Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
belleager · 14/04/2023 22:33

PonyPatter44 · 14/04/2023 22:09

To be fair, virtually all American presidents (with the ignoble exception of 45) identify as Irish. Even this dude

A great song - thank you! But tongue-in-cheek as I'm sure you know: he was pleased to acknowledge Irish ancestry but I don't think he ever claimed it shaped him. And yes with patterns of Irish immigration to the US, not surprising you find ancestors for all the presidents.

But it's also about identity. Kennedy and Biden very obviously had life long connections to Ireland, shaped by family tradition, education, religion, politics. Biden would be a very different man (and likely not a president!) without his Irish roots and identity. So all power to him. The Irish diaspora is a real force.

Justanotherlurker · 14/04/2023 22:30

Because they unironically use a one drop rule and usually be the extreme charactisation , go onto Reddit which is predominantly American in usage and look at how the Americans get treated in national subs.

So much so it is now becoming an internet meme and why you are suddenly being aware and offended by it.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 14/04/2023 22:29

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 20:06

Its ridiculous and plain weird when Americans do this.

Biden claiming to be Irish so many hundreds of years later when he also has British and French heritage makes him look like a complete idiot.

If Biden claimed British heritage in the same way right now I am pretty sure that Boris Johnson or Rishi Sunak would have played on this in the same manner as they did the 'special relationship'. Ireland has always had a strong connection with America and while I have many problems with aspects of the politics of that country at the very least without American support the GFA and peace in NI would not have happened.

Hardbackwriter · 14/04/2023 22:12

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 21:34

See I don't think that its in anyway as clearcut as that. If you read stories of the original "colonisers" and those of "emigrants" they're not so different at all. Just lots of ordinary people looking for a better life, an escape, a new identity, an advantage, wealth and riches, excitement and adventure, a chance to practice their religion etc etc

I agree with you, but I think the post you're referring to reveals exactly why people do this, and why they don't claim to be 'English American'. It's because they think their heritage makes them on the side of the 'goodies' and so they get some sort of moral virtue by association without actually having to bother to do anything in particular.

PonyPatter44 · 14/04/2023 22:09

To be fair, virtually all American presidents (with the ignoble exception of 45) identify as Irish. Even this dude

Corrigan Brothers - There's No One As Irish As Barack Obama

Music video by Corrigan Brothers performing There's No One As Irish As Barack Obama. (C) 2008 Universal Music Ireland Ltd.

https://youtu.be/DerVmiZeUDw

DorritLittle · 14/04/2023 22:06

I find it odd too. Having one great grandparent who is Irish means having seven who aren’t.

MrsMikeDrop · 14/04/2023 22:05

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 15:48

Because Americans never accept they're American despite being several generations into being an American. It's just strange.

I've always found this interesting. Because it seems if you're white you can be British, American etc. But if you have coloured skin you'll always be asked "where you're from". Interesting there's a double standard. I always thought people said they were from a certain country after a few generations ie American, Australian, because they didn't actually know where they were from

JudgeJ · 14/04/2023 21:56

MasterBeth · 14/04/2023 15:52

I think, if there's any sneering, it's at Americans with Irish / German / Italian heritage who describe themselves purely as Irish, German or Italian.

If you've been born and brought up in Dublin or Limerick, it sounds strange if a fourth-generation Californian Irish-American starts teling you how Irish they are.

Exactly. It seems to be one of the rules of American politics that anyone wanting to run for the highest office has to find some Irish ancestry to tick that box, failing Irish then they have to find other Celtic roots, eg Trump's Scottish roots.

Bodenesque · 14/04/2023 21:54

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/04/2023 15:52

I'm not aware of any sneering.

I was (and probably still am) very angry at the American supporters of the IRA though. They were not living in the midst of a serious terrorist bombing campaign that claimed many innocent lives.

The lack of insight and naivety was horrendous, otherwise I'd be forced to believe that they were happy to fund the slaughter of so many.

juldan · 14/04/2023 21:51

„My DH grandparents came from Poland in the 1930s. Not even his Dad would claim to be anything other than English. Cos that was where he was born and lived his whole life.”
It depends on individual families and how strongly they identify with their heritage.
My daughter, who is half Polish and half English, attended a Polish weekend school here in the UK. When I met her teachers, I assumed that they were recent immigrants from Poland. It turned out most of them were born and raised in the UK. They still see themselves as Polish- British.
In places like USA and Canada, there are a lot of communities who strongly identify with their Italian, Polish, Irish, Chinese, etc. heritage . They still preserve their traditions, cook their cuisine. Many of them speak their heritage languages, even if they are the second, third or fourth generation of immigrants.
It’s fine if somebody, whose parents/grandparents came from another country, sees themselves as just English/American/Australian, etc.
However, there is nothing wrong with seeing yourself as Italian-Canadian, Irish-American, Chinese-English or Polish-Australian, even though your family emigrated generations ago.
Nobody has a right to say; you are just American/English because you were born there. You are not Irish/German/Italian because you have never lived there.
In fact quite often it is untrue. There are countries which give automatic citizenship to the children of their citizens(e.g. if one of your parents is Polish, you are a Polish citizen regardless of where you live).

TrishM80 · 14/04/2023 21:51

I don't know why it bothers people (particularly British people for some reason). If Joe Biden claimed to be Azerbaijani in the morning, what fuck difference does it make to British people?! 😂

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 21:42

@Mocara it's just how people work, a story repeated over and over through human history and long before "the British " were ever a thing.

Mocara · 14/04/2023 21:42

ProudToBeANorthener · 14/04/2023 18:42

This ☹️

Not offended by who was colluding funding ,arming and prottecting the loyalest contingent then ??? British government and armed forces to name but a few .
Ignorant much ?

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 14/04/2023 21:40

Mocara · 14/04/2023 21:37

British through colours never if ever far below the surface.

Yup.

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 14/04/2023 21:39

Pallisers · 14/04/2023 20:14

I know exactly what the GFA is. I am Irish.

Based on this thread, that means you are American...🤣

Mocara · 14/04/2023 21:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

British through colours never if ever far below the surface.

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 21:34

CordyLines · 14/04/2023 16:24

Brits seem to be raging that the POTUS went to Ireland and swerved the UK. That is where the sneering is coming from I think.

Well when you think about it the British colonised the East Coast of America until they were driven out. They were the invaders. The British colonised many other countries also, so have/had no desire to be anything other than the superior population they seem to think they are.

Immigrants and emigrants on the other hand were not colonisers, and in the case of the Irish particularly, went to US on coffin ships because the British sold what food the Irish could produce during the Great Famine back to Britain (Trevalyan's corn), and left the natives to either starve or leave.

There is a different dynamic involved in emigres than there is to those who didn't HAVE to emigrate i.e. were the overlords.

No wonder there is such a longing for ancestry, I think it is great to seek out your roots and have a rant as to why you are where you are. America has opened its arms to many people who needed it badly. Thank you America.

See I don't think that its in anyway as clearcut as that. If you read stories of the original "colonisers" and those of "emigrants" they're not so different at all. Just lots of ordinary people looking for a better life, an escape, a new identity, an advantage, wealth and riches, excitement and adventure, a chance to practice their religion etc etc

Mocara · 14/04/2023 21:15

Horizons83 · 14/04/2023 16:44

Last time I checked Belfast was part of the UK...

Ignorant statment much !

Mocara · 14/04/2023 21:12

CordyLines · 14/04/2023 16:24

Brits seem to be raging that the POTUS went to Ireland and swerved the UK. That is where the sneering is coming from I think.

Well when you think about it the British colonised the East Coast of America until they were driven out. They were the invaders. The British colonised many other countries also, so have/had no desire to be anything other than the superior population they seem to think they are.

Immigrants and emigrants on the other hand were not colonisers, and in the case of the Irish particularly, went to US on coffin ships because the British sold what food the Irish could produce during the Great Famine back to Britain (Trevalyan's corn), and left the natives to either starve or leave.

There is a different dynamic involved in emigres than there is to those who didn't HAVE to emigrate i.e. were the overlords.

No wonder there is such a longing for ancestry, I think it is great to seek out your roots and have a rant as to why you are where you are. America has opened its arms to many people who needed it badly. Thank you America.

Perfectly said 👏 its the journey that many were forced to take , the survival and generational achievment that motivates people to proudly share their ancestry.
This in it's self explains the sneering and jealousy of those who's countries were the oppressers.They cant ever no the shared pride in ancestoral connections .

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 14/04/2023 20:56

In alphabetical order (going back to my great grandparents) I'm a mix of English, Irish, Roma, Russian and Welsh. I got the fairytales, the food and the traditions but I'm not Irish (even though they'd give me a passport) or Russian or Welsh. I don't even feel particularly English (lived there for 5 years as a very young child, never as an adult). Thus I admit I find it hard to understand people who identify so much with a country they've in many cases never visited. The stories I heard of Russia for example as a small child bear no resemblance to the Russia of today and my Russian family members have very different cultural references. One of my close friends co parents with a German American (great grandparents generation, he's never visited) and he assumed I must just have relatives from one country because I didn't overexplain my background at first meeting. When I answered his questions, he was annoyed that I don't identify as some hybrid and despite our original conversation being over 7 years ago, still brings it up.

My mil is Irish and identifies as such (grew up on the border with family on both sides). Dh doesn't consider himself Irish at all even though he has loads of family members living in Ireland and Northern Ireland. He works in a field which brings him into contact with many Americans and for some reason, people who are many generations removed from Ireland seem to take it personally that he doesn't identify as Irish. It came up recently with a St Patrick's day quiz (which he won) and he's not sure what annoyed the few Irish Americans more, the fact that they lost or that despite having an Irish parent, he doesn't see himself as Irish (it came up because they wanted to know how he won).

Speaking to an American who calls themselves Irish, I'd understand what they mean. It's the fact that many Americans seem to want me and dh and others to categorise ourselves in the same way and won't let it lie, which annoys me.

Trivium4all · 14/04/2023 20:46

Fuerza · 14/04/2023 19:58

I think it's because they don't update their stereotypes. I'm not from the UK, but my gp were Canadian. I'd get so much sideways eyeroll if I described myself as Canadian.

There's something to that. While it's perfectly understandable for people who have emigrated to wish to preserve aspects of their original culture, those cultures also evolve, away from the preserved version in North America (or anywhere else). When moving to Canada as a child, I didn't really recognise much of the "German culture" of the local German-Canadians, most of whose families had immigrated pre-war or earlier. To me, it appeared like some weird sort of Bavarian-Oktoberfest stereotype, not anything to do with modern Germany. So it felt very odd to hear classmates with German ancestry who didn't speak the language fluently and had never been to Germany call themselves "German", and it did feel a bit presumptuous. Now I'm weird in terms of my childhood cultural references being German, young-adult ones being mostly Canadian, and more recent adult onces being mostly British. Like some others on this thread, I don't completely seem to fit in with any of these.

Ludo19 · 14/04/2023 20:28

belleager · 14/04/2023 20:23

Not at all. I'm responding to the whole conversation quoted, but I did read your answer as agreeing Americans' views on ancestry were "weird", unlike your own.

Sorry if I misjudged you. But my comment stands for the posts you quoted, if so.

I was actually agreeing on the person I quoted about relating to where I was born. I wasn't being derogatory to America at all. I'm happy to have Irish and Dutch ancestry for all I know actually hope there's more thrown in but I can only relate to being Scottish.

Maybe don't jump to conclusions.

belleager · 14/04/2023 20:23

Ludo19 · 14/04/2023 20:17

Eh?

I never said EVERYONE needs to agree. It's plain to see you're just out to ruffle feathers.

Not at all. I'm responding to the whole conversation quoted, but I did read your answer as agreeing Americans' views on ancestry were "weird", unlike your own.

Sorry if I misjudged you. But my comment stands for the posts you quoted, if so.

Ludo19 · 14/04/2023 20:17

belleager · 14/04/2023 19:46

That's fine for you. Why shouldn't their way be fine for them?

I don't think this is something the world needs to agree on!

Eh?

I never said EVERYONE needs to agree. It's plain to see you're just out to ruffle feathers.

Pallisers · 14/04/2023 20:14

Hardbackwriter · 14/04/2023 18:51

Aside from the quite hilarious fact that you wrote that long and pompous post without knowing when the GFA was - celt-splaining indeed! - I think an objective observer would have to agree that the role of Americans believing they're Irish was at best a mixed blessing for the Troubles, what with all the funding the IRA.

I know exactly what the GFA is. I am Irish.