Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
IcedPurple · 16/04/2023 15:26

belleager · 16/04/2023 12:57

With respect though - Irish-Americans aren't calling themselves British, or Welsh. Is it really for you to say that they and the people of Ireland use the term Irish? Lots of people have explained on this thread that there are strong traditions of migrant culture and diaspora linking Ireland and America and shaping language use.

If it's not in your culture, I respect that, but it in Irish and American cultures.

It is not in Irish culture.

A person from Dublin who had some great grandparents from, for example, Germany, would never describe themselves as German. They would describe themselves as Irish. Which is what they are.

postapesto · 16/04/2023 15:08

Oriunda · 16/04/2023 14:29

My son is half Italian and half English (and that English is not even half, as I'm one eighth German). Being born in the UK does not cancel out his Italian nationality. We don't even live in the UK anymore. He's entitled to think himself Italian, English or anything in between.

If he has an Italian parent, he can call hinself Italian. His grandchildren can't though.

Curseofthenation · 16/04/2023 14:34

@Oriunda I didn't say he wasn't entitled to describe himself as he wants. I just said I wouldn't in his shoes unless I actually grew up and lived in Italy.

belleager · 16/04/2023 14:33

Oriunda · 16/04/2023 14:29

My son is half Italian and half English (and that English is not even half, as I'm one eighth German). Being born in the UK does not cancel out his Italian nationality. We don't even live in the UK anymore. He's entitled to think himself Italian, English or anything in between.

Yes, nobody can tell the boy he's being insincere if he claims Italian identity. That's only for him to judge.

Oriunda · 16/04/2023 14:29

Curseofthenation · 16/04/2023 14:19

@Oriunda I can see that under Italian laws you may have the right to claim citizenship but it would still be insincere for your son to call himself Italian if he was born and raised in the UK. If I were your son then I would still say that I had Italian heritage rather than 'I am Italian'. That's just me though.

@Busybutbored Obviously I was talking about how someone describes themselves rather than their genetics. For all you know, that Italian grandparent could have a Greek grandparent and then we're really getting ourselves in a pickle, aren't we? No one is entirely from one country genetically as humans are melting pots when it comes to genes. Breaking news huh? It's silly to say that you are 1/4 Italian. To be Italian is a lot more than your genetics, that is what I am saying.

People outside of the US will think it is a bit odd to go around cherry picking fractions of your genes that relate to various countries and exclaiming 'I'm Italian!' to anyone in Rome that will listen.

My son is half Italian and half English (and that English is not even half, as I'm one eighth German). Being born in the UK does not cancel out his Italian nationality. We don't even live in the UK anymore. He's entitled to think himself Italian, English or anything in between.

belleager · 16/04/2023 14:28

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/04/2023 14:20

There's a cultural difference between the UK and US on this, obviously.
In the UK, anyone with citizenship is considered British and it's bad form to ask where someone is from. If you ask a black person in Britain where they are from, they are probably going to say "London" and get annoyed with any further probing, even if their parents were born elsewhere. The idea of a black British person being called African, unless they were actually born there and have current citizenship there, is laughable and has racist undertones. Yet in America, even black people who were imported as slaves 200 years ago and have no link with Africa whatsoever are called African American.
For white British people with a British accent, if someone asks where you're from, they mean what town did you grow up in. They'd be surprised if you came out with any family history.

Exactly. We use concepts and language differently in different cultures.

Once we put in the effort to understanding each other, instead of banging on about people being strange or wrong (because obviously we are Right), that's a great thing.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 14:26

AAAAABBBBBCCCCC · 16/04/2023 08:24

My grandparents are Irish but I wouldn’t ever claim to be. It’s just possibly a bit strange to claim to be from
a country when you haven’t ever stepped foot in it!

So why does the same logic not work with people of colour. You could have a fourth generation black person living in the USA and they are still referred to as African American. Or with grandparents who are black (not necessarily African) but their grandchildren are still called AA. And most of them have never been to Africa, either. It's bizarre.

That is due to slavery. No records were kept as to where they were originally from. The ports they departed from yes, but not their place of origin.

belleager · 16/04/2023 14:22

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 14:13

That is very deprecating to the Irish useful idiots and all that. Let's not.

Second of all - the Irish American vote is not the block it used to be. Sorry to any Irish here but actually a huge % of the Irish American vote goes Republican in this day and age. See most of the presenters on Fox News for example.

We know that! We're not idiots - thank you for that! - useful or otherwise. Biden can do his own electoral calculations, if that's all this is about.

It doesn't mean that Biden's interest, and Irish-American networks and diaspora generally, aren't a benefit to our country. The about-face from Boris Johnson on the Good Friday Agreement when Biden was elected was quite a satisfying (and important) moment.

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/04/2023 14:20

FurAndFeathers · 16/04/2023 13:27

@Greenfinch7

I’ve certainly experienced white Americans struggle to ‘categorise’ black British people! One chap insisted on calling them ‘African -American’ because he couldn’t seem to compute that black people could be simply ‘British’.

perhaps it’s symptomatic of the America obsession with heritage, but it’s certainly something Europeans find odd.

There's a cultural difference between the UK and US on this, obviously.
In the UK, anyone with citizenship is considered British and it's bad form to ask where someone is from. If you ask a black person in Britain where they are from, they are probably going to say "London" and get annoyed with any further probing, even if their parents were born elsewhere. The idea of a black British person being called African, unless they were actually born there and have current citizenship there, is laughable and has racist undertones. Yet in America, even black people who were imported as slaves 200 years ago and have no link with Africa whatsoever are called African American.
For white British people with a British accent, if someone asks where you're from, they mean what town did you grow up in. They'd be surprised if you came out with any family history.

Curseofthenation · 16/04/2023 14:19

@Oriunda I can see that under Italian laws you may have the right to claim citizenship but it would still be insincere for your son to call himself Italian if he was born and raised in the UK. If I were your son then I would still say that I had Italian heritage rather than 'I am Italian'. That's just me though.

@Busybutbored Obviously I was talking about how someone describes themselves rather than their genetics. For all you know, that Italian grandparent could have a Greek grandparent and then we're really getting ourselves in a pickle, aren't we? No one is entirely from one country genetically as humans are melting pots when it comes to genes. Breaking news huh? It's silly to say that you are 1/4 Italian. To be Italian is a lot more than your genetics, that is what I am saying.

People outside of the US will think it is a bit odd to go around cherry picking fractions of your genes that relate to various countries and exclaiming 'I'm Italian!' to anyone in Rome that will listen.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 14:18

GaryLurcher19 · 16/04/2023 04:42

They haven't been brought up with any such cultures though, have they? They've been brought up American. Nowt wrong with that but it isn't the same.

I'm yet to see this 'air of superiority' that we Brits are supposed to have. I assume you mean disagreement. If you think disagreement equals superiority, then you need help.

We are "superior" in our attitude though.

It is our way or no way. In fact without that belief we would never have had an empire.

We still think our ways are best, our way of speaking English is the correct way, our table manners are the correct ones, our social mores are the correct way, and so on.

@Whenharrymetsmelly is not wrong. Unfortunately.

4plusthehound · 16/04/2023 14:13

TizerorFizz · 16/04/2023 11:44

Biden’s engagement with his very very distant roots is pure electioneering. American style! The Irish were just the useful people. God help America putting up with this!

That is very deprecating to the Irish useful idiots and all that. Let's not.

Second of all - the Irish American vote is not the block it used to be. Sorry to any Irish here but actually a huge % of the Irish American vote goes Republican in this day and age. See most of the presenters on Fox News for example.

OliveViolet · 16/04/2023 14:00

I have always thought it strange how many Irish people get so annoyed at anyone with Irish roots mentioning it.

It doesn't seem to apply to other countries. Mostly people are proud if someone mentions their heritage.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 13:49

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 13:41

No one said that there wasn't any racism in Europe. You're trying to put words in my mouth.

No, just referring to your last paragraph in that quote:

Incidentally, many African-Americans who have moved to Europe have said how they appreciated being treated as "just Americans", with no one caring about the colour of their skin or crossing the street to avoid them.

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 13:41

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 13:19

Ah yes, because everyone knows there is no racism in Europe🙄

No one said that there wasn't any racism in Europe. You're trying to put words in my mouth.

FurAndFeathers · 16/04/2023 13:27

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:44

We're not on about people describing themselves as "Irish-American" though, it's those claiming to actually be Irish. No African-Americans are going around claiming to be actually African and telling Senegalese people how they should run their country.

Incidentally, many African-Americans who have moved to Europe have said how they appreciated being treated as "just Americans", with no one caring about the colour of their skin or crossing the street to avoid them.

@Greenfinch7

I’ve certainly experienced white Americans struggle to ‘categorise’ black British people! One chap insisted on calling them ‘African -American’ because he couldn’t seem to compute that black people could be simply ‘British’.

perhaps it’s symptomatic of the America obsession with heritage, but it’s certainly something Europeans find odd.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 13:19

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:44

We're not on about people describing themselves as "Irish-American" though, it's those claiming to actually be Irish. No African-Americans are going around claiming to be actually African and telling Senegalese people how they should run their country.

Incidentally, many African-Americans who have moved to Europe have said how they appreciated being treated as "just Americans", with no one caring about the colour of their skin or crossing the street to avoid them.

Ah yes, because everyone knows there is no racism in Europe🙄

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 16/04/2023 13:09

BuddyandTinsel · 16/04/2023 09:02

Their descendants will always be descendants of a King. Harry's children were born in England to an English Father and American Mother so are British-American living in America.

If the next few generations marry American partners and have children born in America then they're American with some British ancestry.

But not British.

Harry's daughter was born in California, wasn't she? So born in America to an English father and American mother. She is an American citizen by birth. Is it ok with everyone here if she refers to herself as British American? I know there's so much concern about "cultural appropriation" by several posters🙄

belleager · 16/04/2023 12:58

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:55

I travel a lot in America - I am Irish, born in Ireland, live in Ireland. American People tell me they too are Irish all the time. I just find that a bit odd. One fellow Irish man complemented me on my English language skills😂. He clearly knew nothing about Ireland despite claiming to be Irish!!

There are more than a few Americans who seem surprised at how well the English speak English.

There are more than a few idiots in every country and culture. Irish, American, English, Welsh, whatever. So what?

belleager · 16/04/2023 12:57

With respect though - Irish-Americans aren't calling themselves British, or Welsh. Is it really for you to say that they and the people of Ireland use the term Irish? Lots of people have explained on this thread that there are strong traditions of migrant culture and diaspora linking Ireland and America and shaping language use.

If it's not in your culture, I respect that, but it in Irish and American cultures.

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:55

I travel a lot in America - I am Irish, born in Ireland, live in Ireland. American People tell me they too are Irish all the time. I just find that a bit odd. One fellow Irish man complemented me on my English language skills😂. He clearly knew nothing about Ireland despite claiming to be Irish!!

There are more than a few Americans who seem surprised at how well the English speak English.

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:44

Greenfinch7 · 14/04/2023 17:29

Gosh, if anyone is sneering here it is not the Americans...

You folks just love sneering at us, and I admit we give you a lot of material to work with. This does seem a bit thin on the ground.

Are you brave enough to sneer at people calling themselves African American? That might be a bit objectionable.

We're not on about people describing themselves as "Irish-American" though, it's those claiming to actually be Irish. No African-Americans are going around claiming to be actually African and telling Senegalese people how they should run their country.

Incidentally, many African-Americans who have moved to Europe have said how they appreciated being treated as "just Americans", with no one caring about the colour of their skin or crossing the street to avoid them.

FurAndFeathers · 16/04/2023 12:37

Jemandthehologramsunite · 16/04/2023 12:30

The prejudice and hate on this thread is vile, it's not surprising to see why exiled people may have formed bonds when they moved to other countries if this is the attitude 100s of years later. Not very inclusive at all. I don't think Chinese/Vietnamese/Jamaican/Pakistani etc would have the same attitude if a person with a great grandparent came to visit their country, they'd probably be warm and welcoming. That in itself is quite telling.

What specifically is hateful about the post you quoted?

Evanna13 · 16/04/2023 12:35

Jemandthehologramsunite · 16/04/2023 12:30

The prejudice and hate on this thread is vile, it's not surprising to see why exiled people may have formed bonds when they moved to other countries if this is the attitude 100s of years later. Not very inclusive at all. I don't think Chinese/Vietnamese/Jamaican/Pakistani etc would have the same attitude if a person with a great grandparent came to visit their country, they'd probably be warm and welcoming. That in itself is quite telling.

Yes, the prejudice shown on this thread is absoutley disgusting to see in this day and age. I have been surprised by it as I thought I lived in a more tolerant world.

Jemandthehologramsunite · 16/04/2023 12:30

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 12:11

Well when Americans claim to be more Irish than the Irish, or more Scottish than the Scots, yet haven't set foot in either country for five generations and could barely place them on a map - and have the cheek to lecture the people actually living in those countries about local politics (usually from a nationalist stance after having watched too many Braveheart films or whatever), perhaps it is they who need to read up on history.

The prejudice and hate on this thread is vile, it's not surprising to see why exiled people may have formed bonds when they moved to other countries if this is the attitude 100s of years later. Not very inclusive at all. I don't think Chinese/Vietnamese/Jamaican/Pakistani etc would have the same attitude if a person with a great grandparent came to visit their country, they'd probably be warm and welcoming. That in itself is quite telling.