Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 22:23

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:14

No, you didn't understand my post at all and are getting angry on the basis of something I never said.

My point was that it's strange to me how an American president would go out of his way to emphasise his 'Irishness' even though his ancestry is very distant, and mixed with other nationalities. Whereas a British PM of recent Indian heritage would be very unlikely to do anything similar. Just like the several Australian PM's of recent British heritage do not emphasise their 'Britishness', to give another example. It seems like one of those things which is peculiar to America and Americans.

That was my point. But if you're determined to be offended there's not much I can do.

My point is I'm sure most Indians wouldn't give a flying fuck if Rishi went to India and said that, in fact they'd be quite happy and probably feel quite proud about it. Even if you think it's strange.

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 22:22

people are different and use concepts differently

OK. I have one Welsh grandfather, who moved to England as a teen.
Welsh people would not be tolerant of my declaring myself Welsh.

Another of my grandparents was full Romany.
I ain't a gypsy, as any Romany traveller could tell in under 30 seconds.

I had a Scottish great-grandmother.
Scots would correct me in short order if I said I was Scottish.

The Scottish great-grandmother had a French parent.
Any French person would give me the "are you okay?" look if I told them I was French.

I'd suggest that "people use concepts differently" means "Americans have decided to use the concept of nationality in a different way from everyone else".

And that the actual natives of the identities you have hijacked appear understanding & welcoming to you because your actual nationality - American - represents the world's richest & most powerful entity. People are wary of crossing you, especially your President.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:20

Even though most Irish-Americans are descended NOT from Catholics, but from the Protestants.

Didn't many of these identify as Scottish or Ulster Scot rather than Irish?

DownNative · 15/04/2023 22:18

Pallisers · 14/04/2023 16:39

America is a country of immigrants. There is a lot of pain in that fact. It wasn't all "america looks nice, lets move there and be americans" For many many people in the past they left family, friends, traditions, cultures and never saw them again. They were economic immigrants or fleeing pogroms or famines or war etc. It is any surprise that those immigrants would try to remember and honour their traditions?

Yeah, americans say "I'm italian" they don't actually mean they are Italian. They mean "we follow some Italian traditions, do the seven fishes on xmas eve, have pasta at every big occasion, will some day plan a trip to Italy to see where our great grandparents came from' They know they are american. They don't need brits to tell them that (despite apparently being just teenagers trying to keep up with the big older real adult countries in the world ffs)

I think Joe Biden gave the perfect opportunity for people to sneer at the Irish and at Americans - win/win. usually they have to chose.

And all that Irish americanism in politics has had a real benefit for Ireland - and for the UK. Thanks in part to american and irish american intervention, 10 years ago a civil war in the UK - that the UK seemed unable to stop and that caused untold suffering to UK subjects - ended

The United States is a country built upon immigration, sure, but that doesn’t automatically mean all of that was due to painful or difficult circumstances.

Take the Irish-American story there. The first to leave the island of Ireland were mainly Protestants from Ulster in search of better lives, especially economically motivated so jobs/new industry. These people mainly settled where agriculture could be done in the United States. They helped set the basis for the United States, were involved in the Declaration Of Independence and more US Presidents come from this group than any other. An example of that is James Buchannan who was Democratic state Assembly man, US Congress member, US minister to Russia, Secretary of State, minister to Britain and President.

Buchanan once said: “My Ulster blood is my most priceless heritage” and there is a mural in Belfast dedicated to him. It's a Loyalist/Protestant mural.

There's another mural dedicated to President George Washington in relation to these Ulster Protestants. Washington spoke of these Protestants in glowing terms: "When our friendless standards were first unfurled, who were the strangers who first mustered around our staff, and when it reeled in the fight who more brilliantly sustained it than Erin's generous sons".

The mural dedicated to him carries a quote attributed to him: "....“If defeated everywhere else, I will make my stand for liberty, among the Scots-Irish in my native Virginia."

The Catholic Irish came later to the United States and mainly settled in urban cities - Boston and New York, famously.

Yet Irish-Americans and non-Americans often think in terms of the Catholic Irish in relation to the United States. Even though most Irish-Americans are descended NOT from Catholics, but from the Protestants. And most of them not only misunderstand their own ancestry, but misunderstand the Protestants of Northern Ireland. The Irish Times article I posted a page or two back shows they "thought the Protestants were devils".

America's Irish Protestants are known as the invisible Irish and this is largely due to the idea that to be Irish you had to be Catholic. A dangerous equation.

https://religionnews.com/2014/03/17/irish-americans-religion-politics/

Likewise, it was dangerous equating Catholicism with Nationalism/Republicanism. See, these ideas were rooted in bigotry which the late John Hume recognised:

"Catholics of all shades of political thought are expected to band together under the unconstructive banner of Nationalism. This dangerous equation of Nationalism and Catholicism has simply contributed to the postponement of the emergence of normal politics in the area..."

My point is that in the United States there has built up a mythology of what Irishness is, especially basing it on Catholicism. And that Americans tend to believe anyone who left the island of Ireland for the United States did so due to the Famine, for example. The "coffin ships" is another recurring story which Irish-America has told over and over again, but this gives the impression this was normal for the people of the time. Historians have cast doubt on this aspect of the Transatlantic migration and noted that the stories of other Irish migrations have been ignored in popular culture - i.e., those to Great Britain and Australia as well as New Zealand. Details of a book dealing with this aspect of history can be found here:

https://www.irishcentral.com/opinion/others/irish-famine-coffin-ships

Joe Biden himself comes from this Irish-American background that's rooted in Catholicism. He even referred to the aforementioned "coffin ships" which historians have cast doubt on. Biden clearly ascribes to the problematic concept that to be Irish you had to be Catholic. This goes some way to explaining his comfortable relationship with Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA. It explains his clear discomfort at being in Northern Ireland - contrast that with how he behaved in the Republic of Ireland which is still largely Catholic, albeit less than in the past.

Irish historian, Liam Kennedy (from Tipperary, ROI) and Emeritus Professor Of Economic History at Queen's University of Belfast reminds us that:

"The stridently nationalistic manifestations of 'Irishness' in recent decades belong in the main to the Catholic Irish of America rather than to Irish-Americans generally, and even then only to a minority within that subset of the Irish Diaspora....a majority of the descendants of Irish immigrants to the USA were of Protestant origin and cannot be assumed to share the same sentiments and world view. Of those of Catholic Irish descent, most are not militant Irish Nationalists and some had crossed over to other faiths or none."

The long and short of it is that the stories Irish-Americans tell themselves each generation of the island of Ireland is "a melange of partial truths, selective recollection and special pleading". Especially Catholic Irish of America.

All of which we can observe in Joe Biden's behaviour, especially this week. Unlike Bill Clinton in the 1990s, Biden cannot credibly act as a mediator in relationships between Northern Ireland's divided people, between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland as well as between Great Britain and the Republic.

To end, the poster above seems pretty confused, especially in their last paragraph. For one thing, the United Kingdom definitely did NOT have a "civil war" "ten years ago"!

For another, what we had in Northern Ireland was NOT a civil war. It was a criminal terrorist campaign of murder, intimidation, punishment beatings. My family and I lived through it - our experience of the Troubles does not match that from actual war zones such as WW2, Gulf War and so on. It's ignorance and/or gaslighting to suggest otherwise. A quick look at the statistics is instructive - fewer than 4,000 people died during the Troubles.

In over a year in Ukraine, the Russian instigated war has claimed the lives of over 100,000 people. And it will claim many more this year.

The conditions could not be more stark! Of course, it suits Republican and Loyalist terrorists to claim it was a war. But we could largely go about our normal lives - people went to work and school as normal.

Normal life of any description is not possible in Ukraine.

And what truly paved the way towards the Belfast Agreement was the defeat of the Provisional I.R.A and Provisional Sinn Féin. A story largely ignored, especially as the UK Government wanted to offer a "golden bridge" to them.

The takeaway from this is that the stories of Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland along with Great Britain is far more complex than many will acknowledge.

Definitely bears very little relation to the ideas too many Irish-Americans hold to this day.

How bizarre is it that Biden's mother refused to sleep in a bed Queen Elizabeth II once slept in?!

People in modern day Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland simply do not think like this.....

St. Patrick's Day Graph: Irish in America are Protestant, not Catholic

Most Irish in America aren't Catholic. And they're split evenly between political parties.

https://religionnews.com/2014/03/17/irish-americans-religion-politics

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:17

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:07

Well I've lived most of my life in Ireland, and I don't recall meeting anyone who struggles to understand what a third-, fourth-, fifth- generation Irish American means when they call themselves Irish. The Irish President, the Oireachtas, the various celebrities and crowds meeting Biden all seem to be coping fine.

They're hardly going to roll their eyes at him, are they? Though no doubt many will when the cameras aren't rolling.

Whatever any of them may think of Biden, they know what he's talking about. They echo his language themselves. His conception of Irishness is well understood. Diaspora is taken pretty seriously in Irish politics.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:14

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 22:06

I think I understood it pretty well ... Imagine Rishi Sunak going on about how 'Indian' or maybe 'Kenyan' he feels.

I'm guessing even though I'm a third generation Kiwi with Indian ethnicity you'd sneer at me for feeling "Indian" too if I went back to India? So yeah that does make me feel quite angry actually. Just like another thread on here saying that someone isn't Pakistani because they werent born there. I can't believe so many of the batshit comments on here, some people should really feel embarrassed for themselves.

No, you didn't understand my post at all and are getting angry on the basis of something I never said.

My point was that it's strange to me how an American president would go out of his way to emphasise his 'Irishness' even though his ancestry is very distant, and mixed with other nationalities. Whereas a British PM of recent Indian heritage would be very unlikely to do anything similar. Just like the several Australian PM's of recent British heritage do not emphasise their 'Britishness', to give another example. It seems like one of those things which is peculiar to America and Americans.

That was my point. But if you're determined to be offended there's not much I can do.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:07

Well I've lived most of my life in Ireland, and I don't recall meeting anyone who struggles to understand what a third-, fourth-, fifth- generation Irish American means when they call themselves Irish. The Irish President, the Oireachtas, the various celebrities and crowds meeting Biden all seem to be coping fine.

They're hardly going to roll their eyes at him, are they? Though no doubt many will when the cameras aren't rolling.

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 22:06

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 21:56

It must be you who is 'angry' as you seem to have completely misunderstood my post.

I think I understood it pretty well ... Imagine Rishi Sunak going on about how 'Indian' or maybe 'Kenyan' he feels.

I'm guessing even though I'm a third generation Kiwi with Indian ethnicity you'd sneer at me for feeling "Indian" too if I went back to India? So yeah that does make me feel quite angry actually. Just like another thread on here saying that someone isn't Pakistani because they werent born there. I can't believe so many of the batshit comments on here, some people should really feel embarrassed for themselves.

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:03

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 21:42

In America yes. But in Ireland, no they don't. That's just not true.

I'm fairly widely travelled, and in any country I've been in except America, if you say you're 'Irish', or 'Italian' or 'Swedish' or whatever, it is understood only one way. That you are from that country. Nobody would think 'Obviously when you say you're Irish what you really mean is that some of your ancestors left Ireland over a century ago.' That meaning is specific to Americans.

And sure, people can use terms whatever way they wish, provided they're prepared to accept that people might totally misunderstand what they are saying and feel a bit annoyed at their ignorance of cultural and linguistic norms outside their own country.

Well I've lived most of my life in Ireland, and I don't recall meeting anyone who struggles to understand what a third-, fourth-, fifth- generation Irish American means when they call themselves Irish. The Irish President, the Oireachtas, the various celebrities and crowds meeting Biden all seem to be coping fine.

I too have travelled widely. You learn that people are different and use concepts differently. French views of nationality are different from British, Irish, American. In every culture you'll have people who can't make that leap to realising concepts aren't fixed and stable. But mostly, mingling, listening and reflecting sort that out.

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 21:58

This thread reinforces the English stereotype - You think this is only English?!

I promise you, the rest of the world doesn't go around declaring their nationality based on a selected sample of their forebears.

The only other times something similar happens, is where a nationality has been forcibly subsumed by an aggressor and they're trying hard to hold on to their cultural (and, usually, religious) identity. It's notable that these groups don't cherry-pick from mixed ancestry; they marry in-group and deplore signs of watering down.

not much has changed from colonial times - When you're the ones telling Italians that Italian doesn't necessarily mean from Italy, you might want a little rethink about who's behaving like a colonist.

they don't have a history to be proud of - 🤣🤣🤣 for fuck's sake!

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 21:56

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 21:54

Let me take a wild guess and assume you're not Indian ... Actually Indians celebrated Rishi becoming Prime Minister all over the world, you may or may not be aware but the term "Indian" is very broad, different languages, religions etc. Yet they came together to celebrate the achievement of "one of their own". Think about that for a moment, it's actually quite special. If that makes you angry then you should probably think about why that is.

It must be you who is 'angry' as you seem to have completely misunderstood my post.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 21:55

Startwithamimosa · 15/04/2023 21:45

Well said! This thread reinforces the English stereotype of thinking they're superior to everyone else, not much has changed from colonial times. Also because they don't have a history to be proud of and people don't want to identify with being English it's hit a nerve. People think of English as pompous and unfriendly, whereas Irish, Scottish and Welsh are friendly and charming and they don't like it at all. Rude amd ignorant beyond belief to say who can and can't identify with their heritage.

The English don't have a history to be proud of, I think you'll find that is the British and we weren't the only ones that colonised countries. I think stereotypes are abound on this thread as the make up of British people is really diverse and yet people don't want to hear that. Equally, unfortunately, racism is alive and kicking in all countries unfortunately very much including Ireland especially in comparison to their European counterparts. As was said before no one is particularly sneering, it is more bewilderment.

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 21:54

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 19:51

And he's not just any American, is he? He's the President.

Imagine Rishi Sunak going on about how 'Indian' or maybe 'Kenyan' he feels. Yet he has recent Indian ancestry.

Let me take a wild guess and assume you're not Indian ... Actually Indians celebrated Rishi becoming Prime Minister all over the world, you may or may not be aware but the term "Indian" is very broad, different languages, religions etc. Yet they came together to celebrate the achievement of "one of their own". Think about that for a moment, it's actually quite special. If that makes you angry then you should probably think about why that is.

HamBone · 15/04/2023 21:45

It may be understood that way in America, but there's a vast world outside America where the whole idea just seems odd.

Thats exactly what I mean, @IcedPurple, IME, Americans who call themselves Irish rather than Irish American genuinely don’t realize how weird it sounds to the rest of the world.

One of my American friends refers to himself as Italian as he had Italian great-grandparents. He’s visited Italy once and doesn’t have citizenship.

OTOH, I have a Peruvian friend whose Italian grandparents emigrated to Peru and so his family has both Italian and Peruvian passports. They just refer to themselves as Peruvian here in the US.

It’s two different ways of looking at heritage-where you were brought up vs. your ancestry, I suppose.

Startwithamimosa · 15/04/2023 21:45

OverCCCs · 15/04/2023 16:43

100% agreed! The attitudes of cultural superiority shown on this thread are shocking. I would have expected to see them 20 years ago, but I thought that in 2023 most people in Britain were informed and cosmopolitan enough to be able to appreciate cultural relativism.

The UK way of defining one’s identity is merely a social construct and inherently not the only correct way to do so. Hence, as previous posters have pointed out, how many Americans self-identify today based on complicated historical factors, or how some countries assign citizenship differently from the UK system, are not “weird” or “daft” or “wrong.”

So many of you sound incredibly insecure, reacting defensively and hostilely to a practice that doesn’t align with yours out of—what? Insecurity? A desire to feel superior? 🙄

I’m starting to wish that basic anthropology and sociology concepts were taught better in schools, because there is really no excuse other than ignorance and close-mindedness for calling a country’s benign self-identification patterns “stupid.”

Well said! This thread reinforces the English stereotype of thinking they're superior to everyone else, not much has changed from colonial times. Also because they don't have a history to be proud of and people don't want to identify with being English it's hit a nerve. People think of English as pompous and unfriendly, whereas Irish, Scottish and Welsh are friendly and charming and they don't like it at all. Rude amd ignorant beyond belief to say who can and can't identify with their heritage.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 21:42

belleager · 15/04/2023 21:36

In America and Ireland, people do understand this usage. It's okay for others not to be familiar with it, but why should the people concerned not use the terms the way they want to?

There's no point in laying down the law about it meaning only one thing. (I know you haven't done this yourself). That's obviously not true!

In America yes. But in Ireland, no they don't. That's just not true.

I'm fairly widely travelled, and in any country I've been in except America, if you say you're 'Irish', or 'Italian' or 'Swedish' or whatever, it is understood only one way. That you are from that country. Nobody would think 'Obviously when you say you're Irish what you really mean is that some of your ancestors left Ireland over a century ago.' That meaning is specific to Americans.

And sure, people can use terms whatever way they wish, provided they're prepared to accept that people might totally misunderstand what they are saying and feel a bit annoyed at their ignorance of cultural and linguistic norms outside their own country.

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 21:36

@HamBone, I appreciate your tolerance and understanding.

I've never fully recovered from the shock of an American customer subjecting me to a long and extremely aggressive rant about nobody speaking English - in Switzerland, where everybody speaks at least 2 languages, often 4 or 5 - and my (bog standard, no regional accent) English being hard to understand, why couldn't I speak properly?

Add in many subsequent doozers from Americans while travelling the world, demonstrating that foreign travel had done nothing to expand their geographic knowledge or historical awareness, and I decided to completely ignore all such crap for the sake of my sanity. I wouldn't say I'm sneering so much as dismissing 🤷🏼‍♀️

belleager · 15/04/2023 21:36

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 21:32

But it's not 'widely understood' that being 'Irish' means some of your great grandparents came from there, but you have never lived there yourself and would not qualify for citizenship. It may be understood that way in America, but there's a vast world outside America where the whole idea just seems odd.

In America and Ireland, people do understand this usage. It's okay for others not to be familiar with it, but why should the people concerned not use the terms the way they want to?

There's no point in laying down the law about it meaning only one thing. (I know you haven't done this yourself). That's obviously not true!

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 21:32

belleager · 15/04/2023 21:29

I am Irish" means you're FROM IRELAND

That's one of several meanings. Others are widely understood and recognised.

But it's not 'widely understood' that being 'Irish' means some of your great grandparents came from there, but you have never lived there yourself and would not qualify for citizenship. It may be understood that way in America, but there's a vast world outside America where the whole idea just seems odd.

belleager · 15/04/2023 21:29

I am Irish" means you're FROM IRELAND

That's one of several meanings. Others are widely understood and recognised.

HamBone · 15/04/2023 21:28

@GarlicGrace Tbh, I don’t attribute it to a U.S.-centric view of the world, it’s ignorance and not being well-travelled.
People aren’t being deliberately obtuse, they just don’t know. 🤷

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 21:24

FurAndFeathers · 15/04/2023 20:59

You’re genuinely suggesting that Americans don’t realise that the term Irish has any other meaning than Irish American?

it genuinely doesn’t occur to them them that Irish might actually mean Irish?!?
and you think that’s reasonable? 😂

yep I’m afraid I’m sneering at that @Anonymous48 😂

Yep, and I'm fed up of US-centric justifications. I've also seen & heard loads of Americans being clueless that Spanish is the native language of a country called Spain: they think it's unique to Mexicans & Puerto Ricans 😂 Exactly the same with English being the native language of England. And let's not think about the fact that Georgia is a European country as well as an American state!

"I am Irish" means you're FROM IRELAND. When you insist it also means American with some Irish ancestry, you're displaying your American supremacist perspective which, not surprisingly, gets everyone else's back up.

HamBone · 15/04/2023 21:24

FurAndFeathers · 15/04/2023 20:59

You’re genuinely suggesting that Americans don’t realise that the term Irish has any other meaning than Irish American?

it genuinely doesn’t occur to them them that Irish might actually mean Irish?!?
and you think that’s reasonable? 😂

yep I’m afraid I’m sneering at that @Anonymous48 😂

@FurAndFeathers Having lived in the US for over a decade and married to an American, my perception is that SOME Americans are unaware of the linguistic difference in other parts of the world. Of course they know that saying you’re “Italian” can mean that you’re an Italian citizen and live in Italy, but they don’t realize that calling themselves “Italian”
(when they’re actually Americans with distant Italian heritage) can be confusing to other people.

CordyLines · 15/04/2023 21:20

British culture abroad is not generally something to be that proud of. So a low profile is best in the circumstances.

belleager · 15/04/2023 21:16

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 20:59

So in the unlikely event that Americans voted in an ethnically Indian president, would they be happy for him to go to Delhi, and address the parliament saying how he felt 'at home' in India? And refer to Indians as 'us'? Just like Biden did in Ireland?

Somehow I doubt it.

Not everyone was happy when Obama did that in Kenya. I'd imagine any Indian president would face racism, unfortunately. But being American does not require Americans to detach themselves from their wider heritage.

I really don't know what the response would be if Sunak spoke this way - I can't think of any parallel in British politics, but maybe I'm missing something.