. I usually go to Wikipedia for these kinds of things.

I would try a google of "first nations", America?

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 19:31

Oops not late it's mid early modern

suburbophobe · 14/04/2023 19:31

The territory now known as the USA was populated long before Columbus set sail but it wasn't the USA then but a series of nations (how many, who was in charge and to what extent the concept of nationhood applied is hotly debated).

I don't disagree with you but a link would be helpful to back up your statement.

I would really be interested. I usually go to Wikipedia for these kinds of things.

belleager · 14/04/2023 19:31

TreesAtSea · 14/04/2023 19:16

Agreed

I wouldn't agree.

African American was popularised by Black Americans as a term without direct racial connotations - it was about place of origin, not colour of skin.

Black British, White British (and Black American, since that term is used alongside African American) are all standard use.

What this whole discussion suggests to me is that people are very quick to presume that there's one "right" approach to language, culture, and identity. And it happens to be the one known best in Britain.

You need to look at the history to understand the significance. Our cultures reflect our histories. There is no reason to assume British (or European) terms and concepts are the default.

(British Asian - I don't know where the term comes from. But if Sunak identifies as British Asian, good on him).

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 19:31

MissConductUS · 14/04/2023 19:28

I dunno. The town where I live was established by a land grant from King Willian III (William of Orange) in 1697. That's old enough for me.

To put it into context of European history, that's the late Early Modern Period... Not meaning to patronise just explaining that in terms of cultural development America really is very young, and as per my earlier analogy like a tween flexing its muscles a bit.

CeliaNorth · 14/04/2023 19:30

Of course Biden swerved the UK

He visited Belfast.

Belfast is in the UK.

MissConductUS · 14/04/2023 19:28

greenlychee · 14/04/2023 18:50

i feel like American modern history isn't really that old and so they want to feel like they come from somewhere with more history and roots.

I dunno. The town where I live was established by a land grant from King Willian III (William of Orange) in 1697. That's old enough for me.

PrestonHood121 · 14/04/2023 19:23

America is a young country, so to speak. It’s just what they do. Many people never leave the USA so banging on and on about their heritage gives them a way to make polite (or not) conversation when they meet someone from Europe or wherever they want to be from.

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 19:19

MooseBreath · 14/04/2023 19:13

Except they do claim it. My ancestry is from Russian Ashkenazi Jew and Irish Catholic immigrants. Both marginalized communities. When both sides arrived in North America, their surnames were spelled incorrectly due to disdain. It's important for me to celebrate my heritage, and it's not "cringe" or "rude" for me to do so. Am I supposed to just forget that I had relatives in Auschwitz or suffering from the Potato Famine just because they were European and I am North American? I don't claim to have experienced it, but I certainly have their cultures as part of my own.

Misspelling happens in all cultures though. My own family have multiple spellings or our surname through the generations because of illiteracy, it's been interesting to trace the family tree due to this.

Irish migrants to England usually dropped the O' part of the surname as another example. Fwiw I think it's lovely to celebrate the whole of who you are but as with others I find it baffling the way it's phrased and how adamant Americans are about how they identify.

phoenixrosehere · 14/04/2023 19:18

WhiplashGirlchild · 14/04/2023 18:38

I wonder why Americans never seem to go around claiming "I'm Chinese", "I'm Nigerian"? It turns out that not all nationalities and cultures are fair game for people to claim. They'll say "I'm part Chinese" or "I have Nigerian heritage" like the rest of the English speaking world. The wholesale hijack of European identities is somewhere between cringe and plain rude.

The cringe is assuming that the groups you mention don’t because you have never heard it.

TreesAtSea · 14/04/2023 19:16

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 19:07

I agree with the posters who say it seems to be tinged with racism when they say it. I remember there was a bit of a fracas across the internet over the idea of Rishi Sunak being English. A lot of Americans couldn't grasp that idea that to us he's English, because he is. They saw his race and ethnic heritage first nationality second, we tend to do it the other way round here. British Asian rather than African American. It's a subtle but noticeable difference.

Agreed

Grimbelina · 14/04/2023 19:15

I have had more than one relative who mysteriously developed an Irish accent after going to live in the US! They had a great life out there with their whole new identity (we are all roughly a quarter Irish but it had never occurred to me - or I think anyone else in the family - to consider ourselves anything other than English).

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 19:13

suburbophobe · 14/04/2023 18:48

But America is a child in terms of global history and identity.

The ancestors of Native Americans may have lived on and around the Bering Strait for about 10,000 years before streaming into the Americas

There, fixed that for you.

You do know don't you that what we are taught in school as children only relates to one country's history?

Non stop Henry VIII anyone? "Divorced, beheaded, died, divorced, beheaded, survived"....

Yes and no. The territory now known as the USA was populated long before Columbus set sail but it wasn't the USA then but a series of nations (how many, who was in charge and to what extent the concept of nationhood applied is hotly debated).

MooseBreath · 14/04/2023 19:13

WhiplashGirlchild · 14/04/2023 18:38

I wonder why Americans never seem to go around claiming "I'm Chinese", "I'm Nigerian"? It turns out that not all nationalities and cultures are fair game for people to claim. They'll say "I'm part Chinese" or "I have Nigerian heritage" like the rest of the English speaking world. The wholesale hijack of European identities is somewhere between cringe and plain rude.

Except they do claim it. My ancestry is from Russian Ashkenazi Jew and Irish Catholic immigrants. Both marginalized communities. When both sides arrived in North America, their surnames were spelled incorrectly due to disdain. It's important for me to celebrate my heritage, and it's not "cringe" or "rude" for me to do so. Am I supposed to just forget that I had relatives in Auschwitz or suffering from the Potato Famine just because they were European and I am North American? I don't claim to have experienced it, but I certainly have their cultures as part of my own.

Endlesssummer2022 · 14/04/2023 19:12

Of course Biden swerved the UK and who can blame him. Why would he want to be knocking about and taking photos with lunatics like Suella Braverman?

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 19:09

suburbophobe · 14/04/2023 18:48

But America is a child in terms of global history and identity.

The ancestors of Native Americans may have lived on and around the Bering Strait for about 10,000 years before streaming into the Americas

There, fixed that for you.

You do know don't you that what we are taught in school as children only relates to one country's history?

Non stop Henry VIII anyone? "Divorced, beheaded, died, divorced, beheaded, survived"....

I don't know what type of school you went to but my history lessons were varied and included a wide scope of global history.

belleager · 14/04/2023 19:08

Mendholeai · 14/04/2023 18:54

It makes. Sense to Americans and brings them a sense of kinship, culture and belonging. It’s a newish country and there is a definite sense of lack- missing that rich history that most countries have. Saying they are Irish or Scottish makes them feel they belong.

Getting involved in complex political situations and accidentally offending nations is taking kinship a bit too far.

Those of us with a rich cultural history forged by centuries of warfare have learned the subtle art if shutting up, remaining neutral, and realising that we don’t know enough to say anything. This is probably why we talk
about the weather

I find patronising Americans for being a young nation (if we are only counting from 1492. Or 1776. Though people were there before that) a bit much.

People in Europe don't go around drawing on centuries of wisdom every time they open their mouths. Most of them know very little history.

It's more relevant to the European connection that if you are a white American, your ancestors arrived some time after the introduction of print, and probably within the period of shipping lists and parish registers, and even quite likely after introduction of a census. They came from somewhere. You can usually find out where. Or your family may never have forgotten.

It's an outward looking history.

Whereas if I have Vikings among my ancestors, chances of me finding that shipping list or immigration record are fairly slim.

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 19:07

I agree with the posters who say it seems to be tinged with racism when they say it. I remember there was a bit of a fracas across the internet over the idea of Rishi Sunak being English. A lot of Americans couldn't grasp that idea that to us he's English, because he is. They saw his race and ethnic heritage first nationality second, we tend to do it the other way round here. British Asian rather than African American. It's a subtle but noticeable difference.

belleager · 14/04/2023 19:02

Theluggage15 · 14/04/2023 18:51

Nope @belleager My dad is English, my mum was Welsh. I don’t say I’m Welsh as I was born and brought up in England and have an English accent. I would look a complete twat if I told a Welsh person born and bred that I was Welsh. You don’t pick the bit of your ancestry that you fancy.

Interesting, and thanks for answering. But what you and @UrsulaBelle are talking about in your posts are subjective standards, probably roughly a match with the wider cultural consensus in the UK.

And even there, in your relatively straightforward situations, there is nuance. There's no universal rule about identity. Born and bred? Accent? Rugby rules? You have a right to identify as English, and your upbringings seem to have encouraged that, but there are choices there.

happyumwelt · 14/04/2023 19:01

It's daft if it is generations back - most people have mixed heritage of this sort in the UK too, but the majority will either say British, or identify with one of the four UK nations. I probably have a similar percentage of Irish as Biden (5%) but didn't know the great great grandparent who provided me with that smidge of Irish and would never claim to be Irish.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/04/2023 18:57

Biden managed to mix up the Black & Tans with the All Blacks ruby team

So I've just been reading; I'd laugh except it's not funny

Somebody really should get this guy out of public view ...

StephanieSuperpowers · 14/04/2023 18:55

ProudToBeANorthener · 14/04/2023 18:42

This ☹️

Oh dear. Probably better then not to watch on as people get burned out of their homes or civil rights protesters get shot in the streets. It makes people feel sad enough to try to do something about it. Not the government in charge of ensuring it doesn't happen, obviously. Or the electorate who think they have it coming. People who actually care.

Mendholeai · 14/04/2023 18:54

It makes. Sense to Americans and brings them a sense of kinship, culture and belonging. It’s a newish country and there is a definite sense of lack- missing that rich history that most countries have. Saying they are Irish or Scottish makes them feel they belong.

Getting involved in complex political situations and accidentally offending nations is taking kinship a bit too far.

Those of us with a rich cultural history forged by centuries of warfare have learned the subtle art if shutting up, remaining neutral, and realising that we don’t know enough to say anything. This is probably why we talk
about the weather

emptythelitterbox · 14/04/2023 18:53

Americans being sneery?

But other countries seems to judge Americans harshly for anything.

Hardbackwriter · 14/04/2023 18:51

Pallisers · 14/04/2023 16:39

America is a country of immigrants. There is a lot of pain in that fact. It wasn't all "america looks nice, lets move there and be americans" For many many people in the past they left family, friends, traditions, cultures and never saw them again. They were economic immigrants or fleeing pogroms or famines or war etc. It is any surprise that those immigrants would try to remember and honour their traditions?

Yeah, americans say "I'm italian" they don't actually mean they are Italian. They mean "we follow some Italian traditions, do the seven fishes on xmas eve, have pasta at every big occasion, will some day plan a trip to Italy to see where our great grandparents came from' They know they are american. They don't need brits to tell them that (despite apparently being just teenagers trying to keep up with the big older real adult countries in the world ffs)

I think Joe Biden gave the perfect opportunity for people to sneer at the Irish and at Americans - win/win. usually they have to chose.

And all that Irish americanism in politics has had a real benefit for Ireland - and for the UK. Thanks in part to american and irish american intervention, 10 years ago a civil war in the UK - that the UK seemed unable to stop and that caused untold suffering to UK subjects - ended

Aside from the quite hilarious fact that you wrote that long and pompous post without knowing when the GFA was - celt-splaining indeed! - I think an objective observer would have to agree that the role of Americans believing they're Irish was at best a mixed blessing for the Troubles, what with all the funding the IRA.