Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 18:11

postapesto · 15/04/2023 17:57

Because they are culturally appropriating from others.

No, they're not. If an American of Polish descent chooses to observe some of the customs handed down to them thru the generations, they are not appropriating anything. This is literally part of their culture.

This isn't hard to understand. It's fine that the use of Polish-American isn't something you like or agree with, but there is no cultural appropriation.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 18:10

Actually, the only person to bring it up was the son of an Irish Mother who remarked on it to him, he then talked about it to DD and we are in Southern England so no one has ever mentioned it.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 18:09

My DC have an Irish surname but are not really bothered like all of their friends

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 18:07

I think Florenz makes a good point, surely it is better to get on and assimilate ourselves in to a community/society than continually highlight are differences to the detriment of our relations and freedom of choice. I am married to a Jewish man and I'm not Jewish, I have Swedish and German heritage if you are looking back to the 19th century. My DC have an Irish surname. My MIL was married to an English man with a mother that was born in Ireland.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 17:57

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 17:56

Why do you care?

Because they are culturally appropriating from others.

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 17:56

Florenz · 15/04/2023 15:39

Americans should feel confident enough to describe themselves as Americans instead of harking back the old country that their ancestors fled from to seek a better life in America.

Why do you care?

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 17:43

They want to keep us as a quaint wee theme park.

@LampLamp Ah, the "Brigadoon"/" Quiet Man" crowd😂Were they expecting an invite to have some Irish soda bread back at your thatch roofed cottage?

I think people like that don't mean any harm or disrespect, but they should absolutely educate themselves unless they enjoy being seen as boorish simpletons.

Hopefully they learned something useful during their stay!

tabulahrasa · 15/04/2023 17:34

forgodssnake · 15/04/2023 17:19

And maybe, just maybe these identities are the result of being regarded as a lesser human being due to one's roots - not protestant, not from Anglo-Saxon sphere-thus, a barbarian.

There is a difference between people who grow up in mainstream American culture and never learnt their roots (they are ridicules) and people who experienced immersion into ancestors' culture.
I know people who are like 4th or 5th generation, but grow up speaking language, learning history at weekend schools etc.

And it happens in the UK as well, and for the full disclosure, it is not a bad thing as long, as it dose not prevent assimilation into mainstream culture.

To be fair, I don’t think most people have an issue with mixed identities (obviously that post does)

It’s more when there’s a lack of differentiation between the whichever type of American heritage and actual direct experience of that country.

But mostly when people are obnoxious about it - I’ve seen Italian Americans online arguing with Italians over pronunciation of Italian words, or I follow a woman on Tiktok from Glasgow whose grandparents came over from China, her and both her parents were born here and Americans frequently have issues with her being Scottish.

Obviously some people are obnoxious on the other side of the argument too, but they’re my beefs with it.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 17:33

LampLamp · 15/04/2023 17:27

Yes they are racists (and I agree re Facebook - I’m no longer on it), plain and simple.

A long with that example goes the others I’ve mentioned where Irish Americans want to keep what they see as Irish traditions alive in their American communities but begrudge actual Irish people moving forward and modernising.

I was in Cavan last week having a drink with a few friends and family friends came across an “Irish American” group who were astonished that none of us were drinking Guinness or Harp. FFS.

They want to keep us as a quaint wee theme park.

Which is just part of the reason we don't like them saying they are Irish. They're not Irish, they don't know Ireland. They think its still all donkeys and tenements and begorrah. They haven't the first clue about modern, multicultural 21st century Ireland with its problems and its successes.

LampLamp · 15/04/2023 17:27

Yes they are racists (and I agree re Facebook - I’m no longer on it), plain and simple.

A long with that example goes the others I’ve mentioned where Irish Americans want to keep what they see as Irish traditions alive in their American communities but begrudge actual Irish people moving forward and modernising.

I was in Cavan last week having a drink with a few friends and family friends came across an “Irish American” group who were astonished that none of us were drinking Guinness or Harp. FFS.

They want to keep us as a quaint wee theme park.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 17:24

LampLamp · 15/04/2023 17:07

I’m Irish. Was born there, lived there until I was 18 and return regularly.

I used to be in a few Facebook groups for people with my very Irish surname, groups which included a great deal of Americans - in discussions the majority say they have never visited.

All fine well.

That is until my cousin joins the group and participates.

You see, my cousin is black. She was born in Ireland, was raised there, went to school there and has worked and raised her kids all over the island.

The “Irish Americans” kicked off massively saying we were:

  • “diluting our gene pool
  • ”modern day Irish people will be held responsible by the true Irish (apparently many “Irish Americans” consider the people who left Ireland during the genocide to be the true Irish) for allowing this to happen”
  • True Irish people look like XYZ and posted photos.

Turns out they were actually livid about many things which modern, progressive Ireland has done or is working toward, but they were especially angry about ethic minorities living there.

This is a huge group BTW, with over 250,000 people, with over half of them from the USA.

I’ve met many an American who asks me if I’m Irish and I say yes, they say “oh me too, my greatx10 grandparents came over, I love cabbage and corned beef on patties day” (a tennament NYC Jewish import, nothing to do with the Irish) 😒
They genuinely talk to me like they have the same lived experience.

I’ve mentioned to a number of “Irish Americans” that I grew up in a border town and had some difficult experiences because of it (Terrorism etc). They were disgusted Irish people don’t spend every day thinking about achieving a United Ireland at any cost and we should be ashamed of ourselves.
As if many of us didn’t live through a war, and as much as a United Ireland is a lovely dream, peace in the meantime means much more to 99% of all Irish born (and even second generation people) I know.

They want a fight and we have lived through it. I’m bored of hearing their shit about being just as Irish as me or more Irish than my cousins of colour.

This is why I asked about racism in Ireland and diversity earlier in the thread but was ignored. According to a report commissioned by The Irish Council For International Students in 2021, 40% had experienced racism and the European Commission have reported how it doesn't fair as well as it's European counter parts on this front.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 17:20

@LampLamp The people you're describing are racists, pure and simple. That isn't about identifying as Irish-American, it's unabashed racism.

A lot of people who join these Facebook groups and become heavily invested in them exhibit strange anti-social behavior. There's a reason younger people have mostly abandoned Facebook.

forgodssnake · 15/04/2023 17:19

Florenz · 15/04/2023 16:46

It divides American society to have Irish-Americans, African-Americans, Italian-Americans, Polish-Americans instead of just "Americans".

And maybe, just maybe these identities are the result of being regarded as a lesser human being due to one's roots - not protestant, not from Anglo-Saxon sphere-thus, a barbarian.

There is a difference between people who grow up in mainstream American culture and never learnt their roots (they are ridicules) and people who experienced immersion into ancestors' culture.
I know people who are like 4th or 5th generation, but grow up speaking language, learning history at weekend schools etc.

And it happens in the UK as well, and for the full disclosure, it is not a bad thing as long, as it dose not prevent assimilation into mainstream culture.

CordyLines · 15/04/2023 17:15

I blame the education system, the Daily Mail and the Telegraph. Oh and the war.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 17:10

OverCCCs · 15/04/2023 16:43

100% agreed! The attitudes of cultural superiority shown on this thread are shocking. I would have expected to see them 20 years ago, but I thought that in 2023 most people in Britain were informed and cosmopolitan enough to be able to appreciate cultural relativism.

The UK way of defining one’s identity is merely a social construct and inherently not the only correct way to do so. Hence, as previous posters have pointed out, how many Americans self-identify today based on complicated historical factors, or how some countries assign citizenship differently from the UK system, are not “weird” or “daft” or “wrong.”

So many of you sound incredibly insecure, reacting defensively and hostilely to a practice that doesn’t align with yours out of—what? Insecurity? A desire to feel superior? 🙄

I’m starting to wish that basic anthropology and sociology concepts were taught better in schools, because there is really no excuse other than ignorance and close-mindedness for calling a country’s benign self-identification patterns “stupid.”

I think most British people don't relate to this depiction of them on the thread and see it is a dated perception of what it is to be British. The make up of British people and one poster claimed that to really mean English for the terms of reference on this thread, is really diverse and that diversity is the make up of the British identity now not the one that is being portrayed on this thread. Many English people with that heritage (Biden's) and closer in generations would not say they were Irish so it is not sneering it is genuine misunderstanding.

LampLamp · 15/04/2023 17:07

I’m Irish. Was born there, lived there until I was 18 and return regularly.

I used to be in a few Facebook groups for people with my very Irish surname, groups which included a great deal of Americans - in discussions the majority say they have never visited.

All fine well.

That is until my cousin joins the group and participates.

You see, my cousin is black. She was born in Ireland, was raised there, went to school there and has worked and raised her kids all over the island.

The “Irish Americans” kicked off massively saying we were:

  • “diluting our gene pool
  • ”modern day Irish people will be held responsible by the true Irish (apparently many “Irish Americans” consider the people who left Ireland during the genocide to be the true Irish) for allowing this to happen”
  • True Irish people look like XYZ and posted photos.

Turns out they were actually livid about many things which modern, progressive Ireland has done or is working toward, but they were especially angry about ethic minorities living there.

This is a huge group BTW, with over 250,000 people, with over half of them from the USA.

I’ve met many an American who asks me if I’m Irish and I say yes, they say “oh me too, my greatx10 grandparents came over, I love cabbage and corned beef on patties day” (a tennament NYC Jewish import, nothing to do with the Irish) 😒
They genuinely talk to me like they have the same lived experience.

I’ve mentioned to a number of “Irish Americans” that I grew up in a border town and had some difficult experiences because of it (Terrorism etc). They were disgusted Irish people don’t spend every day thinking about achieving a United Ireland at any cost and we should be ashamed of ourselves.
As if many of us didn’t live through a war, and as much as a United Ireland is a lovely dream, peace in the meantime means much more to 99% of all Irish born (and even second generation people) I know.

They want a fight and we have lived through it. I’m bored of hearing their shit about being just as Irish as me or more Irish than my cousins of colour.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 16:52

Smallyellowbird · 15/04/2023 15:30

Some Britissh people can't accept the the President of the US visited Ireland and not Britian, so they're criticising Biden and his identification as an Irish-American.

I don't think he's anti-Brirish as such, but Britian in general doesn't seem particularly bothered by the anniversary of the Good Friday agreement, and in Johnsons links with Trump and their rhetoric on immigration the Tory Party seem to have aligned themselves with the Republicans, so why would Biden be a fan?

The special relationship is really over - Britian isn't a global player anymore.

He visited both the UK and Ireland.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 16:50

On a Scottish Facebook group I had an American woman tell me I obviously knew nothing about Scotland

I wouldn't put a lot of store in what some random obnoxious person says on Facebook. That's not representative of most Americans.

It is bizarre how they describe themselves like some sort of mixed breed dog.

You sound like a deep thinker....🤔

Florenz · 15/04/2023 16:46

It divides American society to have Irish-Americans, African-Americans, Italian-Americans, Polish-Americans instead of just "Americans".

OverCCCs · 15/04/2023 16:43

belleager · 15/04/2023 09:48

The fact that British people do things one way doesn't make that the only right way. There's a whole wide world out there. There are some remarkably intolerant attitudes on this thread.

100% agreed! The attitudes of cultural superiority shown on this thread are shocking. I would have expected to see them 20 years ago, but I thought that in 2023 most people in Britain were informed and cosmopolitan enough to be able to appreciate cultural relativism.

The UK way of defining one’s identity is merely a social construct and inherently not the only correct way to do so. Hence, as previous posters have pointed out, how many Americans self-identify today based on complicated historical factors, or how some countries assign citizenship differently from the UK system, are not “weird” or “daft” or “wrong.”

So many of you sound incredibly insecure, reacting defensively and hostilely to a practice that doesn’t align with yours out of—what? Insecurity? A desire to feel superior? 🙄

I’m starting to wish that basic anthropology and sociology concepts were taught better in schools, because there is really no excuse other than ignorance and close-mindedness for calling a country’s benign self-identification patterns “stupid.”

Amispringy · 15/04/2023 16:38

Smallyellowbird · 15/04/2023 15:30

Some Britissh people can't accept the the President of the US visited Ireland and not Britian, so they're criticising Biden and his identification as an Irish-American.

I don't think he's anti-Brirish as such, but Britian in general doesn't seem particularly bothered by the anniversary of the Good Friday agreement, and in Johnsons links with Trump and their rhetoric on immigration the Tory Party seem to have aligned themselves with the Republicans, so why would Biden be a fan?

The special relationship is really over - Britian isn't a global player anymore.

I would imagine most British people don't care

jeffgoldblum · 15/04/2023 16:32

Ok @KnittingNeedles , I got you've mixed up with you , so your correct, however it still isn't as bad a misspelling a country name wrong ( and different) five times in one post!
As I said I'm not a pedant but that was spectacular spelling.

BashfulClam · 15/04/2023 16:20

On a Scottish Facebook group I had an American woman tell me I obviously knew nothing about Scotland and should really visit it. I pointed out I was born in Scotland and have lived here my whole life, my parents , Grandparents, great Grandparents etc are Scottish. My family can be traced back to the original clans and some Viking invaders…she was Scottish apparently as her Great, Great, Great Grandmother was Half Scottish. She still maintained she knew more about Scotland than I did despite never setting foot on Scottish soil.

It is bizarre how they describe themselves like some sort of mixed breed dog.

KnittingNeedles · 15/04/2023 16:07

@jeffgoldblum when you're in a hole, stop digging.

I wrote, you wrote
I have written, you have written (or you've written)

You've wrote is incorrect just as "I written the letter" is incorrect.

jeffgoldblum · 15/04/2023 15:58

.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?