Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 21:15

Everytime a comparison to other cultures and nationalities in regard to making a big deal of heritage is made on this thread or when I made a point of the makeup of a British society now, it is either ignored or dismissed as not relevant because America is different, all countries are different from each other, so it is not really an argument. If Irish people had to leave Ireland like my DH's Gran as a baby did due to poverty and oppression or his Jewish grandparents from Europe and Ukraine what is the difference? A poster stated earlier that the British are not allowed to have a moral moan about innocent lives as they are British but the make up of British people is varied and diverse.

FurAndFeathers · 15/04/2023 20:59

Anonymous48 · 14/04/2023 16:49

Please don't sneer. It's not a good look.

This meaning of Irish=Irish American or Italian=Italian American is so well used and understood in the US, I'm sure that most Americans don't even realize it might not be used the same way elsewhere, It's not about being arrogant.

You’re genuinely suggesting that Americans don’t realise that the term Irish has any other meaning than Irish American?

it genuinely doesn’t occur to them them that Irish might actually mean Irish?!?
and you think that’s reasonable? 😂

yep I’m afraid I’m sneering at that @Anonymous48 😂

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 20:59

belleager · 15/04/2023 20:31

I'd like to hear that and would respect him for it, if he wanted to talk about his identity this way. But maybe it would put his position in British politics at risk.

America is just a different political culture from Britain.

So in the unlikely event that Americans voted in an ethnically Indian president, would they be happy for him to go to Delhi, and address the parliament saying how he felt 'at home' in India? And refer to Indians as 'us'? Just like Biden did in Ireland?

Somehow I doubt it.

DorritLittle · 15/04/2023 20:40

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 02:28

People are going to experience these things differently. You are also generation away from your mothers experience.

I do feel the Irish identity is so much stronger in America because it is so far away. Those who left for America knew they would never go back home, never see the people and places they loved again. It must have been so hard.

Yes it must have been really hard to be so far away and only be able to write home, and lots of Irish were still emigrating for work in the 50s. It’s no wonder Irish communities stuck together then.

barmycatmum · 15/04/2023 20:38

Dutch1e · 15/04/2023 19:08

White Australia is also very young, also forced people to leave their homelands, and also did a fair bit of genocide. Yet somehow we manage to not be "Irish" all the time and no-one needs to be patient with us. In a country with internet access there's really no excuse for total ignorance of the world even when the education system is questionable and people can't afford to travel

Oh, I’m not looking to excuse anyone. But I’m also not looking to attack anyone, either. 💁🏻‍♀️
it’s an engaging discussion, to me- I don’t see how it can be any kind of competition, when we all have such completely separate experiences.

belleager · 15/04/2023 20:31

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 19:51

And he's not just any American, is he? He's the President.

Imagine Rishi Sunak going on about how 'Indian' or maybe 'Kenyan' he feels. Yet he has recent Indian ancestry.

I'd like to hear that and would respect him for it, if he wanted to talk about his identity this way. But maybe it would put his position in British politics at risk.

America is just a different political culture from Britain.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 19:51

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:05

You get the impression that being American is really important to identity there -'U S A' chants etc so it is quite confusing.

And he's not just any American, is he? He's the President.

Imagine Rishi Sunak going on about how 'Indian' or maybe 'Kenyan' he feels. Yet he has recent Indian ancestry.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 15/04/2023 19:49

You get the impression that being American is really important to identity there -'U S A' chants etc so it is quite confusing.

What's causing your confusion?

DownNative · 15/04/2023 19:47

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 19:24

I don't need a counter-argument. Noraid were misguided, deluded twats, but bad as they were, even they never went as far as directly profiting from another country's genocide. That's just sick. I wonder if that poster is just as "angry" about that. I doubt it.

You do if you want to have a point. There's a reason the Appeal To Hypocrisy is a logical fallacy.....

Dutch1e · 15/04/2023 19:41

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 19:26

Oh the old feud continues in Australia don't worry.

My uncle married an Aussie girl. Her dad was quite upset at her marrying an Irishman. He was a Freemason. Perhaps it's fading a bit now though.
Yes@CordyLines Oz is a much younger country than the US or Canada but Australian ppl I know are interested in the convict ships and rebellions against authority like Eureka Stockade.

Yeah, I'm Australian but thanks for explaining Australian culture to me

Heatherbell1978 · 15/04/2023 19:34

There really is nothing more irritating than being Scottish and having to listen to loud Americans telling you they're also Scottish because their great great great great great grandparents were from here. Eh no you're American.

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 19:26

Dutch1e · 15/04/2023 19:08

White Australia is also very young, also forced people to leave their homelands, and also did a fair bit of genocide. Yet somehow we manage to not be "Irish" all the time and no-one needs to be patient with us. In a country with internet access there's really no excuse for total ignorance of the world even when the education system is questionable and people can't afford to travel

Oh the old feud continues in Australia don't worry.

My uncle married an Aussie girl. Her dad was quite upset at her marrying an Irishman. He was a Freemason. Perhaps it's fading a bit now though.
Yes@CordyLines Oz is a much younger country than the US or Canada but Australian ppl I know are interested in the convict ships and rebellions against authority like Eureka Stockade.

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 19:24

DownNative · 15/04/2023 18:36

Perhaps, but you're missing the point that you have failed to respond to that members point.

Appeal To Hypocrisy is a logical fallacy where a person is using it in lieu of a counter-argument....

I don't need a counter-argument. Noraid were misguided, deluded twats, but bad as they were, even they never went as far as directly profiting from another country's genocide. That's just sick. I wonder if that poster is just as "angry" about that. I doubt it.

CordyLines · 15/04/2023 19:15

Many Australians are descended from Irish and British convicts who were transported for stealing a sheep.

Is that something current Australians are interested in via ancestry?

Dutch1e · 15/04/2023 19:08

barmycatmum · 15/04/2023 18:37

I’m an American, and I also lived in Germany for years, and the one thing I can add to this discussion is: we are a very young, naive country. When I moved back from Germany, I had people asking if I was a “communist” since I had lived in Germany. Just incredible ignorance.

many people here have not been out of the country - ever- in their entire lives.

we don’t have the kind of history you all do- we think a building is “old” if it was built in the 1800’s!

So all of our ancestors (except Native Americans) came over from somewhere almost within our memory. Maybe a few generations removed, but it’s still the blink of an eye when compared to the history in the UK and elsewhere.

“No Irish Need Apply” was a sign in many shops- just to bring up the Irish thing, Irish immigrants were treated very badly -
so within the melting pot of the USA, we still have these areas where people were handed down the idea that they are Irish, or they are Polish, or they are Russian, etc. because that’s how they kept safe.

traditions were preserved within those groups, but they also changed over time, so it’s watered down and probably completely bizarre to someone actually from those countries - it’s a tradition from the time immigrants arrived, that has been preserved by word of mouth or communal sharing. It might be so far removed from the actual tradition, that it’s completely different.

People might connect very passionately with their ancestry (like Biden does) because ultimately it’s an Underdog story, and their family had to be scrappy and wily and f*cking survive by any means.

Or there are also those who are snobby as hell about their lineage, because we had “old families” especially in Boston and New York, families with old money forming our version of aristocracy.

I can see how ridiculous it is to other countries - but when you’re a mixed mutt in a country with no roots here, one has to try to form an identity, and learning about our ancestors is the way many of us do that.

however. I really wish more Americans would travel and would learn other languages. It is so embarrassing .. the ignorance.

but at the same time, that I say that is a bit classist - many cannot afford to travel, and can’t afford education. So they take their learning from their family “roots,” I suppose.

thanks for being patient with us; America is basically the equivalent of a pre-teen child 😂🥳

White Australia is also very young, also forced people to leave their homelands, and also did a fair bit of genocide. Yet somehow we manage to not be "Irish" all the time and no-one needs to be patient with us. In a country with internet access there's really no excuse for total ignorance of the world even when the education system is questionable and people can't afford to travel

DownNative · 15/04/2023 19:07

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:05

You get the impression that being American is really important to identity there -'U S A' chants etc so it is quite confusing.

And the US flag on flagpoles on residential properties too. Pretty popular there!

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:05

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 18:54

Surely he's more American than he is anything else?

You get the impression that being American is really important to identity there -'U S A' chants etc so it is quite confusing.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 18:54

KnittingNeedles · 14/04/2023 18:35

Biden also has 10 out of 16 great grandparents who were Irish. He's more Irish than he is anything else.

https://www.itv.com/news/2023-04-11/is-joe-biden-the-most-irish-us-president-in-history

Surely he's more American than he is anything else?

barmycatmum · 15/04/2023 18:37

I’m an American, and I also lived in Germany for years, and the one thing I can add to this discussion is: we are a very young, naive country. When I moved back from Germany, I had people asking if I was a “communist” since I had lived in Germany. Just incredible ignorance.

many people here have not been out of the country - ever- in their entire lives.

we don’t have the kind of history you all do- we think a building is “old” if it was built in the 1800’s!

So all of our ancestors (except Native Americans) came over from somewhere almost within our memory. Maybe a few generations removed, but it’s still the blink of an eye when compared to the history in the UK and elsewhere.

“No Irish Need Apply” was a sign in many shops- just to bring up the Irish thing, Irish immigrants were treated very badly -
so within the melting pot of the USA, we still have these areas where people were handed down the idea that they are Irish, or they are Polish, or they are Russian, etc. because that’s how they kept safe.

traditions were preserved within those groups, but they also changed over time, so it’s watered down and probably completely bizarre to someone actually from those countries - it’s a tradition from the time immigrants arrived, that has been preserved by word of mouth or communal sharing. It might be so far removed from the actual tradition, that it’s completely different.

People might connect very passionately with their ancestry (like Biden does) because ultimately it’s an Underdog story, and their family had to be scrappy and wily and f*cking survive by any means.

Or there are also those who are snobby as hell about their lineage, because we had “old families” especially in Boston and New York, families with old money forming our version of aristocracy.

I can see how ridiculous it is to other countries - but when you’re a mixed mutt in a country with no roots here, one has to try to form an identity, and learning about our ancestors is the way many of us do that.

however. I really wish more Americans would travel and would learn other languages. It is so embarrassing .. the ignorance.

but at the same time, that I say that is a bit classist - many cannot afford to travel, and can’t afford education. So they take their learning from their family “roots,” I suppose.

thanks for being patient with us; America is basically the equivalent of a pre-teen child 😂🥳

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 18:36

LampLamp · 15/04/2023 17:27

Yes they are racists (and I agree re Facebook - I’m no longer on it), plain and simple.

A long with that example goes the others I’ve mentioned where Irish Americans want to keep what they see as Irish traditions alive in their American communities but begrudge actual Irish people moving forward and modernising.

I was in Cavan last week having a drink with a few friends and family friends came across an “Irish American” group who were astonished that none of us were drinking Guinness or Harp. FFS.

They want to keep us as a quaint wee theme park.

You can only get Harp in Northern Ireland now surely?

I live near a very touristy area and I've yet to encounter the stereotyped ' Returned Yank' noisy American of yore. Mostly they are hyper aware that their reputation precedes them.

Also they seem pretty clued up about politics - especially if it's not their first visit to Ireland - and usually agnostic about whether or not the country should reunite for example. The Internet has doubtless helped to disabuse them of some romantic notions.

That and the cost of living ! They are too busy being in shock 🤯 at the prices to worry overmuch about the absence of donkeys etc. OK so they might spend time trying to track distant rellies. Why not though? Half the world is on 23 andme ffs.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 18:36

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 18:12

And likewise I'm sure Yemenis, those who haven't been slaughtered yet that is, are perfectly valid in feeling anger at British taxpayers directly profiting to the tune of billions of pounds from their death and destruction.

Perhaps, but you're missing the point that you have failed to respond to that members point.

Appeal To Hypocrisy is a logical fallacy where a person is using it in lieu of a counter-argument....

mindutopia · 15/04/2023 18:34

I’m American (by birth annd lived there til late 20s) and have personally not experienced any sneering. But Americans are obnoxiously keen to claim they are SOMETHING (and some of them while denigrating anything that it’s AMERICAN!).

I was raised to believe I was Irish (my dad had a typically Irish surname). The family story is we’re Irish. Everyone in my part of America wants to be Irish or Italian. I did my genealogy as an adult in my 40s. No evidence of any family from Ireland. Everyone from England, no idea where the Irish name came from.

So if there is any sneering, I think it’s perhaps in this context, and also about how quite a few Americans (again I speak as an American) are quite anti anything that isn’t red white and blue American, yet are keen to claim a European ancestry.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 18:34

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 18:17

Are you angry at American/ Canadian/ South African supporters of the UDA and UVF?

To say nothing of their Scottish supporters and even members. Case of least said the better maybe.

Why wouldn’t that member be angry at Loyalist terrorist groups too?!

You've no reason to presume what you did. From what I can gather, they're a GB resident so naturally PSF/PIRA will be their main focus.

Anyone who supports an illegal terrorist group is in the wrong. I doubt there are American, Canadian and South African supporters of any of the Loyalist terrorist groups. In fact, I'd be amazed if they've heard of them!

The reason why a lot of people in North America and South Africa know of PSF/PIRA is because the Provos built up an international presence deliberately. Often in order to acquire funding and/or weapons. Aside from the international media coverage of their atrocities, obviously.

The Loyalists didn't try this, IIRC.

Also, Whataboutery and Appeal To Hypocrisy are logical fallacies as well. AKA errors in logic and reasoning.

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 18:17

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/04/2023 15:52

I'm not aware of any sneering.

I was (and probably still am) very angry at the American supporters of the IRA though. They were not living in the midst of a serious terrorist bombing campaign that claimed many innocent lives.

Are you angry at American/ Canadian/ South African supporters of the UDA and UVF?

To say nothing of their Scottish supporters and even members. Case of least said the better maybe.

TrishM80 · 15/04/2023 18:12

DownNative · 15/04/2023 14:56

But you're attempting to use the Tu Quoque Fallacy or the appeal to hypocrisy. Fallacies are errors I reasoning and logic.

Relying on that is not really a valid argument.

I'll add that the US Government also didn't take a favourable attitude to NORAID. In short, that poster is perfectly valid in feeling anger at ignorant East Coast Americans for funding PSF/PIRA through NORAID.

Myself even more so since they were helping give them the means to destroy my country, land and people.

EC US ignorant attitudes also was a factor that enabled PSF/PIRA to fight on once we'd defeated them in their insurgent phrase by 1974. With that help and Libya's, PSF/PIRA turned into a cell structure which was also eventually defeated.

And likewise I'm sure Yemenis, those who haven't been slaughtered yet that is, are perfectly valid in feeling anger at British taxpayers directly profiting to the tune of billions of pounds from their death and destruction.