Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?

262 replies

Hedwigharlot · 14/04/2023 13:42

The cartoon depicts him dressed as a leprechaun. It's like a depiction of Irish people from a Punch Magazine in the 19th century. Who thought it was appropriate? And why are the British media working themselves up into such a jealous frenzy over Biden coming to Ireland? Very poor behaviour.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Cathy31 · 14/04/2023 18:45

@Quveas Ireland was an island a century ago, and will probably be a reunified island nation in my lifetime. Partition is a current, and recent, and almost certainly temporary, feature of Irish political geography. Geography without history is an easy route to erasing colonialism and thereby naturalising colonial structures.

TitsHerbert · 14/04/2023 18:44

It's not satire. It's offensive

Cathy31 · 14/04/2023 18:39

@DandyMandy who are 'our own people'? Only those born in Ireland? Only those whose parents were born in Ireland? Both? What if your granny was born in Ireland, but had to emigrate to Liverpool because of the poverty that came of British colonial policy. Wouldn't it be another kick in the teeth if her children and grandchildren couldn't enjoy the benefits of Irishness, just because she suffered the hardships? Irish people know too well the painful, irrevocable losses that go with emigration. If we don't want people coming to Ireland, let's ask what's made them risk those losses, and how we, now a rich nation, can make their countries of origin better places to live.

@DisquietintheRanks It's not quantifiable, not police-able, but either people are Irish and enjoying the silly/stereotypical parts of our culture in good faith or they're not - they're being anti-Irish. But as a guide, if you're writing for the Times, stay well away from attempts to satirise Irish people, or Black people, or racism generally. You'll probably get it wrong and make an eejit of yourself. Likewise if you're surrounded by English people who are finding your leprechaun impression hilarious, or you're using the n word (even in quotes, even just singing along to a song) in a room full of white people, you're probably a long way from wit/satire/ innocent fun, and well on the way to racism.

belleager · 14/04/2023 18:37

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 18:13

So roughly how much Irish blood does a person have to have before they're allowed to adopt Irish stereotypes without it being offensive?

I wouldn't reduce it to blood. Genuine cultural identification with Ireland, in such spirit that Leprechauns are adopted in fun or affection, is one thing.

But even if this cartoonist was Irish - the London Times is not. So it should not have printed a cartoon drawing on a long tradition of anti-Irish snobbery in the British media.

Quveas · 14/04/2023 18:27

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 18:14

So we should allow our very small island to be overwhelmed with others? Yeah right. Irish people are too nice for their own good. We need to put our own people first.

Whilst you are reading up on your history, you might want to throw in some geography. Regrettably, Ireland is not an island. And isn't that entirely the point? Although I suspect its going right over your head.

Quveas · 14/04/2023 18:19

KettrickenSmiled · 14/04/2023 15:57

It's like a depiction of Irish people from a Punch Magazine in the 19th century.

Yeah, because British/English people never take the piss out of themselves by resorting to stereotypes ... Hmm

If people want to take the piss out of themselves, fine. Have at it. Stereotype other people and that isn't OK.

Ponoka7 · 14/04/2023 18:16

@Goldenbear , read up on the equality act, which explains how people are grouped via shared geographical location, culture, ethnicity, religion etc.

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 18:14

Cathy31 · 14/04/2023 18:08

@DandyMandy Irish migrants were 'illegals' in many countries not so long ago. We (Irish) should be welcoming immigrants with open arms, the way we would have liked it when we were the (often illegal, sometimes 'criminal') immigrants.

So we should allow our very small island to be overwhelmed with others? Yeah right. Irish people are too nice for their own good. We need to put our own people first.

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 18:13

mathanxiety · 14/04/2023 17:39

So it's OK to depict Irish people as leprechauns if you're not Irish? Because it looks to you as if the Irish have embraced the leprechaun thing?

If your answer is yes, then you've got a lot of education ahead of you.

Begin with a look at rap and dig deep into why certain terms are OK for some to use and not OK for others

So roughly how much Irish blood does a person have to have before they're allowed to adopt Irish stereotypes without it being offensive?

Cathy31 · 14/04/2023 18:08

@DandyMandy Irish migrants were 'illegals' in many countries not so long ago. We (Irish) should be welcoming immigrants with open arms, the way we would have liked it when we were the (often illegal, sometimes 'criminal') immigrants.

belleager · 14/04/2023 17:48

ACynicalDad · 14/04/2023 17:11

He's not much more Irish than English and the Biden name comes from Sussex, he's a plonker about it and he's trying to play the arbiter when he's clearly biased against the UK. The joke is on him, not the Irish. I'd want him to loose if Trump wasn't his likely opponent.

There was no "British-American" culture for Biden to grow up in, though - he wasn't a WASP. He could choose which of his ancestors to identify with anyway. He doesn't deny having English ancestors. He says that they aren't important to his sense of identity.

He is also, obviously, a republican. He is President of the United States. Ireland and America have intertwined histories of revolution, independence from Britain, and republicanism. Britain will celebrate a royal heritage with the coronation of Charles III and that's the right of British subjects, obviously. But other heritages may appeal more to other people.

This isn't about DNA. It's about the values his family chose to maintain and that he chose to embrace. His life story is pretty consistent. He has a bit of a rose-tinted view of the country (or maybe he's just a diplomatic and courteous guest). But he is not much different from thousands of Irish-Americans who come "home" every year. They are real people reflecting on real experiences of life in the Irish diaspora.

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 17:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

mathanxiety · 14/04/2023 17:39

GreyGreyGrey · 14/04/2023 17:05

Here is a photo of Americans dressed as Leprechauns on St Patrick’s to identify with their Irish-ness.
Here is a photo of Irish football fans using the Leprechaun trope.
Here is a photo of a General Mills breakfast cereal using a Leprechaun to promote its Lucky Charms breakfast cereal that you find “at the end of the rainbow.”

This stuff is tiresome, but to single out the Times for picking up on s well known trope that Biden has dove into head first seems a bit of a stretch.

So it's OK to depict Irish people as leprechauns if you're not Irish? Because it looks to you as if the Irish have embraced the leprechaun thing?

If your answer is yes, then you've got a lot of education ahead of you.

Begin with a look at rap and dig deep into why certain terms are OK for some to use and not OK for others

mathanxiety · 14/04/2023 17:36

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 16:35

The amount of Britsplaining on here is sickening. The oppressors speaking on behalf of the oppressed. Nothing ever changes.

THIS ^^

Jewel1968 · 14/04/2023 17:35

I am Irish living in UK with children (father is not Irish) who don't have a strong connection to their Irish heritage. However, I think if I was forced to leave Ireland because of the Great Hunger I might have made more of an effort to ensure my kids were connected to their Irish heritage. I do think the Great Hunger has had a long lasting impact on the subsequent generations and still reverberates today.

I don't know a whole lot about Biden but I know the part of Ireland very well his family left for the US. I am sure he is thinking of vote share.

mathanxiety · 14/04/2023 17:35

RobinStrike · 14/04/2023 15:34

I agree with @Notegoat . It combines his hammy fake Irishness/ anti English sentiment while over there when it the DUP was super sensitive to his claims to be and support Ireland. None of it helped and was seen over here to be almost as bad as the cartoon is perceived in Ireland.

God forbid anyone should offend the delicate sensibilities of the DUP, who are in danger of being relegated to second largest political party in NI, en route to the dustbin of history.

All the combined Unionist parties are currently outnumbered by Sinn Fein, Alliance, and the SDLP.

FourTeaFallOut · 14/04/2023 17:34

Wait, I can't work this out? How many generations do you have to go back before you move from being a victim of British oppression to being a British coloniser? Would I be getting reparations or putting my hand in my pocket? Does it depend on how jealous or not jealous I am?

RocketPanda · 14/04/2023 17:32

@DandyMandy The 'illegals' as you call them have lived and worked in Ireland and passed the citizenship test, the same as most other countries. They enhance our country, nobody wanted to come here for years because we were a struggling new independent state.

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 17:32

stayathomer · 14/04/2023 17:31

This website itself is extremely anti-Irish yet it never gets called out on here.
I actually think the opposite, I was always worried I shouldn’t be commenting on a uk website as I’m Irish but have never faced anyone commenting on the fact that when I make comparisons I use Irish references (eg I’ll talk about pennys not Primark or quote the euro). The people who get offended by leprechauns etc are people who’ll get offended no matter what, sure as Irish we capitalise on oirishness when it suits us- look at our touristy shops, at guinesses etc

You sound extremely self hating so I'm not going to waste my time writing a longer reply.

stayathomer · 14/04/2023 17:31

This website itself is extremely anti-Irish yet it never gets called out on here.
I actually think the opposite, I was always worried I shouldn’t be commenting on a uk website as I’m Irish but have never faced anyone commenting on the fact that when I make comparisons I use Irish references (eg I’ll talk about pennys not Primark or quote the euro). The people who get offended by leprechauns etc are people who’ll get offended no matter what, sure as Irish we capitalise on oirishness when it suits us- look at our touristy shops, at guinesses etc

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 17:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/04/2023 17:26

My Irish family are all for us claiming our citizenship rights (I have it automatically through my father as he was Irish) but I can pass it on to my children too. They think we’d be mad not too.

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 17:26

Jujujuly · 14/04/2023 17:17

Why not? Many other countries have similar rules.

Ireland has a completely different outlook from Britain in that it recognises and values its huge diaspora. Emigration has been a part of Irish history for hundreds of years.

Because as far as I'm concerned Irish citizenship is handed out like sweets. It's too easy to get even illegals are being made citizens.

RocketPanda · 14/04/2023 17:26

Also worth noting that the Irish language will never recover from the penal laws. Words, phrases, customs are lost forever. As a ruthless oppressor Britain has done so much harm to Ireland. And this is something that must be acknowledged. That right now a lot of generational British prospered by starving Irish people to death.
A British newspaper printing such a cartoon would be like an American one mocking slavery.

mathanxiety · 14/04/2023 17:26

Random789 · 14/04/2023 14:21

Unrealistic as opposed to what - the British stereotype of the Irish?

What stereotype is this? I'm old enough to rember the hideously racist depictions of Irish people as unintelligent. But do we really still see this?I mean, is it really still a cultural phenomenon that extends beyond a very small number of out-and-out racist dinosaurs?

Very clearly it is. Have you seen the cartoon?

Do you not sense the seething jealousy?

Loving the suggestions of some really obscure meta humour here Hmm

Yeah, that's what this cartoon is.