Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Mittens1717 · 15/04/2023 00:32

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 00:30

I am Irish and I have no problem with Biden or anybody else claiming to be Irish American or Irish. If they are speaking with an American accent and say they are Irish I obviously know they mean they are of Irish descent, they are Irish American.

Biden's ancestors are 10/16 Irish. He grew up in Scranton in a very Irish community. He spent a lot of time with his grandparents whose parents came from Ireland.
The Irish who travelled to America did so out of necessity, they formed communities and ensured they passed down their Irish culture and traditions to the next generation. This could be through religion by going to mass every Sunday, the importance of family, Irish music and poetry, children attending Irish dancing lessons and/or playing Irish sports, attending Irish Catholic schools.
Joe Biden talks about how his grandparents and parents were so proud of their Irish culture, about how they told him 'the best bit of him was Irish' and about how he was equal to anyone, no better or no worse than anyody else. It was this upbringing that formed his identity and that of millions more Americans of Irish descent. He clearly has a strong affinity for Ireland, it was an important part of his culture growing up and he has visited Ireland on many occasions and has made strong connections with his cousins etc.

Personally I think that it is really nice that so many Irish Americans have held on to that culture and identity.

👏👏

Mittens1717 · 15/04/2023 00:30

Swiftbushome · 14/04/2023 16:04

It's just claiming to be something you're not though isn't it? Biden is American. He goes to Ireland and says he's "home" except he isn't so it's a lie. I bet a load of Brits could claim to be Vikings for instance if you look back for enough. I think it's one thing to say you have "Viking heritage" for example but to call yourself a Viking is just lying. And that is what a lot of Americans do when they claim to be Irish or Italian or whatever. They're not, they're American. A lot of the time their parents and even grandparents were born in America as well.
And Biden for example only talks up the Irish side of his ancestry - his mother's side. He keeps quiet about his father's heritage which has been shown to have been slave owners! Really annoys me.

Biden also talks about his fathers side who were also Irish, in fact he speaks a lot about his Irish heritage on his Fathers side, and he has many cousins in Co Mayo whom he visits each time he comes here

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 00:30

I am Irish and I have no problem with Biden or anybody else claiming to be Irish American or Irish. If they are speaking with an American accent and say they are Irish I obviously know they mean they are of Irish descent, they are Irish American.

Biden's ancestors are 10/16 Irish. He grew up in Scranton in a very Irish community. He spent a lot of time with his grandparents whose parents came from Ireland.
The Irish who travelled to America did so out of necessity, they formed communities and ensured they passed down their Irish culture and traditions to the next generation. This could be through religion by going to mass every Sunday, the importance of family, Irish music and poetry, children attending Irish dancing lessons and/or playing Irish sports, attending Irish Catholic schools.
Joe Biden talks about how his grandparents and parents were so proud of their Irish culture, about how they told him 'the best bit of him was Irish' and about how he was equal to anyone, no better or no worse than anyody else. It was this upbringing that formed his identity and that of millions more Americans of Irish descent. He clearly has a strong affinity for Ireland, it was an important part of his culture growing up and he has visited Ireland on many occasions and has made strong connections with his cousins etc.

Personally I think that it is really nice that so many Irish Americans have held on to that culture and identity.

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 00:16

Alot of these attitudes are really problematic. My child is one sixteenth of a "native" of the colonised country they live in ... for me it will be very important that they understand and retain that part of their culture. What many posters are basically saying is because they will look white, and most people will think they are white it will be ridiculous for them to also identify with that part of their ethnicity, race and culture. That's white washing in the ultimate form! I think some of you posters really need to think about what you are saying and the implications of that.

HamBone · 15/04/2023 00:15

Dotcheck · 14/04/2023 23:33

I agree with @Anotheronetwoone

I Am Canadian. My mother’s family ( her grandfather) came from the Ukraine. They settled in a town mostly populated by others from the Ukraine, spoke the language, ate the food, followed the religion and customs, much the same way they would have in the Ukraine.
They came to a country with very low population, no settled towns. They were given land ( yes, I know this is problematic) and sent to populate an area where there was very little infrastructure. Basically, there was no ‘Canadian’ identity. Of course they hung on to their Ukrainian identity- what else was there? This was handed down through the generations.
Their temerity was enormous. At what point do you think people just let go of it? We are all Canadian but ignoring the Ukrainian heritage is impossible

@Dotcheck My husband’s family was similar, his great-grandparents lived in Croatian and Polish immigrant communities and learned limited English. Their children went to school in the US though and married outside the communities so the languages and most traditions were gradually lost.

I wonder whether these connections might be less important to younger generations as the world’s a much smaller place now? The countries your ancestors left aren’t mythical places now, you easily my find out about them and watch TikTok’s made practically anywhere!

DixonD · 14/04/2023 23:51

MattDamon · 14/04/2023 16:22

The United States is primarily a country of immigrants. It makes sense for them to talk about where they came from. Something like 10% of Americans are direct descendents of the Pilgrims who came over on the Mayflower.

This - if I were an American I’d spend hours researching my ancestry. I do already, but I’m British and most of my ancestry is southern and east England. I have Welsh great grandparents but I am not Welsh - I have welsh ancestry. If I were American I’d describe it in the same way.

There’s no harm in finding out where you came from - it’s fascinating, and addictive!

ChocChipHandbag · 14/04/2023 23:46

Dotcheck · 14/04/2023 23:33

I agree with @Anotheronetwoone

I Am Canadian. My mother’s family ( her grandfather) came from the Ukraine. They settled in a town mostly populated by others from the Ukraine, spoke the language, ate the food, followed the religion and customs, much the same way they would have in the Ukraine.
They came to a country with very low population, no settled towns. They were given land ( yes, I know this is problematic) and sent to populate an area where there was very little infrastructure. Basically, there was no ‘Canadian’ identity. Of course they hung on to their Ukrainian identity- what else was there? This was handed down through the generations.
Their temerity was enormous. At what point do you think people just let go of it? We are all Canadian but ignoring the Ukrainian heritage is impossible

I thought it was considered inappropriate to call Ukraine "The" Ukraine these days?

montysma1 · 14/04/2023 23:40

I sneer. At tartan obsessed Americans who claim to be "Scotch" and think we al Iive with our clans.

belleager · 14/04/2023 23:37

MuddlingMackem · 14/04/2023 23:21

It's interesting how the American posters explain the importance of their heritage as so many immigrants were forced by circumstance to leave their country of origin.

I would think that actually there are a lot of immigrants to the UK who also emigrated unwillingly - eg, those who escaped the Nazis, Ugandan Asians, and of course the current wave of Hong Kongers. I would be interested to know if any descendants of such immigrants to Britain also give their ancestry such prominence in their identity, or just says they're British.

Up to them. Presumably, people are less likely to maintain these identities if the disadvantages outweigh the advantages, or if an emphasis on family heritage is less socially acceptable. Urbanisation, settlement patterns etc play a part. Social welfare state too.

It's not just about where you migrate from: it's about where you migrate to.

missinglalaland · 14/04/2023 23:35

Growing up, I remember kids asking each other “where are you from?” Or “What are you?”

We were all white. No one minded the question and everyone liked answering, proud to share their heritage.

That was 40 years ago. Maybe things have changed, but I doubt it.

Dotcheck · 14/04/2023 23:33

I agree with @Anotheronetwoone

I Am Canadian. My mother’s family ( her grandfather) came from the Ukraine. They settled in a town mostly populated by others from the Ukraine, spoke the language, ate the food, followed the religion and customs, much the same way they would have in the Ukraine.
They came to a country with very low population, no settled towns. They were given land ( yes, I know this is problematic) and sent to populate an area where there was very little infrastructure. Basically, there was no ‘Canadian’ identity. Of course they hung on to their Ukrainian identity- what else was there? This was handed down through the generations.
Their temerity was enormous. At what point do you think people just let go of it? We are all Canadian but ignoring the Ukrainian heritage is impossible

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:33

@Anotheronetwoone I'm not put out in the slightest 🤣

I saw this thread and decided to comment as a) it's a public chat board and b) it's talking about a very peculiar quirk of Americans that I - and clearly many many others - have noticed.

I feel more perplexed than sneery to be honest but that might be just typical of my ilk.

Interesting that you've mentioned the British media in your strop to me but I neither control or represent whatever media you've seen so it's irrelevant.

belleager · 14/04/2023 23:32

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:09

As I said earlier in the thread (and following on from what you're saying) there's a very subtle difference in language. British is usually stated first (such as British Asian) unless specifically addressing race (then it's Black British). In America it's ethnicity first (Irish American) always. It's just an arse about face way of doing things and for me probably hampers race relations by keeping people firmly in a box rather than having a shared identity and then your individual one.

Thinking about it that's about right for America though, it's a very individualistic nation politically and socially. Maybe that's partly why they don't yet use a collective identity they are proud of.

I think this is a major stretch. Interesting to think about but not convincing.

The convention isn't as strong as you suggest: you'll hear Chinese British Asian British, Indian British. Black British and Asian British are the two on the UK census. Actually what is most interesting about that census (and these categories are used elsewhere too) is that you can't identify as e.g. Caribbean British. You can be Black Caribbean. You can't be Irish British. Some ethnicities can be British, some can't.

America is less divisive if we go by language alone. But I don't think we should. People have their own, historically shaped, identities. They have preferred terms. Bureaucrats don't always think very hard. So I wouldn't read too much into it.

There are a few places on this thread where people imply that Americans just haven't got as far as the rest of us, yet. I'd like to know what it is they haven't achieved that Britain has. It is funny, because America was born of a notion of progress that suggested leaving the monarchy behind. It's not a failed or delayed Britain, whatever else it is. It is a distinct culture. I have never had the impression Americans are less proud of their American identity than the British.

MrsMikeDrop · 14/04/2023 23:30

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:18

"I wonder also if @GordanoBenito and her ilk would have told Ngozi Fulani why is she playing up her African heritage and wearing African dress as she is British - somehow I don’t think so! 🙄"

@Anotheronetwoone My ilk? Would you care to elaborate what you mean by that?

Ngozi's parents were immigrants so she has direct living experience of her heritage. This thread started specifically about Americans and I'm taking about Americans who claim to be Irish American etc even when their family has lived in the US for several generations with no living experience of what it means to be an Irish person.

I posted upthread about this. Coloured people are always asked "where they come from" even if they are third, fourth etc generation. It seems if you are coloured you will always be asked what your ethnicity is. Yet if you do this if you are white, this is ridiculous to many. Very, very bizarre. Is fourth generation Chinese American allowed to identify as a Chinese American? Or is that ridiculous too?? Genuine question and something to think about

Anotheronetwoone · 14/04/2023 23:23

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:18

"I wonder also if @GordanoBenito and her ilk would have told Ngozi Fulani why is she playing up her African heritage and wearing African dress as she is British - somehow I don’t think so! 🙄"

@Anotheronetwoone My ilk? Would you care to elaborate what you mean by that?

Ngozi's parents were immigrants so she has direct living experience of her heritage. This thread started specifically about Americans and I'm taking about Americans who claim to be Irish American etc even when their family has lived in the US for several generations with no living experience of what it means to be an Irish person.

Ah ok so people are allowed to be proud of their heritage if you approve of the circumstances but otherwise it’s not permitted. I get it.

You’re Ilk - sneery people who can’t stand someone else being happy to embrace their heritage as Americans do and Biden has this week. I find it pathetic how put out you are by Americans being proud of their roots.

and the absolute tantrums by the British media that Ireland is getting global attention and is Biden’s ‘favourite’ have been ridiculous. 🙄

MuddlingMackem · 14/04/2023 23:21

It's interesting how the American posters explain the importance of their heritage as so many immigrants were forced by circumstance to leave their country of origin.

I would think that actually there are a lot of immigrants to the UK who also emigrated unwillingly - eg, those who escaped the Nazis, Ugandan Asians, and of course the current wave of Hong Kongers. I would be interested to know if any descendants of such immigrants to Britain also give their ancestry such prominence in their identity, or just says they're British.

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:20

@Isanyoneup "It's just an arse about face way of doing things and for me probably hampers race relations by keeping people firmly in a box rather than having a shared identity and then your individual one."

Totally agree with you on this point.

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:18

"I wonder also if @GordanoBenito and her ilk would have told Ngozi Fulani why is she playing up her African heritage and wearing African dress as she is British - somehow I don’t think so! 🙄"

@Anotheronetwoone My ilk? Would you care to elaborate what you mean by that?

