Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Chickenkeev · 15/04/2023 15:50

Florenz · 15/04/2023 15:39

Americans should feel confident enough to describe themselves as Americans instead of harking back the old country that their ancestors fled from to seek a better life in America.

That's a bit silly. What's wrong with accepting and embracing your history? There are plenty of Irish clubs in England.

Qbish · 15/04/2023 15:44

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 15:39

I really don't think people read or listen to the news enough to even notice let alone be affronted by his visit. I seriously wonder how many of the British population would know who the U.S president is.

I listened to his speech, live. Because I was actually interested. And, btw @Smallyellowbird , he did visit Britain.

I was amazed that he sounded vaguely lucid. Because just like Trump, but in a different way, you can't rely on that with Biden.

Florenz · 15/04/2023 15:39

Americans should feel confident enough to describe themselves as Americans instead of harking back the old country that their ancestors fled from to seek a better life in America.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 15:39

Smallyellowbird · 15/04/2023 15:30

Some Britissh people can't accept the the President of the US visited Ireland and not Britian, so they're criticising Biden and his identification as an Irish-American.

I don't think he's anti-Brirish as such, but Britian in general doesn't seem particularly bothered by the anniversary of the Good Friday agreement, and in Johnsons links with Trump and their rhetoric on immigration the Tory Party seem to have aligned themselves with the Republicans, so why would Biden be a fan?

The special relationship is really over - Britian isn't a global player anymore.

I really don't think people read or listen to the news enough to even notice let alone be affronted by his visit. I seriously wonder how many of the British population would know who the U.S president is.

Anyotherdude · 15/04/2023 15:36

@jeffgoldblum ”written”😉😂

jeffgoldblum · 15/04/2023 15:33

I'm not normally a pedant but you've spelt Britain wrong every time you've wrote it in that post.

Fairislefandango · 15/04/2023 15:32

Some Britissh people can't accept the the President of the US visited Ireland and not Britian, so they're criticising Biden and his identification as an Irish-American.

Ummm... I really don't think it's that. I don't imagine anyone particularly cares where he visits!

Smallyellowbird · 15/04/2023 15:30

Some Britissh people can't accept the the President of the US visited Ireland and not Britian, so they're criticising Biden and his identification as an Irish-American.

I don't think he's anti-Brirish as such, but Britian in general doesn't seem particularly bothered by the anniversary of the Good Friday agreement, and in Johnsons links with Trump and their rhetoric on immigration the Tory Party seem to have aligned themselves with the Republicans, so why would Biden be a fan?

The special relationship is really over - Britian isn't a global player anymore.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 15:29

postapesto · 15/04/2023 15:22

This is a myth trying to dispel what people think is a myth but is not. Corned beef is absolutely Irish, we were making and exporting corned beef before America even existed as a country. It was eaten with cabbage, amongst other things.

When Irish immgrants couldn't find it in america, they bought a similar meat from Jewish butchers. Because they were used to it at home. Cork people ate a lot of corned beef.

It's the opposite way round. Historically, the Irish didn't eat beef and so there isn't a tradition of eating corned beef on either side of the border.

The Smithsonian did a good job of setting the record straight on this one:

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/is-corned-beef-really-irish-2839144/

Corned beef and cabbage

Is Corned Beef Really Irish?

The rise and fall and rise of the traditional St. Patrick's Day meal

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/is-corned-beef-really-irish-2839144

postapesto · 15/04/2023 15:22

DownNative · 15/04/2023 13:52

Well, I'm sure a lot of those Americans would tell you that corned beef and cabbage is an Irish tradition they uphold.

Except....it really isn't!

Turns out this is a Jewish thing that the descendants of Irish emigrants started in the New World. Historically, corned beef and cabbage is not remotely associated with the Island of Ireland.

Neither is green beer or even those St Patrick's Day parades which are both American cultural inventions that became popular in the British Isles from the 1990s onwards.

I did read a study once that concluded most Irish-Americans identify that way NOT in relation to the island of Ireland, but to a relative before them who was Irish. A way of keeping their memory alive.

That would explain their out of date views of the island as well. If I can find it, I'll post it.

This is a myth trying to dispel what people think is a myth but is not. Corned beef is absolutely Irish, we were making and exporting corned beef before America even existed as a country. It was eaten with cabbage, amongst other things.

When Irish immgrants couldn't find it in america, they bought a similar meat from Jewish butchers. Because they were used to it at home. Cork people ate a lot of corned beef.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 15:19

Anonymous48 · 14/04/2023 16:49

Please don't sneer. It's not a good look.

This meaning of Irish=Irish American or Italian=Italian American is so well used and understood in the US, I'm sure that most Americans don't even realize it might not be used the same way elsewhere, It's not about being arrogant.

It is literally about being arrogant, and we will continue to sneer.

Americans banging on about being Irish and eating cabbage and drinking guiness and singing Danny Boy...when they know absolutely nothing about the 21st country of Ireland. Not a damn thing. It's so fucking annoying. "I'm Irish" no you're fucking not, sod off, is what Irish people are thinking.

Qbish · 15/04/2023 15:03

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 14:48

So successive British govts who pursued these policies got elected by accident?

Ha ha, yes. Absolutely no-one in the UK objected to the Iraq war. Not a single person. All those millions marching against it? (Including me.) Didn't happen And so we kept voting different governments in, based on their campaign promises to invade/bomb other countries.

Please do stop with your whataboutery. You have no answer to the fact that NORAID donators chose to fund the IRA.

TheVanguardSix · 15/04/2023 14:58

Answering the OP’s question: Because the journey of becoming American generally comes at a loss. So we cling. I’m first generation American. My mother came to America, to Brooklyn NY, as you do, from an impoverished Ireland. My father was a Polish/German Holocaust survivor who came into Ellis Island as a refugee along with his mother and sister. I have no living relatives on my father’s side.

I’m a Californian more than I am an American. When my brother died two years ago, I spoke at his funeral l, referring to my brother as an American son because we are as American as you can get. There was a poignancy in my language.
We are the American product of European survivors of persecution. I am the living testament to my family’s loss.

America is so flawed, so divided, crazy in many ways and yet it’s where our family respawned. America is where the universe leaned in and said, ‘Here’s your second chance.’ My aunt, my father’s sister, for me as a woman, is my example. She had survived rape, death camp, loss of her father and extended family members. She became an economist for the science and engineering department of the World Bank in the States. I always tell my children, as sure as you breathe, no opportunity is a missed one. You take various forks in the road. You take one opportunity and not the other. That’s ok. You can always be that Phoenix flight in life. We are constantly being reborn throughout our lives. And being an American taught me that. It is not the land of milk and honey. No place is. But in my father’s youth, it was still a place of possibility after experiencing such trauma. I am as much tied to my old roots, roots ripped from my grandparents’ history and placed sloppily into my own lap, as I am to my American being. I’m very much an American in the UK, even after 27 years here.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 14:56

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 14:21

Yes indeed, the US, like the UK, has been a huge exporter of death and destruction globally.

But I singled out Britain specifically in my response to that poster, purely for the reason that British people are unqualified to moralise to anyone about "innocent lives". The UK Exchequer still profits hugely from arms exports to despotic and genocidal regimes.

But you're attempting to use the Tu Quoque Fallacy or the appeal to hypocrisy. Fallacies are errors I reasoning and logic.

Relying on that is not really a valid argument.

I'll add that the US Government also didn't take a favourable attitude to NORAID. In short, that poster is perfectly valid in feeling anger at ignorant East Coast Americans for funding PSF/PIRA through NORAID.

Myself even more so since they were helping give them the means to destroy my country, land and people.

EC US ignorant attitudes also was a factor that enabled PSF/PIRA to fight on once we'd defeated them in their insurgent phrase by 1974. With that help and Libya's, PSF/PIRA turned into a cell structure which was also eventually defeated.

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 14:48

Qbish · 15/04/2023 14:35

The British public didn't choose to fund those campaigns. NORAID donators chose to fund the IRA.

So successive British govts who pursued these policies got elected by accident?

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 14:48

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 14:21

Yes indeed, the US, like the UK, has been a huge exporter of death and destruction globally.

But I singled out Britain specifically in my response to that poster, purely for the reason that British people are unqualified to moralise to anyone about "innocent lives". The UK Exchequer still profits hugely from arms exports to despotic and genocidal regimes.

I don't know about that the 'British' are made up of a huge diverse range of people who can absolutely moralise about 'innocent lives'. What does British mean to you as you sound like you have a narrow view of that make-up.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 14:39

CordyLines · 15/04/2023 10:54

I understand, and I did say "those who voted for it" in my post.

Yes but your hyperbolic comments depict the British as English (for a start), xenophobic, inward looking, racist, royalist and Anglo - Saxon that have only married or partnered with fellow Anglo-Saxons as this is convenient for your argument. The reality is 48% of the population didn't vote to leave, my wedding was 2 days following the vote to leave the EU and it was overcast by the outcome. My marriage to Jewish man with an Irish surname of which my DC have now. The population of London alone is greater the Scotland so yes of course it is most likely that the votes to leave the EU would have and were made by the English, of you look at the Map for that vote of 60% in much of the North east - strangely this is the area my DH's Gran moved to and settled as a baby from Ireland. In the south where we live the vote was not wanting to leave. London/south east is huge and diverse.

StephanieSuperpowers · 15/04/2023 14:39

Qbish · 15/04/2023 14:35

The British public didn't choose to fund those campaigns. NORAID donators chose to fund the IRA.

It's a shame the British public weren't interested in what was happening in NI, really. Just think - it could have all been stopped before it got to that point.

Qbish · 15/04/2023 14:35

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 13:15

I can guarantee you that British taxpayers' funding of the bombing campaigns in Afghanistan and Iraq, and continued supply of arms to the evil Saudi regime to commit genocide in Yemen, has cost far, far more innocent lives.

The British public didn't choose to fund those campaigns. NORAID donators chose to fund the IRA.

MissConductUS · 15/04/2023 14:29

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 13:58

Conversely, and quite amusngly, Americans think we Brits are exotic, and somehow more learned and knowledgeable. 😂

True. It's utter madness, I know. 😁

We get loads of British tourists in NYC; they are our favorite group overall.

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 14:21

DownNative · 15/04/2023 13:37

Odd how you've not mentioned the United States of America in relation to Afghanistan and Iraq there.

Some might well point out that the US is the single biggest military aggressor in our time....🤷‍♂️

Yes indeed, the US, like the UK, has been a huge exporter of death and destruction globally.

But I singled out Britain specifically in my response to that poster, purely for the reason that British people are unqualified to moralise to anyone about "innocent lives". The UK Exchequer still profits hugely from arms exports to despotic and genocidal regimes.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 14:13

Fuerza · 15/04/2023 12:02

I agree with posters saying it doesn't bother them how Americans identify. It's their way. Not the right way or the wrong way, just their way. Where I live, if an obviously mixed race kid opens their mouth and has a local accent, that's it, deal sealed, they're Irish. But those are our unwritten rules. Other countries have their own. So be it!

Does Ireland have any issues at all with embracing diversity in comparison to it's EU counterparts, does the U.S have any race relation problems or is it just the British?

LuluBlakey1 · 15/04/2023 14:03

I don't find it completely ridiculous. There were millions of Irish people (from a small population) who went to America. I think the link is felt from both countries.

I consider myself English but am aware of and interested in my Irish great-grandparents - 4 of the 8- and would like to know more than I have been able to find out, particularly about the social history. I have been to the bits of Ireland they came from, just to see what it's like. I don't identify as Irish but my surname was distinctly Irish and often commented on as being so, before I married DH. Their religion, customs and traditions were still felt in my family until my father died.

Mendholeai · 15/04/2023 13:58

Conversely, and quite amusngly, Americans think we Brits are exotic, and somehow more learned and knowledgeable. 😂

LuluBlakey1 · 15/04/2023 13:55

proppy · 14/04/2023 16:07

@Anonymous48 so what Irish traditions & customs would Irish Americans uphold?

I think it's mainly in Northern States. They have huge St Patrick's Day celebrations in New York, Irish association groups in many jobs eg NYPD, New York Firefighters, Irish-American political pressure organisations, Irish-American fund-raising organisations, sporting institutions, Irish-American catholic organisations, hospitals, children organisations, universities, colleges and schools supported financially by I-A religious organisations. There are I-A social clubs I think most of the cultures/traditions would be based on religion, sport (baseball and dancing particularly), and music , apart from St Patrick's Day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread