Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take pressure off and just cook what she wants?

140 replies

ChickenBurgersAndWaffles · 14/04/2023 14:20

DD is 8, and most likely ND.

She goes through phases where she insists she dislikes everything put on her plate, bar maybe one or two things, currently it’s everything apart from chicken burgers and waffles.

She’s spent the last few days insisting she only like chicken burgers and waffles, there’s no point arguing with her or trying to serve her anything else as she just won’t eat it.

She’s always worse when out of routine or tired or worried about something – she’s all of these things, out of routine due to easter holidays, tired from holiday club earlier in the week (that she loves but finds exhausting) and worried as she knows that next term is “transititon” term at school and she always worries about transititions before they happen, even though she’s usually fine and surprises herself by managing. DD is also going to her dads tomorrow until Sunday night and that’s another transititon even though she loves going, the thought of changing homes scares her – she came back to me after a week there on Friday hyped up and very unsettled, usually it’s EOWend for 2 nights but holidays he has a week or a few extra days.

We’ve compromised on that she can have some chocolate after eating and has to have some cucumber or raw carrot on her plate (and she sometimes eats this)

But WIBU to just stop arguing and let her have what she wants? I feel like the worst mum for not forcing her to eat properly like I normally would in these phases but I'm exhausted to.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lifedonttalktomeaboutlife · 18/04/2023 14:50

Haven’t read the full thread but take no advice from anyone with no experience of ND children. Parenting NT children is completely different.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/04/2023 14:48

It sounds like arfid or a sensory issue. To be honest I’d just go with it. Chicken burger, waffle and carrot/cucumber. You know why and can try adding other foods again in a few days. She’s obviously overwhelmed and having safe food makes things easier.

AttentionToDetal · 18/04/2023 14:38

My DS (7) is ND and dinner time has previously been a proper battleground. We sat down at a quiet time and together compiled a list of 10 simple options that would be acceptable for dinner. These included options like a bowl of non-fun cereal, sandwich etc. Plus extras after like a yoghurt/fruit/biscuit. Some days he is just not as hungry.

Things have been much calmer as we rotate through the options and he is now becoming more open to trying different things from my plate or school lunches

Just sharing what has worked (so far) for us. You can only do what you can do and my priority has been to take the stress away from the dinner table as we always ended up in the same place anyway!

JarByTheDoor · 18/04/2023 14:02

Doone21 · 18/04/2023 12:32

That's not a sound basis for evolution.

Neither is healthcare.

Are we reeeeeeally going to have this discussion? Really? Cause it gets quite unpleasant, quite quickly.

Doone21 · 18/04/2023 12:32

That's not a sound basis for evolution.

steppemum · 18/04/2023 12:30

BeBesideTheSea · 14/04/2023 14:27

If she is ND then she is trying to have something reliable and familiar that she can cling on to at this time.

This is not a hill to die on at this moment - give her what she wants, with the cucumber/ carrot on her plate too. Come back to it when she is back in her school routine in a week or so.

I agree with this.

With ND kids, you need to not try and impose the same things that work for NT kids.
The safe food makes her feel safe on days when everything feels out of control due to too many transitions.

If you know that it is just for a while, then pick your battles.
I would serve her the chicken burger with the cucumber if she will tolerate it. If she will eat pudding, don't make it a treat, but just serve it, chocolate or whatever.

By the way, for those who are sniffy about the chocolate, when a friend's dd had a very restricted diet, the nutritionist said as long as she is eating chocolate she will be fine!

Boopydoo · 18/04/2023 12:07

Doone21 · 16/04/2023 21:33

I'm not suggesting anyone is forced to eat anything. I said take it or leave it. Hungry kids eat. Eating food you don't like very much never hurt anyone. Even I can eat parsnips if the situation calls for it

You are ignoring the fact that some people don't feel hunger.

Squamata · 18/04/2023 10:46

Some safe food on her plate. Some other food in the middle of the table you can serve yourselves. Praise if she tries it.

Would she consider something like a smoothie or small cup of soup she can down with some fruit or veg in, away from mealtimes?

I was a fussy child treated with the 'like it or lump it' approach, it was horrible. It genuinely caused me emotional upset to eat food that didn't seem safe. I grew out of it eventually and I've never taken the same approach with my kids.

Tinybrother · 18/04/2023 10:38

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/04/2023 04:43

'Same fooding' (what we refer to it as in my house) is something my ARFID causes when im really stressed or super tired or in lots of pain.

Fortunately, I am an adult so I can generally just get on with it, I try to have some veg on the plate, as well as the familiar thing, but will often run out of steam before I've eaten it all.

Battles over food really don't help, despite the number of people who have never experienced ND related food issues (or even common NT ones!) insisting it does. There is a good chance that they will create massive stress around mealtimes which in turn will cause further food related and stress related problems.

Provide the familiar food.
Provide some other food.
Make sure it's not touching or off putting for any reason.
Don't do bribes or rewards or 'if you eat this then you can have that' and definitely do not do 'oh wow you tried xyz well done see it wasn't so bad'...

If there is dessert, then there is - stick it on the table at the same time it does not matter if its eaten first, middle or last. It is all food.

If there isn't, then there isn't.

Eating regular meals is the habit you want to promote. Avoiding stress is everything. You can widen the range of food someone eats if they are happy and stress free at mealtimes, but you'll NEVER do that by force with someone anxious and over threshold.

Agree with all this. And you are right about common NT food-related issues. It doesn’t help for parents of NT children to be going down the “eat it or go hungry” route either - ok the child may be able to force themselves to eat in a way that the ND child can’t but in the long run it risks creating even more issues while parents assume that they’ve solved the problem. A range of foods offered including enough “safe” ones for the child’s calorie requirements, plus some variation, works much better. One of my children (all NT) always restricts themselves to a narrow range of (fortunately fairly healthy, but extremely boring) options when tired/sad/out of routine, and this low pressure approach often results in more quantity and variety being eaten than it looked like they were going to at the start of the meal - and if it doesn’t, it doesn’t matter.

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/04/2023 04:43

'Same fooding' (what we refer to it as in my house) is something my ARFID causes when im really stressed or super tired or in lots of pain.

Fortunately, I am an adult so I can generally just get on with it, I try to have some veg on the plate, as well as the familiar thing, but will often run out of steam before I've eaten it all.

Battles over food really don't help, despite the number of people who have never experienced ND related food issues (or even common NT ones!) insisting it does. There is a good chance that they will create massive stress around mealtimes which in turn will cause further food related and stress related problems.

Provide the familiar food.
Provide some other food.
Make sure it's not touching or off putting for any reason.
Don't do bribes or rewards or 'if you eat this then you can have that' and definitely do not do 'oh wow you tried xyz well done see it wasn't so bad'...

If there is dessert, then there is - stick it on the table at the same time it does not matter if its eaten first, middle or last. It is all food.

If there isn't, then there isn't.

Eating regular meals is the habit you want to promote. Avoiding stress is everything. You can widen the range of food someone eats if they are happy and stress free at mealtimes, but you'll NEVER do that by force with someone anxious and over threshold.

Tinybrother · 18/04/2023 02:24

letsgotothebeachyay · 14/04/2023 16:29

I wonder if any mum EVER had this conversation even 50 years ago? I don't think so. Dinner was on the table, eat it or don't eat it.
I wonder if any mum on a tight budget haggles with their child over dinner?
I wonder if (not that long ago in the history of man) when the hunter returned from his hunt with a goat for example the child said "I don't wanna eat goat, can you go back and hunt me a chicken" (I can imagine the hunters response to that cheeky request!!!!

A Mum on a tight budget is more likely to restrict to food they know a their child will definitely eat, surely? Because she can’t afford to risk any waste on an “eat it or leave it” basis. Not sure you’ve thought your views on this through very thoroughly.

BashfulClam · 18/04/2023 01:18

SleepingStandingUp · 18/04/2023 00:16

But not all kids experience hunger the same. DS would choose the sensation of hunger over the sensation of putting say yoghurt or spag bol or chocolate milk into his mouth.

‘Hungry kids eat’ ha ha ha no they don’t. I’ll let you meet my husband who would rather be hungry than eat food he doesn’t like. I’ve seen him go 48 hours with no food. Starving hungry but won’t eat unless it’s something he likes.

BashfulClam · 18/04/2023 01:16

letsgotothebeachyay · 14/04/2023 16:39

God Forbid a child go hungry!
Why are people so afraid now of sending a child to be bed hungry?
Trust me they will only go to bed hungry once or twice before they get the message. Don't make loads of work for yourself or issues surrounding food, once u have dished up the dinner your job is done.

What a massive load of shite! How to say ‘I don’t understand neurodiversity’ without actually saying it and just spouting a lot of drivel. My husband had issues with food and had had all his life. I have seen him not eat for 48 hours as none of his ‘safe’ food was available. His mum took him to the Dr in desperation after forcing, cajoling, letting him go hungry..it doesn’t work like that.

SleepingStandingUp · 18/04/2023 00:16

Doone21 · 16/04/2023 21:33

I'm not suggesting anyone is forced to eat anything. I said take it or leave it. Hungry kids eat. Eating food you don't like very much never hurt anyone. Even I can eat parsnips if the situation calls for it

But not all kids experience hunger the same. DS would choose the sensation of hunger over the sensation of putting say yoghurt or spag bol or chocolate milk into his mouth.

drawingmaps · 17/04/2023 23:46

I think if she generally eats well, let her have what she wants during difficult phases. I'm an autistic adult and generally have a very wide and adventurous diet. Apart from being vegetarian for other reasons, in standard times there are maybe two or three dishes I won't eat. However, during times when I am stressed or have a lot on, my palate narrows right down. I can only manage a very few things. That's not me being picky, or difficult, it's just that when there's more than usual to process in my brain then my food has to be as same as possible. If I try to eat something that's not a safe food during that time, I will literally gag and spit it out as fast as I can.
Luckily I'm an adult now and I can adjust as necessary, keep an eye on signs that I need more vitamins and supplement or have smoothies, and it doesn't last that long. Maybe your DD is like me.

Lizzylou67 · 17/04/2023 23:33

Don’t be ridiculous . The lady clearly stated the child is a) 8 and b) likely neurodivergent. Are you aware of the sensory issues that neurodivergent people have with foods?

Lizzylou67 · 17/04/2023 23:29

I have a son with autism this part breaks my heart he actually retchs and can be sick with many foods because of their texture . Mostly I just try to cook what I know he can eat as I can’t watch him struggle with food. it’s a sensory issue and she really can’t help this xx

lifeturnsonadime · 17/04/2023 18:53

MummaN · 17/04/2023 15:45

Appreciate your concern. Perhaps my post wasn't clear for you so I will explain a bit better.

No she doesn't go hungry because she ends up eating it 9 times out of ten. This isn't me giving her a food I know she doesn't like and forcing her to eat it; it's about her trying new foods she hasn't tried before. The classic 'how do you know you don't like it if you haven't tried it'.
If I took her word for it every time I made something new she would never try new foods.
I do not force her to eat it but I let her know that if she doesn't want it, that's fine. No pressure.
The result for us is that she eats it and the next time it is served I've had no fuss.

Ah so she hasn't really got an issue with eating then?

Certainly no neurodiversity or sensory issues like the OP's child.

MummaN · 17/04/2023 15:55

Nanny0gg · 16/04/2023 21:36

So if she tries it, and doesn't like it, she goes hungry because she has to eat the same as everyone else?

@Nanny0gg
No if she tries it she gets the same reward of fuss for being brave and trying something new but I am not going to tell her at the start that she can have something else or she wouldn't try anything.
Thus far she hasn't disliked something new so I haven't had to think up an alternative.
My advise was purely about taking the pressure off, instead of saying "you have to eat it and you're not getting down from the table until you have" we say "you don't have to eat anything but it is dinner time and everyone is sitting at the table so you can sit at the table too".
It works for us.

MummaN · 17/04/2023 15:45

Appreciate your concern. Perhaps my post wasn't clear for you so I will explain a bit better.

No she doesn't go hungry because she ends up eating it 9 times out of ten. This isn't me giving her a food I know she doesn't like and forcing her to eat it; it's about her trying new foods she hasn't tried before. The classic 'how do you know you don't like it if you haven't tried it'.
If I took her word for it every time I made something new she would never try new foods.
I do not force her to eat it but I let her know that if she doesn't want it, that's fine. No pressure.
The result for us is that she eats it and the next time it is served I've had no fuss.

lifeturnsonadime · 17/04/2023 11:03

@MummaN

So you force your child to sit at a table and watch you eat and make her go hungry if she doesn't comply?

Wow.

Your poor child.

Nanny0gg · 16/04/2023 22:41

Doone21 · 16/04/2023 21:39

Utter bollocks I had that as a child. Dinner was served. I ate what I wanted, left what I didn't. If I left it no alternative offered.
I did same raising my kid. I ended up being a fussy eater but he didn't. It literally makes no difference. You obviously had a totally different experience in that you were forced. Which as I'll repeat again, I'm not recommending.

I have one fussy eater and two not.

So doing the same doesn't mean you'll get the result you expect.

Every child is different. I offered various foods but in the end, once their preferences were known then they were given food they enjoyed

Thelastofbus · 16/04/2023 21:40

Just offer her the choice of whatever you are eating that evening. If she doesn't eat it; she goes hungry.

I think this is such shit advice.

Doone21 · 16/04/2023 21:39

Utter bollocks I had that as a child. Dinner was served. I ate what I wanted, left what I didn't. If I left it no alternative offered.
I did same raising my kid. I ended up being a fussy eater but he didn't. It literally makes no difference. You obviously had a totally different experience in that you were forced. Which as I'll repeat again, I'm not recommending.

Nanny0gg · 16/04/2023 21:36

MummaN · 16/04/2023 18:28

It is your responsibility to provide different food experiences. Yes it is exhausting but so rewarding when it pays off.
I have a picky eater myself and she will scream and shout at the table when it isn't something she has had before. We have got in to the routine of telling her she doesn't have to eat it but she has to sit at the table with everyone else while they eat it. We tell her there won't be anything else served for tea so she can leave it if she wants but everyone is having the same and there won't be anything else. Then we ignore any of her negative behaviour. She always ends up trying it and even if she doesn't eat it all, she is rewarded for the good behaviour with lots of fuss.
You can also take the edge off her having to try something new by providing one 'safe food' on her plate - but she is only going to try new things if you give her the opportunities.
If you have Instagram, follow mamaknowsnutrition - she does picky eater tips regularly and I have found it really helpful.

So if she tries it, and doesn't like it, she goes hungry because she has to eat the same as everyone else?