Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Willyoujustbequiet · 15/04/2023 11:06

CordyLines · 15/04/2023 10:40

Reality has to be faced sometimes. The English are not universally admired or even liked as a people around the world. Maybe that is because of its previous colonial history, maybe it's their sense of entitlement and superiority I don't know. But what I do know is that the steam of racism agains the Irish in particular is visibly rising from this thread. It is disgusting but not surprising.

No wonder Brexit happened, it is the evidence that British (English mostly) who voted for it think they are better than everyone else, don't need pesky EU, don't need anyone, we fought and won the war - you peasants. The Royal Family is revered and adored by many, why? Maybe they symbolise the sense of greatness of the Empire or something.

But that no longer exists, and it is no wonder that the formerly colonised have little time for largely English Brits. It is just a fact of history.

And to this day it keeps on giving. I am so disappointed to see the sneering and subtle racism against the Irish in particular on this thread.

Plus ca change et plus reste la meme chose.

Nice bit of casual racism in the morning.

For starters it wasn't the English who colonised it was the British. Just as they themselves were repeatedly throughout history. Just as countless others did. The Irish themselves were.

No country has clean hands so don't let your prejudices conviently cherry pick history.

Modang · 15/04/2023 11:00

Yeah, it's just a bit odd. My grandmother was born in Wales, her ancestors are Welsh, but I don't say I'm Welsh - I've never even been there and grew up England. My grandmother doesn't even say she is Welsh, she moved to England as a child and doesn't have an accent or any of the language. I might say "have some Welsh heritage" if asked but that's it. Similarly I have German great grandparents through my father, but it's nothing to do with me, never met them, never been there, had no impact on me.

gogohmm · 15/04/2023 10:58

It is a bit odd claiming you are a certain heritage when it's really distant. I'm 1/8 German but that doesn't make me German!

phoenixrosehere · 15/04/2023 10:58

diflasu · 15/04/2023 10:10

I don't think there is sneering - some of the US you tubers I follow want to explore their UK and Irish roots and watch a lot of video around these topics - they tend to be affable and curious and comment sections tend to point them at more information and clarify points. There are whole industries out there catering for their visits over.

I see it as a cultural difference - my GGP were welsh but I am still English living in Wales - even my DC going to welsh schools one here since she was 5 see themselves as English though British first I think. My oldest two were born in Yorkshire, a place with as tiring cultural identity, but haven't not really been raise there wouldn't consider them selves Yorkshire men/women.

DH paternal ancestor left Ireland same time as Biden - it's been followed back because of the unusual surname it's likely a corruption of an Irish name - name was spelt different every time till kids seem to have settled on a spelling - none of them think of themselves as Irish - though they are proud of the connection.

I think it only gets negative rather than a cultural quirk when you hear the stories of ethnic minorities born in UK or Ireland who may even be second or third generations get told by US citizens they aren't those nationalities.

I think Biden getting flack because it does seem to be electioneering to his US base around an area that is very sensitive in UK and Ireland politics.

I think it only gets negative rather than a cultural quirk when you hear the stories of ethnic minorities born in UK or Ireland who may even be second or third generations get told by US citizens they aren't those nationalities.

And the same happens here with non-white Americans, yet it’s always made out to be only the States do this.

CordyLines · 15/04/2023 10:54

Gold97 · 15/04/2023 10:52

@CordyLines i for one didn’t vote to leave the EU, along with another 48% of the population, just for balance.

I understand, and I did say "those who voted for it" in my post.

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 10:54

I dunno @CordyLines I'd say your last post sounds pretty racist actually. I think it's weird to claim to be something your not and not just if what you say is Irish. So it really isn't anti-Irish. I mean I could do it and say I'm Jamaican because I have a grandparent from there and lots of cousins living there and even lived there for a few months as a kid. But I'm not Jamaican so I don't. I was born and have lived the majority of my life in London as have my parents therefore I am British. My experience of life is completely different to my cousins who grew up and still live in Kingston. Why would I claim otherwise? I'd also think it was weird if they called themselves British.
And not all English people voted Brexit either fyi. In fact just like Scotland us Londoners voted to stay, because we on the whole consider ourselves European.

Gold97 · 15/04/2023 10:52

@CordyLines i for one didn’t vote to leave the EU, along with another 48% of the population, just for balance.

belleager · 15/04/2023 10:48

mayricio · 15/04/2023 10:22

Lol @Anotheronetwoone that's certainly not why I've said anything. I genuinely believe this is a race issue and it's cementing the whole I'm European because I'm Irish therefore I'm superior to others who are non European. (This being thought process going on before he's even become president)

Being 'Irish' in the USA, as the president, will have political implications that's what's upset a lot of people as well, that he's abusing that stance.

I would say that visible accepted markers of race - being white, in Biden's case - are far more important than ethnicity or identity in establishing how people are categorised in the US. Biden's white, whether his ancestors are Swedish, Polish, Irish, and whether he identifies with them or not.

Irish identity is certainly relevant to an American president. That's useful for Ireland. But Biden's Irish identity long predates his presidency.

Of course this is politics,on both sides. Not every returning Irish American gets a four day state visit! But I don't see many people being upset about it.

It's a good political situation, for Ireland, and perhaps for Biden though the culture where this really mattered is shifting in the US. It's not particularly good for Britain, but why should it be? If British people are upset that Biden declares an emotional attachment to Ireland, they might want to ask why. Can one only respect Britain by putting it first in the pecking order? Can other nations matter as much as Britain?

Dutch1e · 15/04/2023 10:44

I sneer. It's ridiculous and misrepresentative to claim a relative's nationality as your own no matter many times you explain "oh, it's just shorthand" or "what we really mean is..."

The false claim even extends to a completely unfounded sense of authority as well. In one memorable example I had someone in a Facebook group explain Dutch culture to me at great length based on her being Dutch. Although I have Dutch citizenship, live here, and speak the language I rarely call myself Dutch so I heard her out then asked which part of the Netherlands she is from. Turned out she'd never been here but based her Dutchness on one grandparent who was born in a border town.... in Germany 🥴

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 10:40

Name/nationality changed but… my mother called me “Amelie” because it was a pretty name and because I look a certain way, people have always assumed I am French although I am not. It’s affected the way many people treat me (unconsciously) to begin with. So, like it or not certain names do come with cultural markers.

The bigger issue here though is why Biden keeps saying crazy stuff.

CordyLines · 15/04/2023 10:40

Reality has to be faced sometimes. The English are not universally admired or even liked as a people around the world. Maybe that is because of its previous colonial history, maybe it's their sense of entitlement and superiority I don't know. But what I do know is that the steam of racism agains the Irish in particular is visibly rising from this thread. It is disgusting but not surprising.

No wonder Brexit happened, it is the evidence that British (English mostly) who voted for it think they are better than everyone else, don't need pesky EU, don't need anyone, we fought and won the war - you peasants. The Royal Family is revered and adored by many, why? Maybe they symbolise the sense of greatness of the Empire or something.

But that no longer exists, and it is no wonder that the formerly colonised have little time for largely English Brits. It is just a fact of history.

And to this day it keeps on giving. I am so disappointed to see the sneering and subtle racism against the Irish in particular on this thread.

Plus ca change et plus reste la meme chose.

mayricio · 15/04/2023 10:22

Lol @Anotheronetwoone that's certainly not why I've said anything. I genuinely believe this is a race issue and it's cementing the whole I'm European because I'm Irish therefore I'm superior to others who are non European. (This being thought process going on before he's even become president)

Being 'Irish' in the USA, as the president, will have political implications that's what's upset a lot of people as well, that he's abusing that stance.

diflasu · 15/04/2023 10:10

I don't think there is sneering - some of the US you tubers I follow want to explore their UK and Irish roots and watch a lot of video around these topics - they tend to be affable and curious and comment sections tend to point them at more information and clarify points. There are whole industries out there catering for their visits over.

I see it as a cultural difference - my GGP were welsh but I am still English living in Wales - even my DC going to welsh schools one here since she was 5 see themselves as English though British first I think. My oldest two were born in Yorkshire, a place with as tiring cultural identity, but haven't not really been raise there wouldn't consider them selves Yorkshire men/women.

DH paternal ancestor left Ireland same time as Biden - it's been followed back because of the unusual surname it's likely a corruption of an Irish name - name was spelt different every time till kids seem to have settled on a spelling - none of them think of themselves as Irish - though they are proud of the connection.

I think it only gets negative rather than a cultural quirk when you hear the stories of ethnic minorities born in UK or Ireland who may even be second or third generations get told by US citizens they aren't those nationalities.

I think Biden getting flack because it does seem to be electioneering to his US base around an area that is very sensitive in UK and Ireland politics.

Anotheronetwoone · 15/04/2023 10:08

mayricio · 15/04/2023 08:34

@Anotheronetwoone honestly try finding a non Irish Catholic priest ! Why hasn't Biden acknowledged his British heritage?

Because he doesn’t identify with it? And American has tons of non Irish Catholic priests. Obviously!

the bitterness coming out of Britain this week is astounding. Let’s be honest it’s because Ireland is getting so much attention from a powerful man and as many British people are still anti Irish they don’t like it. I really couldn’t imagine this strength of reaction from the U.K. if Biden had gone to Lichtenstein to meet long lost relatives and state he embracing his heritage there.

we’ve had anti Irish cartoons printed in major U.K. newspapers, articles saying most Americans want to be seen as American as apple pie but Biden wants to be as Irish as Paddy’s pig, accusations about why he isn’t embracing his U.K. heritage and so on.

grow up. It’s not all about you.

Anyotherdude · 15/04/2023 10:00

I’ve left the Joe Biden thread as it’s getting ridiculous.
My story:
I have Irish heritage. I visited some distant family in the US and it turns out that they are big on their Irish heritage. So big, in fact, that they named their newborn son “Devon”.
How we managed to keep a straight face I’ll never know, but we didn’t disabuse them of the notion that Devon is in Ireland, choosing to be kind about it instead, and agreeing that it’s a lovely name.
We did have a little laugh between ourselves afterwards about the ludicrous nature of the pride with which they had bestowed the “Irish” name on their son, but we were more baffled than anything else - I mean, had they actually seen a map of the place?
I’m aware that by airing this I could be accused of sneering - but what, exactly, should we have done without causing distant relatives we had only just met some upset?
There are so many stories and anecdotes like this out there - not exclusively from one heritage or another in America - but I notice that it does seem to be mostly American citizens with Irish or Italian “Roots” that appear to have formed some of the most pride in an ancestry that they haven’t bothered to fact-check. If, by noting this, I am sneering, then I’ll just keep it to myself and my immediate family in future - it is funny, though…

belleager · 15/04/2023 09:58

MrsMariaReynolds · 15/04/2023 09:56

You have to have grown up in America to truly understand the dual (or more) ancestral identity that most feel. It's no different than the Italian American, Polish, etc. communities I grew up amongst. People are proud of where they come from, I don't get why that's so odd.

Fwiw, I used to identify as "Irish" when I lived in the States. My dad was born in Ireland and both of mothers parents were born there. I was a first-ish generation and grew up in a very proud immigrant culture complete with dance, parades, foods, etc.

But when I moved to the UK, I picked up very quickly that "being British" was more desirable than ethnic identity (sadly)than and it was quite clear that the prevailing attitude is that you are no more defined than by your place of birth.

That's very interesting. I thought that might be the case.

MrsMariaReynolds · 15/04/2023 09:56

You have to have grown up in America to truly understand the dual (or more) ancestral identity that most feel. It's no different than the Italian American, Polish, etc. communities I grew up amongst. People are proud of where they come from, I don't get why that's so odd.

Fwiw, I used to identify as "Irish" when I lived in the States. My dad was born in Ireland and both of mothers parents were born there. I was a first-ish generation and grew up in a very proud immigrant culture complete with dance, parades, foods, etc.

But when I moved to the UK, I picked up very quickly that "being British" was more desirable than ethnic identity (sadly)than and it was quite clear that the prevailing attitude is that you are no more defined than by your place of birth.

MrsMikeDrop · 15/04/2023 09:55

Mustardandchickensandwiches · 15/04/2023 09:29

Correct. His parents or grandparents or great grand parents are from Pakistan. But he is not.

Unbelievable 😳
So if I'm third generation living in England, yet my blood is ethnically from my great-grandparents country, I speak the language, eat the food, listen to the music, etc I must say I am British and I would be ridiculous to think otherwise?? Some of these posts are total batshit 😑

belleager · 15/04/2023 09:53

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 08:47

"It’s the “one drop” rule. Basically it used to be that one drop of African American blood made you black. That tradition still continues in people’s minds and it is why in the UK Meghan would be described as Mixed ethnicity but would be seen as African American in the US."

I fucking hate this train of thought. I have 1 black grandparent. I guess I look a bit like Megan except sadly less beautiful 😆. I would say I'm mixed if anyone asked or if I was filling in a form, but at a glance I'd pass for white and I just consider myself British.
I would HATE to be referred to as an "African American".

About half of the relevant population in the US favour this term. Others don't. The main thing I think is to use the term people prefer for themselves.

I don't think the one drop rule is the driver here. That was the distinction between black and white. African-American was promoted as a way to get away from that history and the use of these terms in law.

Labraradabrador · 15/04/2023 09:52

GordanoBenito · 14/04/2023 23:20

@Isanyoneup "It's just an arse about face way of doing things and for me probably hampers race relations by keeping people firmly in a box rather than having a shared identity and then your individual one."

Totally agree with you on this point.

@Isanyoneup see I find the British way ass backwards. In the American version the ‘Irish’ or ‘African’ is the modifier and therefore less important than the core identity of being American.

belleager · 15/04/2023 09:48

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 03:01

How often do you hear us saying "I'm Welsh English" or "I'm Italian British"?

I'll save your time. Never, We never say that, so this oft-repeated explanation helps not a jot. It's weird & daft!

Over here, we do have concepts such as "Anglo Indian" but even those are old-fashioned now. You're far more likely to hear British POC responding to questions about their origin with "London" or "England".

The fact that British people do things one way doesn't make that the only right way. There's a whole wide world out there. There are some remarkably intolerant attitudes on this thread.

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 09:41

There is so much veiled racism here..so many comments like "I find it odd that someone born in America would call themselves Irish" etc
You might find it odd but it is very much a normal part of American culture. Millions of Americans do not find it odd. It is a different culture so please show some respect. There are parts of British culture that I find odd or different but thats just a part of living in this world. We are all different but understanding and acceptance is so important. If you listen to Biden speak he talks a lot about kindness, tolerance etc

Just because someone identifies as Irish American, they also know that they are primarily American. Joe Biden is the President of the USA, not the President of Ireland. He knows he is American first and has said this but he is also proud of his Irish culture and says its part of what made him who he is today.

People have also said Biden is equally English so why does he not talk about this. He is not equally English, genetically or culturally. 10 out if his 16 g grandparents are Irish. He was brought up surrounded by those Irish grandparents in a very Irish community. He has strong ties to Ireland and has visited many times. Yesterday he visited the shrine at Knock which is very special to him as part of his Catholic faith. He also visited the hospice in Mayo which was partly set up by his cousin. He was there at the initial building of this hospice and visited there again yesterday where his son Beau who sadly passed away from cancer was remembered and acknowledged.

His ties to Ireland are incredibly strong and he has made many private and public visits.

Simonjt · 15/04/2023 09:31

Mustardandchickensandwiches · 15/04/2023 09:29

Correct. His parents or grandparents or great grand parents are from Pakistan. But he is not.

His ethnicity means he will always be from Pakistan.

Mustardandchickensandwiches · 15/04/2023 09:29

Simonjt · 15/04/2023 06:41

So is my Pakistani son not from Pakistan because he hasn’t been?

Correct. His parents or grandparents or great grand parents are from Pakistan. But he is not.

BeetleBailey · 15/04/2023 09:20

My friend just came back from a week in New York. The first thing he said was that everybody thinks that they are Irish lol