Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
MrsMikeDrop · 16/04/2023 08:42

GarlicGrace · 16/04/2023 08:32

Is this more to do with family ties? - Good lord, no!

It's about falsely/imaginatively/sentimentally claiming a nationality which is not yours.

OK, so how long before Harry's kids (or grandkids, great grandkids etc) can't "claim" their history? So even if your Grandfather is the King, you're American? What's the criteria to be accepted? Genuinely interested to see what people think about this.

GarlicGrace · 16/04/2023 08:32

Is this more to do with family ties? - Good lord, no!

It's about falsely/imaginatively/sentimentally claiming a nationality which is not yours.

MrsMikeDrop · 16/04/2023 08:32

AAAAABBBBBCCCCC · 16/04/2023 08:24

My grandparents are Irish but I wouldn’t ever claim to be. It’s just possibly a bit strange to claim to be from
a country when you haven’t ever stepped foot in it!

So why does the same logic not work with people of colour. You could have a fourth generation black person living in the USA and they are still referred to as African American. Or with grandparents who are black (not necessarily African) but their grandchildren are still called AA. And most of them have never been to Africa, either. It's bizarre.

Exactly (and sadly many won't have any idea where they are from as it cannot be traced back).

IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 08:30

AAAAABBBBBCCCCC · 16/04/2023 08:24

My grandparents are Irish but I wouldn’t ever claim to be. It’s just possibly a bit strange to claim to be from
a country when you haven’t ever stepped foot in it!

So why does the same logic not work with people of colour. You could have a fourth generation black person living in the USA and they are still referred to as African American. Or with grandparents who are black (not necessarily African) but their grandchildren are still called AA. And most of them have never been to Africa, either. It's bizarre.

They may call themselves 'African American', but I've never heard them describe themselves as simply 'African', unless of course they are of recent African descent.

I don't think it's the idea of people calling themselves 'Italian American' or 'Irish American' that bothers people here, even if sometimes the links are quite tenuous. It's more the idea of someone like Biden, whose link to Ireland is through great grandparents he never met, going around calling himself just plain 'Irish' that seems ridiculous to some.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 16/04/2023 08:27

Is this more to do with family ties and why people seem to be struggling with this? I know my cousins (well) back to fourth or fifth generations as we have regular family events and the family connection has always been very important and carried through with each generation. My grandparents siblings and their fanilies are in different parts of the world and we all keep contact. I know lots of people like this in RL, particularly immigrant communities.

Then there people who don't even know their first or second cousins, and (especially on mumsnet!) can barely stand their MIL, have NC with one of their siblings and don't want their step kids around if their partner isn't there etc etc so for these people it's not really surprising that they think this way. Apart from their nuclear family, the rest of the family is basically non-existent (and generally speaking it's a white people thing)

GarlicGrace · 16/04/2023 08:27

they aren't really brought up with that culture. Instead they have an American culture with some elements of whatever culture they have inherited

One of my many pointless lockdown obsessions was Italian cookery discussions. Often, you'd get someone coming in with "You're all wrong. THIS is how the dish should be made! How do I know? I'm Italian, and my Nonna taught me." Everyone would fawn over the authentic Italian cook, begging for more.

30 posts and one hour later, someone else turns up: "Hey, Italiana, you're American Italian I guess? Because that is NOT how you make this dish! I know Americans like it that way, but no-one in Italy would put [ingredient] into it or serve it the way you said."

Actually, I can see why I enjoyed them so much 😂

AAAAABBBBBCCCCC · 16/04/2023 08:24

My grandparents are Irish but I wouldn’t ever claim to be. It’s just possibly a bit strange to claim to be from
a country when you haven’t ever stepped foot in it!

So why does the same logic not work with people of colour. You could have a fourth generation black person living in the USA and they are still referred to as African American. Or with grandparents who are black (not necessarily African) but their grandchildren are still called AA. And most of them have never been to Africa, either. It's bizarre.

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 08:23

Zonder · 16/04/2023 08:11

In America, people will often say "I am Irish, I am Italian, I am Polish", whatever, as a way of identifying themselves. They are speaking about how they have been brought up. It means they have been brought up with Irish, Polish, Italian culture. I do not know why people cannot understand this?

Except in my experience they aren't really brought up with that culture. Instead they have an American culture with some elements of whatever culture they have inherited. This is similar to the concept of "3rd culture kids".

The Americans I have met like this hark back to relatives who died before they were born and whose culture is greatly diluted, keeping just a few odd foods or traditions.

I watched a YouTube video recently of an Italian lady living in NYC visiting 'Little Italy' and trying to find Italian-speakers in the Italian restaurants and delis. She found one or two who were born in Italy but that was about it. The rest were American people describing themselves as Italian because their ancestors migrated in the 19th century.

Zonder · 16/04/2023 08:11

In America, people will often say "I am Irish, I am Italian, I am Polish", whatever, as a way of identifying themselves. They are speaking about how they have been brought up. It means they have been brought up with Irish, Polish, Italian culture. I do not know why people cannot understand this?

Except in my experience they aren't really brought up with that culture. Instead they have an American culture with some elements of whatever culture they have inherited. This is similar to the concept of "3rd culture kids".

The Americans I have met like this hark back to relatives who died before they were born and whose culture is greatly diluted, keeping just a few odd foods or traditions.

IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 07:53

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 23:46

Quality posts, @DownNative. Thank you for making the effort.

I agree. I've learned a lot from @DownNative's posts and will read the link later on.

GaryLurcher19 · 16/04/2023 04:42

Whenharrymetsmelly · 16/04/2023 01:40

I agree. It's certainly bringing out that air of superiority and British doing what they've always done, telling other people how they should think and feel. They've been doing that forever ... going into other countries and imposing their views ... why would they stop now. This thread has been quite disturbing to read, although I suppose it's not really very surprising

They haven't been brought up with any such cultures though, have they? They've been brought up American. Nowt wrong with that but it isn't the same.

I'm yet to see this 'air of superiority' that we Brits are supposed to have. I assume you mean disagreement. If you think disagreement equals superiority, then you need help.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 04:36

In the case of Italy, though, anyone with an Italian parentisautomatically considered to be Italian, under the jus sanguinis rule.

@Oriunda Poland works this way as well. Country of birth is not relevant if your parent is a Polish citizen.

GarlicGrace · 16/04/2023 04:02

Creepyrosemary · 16/04/2023 03:50

It's funny that they're never from Wales.

True, that 🤣

But there are pockets of Argentina & Brazil - that I know of; there must be more - where Welsh is still spoken and people use old versions of Welsh national dress with various local adjustments. They have festivals featuring strange line-dances that are based on whatever dances were fashionable in 17th century Wales.

Apparently there's deep animosity between the various 'Welsh' communities.

People be weird Confused

Creepyrosemary · 16/04/2023 03:50

It's funny that they're never from Wales.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 03:29

DownNative · 16/04/2023 01:52

The United States of America is 247 years old this year!

So, it didn't take a few hundred years for the US to become what it is now. The US pretty much took the form we know it today before the 20th Century even dawned!

Well, the Dutch West India company established the New Netherland Colony in 1624.

It was present day New York , New Jersey, Connecticut and parts of Long Island. The British took it over in 1664.

Listen, I am not trying to shout anything down but I am saying that the America we know today, the United States, with home rule and a federal government took quite a while from the first European arrivals.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 03:12

barmycatmum · 15/04/2023 18:37

I’m an American, and I also lived in Germany for years, and the one thing I can add to this discussion is: we are a very young, naive country. When I moved back from Germany, I had people asking if I was a “communist” since I had lived in Germany. Just incredible ignorance.

many people here have not been out of the country - ever- in their entire lives.

we don’t have the kind of history you all do- we think a building is “old” if it was built in the 1800’s!

So all of our ancestors (except Native Americans) came over from somewhere almost within our memory. Maybe a few generations removed, but it’s still the blink of an eye when compared to the history in the UK and elsewhere.

“No Irish Need Apply” was a sign in many shops- just to bring up the Irish thing, Irish immigrants were treated very badly -
so within the melting pot of the USA, we still have these areas where people were handed down the idea that they are Irish, or they are Polish, or they are Russian, etc. because that’s how they kept safe.

traditions were preserved within those groups, but they also changed over time, so it’s watered down and probably completely bizarre to someone actually from those countries - it’s a tradition from the time immigrants arrived, that has been preserved by word of mouth or communal sharing. It might be so far removed from the actual tradition, that it’s completely different.

People might connect very passionately with their ancestry (like Biden does) because ultimately it’s an Underdog story, and their family had to be scrappy and wily and f*cking survive by any means.

Or there are also those who are snobby as hell about their lineage, because we had “old families” especially in Boston and New York, families with old money forming our version of aristocracy.

I can see how ridiculous it is to other countries - but when you’re a mixed mutt in a country with no roots here, one has to try to form an identity, and learning about our ancestors is the way many of us do that.

however. I really wish more Americans would travel and would learn other languages. It is so embarrassing .. the ignorance.

but at the same time, that I say that is a bit classist - many cannot afford to travel, and can’t afford education. So they take their learning from their family “roots,” I suppose.

thanks for being patient with us; America is basically the equivalent of a pre-teen child 😂🥳

bloody hell -

"thanks for being patient with us".

Get off your knees...

Busybutbored · 16/04/2023 02:57

If you have an Italian grandparent, you aren't 1/4 Italian either. You just have an Italian relative

Erm @Curseofthenation do you know how genetics and maths work?? I hope this makes it to the Daily Mail and this is quoted so the government starts to take education a little more seriously 🤣

Oriunda · 16/04/2023 02:22

Curseofthenation · 14/04/2023 17:01

There's nothing wrong with saying that you have Irish ancestors. It doesn't make you Irish.

If you have an Italian grandparent, you aren't 1/4 Italian either. You just have an Italian relative.

No one will judge an American for simply saying 'my ancestors come from Ireland'.

In the case of Italy, though, anyone with an Italian parent is automatically considered to be Italian, under the jus sanguinis rule. My DS, despite having been born in the UK, is Italian in the eyes of the authorities there (I got severely told off at passport control once for not having obtained his Italian ID card; since remedied). Having an Italian grandparent, or even a relative even further back, gives one the right to obtain Italian citizenship easily. Hence why so many Americans of Italian heritage call themselves Italian Americans and actually are, because many of them obtain Italian citizenship.

DownNative · 16/04/2023 02:18

Goldenbear · 16/04/2023 02:03

Absolutely, I've learnt more from you than I ever did on the topic on Irish History on my 'A' level history course in the mid 90s! You sound very knowledgeable DownNative.

I've quite a library of books on Northern Ireland. Most I've read, some I haven't. The quotes I've used from Liam Kennedy is from his book, "Unhappy The Land: The Most Oppressed People Ever, The Irish?".

You might like that - academic, really, but very informative on different aspects. There's a section on Irish-Americans. Deals also with Unionist and Republican ideology - for example, the Ulster Covenant and Irish Proclamation texts are considered as examples of texting terror. Interesting stuff!

I'm always buying* *books, underlining most of them, looking for more information and then writing about them to be passed on to my future descendants so they understand the perspective of my Catholic Unionist family. Now, there's a little understood group!

DownNative · 16/04/2023 02:10

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 01:56

I really think the press are playing this like we are the jilted.

Much as we love to be snooty about Americans we purr very loudly when our Special Relationship outs us on the world stage, jump for joy when we win an Oscar, feel chosen when a US president comes to visit or makes a phone call.

We have been jilted - and we DON"T LIKE IT!

Ah, the US President is making a state visit to the UK in June.

Personally, I think Biden wrongly put pressure on the UK ahead of the Belfast Agreement 25th Anniversary. Biden clearly wanted to be in Belfast to "celebrate" It to some extent which is bizarre. It's not something to celebrate for this reason:

"The greatest injustice in the north of Ireland today is acts committed by paramilitary organisations like the IRA. The taking of human life is the greatest injustice.

Other injustices can be corrected. People can come out of prison, but people cannot come out of their graves."

  • John Hume

Northern Ireland doesn't celebrate that kind of thing. Oh, the politicians like to use it as a backslapping exercise. I find it distasteful because it's the victims of Republican and Loyalist terrorists who've missed out the most. One mention in a small paragraph in the Agreement and vital evidence destroyed which means zero chance of conviction of terrorists. So, justice denied to them which leads to a victim hierarchy.

Biden though shows he doesn't understand Northern Ireland or how delicate our structure is. Nobody really was enthusiastic, waiting for him to make a major gaffe and large crowds didn't turn out. A non-event. Biden is too partisan which isn't good optics for a US President when it comes to Northern Ireland.

But there should have been no hoopla over the 25th anniversary of the Belfast Agreement. Its not an appropriate thing to do for something like that. No-one celebrated in 1998 or the years after in NI. Its weird to do, really.

I don't see it as a jilt for the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Its more like a non-event than anything else. Certainly not close to Clinton's visit in 1995.

Goldenbear · 16/04/2023 02:04

Obviously not just from the history books but living in that context.

Goldenbear · 16/04/2023 02:03

Absolutely, I've learnt more from you than I ever did on the topic on Irish History on my 'A' level history course in the mid 90s! You sound very knowledgeable DownNative.

DownNative · 16/04/2023 01:57

GarlicGrace · 15/04/2023 23:46

Quality posts, @DownNative. Thank you for making the effort.

@GarlicGrace and @Goldenbear thank you and you're both welcome!

My views and knowledge has been shaped by decades of conflict, debate, argument and reading in Northern Ireland. I always hope people come away understanding that little bit more about Northern Ireland's people.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 01:56

I really think the press are playing this like we are the jilted.

Much as we love to be snooty about Americans we purr very loudly when our Special Relationship outs us on the world stage, jump for joy when we win an Oscar, feel chosen when a US president comes to visit or makes a phone call.

We have been jilted - and we DON"T LIKE IT!

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 01:53

DownNative · 16/04/2023 01:37

That doesn't work because the Americans are referring to national identifiers of countries outwith the United States.

In the UK, we have regional identifiers as well, but this is not equivalent to the Irish-American example.

This example would be closer - English/Scottish/Welsh/Northern Irish and British.

Even then, we're simply mixing a regional identity (English/Scottish/Welsh/Northern Irish) with a national one (British).

The Americans aren't doing this.

You are correct of course.

But in the US they are more like our regional markers than a national ident.

Everyone there is "from" somewhere. It is entirely normal to say where.