Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Whalesong · 19/04/2023 22:42

postapesto · 18/04/2023 17:32

You didn't understand. Of course the NI census tells us that some NI people identify as British. They ARE British (technically UK). They aren't identifying as it, they are it. Everypone born in NI is British, even the ones that identify as Irish.

But you wob't find any significant number,if any number at all, of Irish people from the country of Ireland who identify as British. Because they are not, unless they have a British parent, and even then it is extremely likely they would never.

It's cultural. Irish people are Irish and when mistaken for part of the UK tend to be very pissed off. Part of the cultural identity is literally identifying as "not-British, sod off".

You are SO wrong about that. This was one of the key elements of the GFA: that people born in NI could choose whether to BE (not just identify as) British or Irish. And that isn't just reflected in the fact that half of the population has chosen never to hold a British passport. Until recently of course the other half ONLY held British passports, but that all changed with Brexit - now they're all merrily applying for Irish passports, including Ian Paisley Jr.

There was a landmark court case while the UK was still in the EU, of a woman from NI who demanded to be considered as Irish, NOT British. She had been told by the Home Office that her American husband could not live in NI with her, because they failed the stringent rules imposed by the UK on their own citizens for bringing in non-EU spouses. She was invoking the unconditional right of EU citizens to live with their spouse in an EU country OTHER THAN THEIR OWN ( because in your own country, that country's laws supersede those of the EU).

She argued in court, invoking the GFA, that although she was born in NI, as were here parents etc, they were IRISH, not British, so effectively living in another EU country to their home country. So the same rules should apply to her as if she'd been born in Ireland and later moved to NI. And she won.

From then on, the UK recognises that anyone in NI who sees themselves as purely Irish is so. This means that these people are also protected under the Withdrawal Agreement, just like any other EU citizens living in the UK before Brexit - which doesn't apply to Brits. There's a list of advantages, such as continued entitlement to EHIC (which covers more countries than the new British GHIC, which is all British citizens are entitled to).

But the main point is the principle. The very many people in NI who don't see themselves as British, only Irish, are Irish. Period.

Going back to when this was first established, in the 1920s (even though the UK didn't respect it in many ways until the GFA), this is of course the reason for the Common Travel Area between the UK and Ireland. Irish people in the UK have exactly the same right as Brits, including to vote. And vice versa. It has to be that way, because a very large proportion of the population of NI is Irish, not British.

End of History lesson :)

Whalesong · 19/04/2023 22:16

Alondra · 18/04/2023 13:33

I think this thread is the typical British one when someone like Biden, the US President, shows how much he supports the GFA and how little he cares about a trade agreement with the UK, or attending a royal coronation.

The press in the UK, specially the DM, have always bombastically sold how the UK is "the special US friend", and they hate to be shown is really not special.

Spot on! That's exactly what I was trying to say earlier in the thread, but you said it so much more succinctly!

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 19/04/2023 12:30

34 pages. Stomach-disturbing reminder of Harp (I had no idea it was still made). Truly stomach-churning reminder of Sammy W au naturel thanks for that.

No mention that I noticed of the Anglo-Irish, speaking of people whose families can live in a country for centuries without assimilating.

People might think a bit about WASPS, the Know Nothings, the DAR, the sort of attitudes expressed by Thoreau, and all the other factors that help explain why new immigrants to the USA, particularly Catholic immigrants, needed to support each other. Well into the 20th century, Americans of mainly British descent were referred to as 'native Americans', in a lot of political discourse that compares them favourably to Irish and other more recent arrivals. Kennedy's election was a bombshell.

It might also be worth wondering why the habit of raising money to send back to Ireland started - I'm as appalled as anyone at the naivety of people imagining all the money they raised was supporting 'political prisoners' or 'refugees' during the height of the most recent troubles, but American money did help people in Cork after the city was burned down by British forces, did help establish our Dail, did provide protection for people fleeing the shipyard 'clearances, and on and on. It's good that nowadays Irish companies provide so much direct investment in the USA - what goes around comes around.

One of the oddest delusions I encounter among Irish Americans, particularly ones with little contact with the country or its inhabitants, is the belief in 'the Black Irish', dark haired (not dark skinned) descendants of Spanish survivors of Armada wrecks - that morphs into a belief all the 'real' Irish have black hair. nah.

But hurrah for Joe Biden, the most Irish American President since Kennedy (and only the second Catholic), I'm glad he had a good time when he was here, and hope the relationship between the two countries continues to prosper.

