Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?

262 replies

Hedwigharlot · 14/04/2023 13:42

The cartoon depicts him dressed as a leprechaun. It's like a depiction of Irish people from a Punch Magazine in the 19th century. Who thought it was appropriate? And why are the British media working themselves up into such a jealous frenzy over Biden coming to Ireland? Very poor behaviour.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
whatchaos · 15/04/2023 16:28

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 16:00

I don't think I said anything about what Joe Biden was allowed to do or not. It's not up to me. I pointed out that neither of us is Irish. I don't think he's under the impression that he is, but is proud of that part of his heritage and feels attached to the country. He might feel more of an attachment than I do, but as you said, it's not wrong for either of us to feel that way, I have my reasons and Biden has his.

He made what I thought was a bit of an error, but as @DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry explained, the Black and Tans would not loom as large or even at all in the folk memory of someone whose forebear left Ireland in the mid-19th century to escape the famine/English campaign of starvation as it would to me, my father or my grandfather. I got that.

If anyone asks, I tell them of my family history on my dad's side - Irish Catholic immigrants to England. If they want to know about my mum's side, English Protestant, I tell them as much as I can about her family. I don't know that much about either but luckily I've never found people to be that interested.

If I was interested I could find out more, but I am content with the knowledge I have and my life in the here and now. I've always felt that way. My family history never figured in my top 3 topics to tell people about on a blind date. If someone started asking me that would put me off - like they were asking to see my papers. In the same way I imagine people who are not white get fed up with people asking them where they are really from or Jewish people get the creeps when someone fetishes their ethnicity and does Topol impressions

It sometimes happens that someone announces their ethnic background and when it does, I always say: "That's interesting." I don't mean it. I'm just being polite. That's the English in me.

Sorry for any misunderstanding - you said he isn't Irish, and I said he is in terms of what 'Irish' means in the context of the Irish-American diaspora, Irish being shorthand for of Irish descent and raised in an Irish-American milieu.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 16:11

Ireland did very well at the rugby so far this year, but it wouldn't do to get smug.

@DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry you don't need to tell me. I get terribly excited about England at football until we get knocked out on penalties. That's the men, btw.

I watched the World Cup Final and it was thrilling even to someone who has no ties to France or Argentina and knows hardly anything about football.

I must soon away to watch the Grand National. That's another Irish stereotype - that they love horses. I like horsies too but what I really like is big ticket occasions in which I have no personal involvement. Not funerals, though.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 16:00

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 14:49

The Ireland to Britain migrant experience is different than the Ireland to USA experience, as is the diasporic identity politics. Biden has the right to describe himself as having Irish identity if he wishes, just as you have the right to not describe yourself as Irish if you don't wish to. What you and anybody else doesn't have the right to do is say that someone isn't or can't describe themselves as Irish as what that means is context-specific, i.e. in terms of how Americans might describe their identity.

I don't think I said anything about what Joe Biden was allowed to do or not. It's not up to me. I pointed out that neither of us is Irish. I don't think he's under the impression that he is, but is proud of that part of his heritage and feels attached to the country. He might feel more of an attachment than I do, but as you said, it's not wrong for either of us to feel that way, I have my reasons and Biden has his.

He made what I thought was a bit of an error, but as @DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry explained, the Black and Tans would not loom as large or even at all in the folk memory of someone whose forebear left Ireland in the mid-19th century to escape the famine/English campaign of starvation as it would to me, my father or my grandfather. I got that.

If anyone asks, I tell them of my family history on my dad's side - Irish Catholic immigrants to England. If they want to know about my mum's side, English Protestant, I tell them as much as I can about her family. I don't know that much about either but luckily I've never found people to be that interested.

If I was interested I could find out more, but I am content with the knowledge I have and my life in the here and now. I've always felt that way. My family history never figured in my top 3 topics to tell people about on a blind date. If someone started asking me that would put me off - like they were asking to see my papers. In the same way I imagine people who are not white get fed up with people asking them where they are really from or Jewish people get the creeps when someone fetishes their ethnicity and does Topol impressions

It sometimes happens that someone announces their ethnic background and when it does, I always say: "That's interesting." I don't mean it. I'm just being polite. That's the English in me.

saoirse31 · 15/04/2023 15:40

It's part of a long history of anti Irish cartoons by the British media. But these days tbh, it makes them look like stupid bigots as indeed they seem to be....

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 15:37

postapesto · 15/04/2023 15:00

Biden has the right to describe himself as having Irish identity if he wishes, just as you have the right to not describe yourself as Irish if you don't wish to. What you and anybody else doesn't have the right to do is say that someone isn't or can't describe themselves as Irish as what that means is context-specific, i.e. in terms of how Americans might describe their identity

Does he though? The notion that anyone can identify however they like is clearly ludicrous. I mean, I am Irish, Joe Biden is not. Personally I don't care how he identifies, but I know a lot of Irish people do not like non-Irish people claiming to be Irish. It can be seen as pretty insulting.

Having Irish heritage does not make a person Irish, and neither does giving yourself the label of Irish.

As I said, it's context-specific. And so in the context of Irish-American diasporic identity, calling yourself 'Irish' means of Irish heritage. I lived in the USA for a few years and people would often describe themselves as Irish, Mexican, Haitian, Italian and so on, which didn't necessarily mean born in those places, it meant they were from that specific heritage, particularly if they grew up somewhere (eg Scranton in Biden's case) amongst a community which identified strongly with a specific culture. Someone in the UK might (or might not) describe themselves as of Irish descent, whereas in the USA they might describe themselves as 'Irish' within a particular context.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 15:00

Biden has the right to describe himself as having Irish identity if he wishes, just as you have the right to not describe yourself as Irish if you don't wish to. What you and anybody else doesn't have the right to do is say that someone isn't or can't describe themselves as Irish as what that means is context-specific, i.e. in terms of how Americans might describe their identity

Does he though? The notion that anyone can identify however they like is clearly ludicrous. I mean, I am Irish, Joe Biden is not. Personally I don't care how he identifies, but I know a lot of Irish people do not like non-Irish people claiming to be Irish. It can be seen as pretty insulting.

Having Irish heritage does not make a person Irish, and neither does giving yourself the label of Irish.

postapesto · 15/04/2023 14:56

Raquelos · 14/04/2023 13:55

I would have interpreted that as a pop at the rather unrealistic idea of what Irishness is that is held by many of the Irish American community. But if it offends you fair enough. Your perogative etc.

This, it doesn't mock us, it mocks him and his ideas about Ireland (shared by many Americans)

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 14:49

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 14:27

1910s is a bit vague.

@DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry I do apologise. That was vague of me. I didn't think anyone else would be interested in my family history. For anyone who is, my father was born in Killarney in 1918. His father was in London, having left his pregnant wife and three children to get a job in the docks. It was known as a "ticket" and was much prized. The jobs were controlled by family ties and Irish family members already living in London had got it for him. It was a very good reason for leaving Ireland where secure work was harder to find.

Sometime after my father's birth, I think it was 1919 but forgive me for being vague on the details because my dad is no longer available for consultation, my grandfather sent for his wife and children. So they didn't have direct experience of the Black and Tans but they had family still living in Ireland who did. That would be my great grandparents and great aunts and uncles and people like that. Not my grandparents as I said. That was what's known as a slip of the tongue.

That's why I said to @Fimat that British people or people living in Britain of Irish descent, whatever you like to call us, would know who the Black and Tans were. There are quite a lot of us dotted around, especially in English cities like London and Liverpool and thereabouts whose forebears never made it to America.

I also know who the All Blacks are even though I've never been to a rugby match or indeed, New Zealand. Because I'm not interested in rugby I couldn't tell you if Ireland was doing better than England. Are they? If so, that's nice for Irish rugby fans.

Though I am of Irish descent, I'm not Irish and neither is Joe Biden. Though on the Biden Scale of Irishness, I'm a bit more Irish than him. But it's not a competition. He can be proud of his Irish heritage and talk about it as much as he likes. I'm truly happy for him. It's just unfortunate when he makes mistakes. It's funny though. I agree, the cartoon wasn't.

The Ireland to Britain migrant experience is different than the Ireland to USA experience, as is the diasporic identity politics. Biden has the right to describe himself as having Irish identity if he wishes, just as you have the right to not describe yourself as Irish if you don't wish to. What you and anybody else doesn't have the right to do is say that someone isn't or can't describe themselves as Irish as what that means is context-specific, i.e. in terms of how Americans might describe their identity.

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 15/04/2023 14:41

That pattern of emigration, with someone going first and then family members and neighbours following once they have some idea of where to get jobs is so typical of the emigrant experience (and not just the Irish, the eastern Europeans do the same thing atm) and it's part of the glue that keeps the diaspora experience so important and distinctive.

I'm sure people like yours who emigrated during the war of Independence did know all about the black and tans. For people like Biden, descendants of the post-Famine generation, they would never have loomed that large - just one small detail of the overall colonial system.

I wonder whether being 'Polish Irish' or 'Ukrainian Irish' will be a thing in a century's time - I know the Polish government is keen to encourage educational links so that children don't lose touch with home. Easier now of course with world wide access to anything.

Ireland did very well at the rugby so far this year, but it wouldn't do to get smug.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 14:27

1910s is a bit vague.

@DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry I do apologise. That was vague of me. I didn't think anyone else would be interested in my family history. For anyone who is, my father was born in Killarney in 1918. His father was in London, having left his pregnant wife and three children to get a job in the docks. It was known as a "ticket" and was much prized. The jobs were controlled by family ties and Irish family members already living in London had got it for him. It was a very good reason for leaving Ireland where secure work was harder to find.

Sometime after my father's birth, I think it was 1919 but forgive me for being vague on the details because my dad is no longer available for consultation, my grandfather sent for his wife and children. So they didn't have direct experience of the Black and Tans but they had family still living in Ireland who did. That would be my great grandparents and great aunts and uncles and people like that. Not my grandparents as I said. That was what's known as a slip of the tongue.

That's why I said to @Fimat that British people or people living in Britain of Irish descent, whatever you like to call us, would know who the Black and Tans were. There are quite a lot of us dotted around, especially in English cities like London and Liverpool and thereabouts whose forebears never made it to America.

I also know who the All Blacks are even though I've never been to a rugby match or indeed, New Zealand. Because I'm not interested in rugby I couldn't tell you if Ireland was doing better than England. Are they? If so, that's nice for Irish rugby fans.

Though I am of Irish descent, I'm not Irish and neither is Joe Biden. Though on the Biden Scale of Irishness, I'm a bit more Irish than him. But it's not a competition. He can be proud of his Irish heritage and talk about it as much as he likes. I'm truly happy for him. It's just unfortunate when he makes mistakes. It's funny though. I agree, the cartoon wasn't.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 11:26

Livinghappy · 15/04/2023 11:00

One thing I dislike about the cartoon we are discussing here is the implication that a man who loves Ireland can't care for Northern Ireland. The offensive imagery without that would just be twee and irritating. But the political point means that the imagery is being weaponised against what we've been trying to preserve in the face of Brexit etc - hope for harmony on this island

This is a very important post. The cartoon is seeking to diminish an important ally the US (as well as being offensive to Irish people) because it may suit the Westminster political agenda. If the Torys believe they might be a minority after the next GE they could seek alliance from DUP, as Teresa May did previously. The right wing press are already campaigning and they could happily sacrifice peace in NI for an election win.

Back to the topic - enough Irish people on this post have said they find the cartoon offensive so I'm persuaded by them. In the same way I would agree if the majority of Indian or Jewish people found stereotyping offensive & racist.

I think this is a very important point. Biden is deeply invested in the peace process in which US politicians played a significant and notably bipartisan role. He was very prominent on the Senate foreign relations committee which worked with Clinton on NI. It's also in his political interest to uphold international treaties, and the GFA is in danger since Brexit and the disgraceful attitude of the Tories to NI.

As such, the cartoon is offensive not only because of its tiresome stereotyping which reminds Irish people of the way British media have a long history of caricaturing the Irish in dehumanising ways, but also because it suggests Biden doesn't give a toss about NI, whereas he has done more than many active politicians to ensure what passes as peace.

Aside - it's a very unskilled drawing (looks like King Charles as much as Biden) and inaccurate (Biden doesn't drink alcohol).

Guardian12 · 15/04/2023 11:17

The coverage of the visit by the British press has had a very nasty tone. They’ve been trying their best to put Ireland back in its box.

Livinghappy · 15/04/2023 11:00

One thing I dislike about the cartoon we are discussing here is the implication that a man who loves Ireland can't care for Northern Ireland. The offensive imagery without that would just be twee and irritating. But the political point means that the imagery is being weaponised against what we've been trying to preserve in the face of Brexit etc - hope for harmony on this island

This is a very important post. The cartoon is seeking to diminish an important ally the US (as well as being offensive to Irish people) because it may suit the Westminster political agenda. If the Torys believe they might be a minority after the next GE they could seek alliance from DUP, as Teresa May did previously. The right wing press are already campaigning and they could happily sacrifice peace in NI for an election win.

Back to the topic - enough Irish people on this post have said they find the cartoon offensive so I'm persuaded by them. In the same way I would agree if the majority of Indian or Jewish people found stereotyping offensive & racist.

Dishwasherdisaster · 15/04/2023 10:39

Lots of Irish people are saying they find the cartoon offensive.

To those British people arguing that it's not - would you please just stop? Even if you don't understand why, the very fact that it is causing offence should be enough to tell you that this should not have been published. The OP suggests that the cartoon is 'offensive towards Irish people', so even if you don't think it offensive, if you're not Irish then your opinion really isn't relevant.

You can go do more research if you want (eg see upthread for examples of the anti-Irish cartoons of old), but in the meantime please stop arguing that the cartoon is not offensive when you are being clearly told that it is.

Runssometimes · 15/04/2023 10:22

Sure I know. And yer man on CNN that said the Black and Tans were an Irish group. https://twitter.com/cnn/status/1646456960907112448?s=48&t=6dq-4W1XE5uAHLaq1uTzgQ

’tis a pity more people don’t know about Google and parade their ignorance.

https://twitter.com/cnn/status/1646456960907112448?s=48&t=6dq-4W1XE5uAHLaq1uTzgQ

AnElegantChaos · 15/04/2023 10:19

EyesOnThePies · 15/04/2023 10:01

I am another that took this cartoon to be 100% comment in the way that Biden (and many other) Americans embrace a fake, sentimental and insultingly stereotyped ‘Irish identity’. NOT as a depiction of Irish people per se.

Though on a recent St Patrick’s night out in London large groups of Irish people were drinking Guinness, wearing green, and enormous hats exactly like that

Nope, the creator of the cartoon knew exactly what he was doing. Are you Irish or Irish American? Hybrid identities are completely normal and should be celebrated. What makes you say Irish Americans adopt a 'fake' identity and which elements of that do you think play to racial stereotypes? Interesting score-through btw - drinking Guinness on St Patrick's night is hardly playing to historical racial stereotyping and is no different to Scots (home, abroad or otherwise) eating Haggis and drinking malt is on St Andrew's or Burns night.

My kids are mixed race (their father is Black) and they routinely get asked "where are you from" followed by "where are you really from".

Yes this, a lot of Brits seem to want to have it both ways.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 10:13

Runssometimes · 15/04/2023 09:56

Very unlikely to forget about shit show Brexit. My local labour MP campaigned leave and I’ve never voted for him since and told him that NI was an huge part of my Brexit objection. No need for it.

After the vote a colleague asked me wouldn’t Ireland be better off re-joining the union??!!! English friend, married to Italian has had to move her family to France as he worked in FS, our kids were great friends. It’s so sad. I’m baffled by it all, country is poorer for it in my opinion. I understand not everyone agrees and the divisiveness it’s caused here is so regrettable as well.

The BBC even suggested Ireland rejoin the union! https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jan/26/john-humphrys-suggests-ireland-could-quit-eu-and-join-uk

Ireland dismisses suggestion it should quit EU and join UK

BBC’s John Humphrys criticised for putting ‘Brexit solution’ to Irish minister

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jan/26/john-humphrys-suggests-ireland-could-quit-eu-and-join-uk

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 10:09

Anyotherdude · 15/04/2023 09:28

JFC - we are ignorant if we cast Joe Biden as American, not Irish, yet an 83-year old woman is made out to be racist for asking a British-born woman of African extraction where she “really” comes from?
You can’t have it both ways: either your identity is where you were born and raised, or it isn’t.
Claiming to “be” Irish simply because your community, far from Ireland, has developed their own tradition, based on Irish-ness (like the St. Patrick’s day shenanigans, which, until turned by those ex-pat communities into a celebration, consisted of other ex-pat and internal Irish communities of just wearing shamrock and attending Mass on the Saint’s day) does NOT make you Irish.
Nobody is taking the p1$$ out of the Irish here - just the US President.

No, it’s ignorant to not know what it means when he describes himself as Irish in the diasporic sense. He hasn’t said he’s not American, it is possible to have a hybrid identity you know.

And the history of St Patrick’s Day didn’t involve just wearing shamrock - the first parade was actually in the USA in the 1720s. There’s always been an interplay between Irish diasporic identity and Irish living in Ireland identity, with them informing one another just as Irish people have often travelled back and forth between Ireland and the US/UK etc.

StephanieSuperpowers · 15/04/2023 10:09

Though on a recent St Patrick’s night out in London large groups of Irish people were drinking Guinness, wearing green, and enormous hats exactly like that

They are fully within their rights to do that and also object to such depictions of themselves in newspapers which they find disrespectful, demeaning and condescending towards them.

Jewel1968 · 15/04/2023 10:02

Identity is complex. Why are people so bothered about Biden describing himself as Irish. Criticise him for his politics by all means but why criticise him for how he identifies? Why do people feel they can tell him (or anyone) how they should identify?

My kids are mixed race (their father is Black) and they routinely get asked "where are you from" followed by "where are you really from". They are not immediately seen as British. Their identity is their business just like Biden's identity is his business.

EyesOnThePies · 15/04/2023 10:01

I am another that took this cartoon to be 100% comment in the way that Biden (and many other) Americans embrace a fake, sentimental and insultingly stereotyped ‘Irish identity’. NOT as a depiction of Irish people per se.

Though on a recent St Patrick’s night out in London large groups of Irish people were drinking Guinness, wearing green, and enormous hats exactly like that

Runssometimes · 15/04/2023 09:56

Very unlikely to forget about shit show Brexit. My local labour MP campaigned leave and I’ve never voted for him since and told him that NI was an huge part of my Brexit objection. No need for it.

After the vote a colleague asked me wouldn’t Ireland be better off re-joining the union??!!! English friend, married to Italian has had to move her family to France as he worked in FS, our kids were great friends. It’s so sad. I’m baffled by it all, country is poorer for it in my opinion. I understand not everyone agrees and the divisiveness it’s caused here is so regrettable as well.

vera99 · 15/04/2023 09:45

Runssometimes · 15/04/2023 09:03

Cannot believe 55% of people think YABU OP. Am born and bred Irish and living in UK since my twenties. Of course the cartoon is offensive.

Much of the UK Biden coverage has been depressing. But unfortunately anti Irish sentiment is alive and well. I don’t get the bomb, turty tree and a turd or potato ‘jokes’ to my face anymore but I do get told that I can’t possibly be offended at things that I very much am offended by - phrases like beyond the pale or having a paddy. And plenty of examples of that hard of thinking in evidence here in this thread. Ireland will always be my true home and where I belong but I was very happy here in the UK, a country which has given me so much and which I in turn have contributed much to but I’m feeling increasingly uncomfortable here. DH who’s also Irish, we moved here together also feels it.

Some insightful comments here, and wanted to share an article from our own Irish Times on the theme https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/2023/04/14/his-hatred-of-the-uk-has-hardly-been-concealed-how-british-press-covered-bidens-visit/

Biden can be as Irish as he likes, not in the least offended, thing is we don’t get to decide how other people feel about their own heritage. And other people don’t get to tell me what I can and cannot be offended about mine.

Let's not forget that the Tories Brexit has threatened the stability of the UK and peace in Northern Ireland and every woman and her dog knows it. That picture aptly sums up the contempt that most good folk feel for the absolute shit show imposed on us through Tory machinations. It was even better when Joe shoved him out of the way !

Awkward moment Joe Biden appears to push Sunak aside for hug with female US diplomat

Awkward moment Joe Biden appears to push Sunak aside for hug with female US diplomat. Mr Sunak suffered an awkward moment as he greeted Air Force One at RAF ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QIzq5594UUM

belleager · 15/04/2023 09:42

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 15/04/2023 09:32

Anyotherdude
His prejudice relates to historical events, and that’s why it’s perfectly OK to poke fun at him (HIM - not the Irish) for his cultural appropriation!

Prejudice? Or understandable lack of respect for politicians who entered into a painfully negotiated legal agreement (that has saved thousands of UK citizens' lives) and have spent years trying to renege on it, crowned by the mad folly of Brexit.

He hasn't appropriated anything - Irish America has its own culture, and no-one was led to believe over the last week that he is anything other than American, albeit with more than half his roots in Ireland.

Yes. Irish-Americanism is a widespread, long-established culture which is important to both nations. Biden didn't invent it this week. The evidence is that he has been immersed in it all his life

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 15/04/2023 09:32

Anyotherdude
His prejudice relates to historical events, and that’s why it’s perfectly OK to poke fun at him (HIM - not the Irish) for his cultural appropriation!

Prejudice? Or understandable lack of respect for politicians who entered into a painfully negotiated legal agreement (that has saved thousands of UK citizens' lives) and have spent years trying to renege on it, crowned by the mad folly of Brexit.

He hasn't appropriated anything - Irish America has its own culture, and no-one was led to believe over the last week that he is anything other than American, albeit with more than half his roots in Ireland.