Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:27

And all that Irish americanism in politics has had a real benefit for Ireland - and for the UK. Thanks in part to american and irish american intervention, 10 years ago a civil war in the UK - that the UK seemed unable to stop and that caused untold suffering to UK subjects - ended

@Pallisers Irish Americans were sending funds and weapons to the Provisional IRA. They undoubtedly dragged out the conflict that only really ended when the IRA were exhausted enough to be forced to come to the table.

belleager · 16/04/2023 12:14

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:11

Well when Americans claim to be more Irish than the Irish, or more Scottish than the Scots, yet haven't set foot in either country for five generations and could barely place them on a map - and have the cheek to lecture the people actually living in those countries about local politics (usually from a nationalist stance after having watched too many Braveheart films or whatever), perhaps it is they who need to read up on history.

Sure - if that happens, those people should read up on history. Haven't encountered it myself but of course there are anecdotes, as on this thread.

Plenty of Irish-Americans (like Biden) have engaged much more deeply with their Irish heritage.

MMBaranova · 16/04/2023 12:12

Andrew Jackson's Irishness is a bit different from Biden's. Both have heritage from people born in Ireland, but while Biden's seems Irish Catholic on a 10/16 basis, Jackson (and Grant and Wilson and Nixon) have Scots-Irish descent. That generally means Presbyterian Scottish settlers who through the generations migrated Scotland - Ulster (generally) - America, often with an East Coast and then Mid-West migration within the US. All the genealogies of these Presidents are well documented.

I have visited both of these:

https://discovernorthernireland.com/things-to-do/us-grant-ancestral-homestead-p675741

https://www.monreaghulsterscotscentre.com

The former is Grant focused in NI and the other more general in Donegal.

US Grant Ancestral Homestead - Ballygawley

Explore the cottage of the Simpson family with close ties to Ulysses Simpson Grant, the Commander of the victorious Union troops in the American…

https://discovernorthernireland.com/things-to-do/us-grant-ancestral-homestead-p675741

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:11

phoenixrosehere · 14/04/2023 16:30

God knows. To me it’s just another thing some like to be snobby about while knowing next to nothing about U.S history.

Well when Americans claim to be more Irish than the Irish, or more Scottish than the Scots, yet haven't set foot in either country for five generations and could barely place them on a map - and have the cheek to lecture the people actually living in those countries about local politics (usually from a nationalist stance after having watched too many Braveheart films or whatever), perhaps it is they who need to read up on history.

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 12:04

belleager · 16/04/2023 11:36

It's not "factually incorrect" for Varadkar to describe Biden as the "most Irish of all the American presidents", BuddyandTinsel. Varadkar's a medic. He understands hereditary as well as most posters here. He's not counting drops of Irish blood.

He himself is a man of dual heritage, Irish and Indian. I'm sure he has thought about questions of identity. And he made the point that we can be Irish by inheritance and by choice.

Biden's engagement with his Irish roots is pretty obvious. Leo's statement was perfectly reasonable.

This is so true.
Varadkar described him as the most Irish of Irish presidents because in addition to his genetic links he lives his Irishness loud and proud. He grew up immersed in Irish culture, he has visited Ireland many times, he works hard to keep the links alive. His Irish heritage is extremely important to him. Other US politicians have played their Irishness as an electronical card but this is certainly not the case with Biden. It is clear to see how his Irish heritage has formed who he is today and how it is so important to him.

belleager · 16/04/2023 11:54

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 11:44

Biden’s engagement with his very very distant roots is pure electioneering. American style! The Irish were just the useful people. God help America putting up with this!

Any reason why someone might not genuinely want to engage with their family heritage? Or is it just Irish heritage that's not worth bothering about? Funny how many people (not presidents) come over to Ireland for the same reasons every year.

belleager · 16/04/2023 11:50

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 11:41

You're confusing facts with feelings.

Of course it's factually incorrect to suggest he is the most Irish of presidents when other presidents had much closer Irish heritage.

If you believe that someone can be Irish 'by choice' that's a feeling. Not a fact. And a daft one.

Not at all.

You're presenting your definition of Irishness as universal fact. Of course it isn't! Why would it be?

To start with, there would be people in Britain who would qualify for Irish passports with less Irish ancestry than some who don't qualify. There are some who can collect Irish passports now after Brexit because of their parents' choice - to put them on the Foreign born register. If I was born in Ireland I'm not less Irish if I had just the one Irish parent. And so on.

If your view is that proportion of irish-born ancestors is what makes you more or less Irish, that really is just your opinion. I don't see much support for it in law (Irish citizenship) or in culture (Irish identity).

TrishM80 · 16/04/2023 11:49

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 11:15

Who said he hates the UK?

The jist of what people are talking about is Biden having some Irish Great-Great Grandparents who emigrated to the US in the 19th century and he's claiming to be/feel Irish and that visiting Co. Mayo feels like "coming home" and the Taoiseach describing him as the "most Irish of all the American presidents" which is factually incorrect as just an example, President Andrew Jackson was born in the US to Irish parents who migrated to the US from Ireland a few years before he was born. It's a hell of a stretch to suggest anyone who has Irish Great-Great Grandparents is Irish in any way. Biden is an American with Irish ancestry almost 200 years back.

JFK did the same thing in 1963 eulogising about his Irishness when he had closer Irish ancestry than Biden but still Great-Grandparents so not that close. It's PR and the American sentimentality shared by descendants of Irish migrants which influences voting. To the point Bill Clinton even claimed to have Irish ancestry despite there being no evidence of it. Though Clinton did play a great role in the Good Friday Agreement and was inducted into the Irish-American hall of fame. Despite no evidence he has Irish ancestry.

Well, that far right ghoul Arlene Foster (ex-DUP) said there was "no doubt" that he was "anti-British" 😂

Plus Sammy "nature boy" Wilson, also from the DUP (which is essentially a 17th century Old Testament cult masquerading as a "political party") said he was "anti-Protestant"...... despite the inconvenient fact that Biden is married to a Protestant! 😂🤣

Someone should have asked Sammy if he or anyone from the DUP would marry a Catholic, I think we know what the answer would be!

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 11:44

Biden’s engagement with his very very distant roots is pure electioneering. American style! The Irish were just the useful people. God help America putting up with this!

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 11:41

belleager · 16/04/2023 11:36

It's not "factually incorrect" for Varadkar to describe Biden as the "most Irish of all the American presidents", BuddyandTinsel. Varadkar's a medic. He understands hereditary as well as most posters here. He's not counting drops of Irish blood.

He himself is a man of dual heritage, Irish and Indian. I'm sure he has thought about questions of identity. And he made the point that we can be Irish by inheritance and by choice.

Biden's engagement with his Irish roots is pretty obvious. Leo's statement was perfectly reasonable.

You're confusing facts with feelings.

Of course it's factually incorrect to suggest he is the most Irish of presidents when other presidents had much closer Irish heritage.

If you believe that someone can be Irish 'by choice' that's a feeling. Not a fact. And a daft one.

belleager · 16/04/2023 11:36

It's not "factually incorrect" for Varadkar to describe Biden as the "most Irish of all the American presidents", BuddyandTinsel. Varadkar's a medic. He understands hereditary as well as most posters here. He's not counting drops of Irish blood.

He himself is a man of dual heritage, Irish and Indian. I'm sure he has thought about questions of identity. And he made the point that we can be Irish by inheritance and by choice.

Biden's engagement with his Irish roots is pretty obvious. Leo's statement was perfectly reasonable.

TrishM80 · 16/04/2023 11:25

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/04/2023 22:23

My point is I'm sure most Indians wouldn't give a flying fuck if Rishi went to India and said that, in fact they'd be quite happy and probably feel quite proud about it. Even if you think it's strange.

Indeed, an Indian work colleague of mine told me that Indians are extremely proud that a person of Indian extraction such as Sunak has become UK PM (and indeed Leo Varadkar in Ireland before him). 2nd generation Indians becoming leaders of European countries was an extremely big deal for them.

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 11:15

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 10:22

This was primarily a visit to Ireland for Biden. He has Irish ancestors, which he is incredibly proud of. Because he is such a great supporter of Ireland it does not mean he hates the UK. He can love Ireland AND the UK. He has visited the UK previously and will be visiting the UK again in June. He has talked about the special relationship between USA and UK.
It can be hard for Irish people as we were treated so badly by the UK. Our land, our culture and our language were taken. The Irish famine where millions of people died and emigrated was caused by UK policies. After independence Catholics in NI were treated as second class citizens. This is something most people in the UK know very little about. They are told about the IRA, but never told about loyalist paramilitaries. The absolute vast majority of Irish people do not support the IRA and are appalled by them. They just want peace. The current peace is very fragile and recent UK politicians have been an absolute disaster.

Who said he hates the UK?

The jist of what people are talking about is Biden having some Irish Great-Great Grandparents who emigrated to the US in the 19th century and he's claiming to be/feel Irish and that visiting Co. Mayo feels like "coming home" and the Taoiseach describing him as the "most Irish of all the American presidents" which is factually incorrect as just an example, President Andrew Jackson was born in the US to Irish parents who migrated to the US from Ireland a few years before he was born. It's a hell of a stretch to suggest anyone who has Irish Great-Great Grandparents is Irish in any way. Biden is an American with Irish ancestry almost 200 years back.

JFK did the same thing in 1963 eulogising about his Irishness when he had closer Irish ancestry than Biden but still Great-Grandparents so not that close. It's PR and the American sentimentality shared by descendants of Irish migrants which influences voting. To the point Bill Clinton even claimed to have Irish ancestry despite there being no evidence of it. Though Clinton did play a great role in the Good Friday Agreement and was inducted into the Irish-American hall of fame. Despite no evidence he has Irish ancestry.

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 11:13

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 11:06

@Evanna13
For electoral reasons and checking in on ancestors pre Democrat electioneering. Honestly - what else did he actually do? Virtually nothing. He was, so people thought, going to talk to politicians about the GFA and it’s continuation. Frankly he did very little. Visits and glad handing does nothing. Except photo ops. The speech I heard was utter gibberish. He’s little understanding of anything political.

That's your opinion but I enjoyed watching his visit and I thought a lot of what he said in his visit was very meaningful.

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 11:06

@Evanna13
For electoral reasons and checking in on ancestors pre Democrat electioneering. Honestly - what else did he actually do? Virtually nothing. He was, so people thought, going to talk to politicians about the GFA and it’s continuation. Frankly he did very little. Visits and glad handing does nothing. Except photo ops. The speech I heard was utter gibberish. He’s little understanding of anything political.

TrishM80 · 16/04/2023 10:58

postapesto · 15/04/2023 17:57

Because they are culturally appropriating from others.

What difference does it make to you?

DublinFemale · 16/04/2023 10:53

In the times JB family left Ireland, Irish culture was been wiped out.

The Penal Laws were in since late 1600's. Cromwell was taking immense pleasure in slaughtering Irish people using Catholic Churches as stables.

Then we had the combination of the coffin ships and the prison ships. There is a lot of Irish diaspora going back in Australia also, that is due to the prison ships.

For anyone escaping they knew they would never see their homeland again, they were they would never see their families. When they were leaving they did not even know if anything of culture they had would still exist.

A lot of Irish immigrants decided they were keeping their Irishness, they would maintain their traditions/culture of the times, it also would have helped with the homesickness and also a common bond when they were been stigmatised against in America.

It is not hurting anyone and it gives people peace.

Some people don't like it but that's their problem.

I love JB came had a combo holiday and state visit.

He had a very personal moment with the priest in Mayo. Baby Margot stole the show at Leinster House.

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 10:22

This was primarily a visit to Ireland for Biden. He has Irish ancestors, which he is incredibly proud of. Because he is such a great supporter of Ireland it does not mean he hates the UK. He can love Ireland AND the UK. He has visited the UK previously and will be visiting the UK again in June. He has talked about the special relationship between USA and UK.
It can be hard for Irish people as we were treated so badly by the UK. Our land, our culture and our language were taken. The Irish famine where millions of people died and emigrated was caused by UK policies. After independence Catholics in NI were treated as second class citizens. This is something most people in the UK know very little about. They are told about the IRA, but never told about loyalist paramilitaries. The absolute vast majority of Irish people do not support the IRA and are appalled by them. They just want peace. The current peace is very fragile and recent UK politicians have been an absolute disaster.

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 10:05

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 08:53

Biden is playing to the Irish American voters. His garbled speech about being “Irish” is cringeworthy. He’s spend no time actually doing anything to further relationships in Ireland. It’s a publicity stunt and it’s shallow. He spent 5 mins having coffee with Richi Sunak. It’s a total sham. Italy should thank their lucky stars he hasn’t got any Italians in the family!

He actually did a lot in Ireland. He was here for 4 days with a constant schedule of visits, speechs etc...it is his longest state visit.
He had been to Ireland many times previously and his visit reinforced his ties here.

MrsMikeDrop · 16/04/2023 10:05

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 09:02

Their descendants will always be descendants of a King. Harry's children were born in England to an English Father and American Mother so are British-American living in America.

If the next few generations marry American partners and have children born in America then they're American with some British ancestry.

But not British.

Hmmm, yeah doesn't really work with British does it

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 09:02

MrsMikeDrop · 16/04/2023 08:42

OK, so how long before Harry's kids (or grandkids, great grandkids etc) can't "claim" their history? So even if your Grandfather is the King, you're American? What's the criteria to be accepted? Genuinely interested to see what people think about this.

Their descendants will always be descendants of a King. Harry's children were born in England to an English Father and American Mother so are British-American living in America.

If the next few generations marry American partners and have children born in America then they're American with some British ancestry.

But not British.

tabulahrasa · 16/04/2023 08:56

AAAAABBBBBCCCCC · 16/04/2023 08:24

My grandparents are Irish but I wouldn’t ever claim to be. It’s just possibly a bit strange to claim to be from
a country when you haven’t ever stepped foot in it!

So why does the same logic not work with people of colour. You could have a fourth generation black person living in the USA and they are still referred to as African American. Or with grandparents who are black (not necessarily African) but their grandchildren are still called AA. And most of them have never been to Africa, either. It's bizarre.

Well firstly they don’t drop the American part, so it’s not the same...

But also, it’s not a choice when society decides for you. Being black isn’t something people can opt in and out of.

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 08:53

Biden is playing to the Irish American voters. His garbled speech about being “Irish” is cringeworthy. He’s spend no time actually doing anything to further relationships in Ireland. It’s a publicity stunt and it’s shallow. He spent 5 mins having coffee with Richi Sunak. It’s a total sham. Italy should thank their lucky stars he hasn’t got any Italians in the family!

GarlicGrace · 16/04/2023 08:46

MrsMikeDrop · 16/04/2023 08:42

OK, so how long before Harry's kids (or grandkids, great grandkids etc) can't "claim" their history? So even if your Grandfather is the King, you're American? What's the criteria to be accepted? Genuinely interested to see what people think about this.

😂 I dunno. Ask their cousins.

GarlicGrace · 16/04/2023 08:43

and they are still referred to as African American

Yeah, because white Americans are scared of saying black, aren't sure whether they should refer to colour at all, and are still racist so can't help using a label that centres race/colour.

African British isn't a thing - forms have "Black British" in the optional list of ethnicities - and afaik, neither are African French, African Dutch, etc.

Of course black & brown Britons know where their heritage /ethnicity /race /colouring comes from. Of course many seek to explore it in ways that suit them. But no-one else is slapping a label on 'em and, once past their annoying "Caribbean" teenage phase (in some cases), they manage to incorporate their personal identities without needing to keep announcing it. Everybody has a heritage, all of it is mixed.

It's the eagerness to label that feels weird, coupled with creative labelling strategies.