Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
tabulahrasa · 15/04/2023 09:20

Endlesssummer2022 · 15/04/2023 05:07

Obama’s mother was actually Irish born. So he’s genuinely half ethnically Irish and has more claim than the majority of presidents and Irish Americans to being Irish-American.

She was born in Kansas... as were both her parents...

Gold97 · 15/04/2023 09:05

I never really knew this about Americans.

I can understand Irish-American but stating you’re Irish would seem pretty odd over here.

I can totally understand wanting to let others know your heritage though, absolutely.

I’m English, my DF was Scottish, also my maternal DGM was Scottish, I have sometimes jokingly stated I’m 3/4 Scottish, I have a huge family in Scotland as both my DF & DGM had many siblings. I would never state I was Scottish though, that would just be weird to me.

mayricio · 15/04/2023 09:03

@KnittingNeedles imo he's setting the tone for how others define themselves as a powerful world leader he knows this and it's unfair on anyone who simply wishes to claim the heritage of where they live and have had generations in. As PP have said they have known people to be told they cannot be American/British because they are black. They 'have to' fit a defined category attributed to them.

He's drumming up Irish politics in purpose too. there no need for the amount of parading he's doing here. He is a human. He can do things quietly if he wanted to,

Whenharrymetsmelly · 15/04/2023 08:50

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 08:49

@Whenharrymetsmelly I didn't think that post was racist.

Not yours, just the undercurrent to many of the posts.

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 08:49

@Whenharrymetsmelly I didn't think that post was racist.

MrsMikeDrop · 15/04/2023 08:48

Fairislefandango · 15/04/2023 08:44

But again @Fairislefandango what harm is it doing? It's no skin off my nose if someone from deepest Utah decides they're Scottish.

No actual harm, but I expect it's a bit irritating to genuinely Scottish people. It just seems a bit like cultural appropriation.

Would you think the same of you replaced Scottish with Chinese?

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 08:47

"It’s the “one drop” rule. Basically it used to be that one drop of African American blood made you black. That tradition still continues in people’s minds and it is why in the UK Meghan would be described as Mixed ethnicity but would be seen as African American in the US."

I fucking hate this train of thought. I have 1 black grandparent. I guess I look a bit like Megan except sadly less beautiful 😆. I would say I'm mixed if anyone asked or if I was filling in a form, but at a glance I'd pass for white and I just consider myself British.
I would HATE to be referred to as an "African American".

Whenharrymetsmelly · 15/04/2023 08:47

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 08:37

It’s the “one drop” rule. Basically it used to be that one drop of African American blood made you black. That tradition still continues in people’s minds and it is why in the UK Meghan would be described as Mixed ethnicity but would be seen as African American in the US.

I was wondering how long it would be until someone mentioned Meghan. This thread certainly has been eye-opening, such judgement and hate. She didn't really stand a chance did she, can't say Im a fan, but there is certainly an undercurrent of racism in this thread.

KnittingNeedles · 15/04/2023 08:47

I am a genuinely Scottish person. (Parents both Scottish, all 4 grandparents Scottish, born here, raised here, live here). Not irritated. Someone from Utah claiming to be Scottish does not make me less Scottish.

And if they want to come here, spend their money exploring the places their ancestors moved from and support Scottish jobs, more power to their elbow. (Family tartan is not a thing though, and that is a huge misconception not exclusive to N America)

Fairislefandango · 15/04/2023 08:44

But again @Fairislefandango what harm is it doing? It's no skin off my nose if someone from deepest Utah decides they're Scottish.

No actual harm, but I expect it's a bit irritating to genuinely Scottish people. It just seems a bit like cultural appropriation.

KnittingNeedles · 15/04/2023 08:41

mayricio · 15/04/2023 08:36

@KnittingNeedles it's unusual to work out heritage based on number of gp?! And also to discount a heritage based on number of gp?

Obviously not for Americans or Pres Biden. And again, if he wants to define himself as Irish based on 10/16 g grandparents being Irish what harm is he doing?

It doesn't make any people with 2 Irish parents or 4 Irish grandparents any LESS Irish, does it?

Weallgottachangesometime · 15/04/2023 08:41

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 08:37

It’s the “one drop” rule. Basically it used to be that one drop of African American blood made you black. That tradition still continues in people’s minds and it is why in the UK Meghan would be described as Mixed ethnicity but would be seen as African American in the US.

Akala’s book Natives has interesting comments of the ‘racialisation of blackness’ (think that’s the term he used). Pointing out that when visiting his family in other countries he was treated differently/preferentially due to his light skin, where as elsewhere he’d just be considered black despite having both a black and white parent.

Kanaloa · 15/04/2023 08:41

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 08:37

It’s the “one drop” rule. Basically it used to be that one drop of African American blood made you black. That tradition still continues in people’s minds and it is why in the UK Meghan would be described as Mixed ethnicity but would be seen as African American in the US.

Yeah, but it doesn’t make any sense in this context. My friend is British. She isn’t African or American. I don’t think she’s ever even been to America. She would be confused to be called African American. She is black, but calling her African American would be incorrect.

Weallgottachangesometime · 15/04/2023 08:38

My2pence2day · 15/04/2023 08:34

Actually many people, not just Americans do that, most people like to identify and acknowledge their heritage. It's actually British that are the odd ones out. Maybe it's something to do with the class system or something.

That’s interesting I didn’t realise lots of other places thought of identity like that too. It’s very interesting. I have Irish grandparents and a traveler grandparent but I don’t really identify with any of those at all. I find it interesting in terms of family history but it doesn’t come into my sense of self identity.

I don’t think either is wrong or to be sneered at. Just different ways of thinking I suppose.

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 08:37

Kanaloa · 15/04/2023 08:04

I once had an American tell me off for saying black instead of African American. I was talking about a friend of mine, who was born and raised in the UK and has no African heritage. How on earth could she be African American? She is neither African or American! Had a similar issue in a class over there when I referred to the representation of Indian people in The Secret Garden. Was quietly corrected that it is ‘Native American.’

Sometimes I wonder if some people are just blinkered maybe.

It’s the “one drop” rule. Basically it used to be that one drop of African American blood made you black. That tradition still continues in people’s minds and it is why in the UK Meghan would be described as Mixed ethnicity but would be seen as African American in the US.

mayricio · 15/04/2023 08:36

@KnittingNeedles it's unusual to work out heritage based on number of gp?! And also to discount a heritage based on number of gp?

My2pence2day · 15/04/2023 08:34

Weallgottachangesometime · 15/04/2023 08:29

From what I’ve seen the idea of cultural/national identity is very different in the US than it is in the UK. As someone else earlier said, in the UK if you had a grandparent from Ireland who moved to England where your family has lived since, you probably wouldn’t refer to yourself as Irish. Where as in the US they do.

I guess it’s just differences in how people perceive their own identity and culture.

Actually many people, not just Americans do that, most people like to identify and acknowledge their heritage. It's actually British that are the odd ones out. Maybe it's something to do with the class system or something.

mayricio · 15/04/2023 08:34

@Anotheronetwoone honestly try finding a non Irish Catholic priest ! Why hasn't Biden acknowledged his British heritage?

KnittingNeedles · 15/04/2023 08:33

Biden has also got almost equal English heritage with relatives in England but he's deciding to ignore that fact which is also surprising given his apparent desire to claim this (conveniently politically positive) Irish heritage based on his 'roots'

10 out of 16 of his great grandparents were Irish. That means 6 were from elsewhere - he is more Irish than English.

Anotheronetwoone · 15/04/2023 08:32

Biden has also got almost equal English heritage with relatives in England but he's deciding to ignore that fact which is also surprising given his apparent desire to claim this (conveniently politically positive) Irish heritage based on his 'roots'

Bidens dying son was anointed last rights by an Irish Catholic priest - did he do this as it was conveniently politically positive @mayricio

you only need to look around mumsnet at the hundreds of posts if ‘I don’t want MiL to visit at the start when my baby is born, oh my DM is fine she lives round the corner’ , ‘ I am the main cater for her children’ ‘I’ve gone part time’ and so on that may give you an inkling as to why a mothers heritage may have a bigger influence on a child - and in Biden’s case he lived with his maternal grandparents for a time. So I don’t find it even remotely surprising that he identifies more with his mothers side - and all 4 of his grandparents on that side were Irish American.

Weallgottachangesometime · 15/04/2023 08:29

From what I’ve seen the idea of cultural/national identity is very different in the US than it is in the UK. As someone else earlier said, in the UK if you had a grandparent from Ireland who moved to England where your family has lived since, you probably wouldn’t refer to yourself as Irish. Where as in the US they do.

I guess it’s just differences in how people perceive their own identity and culture.

KnittingNeedles · 15/04/2023 08:28

But again @Fairislefandango what harm is it doing? It's no skin off my nose if someone from deepest Utah decides they're Scottish.

There are lots of hobbies that people do that other people feel are daft, but if it's not causing harm to other people, just live and let live. Americans/Canadians in general ARE more interested in their ancestry. Just because you don't "get it" doesn't make them daft.

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 08:27

Artemiasfootsteps has made a very good point actually. While it is accepted and normalised for certain groups to continue their traditions and culture eg Chinese, why us it not acceptable for other groups to do this?

From an outsider’s perspective, regardless of race I would think of someone from America as American because the American culture is really strong - the vast majority of Americans tend to act in a certain way that is typical of Americans. So, an Irish American would be indistinguishable to me from any other type of American as they have certain behaviours, beliefs and mannerisms that only Americans have, regardless of whether they also continue other traditions alongside this.

Fairislefandango · 15/04/2023 08:23

Because banging on about your Irish/Scottish heritage when you have one Irish/Scottish set of great grandparents and have never even been there is daft, especially if you are very in-your-face and flag-wavy about it and weigh in heavily on related historical political issues or cultural controversies you have no experience or knowledge of.

Mind you, I've never really understood the desire to identify with your ancestors. People research their family trees, pick the one great great grandparent who did something interesting or came from somewhere appealing and conveniently ignore all the rest! I don't care where my ancestors come from.

Anotheronetwoone · 15/04/2023 08:23

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 00:30

I am Irish and I have no problem with Biden or anybody else claiming to be Irish American or Irish. If they are speaking with an American accent and say they are Irish I obviously know they mean they are of Irish descent, they are Irish American.

Biden's ancestors are 10/16 Irish. He grew up in Scranton in a very Irish community. He spent a lot of time with his grandparents whose parents came from Ireland.
The Irish who travelled to America did so out of necessity, they formed communities and ensured they passed down their Irish culture and traditions to the next generation. This could be through religion by going to mass every Sunday, the importance of family, Irish music and poetry, children attending Irish dancing lessons and/or playing Irish sports, attending Irish Catholic schools.
Joe Biden talks about how his grandparents and parents were so proud of their Irish culture, about how they told him 'the best bit of him was Irish' and about how he was equal to anyone, no better or no worse than anyody else. It was this upbringing that formed his identity and that of millions more Americans of Irish descent. He clearly has a strong affinity for Ireland, it was an important part of his culture growing up and he has visited Ireland on many occasions and has made strong connections with his cousins etc.

Personally I think that it is really nice that so many Irish Americans have held on to that culture and identity.

I agree completely.