Ngozi's parents were immigrants so she has direct living experience of her heritage. This thread started specifically about Americans and I'm taking about Americans who claim to be Irish American etc even when their family has lived in the US for several generations with no living experience of what it means to be an Irish person.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 23:18

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:11

But Britain is almost entirely populated by migrants. We are a seafaring nation for millennia with a history of migration in all directions from day dot. You'll be hard pressed to find a British person who isn't some hybrid of nationalities.

Exactly. We are all mixed, as are the Irish.

Anyone with any knowledge of our history knows this which is another reason x generation Americans claiming to be Irish or Scottish or whatever is just nonsense.

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:18

Mustardandchickensandwiches · 14/04/2023 23:16

Fun fact, I had a DNA test done out of curiosity a couple of years ago and, I'm as British as you can get.

My ancestors hail from Sheffield. We've migrated slightly south to Nottingham over the millennia.

Seasoned travellers I see, that's an epic voyage to make i can see why it took so long

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:17

missinglalaland · 14/04/2023 23:14

I am an American whose family goes back to before the revolutionary war. Like other Americans whose families have been in North America for generations, I’ve lost all touch with my English roots. They are just too distant and forgotten. I’m more aware of more recent antecedents from Ireland, Scandinavia and German speaking middle Europe, who came more recently.

After so many generations, my background is very mixed. I’m not much of any one thing.

With a list this long, which should I choose?
Irish
English
Scottish
German
Austrian
Hungarian
Belgian
French
Dutch
Danish
French

There is a great deal of English DNA in Americans, it’s just lost in the sands of time, so to speak. The culture is not lost though. There is a strong historical/sociological argument that as the first settlers, the English set the pattern, and subsequent settlers learned English and English folkways thus assimilating and perpetuating English culture. This might not feel true to contemporary English people, but remember the jumping off point was the 1600s. There has been a lot of separate, isolated further development since then.

I find American history and the language and accent formation fascinating. There's a town in the south that has a dialect that is almost unchanged from when the settlers landed. If you want to hear early English they're the best group of people to hear it from, it's like another language compared to modern English.

Mustardandchickensandwiches · 14/04/2023 23:16

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:11

But Britain is almost entirely populated by migrants. We are a seafaring nation for millennia with a history of migration in all directions from day dot. You'll be hard pressed to find a British person who isn't some hybrid of nationalities.

Fun fact, I had a DNA test done out of curiosity a couple of years ago and, I'm as British as you can get.

My ancestors hail from Sheffield. We've migrated slightly south to Nottingham over the millennia.

missinglalaland · 14/04/2023 23:14

I am an American whose family goes back to before the revolutionary war. Like other Americans whose families have been in North America for generations, I’ve lost all touch with my English roots. They are just too distant and forgotten. I’m more aware of more recent antecedents from Ireland, Scandinavia and German speaking middle Europe, who came more recently.

After so many generations, my background is very mixed. I’m not much of any one thing.

With a list this long, which should I choose?
Irish
English
Scottish
German
Austrian
Hungarian
Belgian
French
Dutch
Danish
French

There is a great deal of English DNA in Americans, it’s just lost in the sands of time, so to speak. The culture is not lost though. There is a strong historical/sociological argument that as the first settlers, the English set the pattern, and subsequent settlers learned English and English folkways thus assimilating and perpetuating English culture. This might not feel true to contemporary English people, but remember the jumping off point was the 1600s. There has been a lot of separate, isolated further development since then.

Mustardandchickensandwiches · 14/04/2023 23:12

It's because Americans think their "heritage" makes them so very interesting and different.

I have lost count of the times my American colleague claims to be a direct descendent of William the Conquerer.

Why are they always related to royalty?

It's tiresome and immediately makes me decide the person is a huge bore. Every time.

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:11

Busybutbored · 14/04/2023 23:05

People were very racist of new migrants (still are!) maybe they were proud of their roots and this carried through the generations. Everyone in America knows they're an immigrant so it would be strange to not acknowledge that. Lots of judgement, nasty comments on here 🤨 It is interesting that I think only Americans seem to do this, so there's obviously something different about their history, maybe it's something to do with the way it was colonised.

But Britain is almost entirely populated by migrants. We are a seafaring nation for millennia with a history of migration in all directions from day dot. You'll be hard pressed to find a British person who isn't some hybrid of nationalities.