Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
TomPinch · 15/04/2023 03:32

I'm part of a British / NZ / Australian family with branches in all three countries going back to the mid-19th century. The links are important to us, and the branches are still in touch with each other. It appears to be the same in the Biden family wrt the US and Ireland and completely unexceptional that he should feel connected to his family roots in Ireland.

As it happens, I have Irish ancestry too, but as no one is in contact with any relative in Ireland, it would be odd for me to claim much affinity to the Emerald Isle. Biden, on the other hand, clearly still does have very close and natural links.

I expect a good amount of Biden's antipathy was actually towards the way that the UK government has been carrying on, particularly when Johnson was PM. Biden is the antithesis of Johnson and it's utterly unsurprising that they didn't get on.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 15/04/2023 03:32

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 15:48

Because Americans never accept they're American despite being several generations into being an American. It's just strange.

That’s just a dumb statement. They accept they are Americans and also recognize their ancestry, it’s not that hard to comprehend.

WandaWonder · 15/04/2023 03:28

It's the weird 'Mayflower' connection that there is an air of being better than others I don't get

My2pence2day · 15/04/2023 03:22

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 02:40

I do not understand what the problem is when someone is proud of their culture and heritage.

Being Irish American is a part of who Joe Biden is but it us not everything he is. I understand this. I also understand when Americans say they are Irish it means they have grown up with Irish culture and traditions, often to different degrees.

As an Irish person it does not bother me one bit when Americans say they are Irish or Irish American. I am happy that they are interested in Ireland and proud of their heritage.

We Irish love to see American visitors coming to lreland and I am sure their ancestor's would be so proud that they kept their culture and identity alive through the generations.

I do not understand why people who are not American and not Irish are so concerned about it tbh.

Very well said 👏

Nicecow · 15/04/2023 03:05

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 02:57

It's because Americans think their "heritage" makes them so very interesting and different.

No. It's amusing that so many posters view someone referring to themselves as Irish-American or Italian-American, etc. as "boasting", like there's some sort of cachet in claiming an immigrant heritage. Many immigrants were looked down upon and faced a great deal of prejudice. Still do, in fact.

If anything, it was sometimes an act of defiance: " Yeah, I'm Polish-American, I've heard all the Polish jokes, so what?"

At any rate you'll rarely hear younger Americans referring to themselves as anything other than "American". Their immigrant great-grandparents are distant memories to them and the old-country traditions either forgotten or absorbed into their American way of life. Time has a way of doing that.

Agree. They were very racist against Irish and Polish looking at some history. I can only assume this made their ancestors want to be proud of their history and pass that down. Much like black people there. It's actually lovely. Instead of letting others make them feel ashamed they've embraced their heritage.

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 03:01

Anonymous48 · 14/04/2023 16:25

No, you obviously don't understand. It's semantics.

To many Americans, saying "I'm Irish" means "I'm Irish American."

How often do you hear us saying "I'm Welsh English" or "I'm Italian British"?

I'll save your time. Never, We never say that, so this oft-repeated explanation helps not a jot. It's weird & daft!

Over here, we do have concepts such as "Anglo Indian" but even those are old-fashioned now. You're far more likely to hear British POC responding to questions about their origin with "London" or "England".

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 02:57

It's because Americans think their "heritage" makes them so very interesting and different.

No. It's amusing that so many posters view someone referring to themselves as Irish-American or Italian-American, etc. as "boasting", like there's some sort of cachet in claiming an immigrant heritage. Many immigrants were looked down upon and faced a great deal of prejudice. Still do, in fact.

If anything, it was sometimes an act of defiance: " Yeah, I'm Polish-American, I've heard all the Polish jokes, so what?"

At any rate you'll rarely hear younger Americans referring to themselves as anything other than "American". Their immigrant great-grandparents are distant memories to them and the old-country traditions either forgotten or absorbed into their American way of life. Time has a way of doing that.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 15/04/2023 02:51

I also find they judge those who cannot identify their heritage... despite the many awful reasons behind that.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 15/04/2023 02:50

They cling to it as a cultural marker of identity and status while ignoring American culture as 'cheap'. Despite never living in the cultures they claim to hail from.

They also cherry pick.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/04/2023 02:43

Yeah, americans say "I'm italian" they don't actually mean they are Italian.

It's the oddest thing. I lived in Italy, speak semi-fluent Italian, spend time there a lot, have close friends, could sleep on a number of sofas, and was taught to cook there. If we took a test I would be more 'Italian' than Italian Americans. I'm not Italian. It is clearly a distinct culture, but it's distinct from Italian culture as well as American. Italians don't see themselves in Italian Americans for the most part. This stuff travels one way.

Same in sub-Saharan Africa. Many Americans 'coming home' who were more fish out of water than I was with my blonde hair and Vampiric skin. The local people were bemused that the Americans considered themselves African and didn't see themselves in the newcomers at all. It was a sobering experience. And must have been very sad for the Americans.

I think it's sometimes complicated because often the indigenous cultures cash in with tartan shops and tourist stuff but it's just skin deep.

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 02:40

I do not understand what the problem is when someone is proud of their culture and heritage.

Being Irish American is a part of who Joe Biden is but it us not everything he is. I understand this. I also understand when Americans say they are Irish it means they have grown up with Irish culture and traditions, often to different degrees.

As an Irish person it does not bother me one bit when Americans say they are Irish or Irish American. I am happy that they are interested in Ireland and proud of their heritage.

We Irish love to see American visitors coming to lreland and I am sure their ancestor's would be so proud that they kept their culture and identity alive through the generations.

I do not understand why people who are not American and not Irish are so concerned about it tbh.

sashh · 15/04/2023 02:32

Pallisers · 14/04/2023 16:39

America is a country of immigrants. There is a lot of pain in that fact. It wasn't all "america looks nice, lets move there and be americans" For many many people in the past they left family, friends, traditions, cultures and never saw them again. They were economic immigrants or fleeing pogroms or famines or war etc. It is any surprise that those immigrants would try to remember and honour their traditions?

Yeah, americans say "I'm italian" they don't actually mean they are Italian. They mean "we follow some Italian traditions, do the seven fishes on xmas eve, have pasta at every big occasion, will some day plan a trip to Italy to see where our great grandparents came from' They know they are american. They don't need brits to tell them that (despite apparently being just teenagers trying to keep up with the big older real adult countries in the world ffs)

I think Joe Biden gave the perfect opportunity for people to sneer at the Irish and at Americans - win/win. usually they have to chose.

And all that Irish americanism in politics has had a real benefit for Ireland - and for the UK. Thanks in part to american and irish american intervention, 10 years ago a civil war in the UK - that the UK seemed unable to stop and that caused untold suffering to UK subjects - ended

It's 25 years since the Good Friday agreement.

The people of the island or Ireland voted for it, and the people of NI have kept the fragile peace going.

There was minimal involvement from the US, unlike the Noraid funding.

The sneering, I think, is because as several people have said, saying, "I'm Irish" means "Irish American" in the US, is that it doesn't in the rest of the world, but Americans seem to assume their way is the norm.

Not just with this, the first floor in a building is what the rest of the world calls the ground floor. Keeping eggs in the fridge, again something the rest of the world doesn't do.

I find it quite amusing.

I think in Britain we are much more likely to claim we are from where we are born. Jimmy Carr calls himself a 'plastic paddy', he has Irish parents and an Irish passport but is English.

HamBone · 15/04/2023 02:28

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 00:16

Alot of these attitudes are really problematic. My child is one sixteenth of a "native" of the colonised country they live in ... for me it will be very important that they understand and retain that part of their culture. What many posters are basically saying is because they will look white, and most people will think they are white it will be ridiculous for them to also identify with that part of their ethnicity, race and culture. That's white washing in the ultimate form! I think some of you posters really need to think about what you are saying and the implications of that.

@Mamaneedsadrink If they live there though, aren’t they a citizen of that country and familiar with its traditions and customs?

Are you saying that they have one great-great grandparent whose ancestors were originally from that country?

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 02:28

DorritLittle · 15/04/2023 01:12

A pp makes a good point that Joe Biden was brought up in an Irish Catholic community, in the 50s. My DM was brought up in an Irish community around the same time, going to convents with Irish nuns, doing Irish dancing, with Irish relatives still around and feels similarly. Whereas for me my heritage is interesting to me (I was brought up catholic for example and that’s why) but I don’t feel Irish.

People are going to experience these things differently. You are also generation away from your mothers experience.

I do feel the Irish identity is so much stronger in America because it is so far away. Those who left for America knew they would never go back home, never see the people and places they loved again. It must have been so hard.

Phoebo · 15/04/2023 01:41

DorritLittle · 15/04/2023 01:12

A pp makes a good point that Joe Biden was brought up in an Irish Catholic community, in the 50s. My DM was brought up in an Irish community around the same time, going to convents with Irish nuns, doing Irish dancing, with Irish relatives still around and feels similarly. Whereas for me my heritage is interesting to me (I was brought up catholic for example and that’s why) but I don’t feel Irish.

Well that's a very valid point. Someone can feel more of "something" if they are brought up with those traditions. For example you could have two Italian families, exact same backgrounds and both second generation British. If one has grown up speaking Italian, eating Italian food etc they probably would "feel" more Italian than the other who didn't have anything to do with that background, even though genetically they are the same. Same with a white family who immigrates to China! Identity can't be prescribed to you by someone else, like many posters on here seem to think.

Dotcheck · 15/04/2023 01:39

ChocChipHandbag · 14/04/2023 23:46

I thought it was considered inappropriate to call Ukraine "The" Ukraine these days?

Oh

DorritLittle · 15/04/2023 01:12

A pp makes a good point that Joe Biden was brought up in an Irish Catholic community, in the 50s. My DM was brought up in an Irish community around the same time, going to convents with Irish nuns, doing Irish dancing, with Irish relatives still around and feels similarly. Whereas for me my heritage is interesting to me (I was brought up catholic for example and that’s why) but I don’t feel Irish.

Busybutbored · 15/04/2023 01:07

Talipesmum · 15/04/2023 00:55

It’s fine to be proud of your ancestry. It’s great. But it’s generally weird, for brits / English / welsh / Scots / Irish etc to say that your ancestry is more YOU than the actual place you are from, especially if you haven’t lived in that place or your direct parents haven’t lived in that place. And we note that some bits of ancestry are quoted a lot more than others - so it feels like it’s less about where you’re from and more about what bits of heritage feel interesting and sympathetic. And when people who are actually FROM that place find it hard to identity with your experience. Loads of brits etc have very mixed heritage which we’re happy to acknowledge and proud of - but we recognise we are no longer of that place if we have no direct connections there. Fine to be proud of it and I appreciate that there are immigrant community heritage traditions to be upheld, but please recognise this isn’t in any way the same as being actually from that place any more.

So how long before you aren't allowed to claim that part of your history? And why does this seem appear to apply if you are white? Another poster who made a reference to Obama, that somehow it was even more ridiculous for him to have Irish ancestry compared to other presidents even though of course he was half white. Who's not to say that he might be more Irish than a whiter president, he probably is. This is why I think there is alot to unpack. It's not so black and white, pardon the pun!

StormTreader · 15/04/2023 01:06

Its the feeling of cultural appropriation, like they're approaching it as a fun quirky hobby or treating it like its a kind of star sign.

Theres a lot of history, conflict, real-world historical and current political and cultural issues and debates in every country and having an American turn up wearing a silly green shamrock hat loudly declaring they're Irish and yelling "Top O' the morning!" and thinking thats all that being Irish is is pretty insulting.

On that basis if thats how we're doing it, a lot of Americans are also slave-owners because they're descended from them, but I think they'd agree that actually that doesn't count because it was so long ago. You don't just get to pick all the marshmallows out of your historical cereal.

Talipesmum · 15/04/2023 00:59

Also agree that it’s a clear sign of racism when eg black British people are asked “where are you REALLY from?” The asking of that question is a clear racist flag, an indication that the asker doesn’t see how someone who looks “other” can be from England / wales etc. We want people to be able to say they’re from Wales / England / Ireland etc if that’s where they grew up. So the insistence on heritage as more important than present place can feel jarring and somewhat racist to us.

Talipesmum · 15/04/2023 00:55

Busybutbored · 15/04/2023 00:40

Which is why it's so strange that so many British seem to be upset that Americans are proud of their ancestry. There is alot to unpack there!!

It’s fine to be proud of your ancestry. It’s great. But it’s generally weird, for brits / English / welsh / Scots / Irish etc to say that your ancestry is more YOU than the actual place you are from, especially if you haven’t lived in that place or your direct parents haven’t lived in that place. And we note that some bits of ancestry are quoted a lot more than others - so it feels like it’s less about where you’re from and more about what bits of heritage feel interesting and sympathetic. And when people who are actually FROM that place find it hard to identity with your experience. Loads of brits etc have very mixed heritage which we’re happy to acknowledge and proud of - but we recognise we are no longer of that place if we have no direct connections there. Fine to be proud of it and I appreciate that there are immigrant community heritage traditions to be upheld, but please recognise this isn’t in any way the same as being actually from that place any more.

Phoebo · 15/04/2023 00:48

WhiplashGirlchild · 14/04/2023 18:38

I wonder why Americans never seem to go around claiming "I'm Chinese", "I'm Nigerian"? It turns out that not all nationalities and cultures are fair game for people to claim. They'll say "I'm part Chinese" or "I have Nigerian heritage" like the rest of the English speaking world. The wholesale hijack of European identities is somewhere between cringe and plain rude.

Because they're probably not 🙄🤣 the ones that are, do. Plenty of Chinese Americans etc🤦‍♀️

MrsMikeDrop · 15/04/2023 00:45

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 14/04/2023 19:38

I'm shocked someone never heard of Chinese-American or Asian-American! This is actually a significant part of the population in the US.

It's only if you're white then it doesn't count. But of course if you're not white then you aren't American, or British or Australian or whatever. Then you'll be asked where you're really from. Go figure. 🤷‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏿‍♀️

Rainbowshit · 15/04/2023 00:40

We were skiing in the US and one of the ski guides badges said he was from Glasgow. As I come from and live in Glasgow we stopped to speak to him.

He'd never been to Glasgow in his life. 🙈His mother had been born in Glasgow and moved to the US as a child.

Have to say I was a bit perplexed that someone would say they were from somewhere they had never been to.

Busybutbored · 15/04/2023 00:40

Isanyoneup · 14/04/2023 23:11

But Britain is almost entirely populated by migrants. We are a seafaring nation for millennia with a history of migration in all directions from day dot. You'll be hard pressed to find a British person who isn't some hybrid of nationalities.

Which is why it's so strange that so many British seem to be upset that Americans are proud of their ancestry. There is alot to unpack there!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread