Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
firef1y · 15/04/2023 08:16

Not sneering but I do find it strange that a nation that is made up 99% (at least) of relatively recent immigrants, so many of which are proud of their heritage has so many insular racists.
There again I also find it strange how many insular racists there are in the UK, another nation that consists of the descendents of immigrants, from Romans onwards.
Difference is we don't tend to make such a big deal over who we are decended from. I mean I know I have relatively recent Irish (my grandfather), Polish (grandmother) and a fair amount of Roma (same grandparents), but I still put British on forms that ask for my ethnicity. I can have pride in where I come from, without declaring it all the time.

KnittingNeedles · 15/04/2023 08:14

North Americans are much more interested in their ancestry than English/Welsh/Scottish people. Genealogy is a HUGE thing in North America, multiple TV programmes about it. Anyone who has ever done an Ancestry DNA test will have multiple matches in the US/Canada.

This is not a bad thing, or a weird thing. It is simply that they have interests in different things. Americans/Canadians play ice hockey and baseball. We do not. This just another cultural difference.

Yes it might seem a bit weird calling yourself Scottish or Irish when you've never set foot in Edinburgh or Dublin. But really, what harm is it doing? None whatsoever. And it encourages those North Americans who do feel they have strong ties to any part of the UK to come here and spend money. Which is a positive thing.

https://pureportal.strath.ac.uk/en/projects/understanding-ancestral-tourism-2

Understanding Ancestral Tourism

https://pureportal.strath.ac.uk/en/projects/understanding-ancestral-tourism-2

junebirthdaygirl · 15/04/2023 08:14

I think the lrish stuck together a lot when they arrived ( I'm Irish) and their communities were very definitely lrish. Some even spoke the lrish language among themselves. They grew up doing lrish dancing/ playing garlic games/ marrying among themselves/ attending RC churches together so their children were very conscious of being lrish. I have relatives in the US and this is how they lived. They took a very keen interest in home
They were very focused on education and on doing well. Also lrish people due to their history are often very keen on politics so they often got involved. Two brothers whose parents are from Donegal are in the Senate. Their mom was the school lollipop lady and their dad cleaned an underground car park. They managed to educate their sons to a high level and their conversation at home was about history/ politics etc. They are lrish!!
If one of them or their ancestors became US president l would consider them lrish. Same with my own relatives.

StephanieSuperpowers · 15/04/2023 08:13

Florissant · 15/04/2023 07:06

It's just another way for Brits to sneer at Americans.

And the Irish in a twofer. Find a way to drag the French in and they'll be in heaven.

Kanaloa · 15/04/2023 08:04

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/04/2023 23:02

I agree. Its almost as if being American alone isn't good enough.

I have mixed race family and they have had Americans insist to them they couldn't be British because they are black. Just bizarre.

I once had an American tell me off for saying black instead of African American. I was talking about a friend of mine, who was born and raised in the UK and has no African heritage. How on earth could she be African American? She is neither African or American! Had a similar issue in a class over there when I referred to the representation of Indian people in The Secret Garden. Was quietly corrected that it is ‘Native American.’

Sometimes I wonder if some people are just blinkered maybe.

Kanaloa · 15/04/2023 07:59

It’s not so much sneering that they have ancestry, but I find it odd how they seem to think that ancestry makes them whatever they’re saying. I’ve had people in America before say ‘oh you’re from Ireland! I’m Irish!’ The irony there being that they’re American and if they were Irish they’d probably twig that I’m Scottish!

I mean I’d find it a bit odd if someone with a strong Manchester accent told me they were French, then amended it to explain their ancestors in the 1700s lived in France. If you’ve never been to a country, have no relatives who grew up there, and don’t know anything about that country, it’s a bit odd to say you are from there.

Fuerza · 15/04/2023 07:48

American politicians love the narrative of the Irish arriving in America.

It's all narrative. Watching Better Call Saul when Saul reveals his name is Jimmy McGill (I'm Irish). It's kind of like the default. You're not a wasp, you're the regular American white guy. You're Irish.

it's not just the politicians being cynical, everybody wants to identify with that resilience and capability, even if the truth is that they're 3/4s Polish. For example. Is there a narrative for Poland? Not so much.

So arriving in America and having nothing financially and dealing with the established citizens excluding you to retain their privilege but still overcoming that to be successful and loved is the american dream, but the Irish didn't have nothing, they had each other and they formed parishes and had support/customer bases that way. Other similarly excluded groups weren't doing that.

Startwithamimosa · 15/04/2023 07:45

Bubblesoffun · 15/04/2023 07:22

Uk had plenty of slave labour from countries it invaded. And plenty of killing of indigenous peoples as well. All in the last centuries. I wouldn’t be too cocky if I were you.

And you do realise @Isanyoneup that many countries still feel the negative effects of colonialism to this day? Those in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

mayricio · 15/04/2023 07:43

I don't think people are sneering but I do think this is just another form of 'othering' oneself in a country that has such prominent segregation of people, in the hierarchy of segregated groups European backgrounds are higher up so people cling to them, African Americans weren't even given that choice, they were given a collective heritage title to call themselves regardless of what description they would like to claim for themselves.

Biden has also got almost equal English heritage with relatives in England but he's deciding to ignore that fact which is also surprising given his apparent desire to claim this (conveniently politically positive) Irish heritage based on his 'roots'

Bubblesoffun · 15/04/2023 07:22

DuesExMachina · 14/04/2023 16:07

@Isanyoneup

True, but that was nearly two thousand years ago.

The last band of free Sioux surrendered only about 60 years before the world of Madmen happened.

Totally, totally not comparable. There are people alive today who will remember grandparents telling stories about actually living through those events in the US.

Uk had plenty of slave labour from countries it invaded. And plenty of killing of indigenous peoples as well. All in the last centuries. I wouldn’t be too cocky if I were you.

Goodiewhemper · 15/04/2023 07:20

Anonymous48 · 14/04/2023 17:06

Can you name any republican presidents who were Irish American?

Ronald Reagan although he waited until he was elected to claim his Irish ancestry. When POTUS he visited Ireland and went to the home of his great grandfather. Nixon had some Irish roots as well and did the Irish visit when POTUS.

MooseBreath · 15/04/2023 07:18

As I've said, my heritage is Irish Catholic and Russian Ashkenazi Jew. Much like @artimesiasfootsteps, my parents were the first to marry outside of their heritage. Just because my parents and grandparents never lived in Ireland or Russia doesn't mean their lives weren't impacted massively by their respective cultures.

The food I ate growing up was cooked by my mother who learned to cook from her mother, so we ate traditional Russian recipes every day. We used Yiddish phrases in our everyday life. Despite not being religious, we kept a Mezuzah at the door. We celebrated Jewish holidays with traditions passed down from my Russian ancestors. Similarly, we ate Irish food when visiting my paternal grandparents, celebrated Christmas holidays with Irish traditions, and listened to traditional Irish songs sung by my grandparents.

My great-aunt says we still have relatives in Cork, but I don't know them and certainly wouldn't turn up on their doorstep. All of my Russian relatives either died in the Holocaust or made it to Canada and the USA safely.

So while I would never claim to be a national of Ireland or Russia, you're damn right I am descended from those cultures and it is a huge part of my life. My children will also be a part of these cultures along with their father's English heritage, which happens to be his nationality. My children are dual citizens of the UK and Canada. My youngest has yet to go to Canada. He is still Canadian.

SD1978 · 15/04/2023 07:09

Because (some) see their ancestry- usually multiple generations back, and still being a close associate of that country. You're not Scottish, Irish, Italian etc- you're American with ancestry from those countries. The lack of ability to accept that is probably what irks.

Florissant · 15/04/2023 07:06

It's just another way for Brits to sneer at Americans.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/04/2023 07:05

@SpringBunnies , it’s because the Irish-origin vote is such a big thing in America. Funny how you don’t hear American politicians making a big song and dance about so many other ancestral roots.

artimesiasfootsteps · 15/04/2023 07:02

My family emigrated to the antipodes because of a civil war on one side and the other side because of a lack of land to grow crops, so emigrated to find affordable land..

The families in these communities kept traditions alive and intermarried amongst themselves, (My generation are the first to marry outside the community, I’ve married an Englishman). So whilst we are emigrants, our language, DNA, religion and customs are firmly in the old country. My relatives many of them have never assimilated outside our community and they are 2nd generation.

A close friend of mine is Chinese/antipodean, her family go back to the first wave of emigration to the country as gold diggers. (Btw a very cool background IMO) She is the first person in her country to marry outside the Chinese/antipodean community, her blood is pretty much 100% Chinese, she looks Chinese, why shouldn’t she identify as Chinese first, antipodean second?

I also lived in America for a decade and immigrant communities tend to stick together and intermarry. Germans in Oregon for example, Chinese in SF, Irish in Boston.

Why should communities give up their heritage? Why can’t 1st,2nd 3rd generations enjoy their heritage?

If you don’t fine, but doesn’t mean others shouldn’t 🤷🏻‍♀️

Simonjt · 15/04/2023 06:41

Rainbowshit · 15/04/2023 00:40

We were skiing in the US and one of the ski guides badges said he was from Glasgow. As I come from and live in Glasgow we stopped to speak to him.

He'd never been to Glasgow in his life. 🙈His mother had been born in Glasgow and moved to the US as a child.

Have to say I was a bit perplexed that someone would say they were from somewhere they had never been to.

So is my Pakistani son not from Pakistan because he hasn’t been?

Simonjt · 15/04/2023 06:36

MrsMikeDrop · 15/04/2023 00:45

It's only if you're white then it doesn't count. But of course if you're not white then you aren't American, or British or Australian or whatever. Then you'll be asked where you're really from. Go figure. 🤷‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏿‍♀️

Yep!

MrsMikeDrop · 15/04/2023 06:29

Endlesssummer2022 · 15/04/2023 05:07

Obama’s mother was actually Irish born. So he’s genuinely half ethnically Irish and has more claim than the majority of presidents and Irish Americans to being Irish-American.

This is brilliant! I hope @PonyPatter44 comes back to see this 🤣😳🤦‍♀️

RobinHumphries · 15/04/2023 06:03

I think it’s because they behave like it’s a pedigree whereas in reality they are cross-breeds like the rest of us mutts

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 05:53

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:02

But why do they feel the need to add the African / Irish / Italian etc? If they're born and bred in America, why don't they just say they're American?

Why is their heritage and ancestry so important that it needs to be named over and above their actual birthplace?

Why do you even care?

CanOfGerms · 15/04/2023 05:27

I was musing about this the other day, and how it is in direct contrast to Welsh. I was born in Wales to English parents, lived there for a number of years, but would never be accepted as Welsh. I have cousins born and always lived in Wales, bilingual. But to English parents, so therefore could not describe themselves as Welsh (to The Welsh). It seems to be that we expect the opposite from those in USA.

Endlesssummer2022 · 15/04/2023 05:07

PonyPatter44 · 14/04/2023 22:09

To be fair, virtually all American presidents (with the ignoble exception of 45) identify as Irish. Even this dude

Obama’s mother was actually Irish born. So he’s genuinely half ethnically Irish and has more claim than the majority of presidents and Irish Americans to being Irish-American.

SonicStars · 15/04/2023 05:04

My black South African friend went to university in America. She lost count of the number of times people corrected her saying she was African to "African American." They would just do it as a reflex most of the time, but generally trying to help at other times (in a weird, you can't say that sort of way, that seems to back up what someone said earlier about use of African American vs Irish American vs Irish). Over a 4 year period she found it funny, then frustrating, then insulting, then hilarious.

It was insane. She has a definate accent. She did play on it bit by the end by making a point of saying she was African as opposed to South African, which is what she would say to most people.

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 03:55

HamBone · 15/04/2023 02:28

@Mamaneedsadrink If they live there though, aren’t they a citizen of that country and familiar with its traditions and customs?

Are you saying that they have one great-great grandparent whose ancestors were originally from that country?

Yes, like being Native American for example. I guess this is the problem many mixed children have because people are happy to tell them who they can and can't identify with

Swipe left for the next trending thread