BrBa · 19/04/2023 12:00

GarlicGrace · 17/04/2023 19:39

You know, I'm so over the cult of personal "identity". It's a modern curse! Sure, everybody has a personal identity and also a group identity (often several), a national identity, a cultural identity and so forth. what pisses me off is the idea that you and only you determine your "identity" - you choose it, basically - and then everyone should damn well respect you for what you say you are. To question or disagree is insulting and is "hate".

Our real identities are shape-shifting concepts made up of an individual's core personality and physical features, then overlaid with our roles in various situations and things like our economic & social situations, where we live, our legal status, what we mean to other people and how they see us. To slap an "identity" label on yourself and demand acceptance feels controlling to me. Narcissistic, almost.

Many of the angrier comments in this thread reflect the tug-of-war going on around "trans identities". The same phrases are popping up, including challenges like "who are you to question my identity?" I'd say everyone has that right if they believe they've got cause to. Your identity isn't something you can unilaterally declare, it's a compound of multiple factors including other people's responses to you.

It's clear enough where I stand on this, I just find it an interesting and somewhat exasperating feature of 21st century life.

This trans parallel interested me. In a way our phenotype (or physical expression of our genotype) has much in common with biological sex. Many were not able to simply identify their way out of looking Jewish enough for Hitler for example. Or black enough for the lynch mob. And so on.

The social construct of your national identities and any citizenship you hold is similar to ideas about gender identity. They are, like gender, legal or philosophical constructs rather than a biological fact.

OP posts:
tabulahrasa · 19/04/2023 08:55

The point is though that you don’t know what it means, because it can mean a load of different things.

I’m Scottish, as in, from Scotland and live in Scotland, if I meet someone with an American accent who says they’re also Scottish - I don’t know whether they mean, they have no known connection to Scotland but did a DNA test and it says there is, whether they have distant known ancestors from Scotland, they have close relations from there or they are themselves originally from there... it’s obviously relevant to the conversation we’re having, so then you have to ask what they mean by it, and they could have just started with the relevant bit instead.

Online interactions are the same, except worse because there’s not an accent to make you start at the assumption that they’ve a link to America and they don’t necessarily mean Scottish literally.

Is it a huge deal? No, of course not, but it is sometimes mildly irritating to have to work out what someone means by a word that is usually pretty straightforward when it’s used by everyone else.

AllTheAll · 18/04/2023 23:52

okay okay we get it.

Americans: I'm Irish
British: Noooooo you can't say that. It's fine if you want to say Irish-American. Just say Irish AMERICAN.
Americans: Okay, semantics and cultural wording. Got it. I'm Irish-American.
British: Noooooo you can't be "Irish-American" just because you have distant relatives from like three generations back!
African Americans: ...
British: It's just puzzling. I'm BEMUSED. It's cringe. I'm puzzled. It's daft.
Americans: But we explained it all already. It just works differently in other places. ...oh, it's the IRISH and the AMERICAN part, then, is it?
British: [Saying the quiet part out loud]. Yes, yes it is. We know perfectly well what they mean when they say Irish, as we all know what a 'Weekend' is.

We need to get over ourselves.

Downton Abbey Weekend GIF
Cantstandbullshitanymore · 18/04/2023 21:27

MissConductUS · 18/04/2023 09:39

Show me an American forum where they spend time talking about British people?

There's no such animal. Unless there's something like a royal wedding, we give the Brits no headspace at all. How you do things is of no concern to us, as opposed to the obsession on MN with all aspects of life in America. There was a thread recently about how often American mothers take their children to see a pediatrician. It's bonkers.

@MissConductUS i agree with you and that was my point, Americans don’t spend their time going on and on and on about Brits the way they do on MN.

Any topic that mentions Americans immediately goes crazy with people coming up with random stuff that in many cases don’t even have anything to do with the topic or are just plain false.

A Brit knows one American that does something and concludes all Americans do that lol.

I recall poster said she visited her brother in the US or something and they didn’t eat vegetables while she was visiting hence Americans don’t eat vegetables looool.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 18/04/2023 20:55

Chickenkeev · 16/04/2023 17:45

Ireland gets it a lot worse but we monetise the f*ck out of it!

@Chickenkeev Surely you're 1/500th American then as our specialty is monetizing the f*ck out of things😂

Seriously though, I can't understand people having weird outdated ideas about places in today's information age. How lazy are you that you don't Google a place you plan to visit?!

Dishwasherdisaster · 18/04/2023 20:34

You've emphasised Irish and British 'in that order' a couple of times @DownNative. Just curious as to what you mean exactly. The census in NI didn't record the order of national identity preferences or did it? Or are you talking about yourself or other individuals who have expressed a wish to be thought of as Irish first, then British? Just interested really as I don't quite understand the point you're making.

I would think there are some people in ROI who identify with their British heritage @postapesto, though I think the numbers are much smaller than 1 in 50. Where I am there are a fair number of old estates and quite a few people are CoI. They've been here for generations, some intermarried, some have changed religion in the process, but some haven't done either. I think that group might have a mix of identities like in NI, why wouldn't they?

DownNative · 18/04/2023 18:53

This highlights ghe absurdity of Biden saying he's Irish and the PP saying those in Northern Ireland who identify as Irish and British are not...Irish.

That 2% in NI have far more of a claim than the Americans like Biden do....

Also:

Ireland is an island.

Ireland is not an island.

Both statements are true.

Little wonder outsiders get confused!

DownNative · 18/04/2023 18:47

postapesto · 18/04/2023 18:18

It really IS out of the realms of possibility,and if you are cintinuing to think that Irish people in Ireland are in anyway the same as British people in NI, there really is no point in talking to you any further!

I don't care whether they like my comment or not. A united Ireland is not what most people want anymore. We can't afford them and there's no appetite for it. Irish people do not identify as British,its insane to suggest one in 50 would!

Hang on a minute, you're blatantly shifting the goalposts!

This is what you previously claimed:

"There are people in NI who identify as being British,but they aren't Irish."

There are approximately 2% of the NI population who identify as Irish and British (in that order!). Logically, this doesn't mean they're NOT Irish by any means. All it means is they feel absolutely no conflict between being Irish and British!

To use a public figure as an example, Douglas Beattie identifies as Irish and British. See the attached images for his tweets on the subject.

As is often said, a lot of people in Great Britain will say they're Irish too.

I know of one who is an Irish Nationalist who identifies as Irish and British. Thus person also wants a united Ireland. Good luck telling such people they're not Irish because they also identify as British.

Honestly, you sound pretty close minded here. It's pretty glaring you provide zero evidence for what you say. There's lots in the ROI who consider Northern Ireland Irish and will say those who identify as Irish are Irish, even if they also identify as British at the same time.

You have no evidence to support your argument.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?
Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?
postapesto · 18/04/2023 18:18

It really IS out of the realms of possibility,and if you are cintinuing to think that Irish people in Ireland are in anyway the same as British people in NI, there really is no point in talking to you any further!

I don't care whether they like my comment or not. A united Ireland is not what most people want anymore. We can't afford them and there's no appetite for it. Irish people do not identify as British,its insane to suggest one in 50 would!

DownNative · 18/04/2023 18:15

postapesto · 18/04/2023 17:32

You didn't understand. Of course the NI census tells us that some NI people identify as British. They ARE British (technically UK). They aren't identifying as it, they are it. Everypone born in NI is British, even the ones that identify as Irish.

But you wob't find any significant number,if any number at all, of Irish people from the country of Ireland who identify as British. Because they are not, unless they have a British parent, and even then it is extremely likely they would never.

It's cultural. Irish people are Irish and when mistaken for part of the UK tend to be very pissed off. Part of the cultural identity is literally identifying as "not-British, sod off".

On the contrary, I understood perfectly.

You do realise that a small percentage of people in Northern Ireland identify as Irish AND British (in that order) which is not significant?

You might like to believe that absolutely nobody in the Republic of Ireland would identify as Irish and British, but you're likely to be wrong on that.

More to the point, you cannot prove absolutely none identify that way in the Republic of Ireland.

In any country, you simply cannot state things in absolute terms which is what you're doing. You're relying on a generalisation and stereotype which leads to logical fallacies meaning errors in logic and reasoning.

It's not out of the realms of probability that 1-2% of the ROI population identifies as Irish and British. Same as in Northern Ireland.

And if "Part of the cultural identity is literally identifying as "not-British, sod off", this kind of attitude will hold a united Ireland off too. Indeed, in such a scenario, that kind of attitude would have to change into a more diverse one accepting of the Britishness of the population.

I realise you may not desire a united Ireland, neither do I. But there are those who do and they won't like your comment there.

postapesto · 18/04/2023 17:33

unlikely they would ever. Bloody dyslexia\

postapesto · 18/04/2023 17:32

DownNative · 18/04/2023 16:36

It appears to me that the ROI census does not ask questions about identity. If so, then it's unlikely anyone will tell you they also identify as British too.

But it's not out of the realms of possibility they do, especially since the Northern Ireland census tells us this is so.

You didn't understand. Of course the NI census tells us that some NI people identify as British. They ARE British (technically UK). They aren't identifying as it, they are it. Everypone born in NI is British, even the ones that identify as Irish.

But you wob't find any significant number,if any number at all, of Irish people from the country of Ireland who identify as British. Because they are not, unless they have a British parent, and even then it is extremely likely they would never.

It's cultural. Irish people are Irish and when mistaken for part of the UK tend to be very pissed off. Part of the cultural identity is literally identifying as "not-British, sod off".

EssexMan55 · 18/04/2023 16:55

that's because most people on the mainland would regard people in NI as Irish I think.

DdraigGoch · 18/04/2023 16:47

DownNative · 18/04/2023 13:04

Of course, John has a Hebrew origin.

But it doesn't appear as a surname in the UK until the 15th century in Wales which is the point about a PPs belief we took the US trend of using surnames as forenames. We clearly didn't. 🤷‍♂️

No-one was talking about a "jaunty repurposing of a Welsh surname."

But that's a first name which has become a surname, not a surname that has been used as a first name (the situation the PP was on about).

Until 1536 Wales had a patronymic system; your father's first name became your second name - Evan ap Thomas was Evan, son of Thomas. When Henry VIII formally absorbed Wales into England this system gradually gave way to the English system - whatever second name you had at the time you changed (it started as early as the 13th century with those who had moved to England, in rural areas of Wales this was as late as the 19th century) became the family name, handed down as in England. So Evan was now Evan Thomas and his son was Gwyn Thomas.

Quite different from turning a surname back into a forename. The surname "Price" is a contraction of "ap Rhys" and you wouldn't have seen people give their kids the forename "Price" until possibly quite recently.

DownNative · 18/04/2023 16:36

Dishwasherdisaster · 18/04/2023 16:11

But census figures show that about 2% of people in NI do in fact identify as both British and Irish or as British, Irish and Northern Irish.
I know people in ROI who were born and grew up here but have strong British family links and one or two have English accents. I never asked how they see themselves though...

It appears to me that the ROI census does not ask questions about identity. If so, then it's unlikely anyone will tell you they also identify as British too.

But it's not out of the realms of possibility they do, especially since the Northern Ireland census tells us this is so.

DownNative · 18/04/2023 16:30

postapesto · 18/04/2023 15:50

Not really. There are people in NI who identify as being British,but they aren't Irish

I don't know any Irish person who would identify as British. I know Irish people who have an English parent and are fully entitled to an Irish passport,but they don't identify as British and never would.

All I can say is familiarise yourself with the results of the Northern Ireland census results 2021......🍳 on 😐

You must not be from Northern Ireland otherwise you'd have easily understood the different combinations of identities.

Dishwasherdisaster · 18/04/2023 16:11

postapesto · 18/04/2023 15:50

Not really. There are people in NI who identify as being British,but they aren't Irish

I don't know any Irish person who would identify as British. I know Irish people who have an English parent and are fully entitled to an Irish passport,but they don't identify as British and never would.

But census figures show that about 2% of people in NI do in fact identify as both British and Irish or as British, Irish and Northern Irish.
I know people in ROI who were born and grew up here but have strong British family links and one or two have English accents. I never asked how they see themselves though...

postapesto · 18/04/2023 15:50

DownNative · 18/04/2023 15:27

Perhaps not English, but there ARE Irish identifying people who also identify as British. It's quite logical as they do have British ancestry too.

Not really. There are people in NI who identify as being British,but they aren't Irish

I don't know any Irish person who would identify as British. I know Irish people who have an English parent and are fully entitled to an Irish passport,but they don't identify as British and never would.

Goldenbear · 18/04/2023 15:46

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 18/04/2023 15:31

'Met lots of English saying they're Irish over the years but never met Irish person saying they're English...just an observation :)'

Jesus, who's going to be proud of THAT??

Pride about where you are from is not a cultural norm in England - i.e your place of birth is not an achievement. Obviously, when international sports events take place there is a vague patriotism but mostly it is seen as a bit vulgar to be wrapped in a St George's flag.

Goldenbear · 18/04/2023 15:37

fairycakes1234 · 18/04/2023 15:02

Met lots of English saying they're Irish over the years but never met Irish person saying they're English...just an observation :)

I suppose if you look at this factually, in terms of probability it is much more likely as the population of England is 55 millionish, the population of Ireland 5 million, the population of London alone is 9 million. Generally many more English people to meet in life.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 18/04/2023 15:31

'Met lots of English saying they're Irish over the years but never met Irish person saying they're English...just an observation :)'

Jesus, who's going to be proud of THAT??

DownNative · 18/04/2023 15:27

fairycakes1234 · 18/04/2023 15:02

Met lots of English saying they're Irish over the years but never met Irish person saying they're English...just an observation :)

Perhaps not English, but there ARE Irish identifying people who also identify as British. It's quite logical as they do have British ancestry too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread