Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
DownNative · 15/04/2023 13:52

proppy · 14/04/2023 16:07

@Anonymous48 so what Irish traditions & customs would Irish Americans uphold?

Well, I'm sure a lot of those Americans would tell you that corned beef and cabbage is an Irish tradition they uphold.

Except....it really isn't!

Turns out this is a Jewish thing that the descendants of Irish emigrants started in the New World. Historically, corned beef and cabbage is not remotely associated with the Island of Ireland.

Neither is green beer or even those St Patrick's Day parades which are both American cultural inventions that became popular in the British Isles from the 1990s onwards.

I did read a study once that concluded most Irish-Americans identify that way NOT in relation to the island of Ireland, but to a relative before them who was Irish. A way of keeping their memory alive.

That would explain their out of date views of the island as well. If I can find it, I'll post it.

gloriousg · 15/04/2023 13:38

Yes it's ridiculous to describe yourself as "African American", "Irish American", "Italian American", they are all just American and most of them now have no connection to those countries, just some distant ancestor if that.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 13:37

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 13:15

I can guarantee you that British taxpayers' funding of the bombing campaigns in Afghanistan and Iraq, and continued supply of arms to the evil Saudi regime to commit genocide in Yemen, has cost far, far more innocent lives.

Odd how you've not mentioned the United States of America in relation to Afghanistan and Iraq there.

Some might well point out that the US is the single biggest military aggressor in our time....🤷‍♂️

JarByTheDoor · 15/04/2023 13:36

Curseofthenation · 15/04/2023 12:08

I agree with all of this. Surely most Americans can read a room? They must realise quite quickly that saying 'I'm Scottish' to an actual Scottish person in Scotland is confusing and odd. It makes them look a bit silly. It's unlikely a Scottish person would judge an American for saying they have Scottish heritage.

If an American chooses to ignore the confusion they cause and when they state that they are Scottish on a holiday to Scotland then they deserve a bit of judgement. They probably don't care anyway.

I don't know why people are getting so upset that they may be mildly judged for this type of behaviour outside of the US. It's not as if a Scottish person is going to agressively shout at them for saying something that sounds a bit silly to them!

Yep — not to mention, being, for example, Italian-American is a unique and special thing, a particular branch on the Italian diasporic tree as well as an important part of the US cultural landscape and history, a specific culture or set of cultures that split off from the various regional Italian-Italian (for want of a better descriptor) cultures that its originators came from over a period of time (with occasional new infusions), with those features recombining somewhere else in different ways, resulting in the culture developing somewhat independently — inevitably retaining some features that weren't retained back in Italy, developing new features, being influenced by its new surroundings, until it's something diverse within itself, and while identifiably Italian in flavour, nonetheless distinct and something to be valued for its unique Italian-Americanness. As I'm sure most Italian-Americans feel, and intend to communicate when using the word "Italian" to describe themselves.

If you've got significant Italian ancestry, an Italian surname, have Italian family recipes, cultural practices, religious practices, terminology, or whatever else in your life that can be traced back to Italian cultural origins, then of course it can make perfect sense to think of a component of your identity as being Italian in a genuinely meaningful sense, and for there to be contexts where saying "I'm Italian" would be correctly interpreted as "I have Italian heritage which I identify with in at least some significant way".

But it makes sense that when you're in a context where "I'm Italian" would usually be taken to mean something like "I'm from Italy, I speak Italian, and my culture is at least partly that of [a region of, or a group within] present-day Italy" — like, on an international webforum discussing European politics, or something — it would be clearer to describe yourself as Italian-American, because that is a different thing to what most of the world would understand by the phrase "I'm Italian". Not inferior, just different.

People don't get mildly irritated by it because they think they're better than Americans because they're properly German/Irish/whatever, they get irked because the shorthand that works well between Americans for discussing heritage doesn't translate well for talking to anyone else, so it can look like the American person is trying to claim an identity that doesn't belong to them.

It's not even that big a deal, that a few Americans occasionally discuss their heritage in ways that come across as a bit amusing or rude or unusual or whatever, to people living in some other countries. It's just a funny quirk that people have noticed some Americans occasionally have. People from other countries, including the UK, Ireland, Italy, etc., also often have particular quirks that others will notice are more common among people from there, and that will get commented on and maybe laughed at. I suppose it can feel more socially acceptable, or at least less risky, to comment and joke about quirks that Americans (and Brits, for that matter) have than about those of other nationalities, so maybe it could feel like Americans are uniquely targeted for their little foibles, but when I see joking about the way American individuals discuss their heritage, it doesn't usually look to me like vicious targeted sneering from people who hate Americans, just commenting on a minor thing people have noticed some American people sometimes do that seems funny or a bit weird.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 13:34

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/04/2023 15:52

I'm not aware of any sneering.

I was (and probably still am) very angry at the American supporters of the IRA though. They were not living in the midst of a serious terrorist bombing campaign that claimed many innocent lives.

Ah, you're talking about NORAID which was a Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA front in the United States.

Too many east coast US citizens funded PSF/PIRA through NORAID. Bono, to give him credit, absolutely tore into the "Irish"-Americans on this one in a U2 concert in New York City not long after PSF/PIRA bombed the Enniskillen Remembrance Sunday ceremony in Nov 1987:

“I’ve had enough of Irish-Americans who haven’t been back to their country in 20 or 30 years, come up to me and talk about the resistance, the revolution back home. And the glory of the revolution. And the glory of dying for the revolution. F–k the revolution!

Where’s the glory in bombing a Remembrance Day parade of old-age pensioners, their medals taken out and polished up for the day?”

Bono was right, you know. Those Americans certainly backed off from that kind of thing after 9/11.

East Coast US citizens who have some degree of Irish ancestry have some very funny ideas about Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Many of them are very out of touch with us and they more like speak of an Ireland that hasn't existed for a long time. Closer to an old Ireland their ancestors left for different reasons and at different times in history.

Here's a sample:

https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/abroad/generation-emigration/how-irish-america-sees-ireland-1.2834033

Ironic thing is that for most of them, their ancestors were Protestants known in the US as Scots-Irish, but known in Northern Ireland today as Ulster-Scots as well as Ulster-British. Yet some in the article above admitted they thought Protestants were "devils". Truth is, we in Northern Ireland are a complicated bunch where your religious background doesn't automatically tell you a thing about our political views. For example, I'm a Catholic, but definitely not a Nationalist or a Republican.

Anyway, I digress!

Seems to me most people in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland look at "Irish"-Americans with bemusement whilst being happy to accept US Dollars and Presidential visits. In other words, the identification as Irish-Americans isn't really taken too seriously.

How Irish-America sees Ireland

Ireland: a land of 100m people where abortion is legal and Protestants are ‘devils’. We visit Boston to meet Irish-Americans whose views of Ireland are a mix of confusion and piercing insight. Photographs by Kael Alford

https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/abroad/generation-emigration/how-irish-america-sees-ireland-1.2834033

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 13:15

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/04/2023 15:52

I'm not aware of any sneering.

I was (and probably still am) very angry at the American supporters of the IRA though. They were not living in the midst of a serious terrorist bombing campaign that claimed many innocent lives.

I can guarantee you that British taxpayers' funding of the bombing campaigns in Afghanistan and Iraq, and continued supply of arms to the evil Saudi regime to commit genocide in Yemen, has cost far, far more innocent lives.

Spybot · 15/04/2023 13:05

I live in the US and there is a fixation on heritage among some. On a similar note, what I find very amusing is when people go in ancestry.com and do their family trees like my FIL. He goes on about how is he related to a knight who is buried in Westminster Abbey. People latch onto the heritage that suits them but disregard all the ordinary ancestors who were cleaners, postmen, bus conductors and so on. I suppose it's natural to do that but ordinary folk are interesting to me too. My great grandad was a rag and bone man!

diflasu · 15/04/2023 12:42

Anotheronetwoone · 15/04/2023 12:34

@diflasu From few interviewers I've heard from former leader this visit gone down like a lead balloon

Surely you’re not taking anything Arlene says as representative! She had a hissy fit he didn’t have U.K. flags on his car! I think alot of British people aren’t aware of how off the wall the DUP are. They want to chain up swings in playgrounds on Sundays for crying out loud!

The DUP are the issue at the moment, the unionist side- US presidents focus on the nationalist side - I can take what Arlene says with a huge dose of salt and still see why there may be issues with US presidents visit.

belleager · 15/04/2023 12:41

The DUP is unlikely to get back around the table until after upcoming elections

Biden wasn't there to butter them up. He wanted to send a clear message to the DUP and potential voters that America is keen to invest in Northern Ireland, but that's not going to happen while the people's elected representatives there block the normal democratic functioning of the assembly there. If that went down badly with some, maybe voters will think about which parties have their interests at heart.

missinglalaland · 15/04/2023 12:39

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 11:06

Yes, but your ancestors were not forced to leave because of famine and oppression. They did not create a community built on their culture and traditions. You were not brought up immersed in those cultures and traditions.
You might find it odd but you have a completely different experience. It is not odd in America or in Ireland. It is perfectly normal.

Actually a lot of poor English were forced to immigrate. They were among the first settlers who came to NA as indentured servants and endured incredible hardships breaking the ground for those who would come after.

I am not trying to lionise the “English” here, but it is unfair to cherry pick history to create a biased narrative.

Anotheronetwoone · 15/04/2023 12:34

@diflasu From few interviewers I've heard from former leader this visit gone down like a lead balloon

Surely you’re not taking anything Arlene says as representative! She had a hissy fit he didn’t have U.K. flags on his car! I think alot of British people aren’t aware of how off the wall the DUP are. They want to chain up swings in playgrounds on Sundays for crying out loud!

diflasu · 15/04/2023 12:16

Over and above Britain, particularly with the crazy way the British authorities are acting

I think the UK government is trying to get the DUP who are currently boycott of Stormont to soften their position - I think Sunak's recent N.I agreements they'd hoped would bring them back and it hasn't.

From few interviewers I've heard from former leader this visit gone down like a lead balloon - I'm not sure how true a reflection that is because it's going though UK media lens but I wonder if they are worried this visit it will further entrench the Unionist side.

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 12:15

Fuerza · 15/04/2023 12:02

I agree with posters saying it doesn't bother them how Americans identify. It's their way. Not the right way or the wrong way, just their way. Where I live, if an obviously mixed race kid opens their mouth and has a local accent, that's it, deal sealed, they're Irish. But those are our unwritten rules. Other countries have their own. So be it!

👏 👏

Curseofthenation · 15/04/2023 12:08

JarByTheDoor · 14/04/2023 19:49

People don't make fun of Americans just for stating or being interested in their heritage — it's specific behaviour and language use in specific circumstances that elicits what usually amounts to an eye-roll at most.

(Apologies — I can't easily write perfectly idiomatic US English, so the following might sound a little off, but they're examples of the kinds of things people might say.)

Two Americans chatting together about their heritage:
US 1: "I'm mostly Danish with some German, you?"
US 2: "I'm Irish, and my husband's part Irish too."

Totally fine. Everyone in the conversation gets the context, which is that between two Americans, the American part goes without saying, and an outsider overhearing would get the context too.

A Brit talking to an American:
UK: "So what do Americans do at Christmas?"
US: "I'm actually Italian-American, so it's a little different — we have a lot of traditions going back to before my family came over here."

Also totally fine. Nobody's got any problem with that. The heritage is relevant and interesting and nobody sounds like they're claiming to be anything they're not.

US: "I'm trying to find out more about my Scottish roots — I've found out I'm also English, Irish, West African, French, but my great grandmother was from Aberdeen and right now I want to learn more about what that was like for her."

Still fine, the context shows that when they're saying "I'm French" it's in a family history and heritage context, and even though the Scottish connection is only one part of this person's background, there's nothing wrong with taking an interest in one particular part of the story.

US: Where are you from?
Irish: "I'm Irish, from Cork."
US: " You're Irish? I'm Irish! I love St Paddy's Day, d'you wanna see my shamrock hat? Chucky arla, amirite? Do you know my folk, the Sliggo Connors? What about those nuns, huh? Kiss me, I'm Irish, to be sure! So great to meet another Irish person here." [/mild exaggeration]

🙄

I agree with all of this. Surely most Americans can read a room? They must realise quite quickly that saying 'I'm Scottish' to an actual Scottish person in Scotland is confusing and odd. It makes them look a bit silly. It's unlikely a Scottish person would judge an American for saying they have Scottish heritage.

If an American chooses to ignore the confusion they cause and when they state that they are Scottish on a holiday to Scotland then they deserve a bit of judgement. They probably don't care anyway.

I don't know why people are getting so upset that they may be mildly judged for this type of behaviour outside of the US. It's not as if a Scottish person is going to agressively shout at them for saying something that sounds a bit silly to them!

Fuerza · 15/04/2023 12:02

I agree with posters saying it doesn't bother them how Americans identify. It's their way. Not the right way or the wrong way, just their way. Where I live, if an obviously mixed race kid opens their mouth and has a local accent, that's it, deal sealed, they're Irish. But those are our unwritten rules. Other countries have their own. So be it!

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 12:02

SD1978 · 15/04/2023 07:09

Because (some) see their ancestry- usually multiple generations back, and still being a close associate of that country. You're not Scottish, Irish, Italian etc- you're American with ancestry from those countries. The lack of ability to accept that is probably what irks.

Why does it "irk" you? Why do you even care?

belleager · 15/04/2023 11:58

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 11:44

@belleager and @StephanieSuperpowers I do agree with this 100%. I completely get why Biden is visiting Ireland at the moment and acting as such a strong supporter of Ireland and the Irish. Over and above Britain, particularly with the crazy way the British authorities are acting. I just think it's weird that he claims to BE Irish. Or calls Ireland home.
And I am British. But I am not anti Irish (or American or Irish-American) I just take issue with people claiming to be something they're not. It's dishonest. And weird.

Thanks @Swiftbushome

It is just that if you spend time in Ireland or among Irish Americans you will see that Biden's cultural identity is very normal, and widely understood. A big part of our own, Irish, President's role is to connect with our Irish diaspora. Our politicians all wander the globe doing this every St Patrick's Day. Biden reminds me of all the American relatives who visit just once, in old age, when they've retired. It can be very emotional.

If Biden came to Britain and claimed to be British I would understand people there objecting if that's not in their understanding of Britishness. But this doesn't apply to Ireland.

diflasu · 15/04/2023 11:54

I think Brexit is a complex issue - and as I voted remain and can see no few benefits - but it does seem to be massively misunderstood in USA especially.

I also think it hard to gauge how helpful his spotlight is actually being - I suspect time will tell there.

I'm also not saying it's right how he being mocked - as I do think he genuinely enthusiastic about his visit - but he's engaged in blatant home based electioneering and there will be blow back with that and not everyone prepared to ignore what he is clearly doing and exploiting a cultural quirk to make him seem ridiculous was always going to be on the cards.

I also don't see all the media doing it and no-one in RL I've met is mentioned him at all - so I don't think everyone is sneering - sections of the press - mainly print media - yes - everyone no.

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 11:53

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 11:44

@belleager and @StephanieSuperpowers I do agree with this 100%. I completely get why Biden is visiting Ireland at the moment and acting as such a strong supporter of Ireland and the Irish. Over and above Britain, particularly with the crazy way the British authorities are acting. I just think it's weird that he claims to BE Irish. Or calls Ireland home.
And I am British. But I am not anti Irish (or American or Irish-American) I just take issue with people claiming to be something they're not. It's dishonest. And weird.

He is not claiming to be something he isn't though. He grew up completely immersed in Irish culture. It has been part of his identity for his whole life instilled in him by his parents and grandparents. He has been to Ireland many times, researched his family history and been very close to his Irish cousins for decades. Some American presidents do play up their Irish ancestors but Biden is not one of them.

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 11:44

@belleager and @StephanieSuperpowers I do agree with this 100%. I completely get why Biden is visiting Ireland at the moment and acting as such a strong supporter of Ireland and the Irish. Over and above Britain, particularly with the crazy way the British authorities are acting. I just think it's weird that he claims to BE Irish. Or calls Ireland home.
And I am British. But I am not anti Irish (or American or Irish-American) I just take issue with people claiming to be something they're not. It's dishonest. And weird.

StephanieSuperpowers · 15/04/2023 11:34

It's odd that the peace process in NI is sacred so anything that looks like the US president may benefit from being at the 25th anniversary is appalling abuse but brexit was just fine.

belleager · 15/04/2023 11:29

Also doesn't change fact Biden is using a politically sensitive area to other countries to electioneer for his own ends.

America is a guarantor of the Good Friday Agreement. Until Biden was elected, the Brexiteers in government were all set to break it. They have played with that notion since. They have shown absolute contempt for UK treaty obligations, for all of Ireland (and for international law) in their push to leave the free market.

Biden did draw attention to this, and he had a right to do so.

Whenharrymetsmelly · 15/04/2023 11:19

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/04/2023 11:06

Nice bit of casual racism in the morning.

For starters it wasn't the English who colonised it was the British. Just as they themselves were repeatedly throughout history. Just as countless others did. The Irish themselves were.

No country has clean hands so don't let your prejudices conviently cherry pick history.

That's the equivalent rebuttal to "I'm not racist, I have a black friend" 😂

diflasu · 15/04/2023 11:13

@phoenixrosehere

And the same happens here with non-white Americans, yet it’s always made out to be only the States do this.

I think it happens much less than it every used to and is increasingly seen as unacceptable - it hit the headlines and was widely condemned when there was that were are you from thing at royal event recently.

I'm also not claiming the UK is perfect by any means- the met office conduct around ethic groups in London has been unacceptable and there are many problems and areas we could and should do better in.

I think the USA has long history of pointing to others to avoid looking at their own huge issues though.

Also doesn't change fact Biden is using a politically sensitive area to other countries to electioneer for his own ends.

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 11:06

Modang · 15/04/2023 11:00

Yeah, it's just a bit odd. My grandmother was born in Wales, her ancestors are Welsh, but I don't say I'm Welsh - I've never even been there and grew up England. My grandmother doesn't even say she is Welsh, she moved to England as a child and doesn't have an accent or any of the language. I might say "have some Welsh heritage" if asked but that's it. Similarly I have German great grandparents through my father, but it's nothing to do with me, never met them, never been there, had no impact on me.

Yes, but your ancestors were not forced to leave because of famine and oppression. They did not create a community built on their culture and traditions. You were not brought up immersed in those cultures and traditions.
You might find it odd but you have a completely different experience. It is not odd in America or in Ireland. It is perfectly normal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread