Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is there so much sneering at Americans with European ancestry?

863 replies

BrBa · 14/04/2023 15:47

I don’t understand! I identify with all my ancestors whether they came as religious refugees or early colonisers, were already indigenous to the region or brought in as slaves.

Yours
Swiss, German, Native American North, Central and South, Sephardic, Irish, South East African, Scottish, Acadian/French, and English

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
15
DownNative · 03/07/2023 11:18

Superhanz · 02/07/2023 22:06

I think a lot of Americans sympathised with the Irish people. Irish nationalists in the North were treated like second class citizens, worse than second class citizens.

The United States is a huge country. Any sympathy for the Provisional I.R.A was East Coast based in the US.

Even then, it was only a small subset of the "Irish"-American population there as the information I posted from Liam Kennedy shows.

Most US Citizens were NOT in favour of or sympathetic to the Provisionals at all. The minority on the eastern seaboard who were ended up looking like complete hypocrites after 9/11.

At any rate, US private funding of PIRA ended post-9/11 which helped the Provisionals to largely see they had no further outside funding coming in the future. Of course, Gaddafi's Libya was dealt with which was a bigger source of PIRA weaponry.

As I said, only a minority in the US supported the PIRA. Especially as the US Government made it clear that NORAID was a PIRA front and not a humanitarian one as they claimed purely to circumvent US law.

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 03/07/2023 07:17

They also came from different German-speaking countries in Europe, so don't have a single home nation to identify with. That said, I once spent a very entertaining evening at a German-American Octoberfest dinner in Texas, all sausages, beer, schuhplattler, alpenhorns, dirndl, and lederhosen. And possibly yodelling.

Florenz · 02/07/2023 22:11

You don't really hear about German-Americans very much. Not like you do the Italian-Americans, Irish-Americans etc. A lot of them changed their names and downplayed their ancestry because of the World Wars.

poetryandwine · 02/07/2023 22:07

Two months old is not my idea of a zombie. As someone who lived in America for 15 years and has a British DH I think the post by @Artstudio1 is very interesting.

Superhanz · 02/07/2023 22:06

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/04/2023 15:52

I'm not aware of any sneering.

I was (and probably still am) very angry at the American supporters of the IRA though. They were not living in the midst of a serious terrorist bombing campaign that claimed many innocent lives.

I think a lot of Americans sympathised with the Irish people. Irish nationalists in the North were treated like second class citizens, worse than second class citizens.

SquashedSquashess · 02/07/2023 21:56

ZOMBIE THREAD

Artstudio1 · 02/07/2023 21:30

I am sorry you've experienced negativity from any Americans. I am American, but my DH is Scottish, and we have lived in both the US and the UK for a long time. My guess is that there are more Americans fascinated by foreign accents vs. those (hopefully, few) sneering.

I think our obsession with our ancestry is partly built into our heritage. Many who emigrated to the US missed their homes and culture and instilled a huge sense of sentimentality and loss in their children/grandchildren/etc. through songs and poems, etc., that is still with us now, good or bad.

DownNative · 02/05/2023 15:38

To highlight the absurdity of Biden's whole "I'm Irish!" schtick and visit to the island of Ireland...he forgot the last country he visited recently. 🤦‍♂️

Child 1: "What was the last country you traveled to?"

Biden: "The last country I've traveled — I'm trying to think the last one I was in — I, I've been to 89 — I've met with 89 heads of state so far, so, uh — I'm trying to think. What was the last — Where was the last place I was? It's hard to keep track. Um, I was — "

Child 2: "Ireland!" another child yelled in reply.

Biden: "Yeah, you're right, Ireland. That's where it was. How'd you know that?"

The kid should have said China to see how he'd react to that! 🤣

That massive welcome in the Republic of Ireland appears to be easily forgettable for Ol' Joe...

DownNative · 22/04/2023 07:51

Dishwasherdisaster · 21/04/2023 00:48

I checked and am guessing the 2022 paper you mention is that by CRG Murray, but you're only quoting parts of his opinion.

The decision on the DeSouza case was being appealed when the situation was 'defused' by the UK government who changed the immigration rules for a set period, and so made it unneccessary for Emma DeDouza to renounce British citizenship (something she was not willing to do as she didn't consider herself British in the first place). The appeal was then withdrawn.

Murray also says that " the UK government ..is of the firm view that UK nationality law is consistent with its obligations under the Belfast Agreement obligation and the ECHR."
This agrees with what you say @DownNative.
However, he goes on to say that
" This conclusion is, at least, questionable, given than the cost for persons of NI of £372 to remove their underlying British citizenship constricts their ability to make and 'be accepted' in their citizenship choices."

I'm not a lawyer. I haven't a hope of explaining how exactly each word in a legal document should be properly interpreted.
But I can say that the above does not seem fair to me.
It's clear too that some lawyers agree. The outcome of the DeSouza appeal would have been interesting.

Yes, I was using that which is directly relevant to the discussion. Most of that paper was discussing the issue of EU rights for those NI citizens who want them.

Emma DeSouza is one of a handful of people who benefited from the minor change to the NDNA document.

Yes, the "the UK government ..is of the firm view that UK nationality law is consistent with its obligations under the Belfast Agreement obligation and the ECHR." Meaning they believe it is not in contravention and that meant no amendments were necessary to the British Nationality Act 1981.

While the UK Government requires a fee to be paid for renouncing British nationality, this still means the option is there. In short, its a political issue and NOT a legal issue. Therefore, the Government is correct in saying "UK nationality law is consistent with its obligations under the Belfast Agreement obligation and the ECHR."

Constructive ambiguity will always crash on the shore of law, international and domestic. Law itself fares best when it's not ambiguous. Various politicians make lots of pronouncements about the Belfast Agreement which is simply incorrect, but these are clearly intended to politicise the Belfast Agreement itself in their own favour. It's political interpretation of the Agreement rather than looking at what the Agreement truly says.

Identity, it must be said, is always in flux. Historical inaccuracies can underpin it to the point where there's no interest in changing it. Indeed, violence can push people far away from it that they take on new forms of identity.

By and large, Americans have a number of inaccuracies which underpins their concept of an Irish identity. This can be seen in a handful of articles posted over the last page.

DownNative · 22/04/2023 07:33

Whalesong · 22/04/2023 02:44

Thank you for this. I had no idea that the original judgement was overturned.
This is appalling, as not only does it go against the GFA, but it goes against the agreement of Irish Independence in 1921.
But I agree with you in essentials.

The Belfast Agreement itself has already been covered, but which provisions of the 1921 Anglo-Irish Treaty are you referring to?

Meaning the actual legal text.

Whalesong · 22/04/2023 02:44

DownNative · 20/04/2023 08:35

Emma DeSouza lost her case that you're talking about above. The Home Office still did what she wanted in order to formally end the case.

https://extra.ie/2019/10/14/news/irish-news/emma-desouza-loses-appeal-home-office

And dropped her appeal too:

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-52755553

The people of Northern Ireland are all still officially regarded as British until/unless they formally renounce their British citizenship through official channels.

But this is a very different situation from that which people informally identify themselves. This is identity, essentially. And identity is what the Belfast Agreement deals with - not nationality.

But postapesto is still wrong because such individuals view themselves as Irish, especially in a cultural sense.

Thank you for this. I had no idea that the original judgement was overturned.
This is appalling, as not only does it go against the GFA, but it goes against the agreement of Irish Independence in 1921.
But I agree with you in essentials.

Dishwasherdisaster · 21/04/2023 00:48

I checked and am guessing the 2022 paper you mention is that by CRG Murray, but you're only quoting parts of his opinion.

The decision on the DeSouza case was being appealed when the situation was 'defused' by the UK government who changed the immigration rules for a set period, and so made it unneccessary for Emma DeDouza to renounce British citizenship (something she was not willing to do as she didn't consider herself British in the first place). The appeal was then withdrawn.

Murray also says that " the UK government ..is of the firm view that UK nationality law is consistent with its obligations under the Belfast Agreement obligation and the ECHR."
This agrees with what you say @DownNative.
However, he goes on to say that
" This conclusion is, at least, questionable, given than the cost for persons of NI of £372 to remove their underlying British citizenship constricts their ability to make and 'be accepted' in their citizenship choices."

I'm not a lawyer. I haven't a hope of explaining how exactly each word in a legal document should be properly interpreted.
But I can say that the above does not seem fair to me.
It's clear too that some lawyers agree. The outcome of the DeSouza appeal would have been interesting.

DownNative · 20/04/2023 18:10

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 15:38

The two aren't the same as per above. Personal identity is informal and nationality is formal. Hence, legislation does not use nationality and citizenship interchangeably.

There's no hence. Identity is not the same as citizenship. Citizenship is formal. You quoted the Agreement as saying
"...accordingly confirm that their right to hold both British and Irish citizenship is accepted by both Governments"

Does the word 'both' lead to a bit of ambiguity? As in, could it be taken to mean you can't have Irish citizenship without British citizenship (or at least British first)? As seems to be the case now.

But then that would mean you couldn't have British citizenship without Irish either and that's not the case at all.

With respect, you're doing the same thing Emma DeSouza did in the case she lost - arguing the Agreement says what it doesn't and not taking note of what the law states.

Cambridge University published a paper in 2022 which stated the following:

"The British Nationality Act 1981 ensures that anyone born in Northern Ireland to a parent who is settled or is a British citizen automatically becomes a British citizen. It was not altered in light of the 1998 Agreement. The people of Northern Ireland can thus identify as Irish and can assert their entitlement to Irish citizenship, but if they do, they will be treated in domestic law as dual citizens unless they also take steps to renounce British citizenship."

And:

"Because the people of Northern Ireland were automatically presumed to be British citizens, this change meant that they could no longer circumvent minimum income requirements for securing the residency of family members by asserting their Irish citizenship, unless they also renounced their British citizenship."

The Upper Tribunal concluded in DeSouza's case that the Agreement "does not, in fact, involve giving the concept of self-identification the meaning for which the claimant argues".

In other words, if the Belfast Agreement was referring to nationality as DeSouza essentially argued it would have stated so explicitly. But it does not.

The part of the Belfast Agreement I quoted must be considered in its entirety and not in part.

Indeed, the case of Irish national, Lisa Smith, directly contradicts Emma DeSouza's since Smith was essentially arguing she cannot be excluded from British nationality given her parent was born in Belfast! She argued she should be automatically considered to be a dual British and Irish national. Even though she argued she was Irish and had no intention of acquiring British Nationality leading Judge Underhill to say:

"...it does not seem to me disproportionate to treat her in accordance with her chosen status as a foreign national,” Lord Justice Underhill said, adding that it would be “extraordinary” for her to have the right to freely enter the UK as a British citizen without being willing to acquire that status.
“Ms Smith cannot have it both ways. If she wishes to be treated as a British citizen she must accept the obligations that go with that status, including allegiance to the Crown, which is owed by those who are British from birth just as much as by those who acquire nationality subsequently."

Smith’s lawyer argued that this infringes on her rights as per the Belfast Agreement. But Cambridge noted that "The (Special Immigration) Commission nonetheless maintained that the obligation on someone claiming to have entitlement to British citizenship to take an oath and pledge of allegiance ‘is not inconsistent with the rights of those who wish to identify as Irish’ under the 1998 Agreement."

Theyfurther stated that "Smith’s eagerness to assert dual nationality to prevent exclusion highlights how different claimants are drawing upon very different accounts of how nationality law works in the context of Northern Ireland."

The constructive ambiguity of the Belfast Agreement meets the realities of law - on this issue, domestic.

It demonstrates how identity is often contentious and how people bind it up in a manner that suits themselves. For DeSouza, the Belfast Agreement means the UK Government has no right to automatically designate her a British citizen. For Smith, the UK Government should automatically consider her a British national with dual nationality.

Both invoked the Belfast Agreement, but both cannot be equally true. Both women lost their cases against the UK Government.

In conclusion, there is a hence. The Agreement speaks to identity, not nationality, and both Governments agree not to prohibit their respective citizens from acquiring a British, Irish or both sets of passports.

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 15:38

The two aren't the same as per above. Personal identity is informal and nationality is formal. Hence, legislation does not use nationality and citizenship interchangeably.

There's no hence. Identity is not the same as citizenship. Citizenship is formal. You quoted the Agreement as saying
"...accordingly confirm that their right to hold both British and Irish citizenship is accepted by both Governments"

Does the word 'both' lead to a bit of ambiguity? As in, could it be taken to mean you can't have Irish citizenship without British citizenship (or at least British first)? As seems to be the case now.

But then that would mean you couldn't have British citizenship without Irish either and that's not the case at all.

DownNative · 20/04/2023 15:22

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 14:52

The Agreement speaks of identity which is why the Northern Ireland census asks people about which identity or combination of they hold.

The Agreement also speaks of citizenship.
I'm sure if you consider yourself British, as you do @DownNative, then the legal text doesn’t seem problematic . But I do see Emma DeSouza's point of view I have to say. It does seem unfair. Not sure what the solution is, I'm no lawyer.

It must be remembered that Article 15 under Universal Declaration of Human Rights states "Everyone has the right to a nationality" and "No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his nationality nor denied the right to change his nationality".

Therefore, states such as the UK automatically confer nationality onto its people. It is the citizen under international law who will have to renounce a nationality they don't or no longer identify with.

Identity and nationality are separated in the Belfast Agreement here:

"....recognise the birthright of all the people of Northern Ireland to identify themselves
and be accepted as Irish or British, or both, as they may so choose, and accordingly
confirm that their right to hold both British and Irish citizenship is accepted by both
Governments and would not be affected by any future change in the status of
Northern Ireland."

The two aren't the same as per above. Personal identity is informal and nationality is formal. Hence, legislation does not use nationality and citizenship interchangeably.

Politics and politicians use them interchangeably which can cause problems when it runs into the law.

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 14:52

The Agreement speaks of identity which is why the Northern Ireland census asks people about which identity or combination of they hold.

The Agreement also speaks of citizenship.
I'm sure if you consider yourself British, as you do @DownNative, then the legal text doesn’t seem problematic . But I do see Emma DeSouza's point of view I have to say. It does seem unfair. Not sure what the solution is, I'm no lawyer.

DownNative · 20/04/2023 14:39

The above is a Home Office concession to DeSouza when they weren’t legally obliged to do so....

DownNative · 20/04/2023 14:38

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 20/04/2023 14:23

She also remains a citizen of Northern Ireland. Without being British.

Officially, DeSouza is regarded as an Irish national resident in Northern Ireland. Even though she lost her case.

This doesn't extend to anyone else who hasn't renounced their British national as automatically designated.

The Agreement speaks of identity which is why the Northern Ireland census asks people about which identity or combination of they hold.

DownNative · 20/04/2023 14:36

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 14:19

The GFA speaks of more than identity, it speaks of citizenship, which for most people is the same as nationality.

Emma de Souza, for one, objected to renouncing British citizenship because to her that was akin to saying she was once British. And she didnt accept that and in the spirit of the GFA she should be free not to accept that. It was a major issue for her so it's really not that simple.

In terms of law, it's simpler than DeSouza liked. It's widely accepted within international law that the sovereign power automatically designates nationality to its citizens.

Including those who are separatists.

DeSouza lost on a point of law. Even so, the Home Office still gave her what she wanted which doesn't apply to anyone else.

The Belfast Agreement can and should only be read in terms of what the text says. That is the basis of any Treaty or Law - domestic and international. It stands and falls based on the legal text.

Not spirit.

If that were so, other core parts of the Belfast Agreement could easily be undermined. Indeed, a spirit could undermine the concept of Sovereignty too - including the fact the Secretary Of State NI has sole power over referendums aka UK Government. So, we only go by the legal text.

Anything else is playing politics with it.

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 20/04/2023 14:23

She also remains a citizen of Northern Ireland. Without being British.

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 14:19

The GFA speaks of more than identity, it speaks of citizenship, which for most people is the same as nationality.

Emma de Souza, for one, objected to renouncing British citizenship because to her that was akin to saying she was once British. And she didnt accept that and in the spirit of the GFA she should be free not to accept that. It was a major issue for her so it's really not that simple.

DownNative · 20/04/2023 13:35

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 13:26

"Ms DeSouza criticised the UK government for its failure to bring the Good Friday Agreement into direct legislative alignment with the Northern Ireland Act" (ie the domestic legislation linked to the peace treaty).

I think she was absolutely right to criticise this. Who decided that everyone in NI was still automatically of British nationality post 1998? Because it really doesn’t seem to align with the aims of the GFA.

Regardless the Belfast Agreement doesn't say a word about nationality and only talks about identity in this respect. Much the same way it says nothing about prohibiting a hard border and certainly didn't remove a border as the references to cross-border bodies makes clear.

Irrespective of the British Nationality Act 1981, those citizens who want to officially be regarded as Irish only can simply renounce their British citizenship. In this regard, it meets the aims of the Agreement as the Government with the "sovereign power there" will accept it.

It's not really a major issue.

All sovereign powers automatically assign nationality to citizens. And everyone accepts the legitimate sovereign power of the UK Government in Northern vis a vis the Belfast Agreement itself. The text recognises the UK as having the sovereign power.

Dishwasherdisaster · 20/04/2023 13:26

"Ms DeSouza criticised the UK government for its failure to bring the Good Friday Agreement into direct legislative alignment with the Northern Ireland Act" (ie the domestic legislation linked to the peace treaty).

I think she was absolutely right to criticise this. Who decided that everyone in NI was still automatically of British nationality post 1998? Because it really doesn’t seem to align with the aims of the GFA.

DownNative · 20/04/2023 08:35

Whalesong · 19/04/2023 22:42

You are SO wrong about that. This was one of the key elements of the GFA: that people born in NI could choose whether to BE (not just identify as) British or Irish. And that isn't just reflected in the fact that half of the population has chosen never to hold a British passport. Until recently of course the other half ONLY held British passports, but that all changed with Brexit - now they're all merrily applying for Irish passports, including Ian Paisley Jr.

There was a landmark court case while the UK was still in the EU, of a woman from NI who demanded to be considered as Irish, NOT British. She had been told by the Home Office that her American husband could not live in NI with her, because they failed the stringent rules imposed by the UK on their own citizens for bringing in non-EU spouses. She was invoking the unconditional right of EU citizens to live with their spouse in an EU country OTHER THAN THEIR OWN ( because in your own country, that country's laws supersede those of the EU).

She argued in court, invoking the GFA, that although she was born in NI, as were here parents etc, they were IRISH, not British, so effectively living in another EU country to their home country. So the same rules should apply to her as if she'd been born in Ireland and later moved to NI. And she won.

From then on, the UK recognises that anyone in NI who sees themselves as purely Irish is so. This means that these people are also protected under the Withdrawal Agreement, just like any other EU citizens living in the UK before Brexit - which doesn't apply to Brits. There's a list of advantages, such as continued entitlement to EHIC (which covers more countries than the new British GHIC, which is all British citizens are entitled to).

But the main point is the principle. The very many people in NI who don't see themselves as British, only Irish, are Irish. Period.

Going back to when this was first established, in the 1920s (even though the UK didn't respect it in many ways until the GFA), this is of course the reason for the Common Travel Area between the UK and Ireland. Irish people in the UK have exactly the same right as Brits, including to vote. And vice versa. It has to be that way, because a very large proportion of the population of NI is Irish, not British.

End of History lesson :)

Emma DeSouza lost her case that you're talking about above. The Home Office still did what she wanted in order to formally end the case.

https://extra.ie/2019/10/14/news/irish-news/emma-desouza-loses-appeal-home-office

And dropped her appeal too:

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-52755553

The people of Northern Ireland are all still officially regarded as British until/unless they formally renounce their British citizenship through official channels.

But this is a very different situation from that which people informally identify themselves. This is identity, essentially. And identity is what the Belfast Agreement deals with - not nationality.

But postapesto is still wrong because such individuals view themselves as Irish, especially in a cultural sense.

'We won't be lying down anytime soon' -- Emma DeSouza loses Irish citizenship appeal against UK Home Office

'We won't be lying down anytime soon' - Emma DeSouza loses Irish citizenship appeal against UK Home Office - Extra.ie

Derry woman Emma DeSouza revealed that she has lost an appeal case taken by the UK Home Office against an immigration tribunal ruling concerning her Irish

https://extra.ie/2019/10/14/news/irish-news/emma-desouza-loses-appeal-home-office

sashh · 20/04/2023 04:27

KnittingNeedles · 15/04/2023 08:28

But again @Fairislefandango what harm is it doing? It's no skin off my nose if someone from deepest Utah decides they're Scottish.

There are lots of hobbies that people do that other people feel are daft, but if it's not causing harm to other people, just live and let live. Americans/Canadians in general ARE more interested in their ancestry. Just because you don't "get it" doesn't make them daft.

But it can lead to problems, as referenced several times above Noraid funded terrorism in the UK.

When people believe they are Scottish they think they have a stake in Scotland and in its politics, the same for anywhere else.

South Africa has the wonderful term 'salt dick' which should be more widely used.

Swipe left for the next trending thread