Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
DownNative · 16/04/2023 01:52

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 00:04

That is not really it though.

The British and French did most of the genocide of the Natives.

The land was populated by (mainly) Europeans fleeing unreast, famine, religious intolerence etc in Europe. They were turbulent times.

There was a war of Independance against Britan. but that was inly the 13 colonies. The rest belonged to France, California was Mexican and Texas was ?? I cannot remember.

After the War if Independance there were 13 seperate colonies, with different political and religious beliefs ready and willing to go to war against each other. For example New Jersey and New York had cannons trained on each over the river.

Some wise poeple saw a potiential Europe and decided to try and unify.

It took ages.

But at the tine of the war of Independance there really was not a United States. Not by a long short. Most were still loyal to overseas Kings or religious faiths.

America as it is now took a few hundred years.

I think!

The United States of America is 247 years old this year!

So, it didn't take a few hundred years for the US to become what it is now. The US pretty much took the form we know it today before the 20th Century even dawned!

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?
Whenharrymetsmelly · 16/04/2023 01:40

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 22:52

This thread is so sad, the lack of tolerance of other cultures is astonishing.
In America, people will often say "I am Irish, I am Italian, I am Polish", whatever, as a way of identifying themselves. They are speaking about how they have been brought up. It means they have been brought up with Irish, Polish, Italian culture. I do not know why people cannot understand this? They know they are American, everybody knows that they are American.

To say that someone should dismiss the culture and identity which they have been brought up with because it confuses some people in England is absoutley ridiculous.
Americans, Irish etc clearly understand what it means. We are not offended by it.

I agree. It's certainly bringing out that air of superiority and British doing what they've always done, telling other people how they should think and feel. They've been doing that forever ... going into other countries and imposing their views ... why would they stop now. This thread has been quite disturbing to read, although I suppose it's not really very surprising

DownNative · 16/04/2023 01:37

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 00:22

Think of in regional terms.

So - Americans will say Irish American, Italian American etc.

In England we would say Northerner, Scouse, etc.

Andf if you are not from there but grandmother was you may have a glow about it.

That would be a better frame for the conversation.

That doesn't work because the Americans are referring to national identifiers of countries outwith the United States.

In the UK, we have regional identifiers as well, but this is not equivalent to the Irish-American example.

This example would be closer - English/Scottish/Welsh/Northern Irish and British.

Even then, we're simply mixing a regional identity (English/Scottish/Welsh/Northern Irish) with a national one (British).

The Americans aren't doing this.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 01:12

Qbish · 14/04/2023 16:56

Specifically, Democrat Presidents bang on about being Irish.

The Irish American vote not as significant now in the States.

Hispanic and Asian are where it is at! 😄

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 00:38

@Goldenbear actually all the English people I know irl are lovely and I have some great friends from England.

My comment says SOME people from England are confused by this. I am hopeful that this is a very small minority of people.

I hope this clears it up for you.

HamBone · 16/04/2023 00:27

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 22:06

I think I understood it pretty well ... Imagine Rishi Sunak going on about how 'Indian' or maybe 'Kenyan' he feels.

I'm guessing even though I'm a third generation Kiwi with Indian ethnicity you'd sneer at me for feeling "Indian" too if I went back to India? So yeah that does make me feel quite angry actually. Just like another thread on here saying that someone isn't Pakistani because they werent born there. I can't believe so many of the batshit comments on here, some people should really feel embarrassed for themselves.

@Mamaneedsadrink Slightly off-topic, but I was really surprised to learn from some neighbors that India doesn’t allow dual citizenship so if they want to apply for American citizenship, they would have to surrender their Indian passports! The reverse is true for their American-born children.

So I’m guessing that Rishi Sunak’s parents may no longer have Indian citizenship, which is rather sad if they had to make that hard choice.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 00:22

Smartiepants79 · 14/04/2023 16:15

It’s this.
My grandparents come from Scotland, I don’t claim to be Scottish.
My DH grandparents came from Poland in the 1930s. Not even his Dad would claim to be anything other than English. Cos that was where he was born and lived his whole life.
Americans do sometimes seem to struggle just being American. Some of them seem to need to have some other kind of ancestry.

Think of in regional terms.

So - Americans will say Irish American, Italian American etc.

In England we would say Northerner, Scouse, etc.

Andf if you are not from there but grandmother was you may have a glow about it.

That would be a better frame for the conversation.

missinglalaland · 16/04/2023 00:10

As a previous poster said, “Scots-Irish” settlers were heavily involved in taming the frontier. Their stereo type in the US is too be a bit rough and tumble. Our gun culture traces back to their macho, never back-down, brass necked self reliance.
Despite three hundred years of separation you can look at the DUP and look at a red-state Republican and see some commonalities, even without squinting too hard.
There is about 200 years separating the waves of Scots-Irish immigration and Irish Catholic immigration to America. Despite being from the same island, they are quite different culturally, at least in America. The Catholic/Protestant line is an easy one to draw, but the differences feel more cultural than religious.

A bit off topic, but you certainly can't lump American Catholics together. Irish vs Italian vs German are all distinct in outlook. I can remember my Irish Catholic Aunt complaining about my Austrian Catholic Grandmother's ways, commenting thay she was typical St Luis Catholic. (St Luis being known for its large German population.)

It's a minefield. In multicultural societies, it only works, when we give everyone the benefit of the doubt and interpret their words and actions in the most generous way possible. It's too easy to be offended, and too tempting to seek to be offended as a means for bolstering one's own identity against the foil of a supposed oppressor.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 00:04

DuesExMachina · 14/04/2023 16:01

America is a complex country- built on the slaves of Africans and the genocide of Native Americans.

When you put it like that, it makes sense that many Americans want to align themselves with somewhere else.

That is not really it though.

The British and French did most of the genocide of the Natives.

The land was populated by (mainly) Europeans fleeing unreast, famine, religious intolerence etc in Europe. They were turbulent times.

There was a war of Independance against Britan. but that was inly the 13 colonies. The rest belonged to France, California was Mexican and Texas was ?? I cannot remember.

After the War if Independance there were 13 seperate colonies, with different political and religious beliefs ready and willing to go to war against each other. For example New Jersey and New York had cannons trained on each over the river.

Some wise poeple saw a potiential Europe and decided to try and unify.

It took ages.

But at the tine of the war of Independance there really was not a United States. Not by a long short. Most were still loyal to overseas Kings or religious faiths.

America as it is now took a few hundred years.

I think!

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 23:56

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 22:52

This thread is so sad, the lack of tolerance of other cultures is astonishing.
In America, people will often say "I am Irish, I am Italian, I am Polish", whatever, as a way of identifying themselves. They are speaking about how they have been brought up. It means they have been brought up with Irish, Polish, Italian culture. I do not know why people cannot understand this? They know they are American, everybody knows that they are American.

To say that someone should dismiss the culture and identity which they have been brought up with because it confuses some people in England is absoutley ridiculous.
Americans, Irish etc clearly understand what it means. We are not offended by it.

Who are the 'etc'? Who exactly are 'English' people in your mind as you obviously have some very set ideas about who qualifies to be the evil English! I am married to a Jewish Man with an Irish surname and my DC have the very Irish sounding surname, we all make up the intolerant 'English' you speak of!

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 23:51

Yes I agree, really informative!

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 23:46

Quality posts, @DownNative. Thank you for making the effort.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 23:12

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:42

Interesting. So the 'Scots Irish' term was used as a way to distinguish themselves from Catholic Irish immigrants?

In a sense, yes, because they had a different cultural perspective - the proximity of Scotland to Ulster is an important factor in this. And they took this to the New World. The stereotype, and it IS a stereotype, is that Protestants were industrious, practical whilst the Catholics were creative storytellers. That was the mindset for a long time despite the fact those roles could be reversed. Hence, different identity markers such as Scots-Irish and Catholic Irish.

Even so, migration between Ulster and Scotland had clearly been occurring for centuries before any Scots-Irish identity label.

Before the United States, Ulster itself was a melting pot and long before the Plantation too. To modern eyes, the seas are a "natural barrier", but for most of human history they were viewed as connectors between places. We can still see this today in the UK, Portugal & Madiera and even in the United States - the sea connects territories and people.

Identity has never been fixed. Modern identities is not really what our ancestors would have understood themselves through. Identification with tribe was far more the norm.

Katyrosebug · 15/04/2023 22:53

Years ago me and an ex were in Amsterdam for the weekend, we made friends with 2 Americans, they dec

Evanna13 · 15/04/2023 22:52

This thread is so sad, the lack of tolerance of other cultures is astonishing.
In America, people will often say "I am Irish, I am Italian, I am Polish", whatever, as a way of identifying themselves. They are speaking about how they have been brought up. It means they have been brought up with Irish, Polish, Italian culture. I do not know why people cannot understand this? They know they are American, everybody knows that they are American.

To say that someone should dismiss the culture and identity which they have been brought up with because it confuses some people in England is absoutley ridiculous.
Americans, Irish etc clearly understand what it means. We are not offended by it.

Katyrosebug · 15/04/2023 22:52

Years ago

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 22:46

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:20

Even though most Irish-Americans are descended NOT from Catholics, but from the Protestants.

Didn't many of these identify as Scottish or Ulster Scot rather than Irish?

Used to be Scots-Irish in the Appalachian region. But I think Ulster Scots is the preferred term now. Lots of those wild west frontiers men we grew up reading about were of Ulster Scots origin. Like Davy Crockett , Kit Carson and Jim Bowie.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:42

DownNative · 15/04/2023 22:35

No, Scots-Irish is what they called themselves in the US, but only from the time Catholic Irish emigration began. Before that, they referred to themselves as Irish though not in the same vein as the Catholics did.

Ulster-Scot is a much, much later term which is beginning to be replaced by Ulster-British.

Interesting. So the 'Scots Irish' term was used as a way to distinguish themselves from Catholic Irish immigrants?

DownNative · 15/04/2023 22:35

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:20

Even though most Irish-Americans are descended NOT from Catholics, but from the Protestants.

Didn't many of these identify as Scottish or Ulster Scot rather than Irish?

No, Scots-Irish is what they called themselves in the US, but only from the time Catholic Irish emigration began. Before that, they referred to themselves as Irish though not in the same vein as the Catholics did.

Ulster-Scot is a much, much later term which is beginning to be replaced by Ulster-British.

DownNative · 15/04/2023 22:32

Startwithamimosa · 15/04/2023 21:45

Well said! This thread reinforces the English stereotype of thinking they're superior to everyone else, not much has changed from colonial times. Also because they don't have a history to be proud of and people don't want to identify with being English it's hit a nerve. People think of English as pompous and unfriendly, whereas Irish, Scottish and Welsh are friendly and charming and they don't like it at all. Rude amd ignorant beyond belief to say who can and can't identify with their heritage.

The stereotyping of the English, Scottish, Welsh and Irish in your post is breathtaking in its irony/ignorance!

And I note you didn't even mention the Northern Irish!

Fact is, all these groups are very, very similar to each other. There's a reason we can all move throughout the Common Travel Area without any bother! They all have very much the same plus and minus points, you know!

Those not from our part may not fully appreciate or understand it. But, crucially, we do!

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:31

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:27

In this instance, I really think it is.

Do you know of any other country where people would refer to someone with very distant ancestry as being 'Irish' or 'Italian' or whatever? Not hyphenated Irish or Italian, just plain Irish or Italian? That doesn't happen even in the other 'new world' countries.

Yes, this usage may be specific to America (and to those in dialogue with Americans, especially amongst their diaspora).

But concepts of nationality vary from place to place. There's no one standard.

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:29

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:25

Sure, they'll pander to him and other influential 'Irish' Americans as it's good business.

But Irish people themselves certainly do not refer to people whose great grandparents left a country as being 'from' that country. That is a uniquely American thing.

Irish people understand the concept as Irish Americans use it about themselves - not least because many have relatives in Biden's position. So it's not just the influential Irish-Americans, though obviously you'd make a fuss of a President. Lots of ordinary Irish Americans come home (as they would often put it) to reconnect too.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:27

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:25

Not really. Concepts of nationality vary across time and place. It's not just America vs the rest.

In this instance, I really think it is.

Do you know of any other country where people would refer to someone with very distant ancestry as being 'Irish' or 'Italian' or whatever? Not hyphenated Irish or Italian, just plain Irish or Italian? That doesn't happen even in the other 'new world' countries.

IcedPurple · 15/04/2023 22:25

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:17

Whatever any of them may think of Biden, they know what he's talking about. They echo his language themselves. His conception of Irishness is well understood. Diaspora is taken pretty seriously in Irish politics.

Sure, they'll pander to him and other influential 'Irish' Americans as it's good business.

But Irish people themselves certainly do not refer to people whose great grandparents left a country as being 'from' that country. That is a uniquely American thing.

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:25

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 22:22

people are different and use concepts differently

OK. I have one Welsh grandfather, who moved to England as a teen.
Welsh people would not be tolerant of my declaring myself Welsh.

Another of my grandparents was full Romany.
I ain't a gypsy, as any Romany traveller could tell in under 30 seconds.

I had a Scottish great-grandmother.
Scots would correct me in short order if I said I was Scottish.

The Scottish great-grandmother had a French parent.
Any French person would give me the "are you okay?" look if I told them I was French.

I'd suggest that "people use concepts differently" means "Americans have decided to use the concept of nationality in a different way from everyone else".

And that the actual natives of the identities you have hijacked appear understanding & welcoming to you because your actual nationality - American - represents the world's richest & most powerful entity. People are wary of crossing you, especially your President.

Not really. Concepts of nationality vary across time and place. It's not just America vs the rest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread