Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?

262 replies

Hedwigharlot · 14/04/2023 13:42

The cartoon depicts him dressed as a leprechaun. It's like a depiction of Irish people from a Punch Magazine in the 19th century. Who thought it was appropriate? And why are the British media working themselves up into such a jealous frenzy over Biden coming to Ireland? Very poor behaviour.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Anyotherdude · 15/04/2023 09:30

And I’m out!

Anyotherdude · 15/04/2023 09:28

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 08:40

Why are you parading your ignorance? He is directly 5/8 Irish (10 of his 16 great-great-grandparents were Irish). He grew up in Scranton, a deeply Irish-American town (more than 25% of the population have Irish ancestry) with strong Irish cultural roots including Irish labour politics (the Molly Maguires). Being 'Irish' in the USA is a highly specific diasporic identity. He has visited Ireland many many times, and why should a crowd of ignorant British people take it on themselves to proclaim what his identity is or isn't?

JFC - we are ignorant if we cast Joe Biden as American, not Irish, yet an 83-year old woman is made out to be racist for asking a British-born woman of African extraction where she “really” comes from?
You can’t have it both ways: either your identity is where you were born and raised, or it isn’t.
Claiming to “be” Irish simply because your community, far from Ireland, has developed their own tradition, based on Irish-ness (like the St. Patrick’s day shenanigans, which, until turned by those ex-pat communities into a celebration, consisted of other ex-pat and internal Irish communities of just wearing shamrock and attending Mass on the Saint’s day) does NOT make you Irish.
Nobody is taking the p1$$ out of the Irish here - just the US President.

Runssometimes · 15/04/2023 09:03

Cannot believe 55% of people think YABU OP. Am born and bred Irish and living in UK since my twenties. Of course the cartoon is offensive.

Much of the UK Biden coverage has been depressing. But unfortunately anti Irish sentiment is alive and well. I don’t get the bomb, turty tree and a turd or potato ‘jokes’ to my face anymore but I do get told that I can’t possibly be offended at things that I very much am offended by - phrases like beyond the pale or having a paddy. And plenty of examples of that hard of thinking in evidence here in this thread. Ireland will always be my true home and where I belong but I was very happy here in the UK, a country which has given me so much and which I in turn have contributed much to but I’m feeling increasingly uncomfortable here. DH who’s also Irish, we moved here together also feels it.

Some insightful comments here, and wanted to share an article from our own Irish Times on the theme https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/2023/04/14/his-hatred-of-the-uk-has-hardly-been-concealed-how-british-press-covered-bidens-visit/

Biden can be as Irish as he likes, not in the least offended, thing is we don’t get to decide how other people feel about their own heritage. And other people don’t get to tell me what I can and cannot be offended about mine.

‘His hatred of the UK has hardly been concealed’: how British press covered Biden’s visit

Leprechaun cartoons and president’s coronation ‘snub’ feature amid scornful commentaries

https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/2023/04/14/his-hatred-of-the-uk-has-hardly-been-concealed-how-british-press-covered-bidens-visit/

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 08:54

GreyGreyGrey · 14/04/2023 17:05

Here is a photo of Americans dressed as Leprechauns on St Patrick’s to identify with their Irish-ness.
Here is a photo of Irish football fans using the Leprechaun trope.
Here is a photo of a General Mills breakfast cereal using a Leprechaun to promote its Lucky Charms breakfast cereal that you find “at the end of the rainbow.”

This stuff is tiresome, but to single out the Times for picking up on s well known trope that Biden has dove into head first seems a bit of a stretch.

And here are some anti-Irish cartoons. There's a long long history of anti-Irish racism in British cartoons, usually focussed on racial hierarchies and 'simianising' Irish people to indicate they're sub-human. Given the long history of British oppression, including in Northern Ireland, it's hardly surprising that Irish people are sensitive about British cartoons that stereotype Irish identity.

To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?
To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?
To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?
whatchaos · 15/04/2023 08:40

ACynicalDad · 14/04/2023 17:11

He's not much more Irish than English and the Biden name comes from Sussex, he's a plonker about it and he's trying to play the arbiter when he's clearly biased against the UK. The joke is on him, not the Irish. I'd want him to loose if Trump wasn't his likely opponent.

Why are you parading your ignorance? He is directly 5/8 Irish (10 of his 16 great-great-grandparents were Irish). He grew up in Scranton, a deeply Irish-American town (more than 25% of the population have Irish ancestry) with strong Irish cultural roots including Irish labour politics (the Molly Maguires). Being 'Irish' in the USA is a highly specific diasporic identity. He has visited Ireland many many times, and why should a crowd of ignorant British people take it on themselves to proclaim what his identity is or isn't?

Anyotherdude · 15/04/2023 08:39

@DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry I’m also 1/16th French. I have visited France many times - including the place my distant ancestors came from. I also have affection for them and pride in the achievements of those who were forced to emigrate and retained a sense of their own culture (they were a family of Milliners - Hugenots, who were forced to emigrate because of their religious beliefs).
Having that ancestry, several times removed, does not entitle me to claim I’m French, and neither does having the culture of demonising the English by bad-mouthing them into family lore, entitle Joe Biden to perpetuate it. His prejudice relates to historical events, and that’s why it’s perfectly OK to poke fun at him (HIM - not the Irish) for his cultural appropriation!

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 08:31

RobinStrike · 14/04/2023 15:34

I agree with @Notegoat . It combines his hammy fake Irishness/ anti English sentiment while over there when it the DUP was super sensitive to his claims to be and support Ireland. None of it helped and was seen over here to be almost as bad as the cartoon is perceived in Ireland.

what is his 'anti-English' sentiment exactly?

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 15/04/2023 08:26

Anyotherdude

Biden is 10/16th Irish, not 1/8th. Unlike you, he has visited Ireland frequently over the years and has many family and friends here. He has an affection for them and a pride in the achievements of his ancestors who were forced to emigrate but retained a sense of their own culture. That isn't something to blame him for.

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 15/04/2023 08:20

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 02:00

I’m sorry, but how can people in the uk be offended about the Black and Tans.

@Fimat how unimaginative of you not to realise how afraid Irish people who travelled just over the water to Britain in the 1910s were. My dad came over when he was just a baby. Do you think his parents should have gone to the US? If it was you with a babe in arms and your husband had got a good job in the London docks would you have refused to follow him? Possibly but probably not. We sometimes went to Killarney but we're not Irish and neither is Joe Biden.

The 1910s when the black and tans didn't exist?

1912 maybe after the signing of the Ulster covenant or 1913 during the great strike in Dublin? perhaps 1914 after Ulster unionists introduced 25,000 guns into the sectarian equation and made it clear that Belfast was a dangerous workplace for catholics (and the army made it clear that they would not defend citizens from those armed criminals); what about later in 1914 after war broke out in Europe? how about 1916 when revolution broke out in Ireland? or 1918 when Ireland voted decisively for Independence?

1910s is a bit vague.

The arrival of the black and tans to suppress democracy in 1920 was just one more pimple on the enormous arse of British colonial oppression in Ireland, and Biden's lack of any obsession with them is quite reasonable.

Anyotherdude · 15/04/2023 08:18

It’s because he is claiming that 1/8th Irishness as his “true” heritage.
It’s because many Americans cling to their heritage in a ridiculously sentimental manner, while doing nothing to learn about that heritage/speak the language Etc.
My own Grandfather and Grandmother on my Dad’s side were Irish. Given that my Dad was born and raised by them in the North of England, and I and my siblings in the South of England, I am therefore English through and through (I’ve never even been to Ireland fgs!) and think that people who display an overly emotional attachment to a country they have not even experienced themselves are just being stupidly sentimental over an “affinity” that is not genuine.
I would agree that to portray someone who was born, raised and lived in Ireland in such a way would be racist, but in this case, it’s justified as it points out the hypocrisy and prejudice of the US President.

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 15/04/2023 08:01

ffs, jetlagged notoriously gaffe-prone man makes a slip when expressing pride in the achievement of his rugby-playing cousin.

Big deal. No-one in Ireland cares, though when he made a slightly abashed reference to the slip the next day he got a big laugh.

I think the British just don't like being reminded of the black and tans. Maybe they don't like being reminded of the All Blacks either, or of Ireland's current excellent rugby form.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 15/04/2023 06:30

@Fimat
I’m sorry, but how can people in the uk be offended about the Black and Tans.

My father came to the U.K. in the 50s due to lack of work in the west of Ireland. One of his sisters did the same. My grandparents had their house raided by the Black and Tans who were particularly active in the area.
So people in the U.K. my have direct family history that is relevant.

Piglet89 · 15/04/2023 06:15

Northern Irish Catholic living in London here. Grew up in West Belfast in the 80s.

There are plenty on this thread defending it. Mind you - what do you expect from a web site whose users regularly describe their toddlers as “having a paddy” (perpetuating the lazy stereotype that Irish people can’t control their emotions). I’ve had to report that one about 10 times.

The English have always thought the Irish beneath them though, and still do. This a couple of years ago from the Radio 4’s flagship was particularly stunning:

https://m.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/brexit/bbcs-humphrys-asks-dublin-minister-why-ireland-doesnt-dump-eu-and-throw-lot-in-with-uk/37751860.html

However, Biden’s visit (particularly to Northern Ireland) was embarrassing. “I don’t understand why you would ever leave”. Because they were fucking starving and dying in droves, Joe - that’s why. The All Blacks clanger though? Didn’t even know about that one: fuck ME.

Maybe the animatronics that so obviously power the leader of the free world malfunctioned.

BBC's Humphrys asks Dublin minister why Ireland doesn't dump EU and 'throw lot in' with UK

Ireland's Europe minister dismissed a suggestion the Republic should leave the EU after she was asked - given the her economy's reliance on Britain for exports, revenue and jobs - why it didn't just "throw its lot in" with the UK.

https://m.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/brexit/bbcs-humphrys-asks-dublin-minister-why-ireland-doesnt-dump-eu-and-throw-lot-in-with-uk/37751860.html

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 02:00

I’m sorry, but how can people in the uk be offended about the Black and Tans.

@Fimat how unimaginative of you not to realise how afraid Irish people who travelled just over the water to Britain in the 1910s were. My dad came over when he was just a baby. Do you think his parents should have gone to the US? If it was you with a babe in arms and your husband had got a good job in the London docks would you have refused to follow him? Possibly but probably not. We sometimes went to Killarney but we're not Irish and neither is Joe Biden.

Dishwasherdisaster · 15/04/2023 01:53

Yes, it's offensive. Of course it is.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 00:49

belleager · 14/04/2023 23:47

I think the Black and Tan / All Blacks mix-up must have been a slip-up @limitedperiodonly . Not Freudian, I agree. Just a slip. The man isn't into rugby. He stutters and gets his words wrong. And as a joke it would only offend Irish people. So surely just an error.

Come on.

How could Biden mix up a vital part of the history of Ireland with an important but arguably less important part of the history of New Zealand unless you didn't know or didn't care @belleager ?

I don't think it was malicious. I just think Biden fucked up as he often does because he doesn't know or doesn't care.

As my Irish aunt used to say: "He's a bit of a romancer".

I understand the feelings of the Irish diaspora. I'm part of it, as many of us are in Scotland, England and to a lesser extent, Wales As an Englander, I am used to being dismissed.

But Biden is the latest of a long line of US presidents parading his Irish credentials. That's okay. All I ask is that he gets it right and people don't make excuses when he gets it wrong.

Fimat · 15/04/2023 00:22

limitedperiodonly · 14/04/2023 23:10

It was a bloody stupid thing to say and made me wince.

The Black and Tans murdered people and like yours, my grandparents were also there at the time.

It's burned in all our memories, isn't it?

Conversely, the All Blacks are the national rugby team of New Zealand who waggle their tongues. How could anyone possibly mix that up?

I don't mind Joe Biden, I certainly prefer him to Donald Trump, and find his gaffes charming. But like many politicians he trades on his hinterland and I am not terribly impressed by an American president trading on his Irish heritage when it's much more removed than mine.

I'm less impressed by people saying it's just a Freudian slip

It was, as I said, a Freudian slip and was laughed about here in Ireland. It was the pearl clutching in some uk media that made me wince. I’m sorry, but how can people in the uk be offended about the Black and Tans.

Also, the judgement about how is Irish he is???
There are millions of Italian Americans, African Americans , Latino Americans who who may have a similar family tree and also Cling onto their culture.
My aunt has been in the US for 70 years, her great grand children all have Irish names . They all go to catholic schools and being Irish is a massive part of their identity. Why all the judgement??

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 00:11

And like fuck was the All Blacks/Black And Tan thing was just an innocent gaffe or Freudian slip we shouldn't worry about.

It was not intentional but Biden made a mistake which was very bad. Either he didn't know the difference between the Black and Tans and the All Blacks, or he didn't know or care whether Ireland and New Zealand were different countries with Prime Ministers and people and that. Probably both. Maybe he doesn't know New Zealand exists.

That's not as weird as it sounds I went through US immigration on my British passport and my NZ colleague was detained because the US immigration fuckwit hadn't done geography at school. And she had a gun.

Whatever the toss, that's not conducive to international relations, is it?

Maybe Biden is senile or maybe like most US presidents he doesn't give a shit what happens outside the US. That wouldn't be beyond the realms of possibility for Presidents of the USA including Barack Obama.

Therefore I don't see why anyone of any country would think any of that was good or accept crumbs just because POTUS came from the Old Country.

That's just needy

belleager · 14/04/2023 23:47

I think the Black and Tan / All Blacks mix-up must have been a slip-up @limitedperiodonly . Not Freudian, I agree. Just a slip. The man isn't into rugby. He stutters and gets his words wrong. And as a joke it would only offend Irish people. So surely just an error.

AnElegantChaos · 14/04/2023 23:32

Is this worse than the cartoon I saw a few years ago of Donald Trump wearing a see you Jimmy wig and tam o' shanter when he visited Scotland a few years ago?
If so, why?

Yes I would say it's worse, the caricatures and meanings behind them bear far too much resemblance to 19thc cartoons which were specifically anti-Irish and racist, and the Biden one depicts the Irish in exactly the same way.

I've not seen the Trump one but I'm assuming it was poking fun at Trump rather than Scots. What I'm trying to say (and probably not very well) is that the Biden caricatures are targeting the Irish as much, if not more so, than Biden. Whereas the Trump one I imagine was not specifically intended to stereotype Scots or portray them offensively (a tam-o-shanter cartoon doesn't really seem to have the same connotations to me, historical or otherwise). But as I say, I haven't seen it. If for instance Trump had been portrayed as a drunk Glaswegian - sadly still a common, offensive stereotype - then that would be completely different IMO.

I'm sure others would disagree, but I think it's a hideous cartoon. I lived in a very Irish area of London in the early 90s when anti-Irish discrimination was still pervasive and it makes me wince that this kind of shit is still being portrayed in the mainstream media, and I'm not even Irish. But I also think Biden's gaff was pathetic on his part.

Lydia777 · 14/04/2023 23:17

SoWhat21 · 14/04/2023 20:03

Ive only recently returned to Mumsnet after a long break and this thread reminds me of one of the reasons I stepped away.

the wholly ignorant attitude to Ireland it’s culture history and Irish people themselves is so fucking depressing.

Dont tell an entire group of people who were invaded, oppressed and starved for hundreds of years by your country’s imperialist ambitions what is and is not offensive to us.

Irish relationship with its emigrants is part of our culture. Don't dismiss the real attachment the diaspora that were forced to leave had to their home country and passed down to the next generations. And the attachment we have to them. It wasn’t that many years ago the the economic survival of a lot of Irish at home relied on what was sent back from the US. Sometimes from family that there was no hope of ever seeing again.
There may be politicians in America the throw a green cape around them for political benefit. Obama did when he visited. Joe Biden is not one of them. He is a genuine and sincere attachment to Ireland from childhood. He was part of the group of politicians who worked on issues affecting Ireland and Irish people in America for years while in the Senate. He has visited Ireland many times.

Great post.

limitedperiodonly · 14/04/2023 23:10

Fimat · 14/04/2023 21:07

Freudian slip…nobody in Ireland found it offensive in the slightest. It’s part of our history. The Black and Tans were brutal. My grandparents were in fear of them. As I said , they are part of our history and we did beat them in the end.
I found it interesting that it took until the next day for GB news and daily Mail etc to bring it up. They obviously had to google them.
The Black and Tans are indefensible and the only people who I feel could possible be offended are the All blacks and I’m guessing they couldn’t care less .
The anti Irish sentiment that ‘some’ parts of the British media is peddling is just so petty and salty

It was a bloody stupid thing to say and made me wince.

The Black and Tans murdered people and like yours, my grandparents were also there at the time.

It's burned in all our memories, isn't it?

Conversely, the All Blacks are the national rugby team of New Zealand who waggle their tongues. How could anyone possibly mix that up?

I don't mind Joe Biden, I certainly prefer him to Donald Trump, and find his gaffes charming. But like many politicians he trades on his hinterland and I am not terribly impressed by an American president trading on his Irish heritage when it's much more removed than mine.

I'm less impressed by people saying it's just a Freudian slip

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 14/04/2023 23:08

We’re used the English taking cheap potshots. Water off a duck back at this point.

belleager · 14/04/2023 22:55

Fizzadora · 14/04/2023 22:41

Is this worse than the cartoon I saw a few years ago of Donald Trump wearing a see you Jimmy wig and tam o' shanter when he visited Scotland a few years ago?
If so, why?

Hard to say without seeing it, being Scottish, knowing the history of the image, and knowing what message the cartoonist was attempting to convey about Scotland.

One think I dislike about the cartoon we are discussing here is the implication that a man who loves Ireland can't care for Northern Ireland. The offensive imagery without that would just be twee and irritating. But the political point means that the imagery is being weaponised against what we've been trying to preserve in the face of Brexit etc - hope for harmony on this island.

I mean it's far from the worst I've seen. I don't think anyone is terribly surprised by it. It's just a bit same old, same old, interesting timing with the anti-Irish dig there. Pity the Times printed it but their reputation is hardly up to much these days.

I doubt I'd know enough to say re Scottish example.

Fizzadora · 14/04/2023 22:41

Is this worse than the cartoon I saw a few years ago of Donald Trump wearing a see you Jimmy wig and tam o' shanter when he visited Scotland a few years ago?
If so, why?