Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
bakebeans · 14/04/2023 23:11

MasterBeth · 14/04/2023 15:52

I think, if there's any sneering, it's at Americans with Irish / German / Italian heritage who describe themselves purely as Irish, German or Italian.

If you've been born and brought up in Dublin or Limerick, it sounds strange if a fourth-generation Californian Irish-American starts teling you how Irish they are.

This! 💯

ThePoshUns · 14/04/2023 23:10

I find it rather whimsical

belleager · 14/04/2023 23:10

Well, I'm Irish, and as far as I am concerned Biden and other descendents on Irish emigrants are very welcome to identify as Irish / Irish American.

I do not think that this is an unusual position in my culture or in theirs.

I understand that other nations won't all share this concept of identity. That doesn't make them wrong. Concepts have cultural context. It is normal that we would not all have the same approach.

If there were evidence of Biden manufacturing a connection or faking it, I'd be sorry. But the man is very obviously Irish American of a type half of us are related to! And like most of us, he has British family links too. So what? Irish ancestry isn't a blood purity thing. DNA is thoroughly mixed across Britain and Ireland. Nobody thinks Irish American means no British blood.

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:09

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:02

But why do they feel the need to add the African / Irish / Italian etc? If they're born and bred in America, why don't they just say they're American?

Why is their heritage and ancestry so important that it needs to be named over and above their actual birthplace?

As I said earlier in the thread (and following on from what you're saying) there's a very subtle difference in language. British is usually stated first (such as British Asian) unless specifically addressing race (then it's Black British). In America it's ethnicity first (Irish American) always. It's just an arse about face way of doing things and for me probably hampers race relations by keeping people firmly in a box rather than having a shared identity and then your individual one.

Thinking about it that's about right for America though, it's a very individualistic nation politically and socially. Maybe that's partly why they don't yet use a collective identity they are proud of.

Phoebo · 14/04/2023 23:09

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 23:08

Well said. I wonder also if @GordanoBenito and her ilk would have told Ngozi Fulani why is she playing up her African heritage and wearing African dress as she is British - somehow I don’t think so! 🙄

Exactly!! 👏👏👏
Such double standards.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 23:09

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 23:03

Did it ever cross your mind that Americans hold on tight to their heritage as this was passed down and given huge importance in their upbringing and the upbringing of their parents, grandparents, great grandparents etc. Did you ever stop to think that so many went to America as they had no choice - such as the Irish Americans who had to leave on coffin ships as the British were starving them to death. So to these people they idealise and love their home and heritage - they never wanted to leave and so they want to preserve it as much as they can and tell their children and grandchildren all about how they are Irish even though they live in America and pass on pride on their heritage. Personally I think it’s nice.

Its not their home. It likely hasn't been their home in a hundred plus years.

They may as well idealise Africa.

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 23:08

Busybutbored · 14/04/2023 23:05

People were very racist of new migrants (still are!) maybe they were proud of their roots and this carried through the generations. Everyone in America knows they're an immigrant so it would be strange to not acknowledge that. Lots of judgement, nasty comments on here 🤨 It is interesting that I think only Americans seem to do this, so there's obviously something different about their history, maybe it's something to do with the way it was colonised.

Well said. I wonder also if @GordanoBenito and her ilk would have told Ngozi Fulani why is she playing up her African heritage and wearing African dress as she is British - somehow I don’t think so! 🙄

Phoebo · 14/04/2023 23:06

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 23:03

Did it ever cross your mind that Americans hold on tight to their heritage as this was passed down and given huge importance in their upbringing and the upbringing of their parents, grandparents, great grandparents etc. Did you ever stop to think that so many went to America as they had no choice - such as the Irish Americans who had to leave on coffin ships as the British were starving them to death. So to these people they idealise and love their home and heritage - they never wanted to leave and so they want to preserve it as much as they can and tell their children and grandchildren all about how they are Irish even though they live in America and pass on pride on their heritage. Personally I think it’s nice.

Agree. It's a nice thing

Busybutbored · 14/04/2023 23:05

People were very racist of new migrants (still are!) maybe they were proud of their roots and this carried through the generations. Everyone in America knows they're an immigrant so it would be strange to not acknowledge that. Lots of judgement, nasty comments on here 🤨 It is interesting that I think only Americans seem to do this, so there's obviously something different about their history, maybe it's something to do with the way it was colonised.

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 23:03

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 22:52

"Brits seem to be raging that the POTUS went to Ireland and swerved the UK. That is where the sneering is coming from I think."

@CordyLines You couldn't be more wrong - I'm a 'Brit' and I couldn't care less that Biden is visiting Ireland - why would we?!

The main issue of the thread is something I do - I don't understand why Americans don't just say they're American. It's usually Irish American, Italian American, African American etc. For one of the most patriotic countries in the world, American people are very keen to claim that they're from elsewhere.

I have Italian blood in my family but I'd NEVER describe myself as "Italian British". Neither would most people from other countries - it's a peculiarly American thing.

Did it ever cross your mind that Americans hold on tight to their heritage as this was passed down and given huge importance in their upbringing and the upbringing of their parents, grandparents, great grandparents etc. Did you ever stop to think that so many went to America as they had no choice - such as the Irish Americans who had to leave on coffin ships as the British were starving them to death. So to these people they idealise and love their home and heritage - they never wanted to leave and so they want to preserve it as much as they can and tell their children and grandchildren all about how they are Irish even though they live in America and pass on pride on their heritage. Personally I think it’s nice.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 23:02

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 22:52

"Brits seem to be raging that the POTUS went to Ireland and swerved the UK. That is where the sneering is coming from I think."

@CordyLines You couldn't be more wrong - I'm a 'Brit' and I couldn't care less that Biden is visiting Ireland - why would we?!

The main issue of the thread is something I do - I don't understand why Americans don't just say they're American. It's usually Irish American, Italian American, African American etc. For one of the most patriotic countries in the world, American people are very keen to claim that they're from elsewhere.

I have Italian blood in my family but I'd NEVER describe myself as "Italian British". Neither would most people from other countries - it's a peculiarly American thing.

I agree. Its almost as if being American alone isn't good enough.

I have mixed race family and they have had Americans insist to them they couldn't be British because they are black. Just bizarre.

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:02

Atethehalloweenchocs · 14/04/2023 18:00

Because Americans never accept they're American despite being several generations into being an American. It's just strange.

Ermm, yes they do? That is why they identify as African American, or Irish American?

But why do they feel the need to add the African / Irish / Italian etc? If they're born and bred in America, why don't they just say they're American?

Why is their heritage and ancestry so important that it needs to be named over and above their actual birthplace?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/04/2023 23:00

Lol at us being jealous because Biden visited Ireland and not the UK 🤣

TokyoSushi · 14/04/2023 22:59

It's all just a bit odd. Joe Biden seems to be on a holiday combined with a state visit, playing up his Irish heritage which is in the distant past at best.

I used to live in the US and it's true that few are happy to be 'just' American, however I'm afraid I agree that if they could find some sort of link to bring Irish American then it seemed to have extra kudos.

I probably have similar Irish roots to Joe Biden but it wouldn't occur to be to describe myself as of Irish heritage.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/04/2023 22:59

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 15:48

Because Americans never accept they're American despite being several generations into being an American. It's just strange.

This.

We lives in the US for a while and SO MANY would claim to be Irish, or Scottish hey they’d never been and they were 5th generation. Ridiculous

Justanotherlurker · 14/04/2023 22:57

Ironically Biden has just as much one drop rule heritage to the Uk as he does Ireland, and the fact that it has become tradition for Americans to joke about who will be the Irish connection to share a pint of Guinness with after they have done the essential first few phone calls and visits to the UK on inauguration be.

American presidents want to keep there tax efficient companies in the EU via Ireland, the average American embarrasses themselves by bring up black and tan up the ra rhetoric at any possible convenience and get all U.S.A with any criticism.

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 22:55

@Anonymous48 "To many Americans, saying "I'm Irish" means "I'm Irish American."

Yes, we know that - but saying "Irish American" etc is ridiculous if 2+ generations of you were born and raised in the US!

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 22:52

"Brits seem to be raging that the POTUS went to Ireland and swerved the UK. That is where the sneering is coming from I think."

@CordyLines You couldn't be more wrong - I'm a 'Brit' and I couldn't care less that Biden is visiting Ireland - why would we?!

The main issue of the thread is something I do - I don't understand why Americans don't just say they're American. It's usually Irish American, Italian American, African American etc. For one of the most patriotic countries in the world, American people are very keen to claim that they're from elsewhere.

I have Italian blood in my family but I'd NEVER describe myself as "Italian British". Neither would most people from other countries - it's a peculiarly American thing.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 22:51

SilverGlitterBaubles · 14/04/2023 22:29

If Biden claimed British heritage in the same way right now I am pretty sure that Boris Johnson or Rishi Sunak would have played on this in the same manner as they did the 'special relationship'. Ireland has always had a strong connection with America and while I have many problems with aspects of the politics of that country at the very least without American support the GFA and peace in NI would not have happened.

No. Because we really don't care and think its utterly bizarre. Its not just British people either. Europeans think this too.

Fair enough if its your parents possibly grandparents, but otherwise claiming you are XYZ because of long dead ancestors makes you look like a fool. Its fake and smacks of a fetish.

Where does it stop? I guess I must identify as a Viking lol.

belleager · 14/04/2023 22:46

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 22:42

Let’s be honest. The sneering is purely as Joe Biden, one of the most powerful men on earth is immensely proud of and lives out his Irish heritage. Many British people (as evident with racist cartoons in one of the main papers, on Twitter and general sneering in U.K. media that prompted the OP to start this thread) view Irish people as lesser and so can’t stand that someone so important is giving Ireland and Irishness centre stage in the world and media.

I was interested in his emphasis on democracy and republicanism.

I am less surprised than I was that he's not going to Charles's coronation. I don't think that's about disliking or disrespecting Britain. But as he puts it - values.

belleager · 14/04/2023 22:43

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 22:39

That explanation conveniently forgets that Britain was invaded and oppressed by a variety of other people throughout history.

Also that the Irish themselves were colonisers.

Its cherry picking history

Mmm. But it's mass migration of the 19th century in particular that shaped Irish-American culture, and the continuation through the 20th century that shaped ideas of Irish diaspora.

I don't disagree with you about settlers and colonisers - it's not as simple as that. But the fact that the Irish in their major waves of emigration left reluctantly and often in traumatic circumstances shaped their bonds to each other and to Ireland for generations afterwards. These things fade. But you are still seeing them play out in Irish and American culture now.

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 22:42

Let’s be honest. The sneering is purely as Joe Biden, one of the most powerful men on earth is immensely proud of and lives out his Irish heritage. Many British people (as evident with racist cartoons in one of the main papers, on Twitter and general sneering in U.K. media that prompted the OP to start this thread) view Irish people as lesser and so can’t stand that someone so important is giving Ireland and Irishness centre stage in the world and media.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 22:39

Mocara · 14/04/2023 21:12

Perfectly said 👏 its the journey that many were forced to take , the survival and generational achievment that motivates people to proudly share their ancestry.
This in it's self explains the sneering and jealousy of those who's countries were the oppressers.They cant ever no the shared pride in ancestoral connections .

That explanation conveniently forgets that Britain was invaded and oppressed by a variety of other people throughout history.

Also that the Irish themselves were colonisers.

Its cherry picking history

Testina · 14/04/2023 22:35

“i identify with all my ancestors…

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English”

Well, like a PP said it’s more bewilderment than sneering. Trotting out words like “identify” - in what way exactly do you “identify with both your Swiss and Native American (very distant) relatives? I just don’t see that you can. It just sounds like you’ve done Ancestry DNA and are attention seeking over being Jewish and African and Scottish. I mean, basically - bollocks are you! Hence - bewilderment. It’s laughably tenuous.

Qbish · 14/04/2023 22:35

PonyPatter44 · 14/04/2023 22:09

To be fair, virtually all American presidents (with the ignoble exception of 45) identify as Irish. Even this dude

What do you mean by "even this dude" when you refer to Obama?

Are you being just a little bit racist, there?