Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?

262 replies

Hedwigharlot · 14/04/2023 13:42

The cartoon depicts him dressed as a leprechaun. It's like a depiction of Irish people from a Punch Magazine in the 19th century. Who thought it was appropriate? And why are the British media working themselves up into such a jealous frenzy over Biden coming to Ireland? Very poor behaviour.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Chulainn · 15/04/2023 21:11

What I don't understand is why people are still making excuses for this depiction of Biden and his Irishness. Many Irish people on this thread have said they find it offensive. Instead of many accepting that, it seems there are loads of people excusing the offence by telling us that Biden isn't Irish, we shouldn't be offended, they aren't offended, we are misunderstanding what the cartoon is really about etc.

Whether anyone in the UK of Irish origin feels as Irish as Biden is irrelevant. He feels a deep connection to Ireland, exemplified by his trip to Mayo. He visited a hospice that is named for his son Beau, where he himself turned the sod when it was being built. He met, by accident not design, the priest who gave Beau his last rites. He was at a church one of his distant grandfathers helped build. It seemed like yesterday was very personal to Biden for many reasons, all connected to his family and Ireland.

We can speculate forever if Irish Americans should claim to feel Irish and there will be views on both sides. However, can we all please agree that this cartoon should not have been published as it has offended many Irish people (on and off this thread). Irish people should not have to explain why we are offended. It should be accepted. Arguing against that is offensive in itself.

ncfaily · 15/04/2023 21:01

America is multicultural with a lot of diversity among white Americans that perhaps isn't obvious to British people without a strong sense of immigrant America. Joe Biden went to Catholic school which means fee-paying in the US - but they were generally 'cheap' private schools run by religious orders, very different to the elite prep schools.

His children were christened and raised as Catholic, so it's something he has sought to pass on. US Catholics tended to sort themselves into parishes they felt more comfortable in, usually on ethnic/national lines and following patterns of migrant settlement. So for Biden to say 'Irish' is a shorthand for a particular American way of life which is basically religious, Catholic, urban - but a specific version of that, the Irish American version.

Someone said Biden is an English surname - my guess would be they were Protestant but in a mixed marriage the Catholicism got passed on. There weren't historically so many English Catholics migrating to the US. I could be wrong. It seems though that the Irish identity survived in his family more than the English. Other families did differently.

The fact people don't explicitly say 'British American' doesn't mean that Britishness/Englishness hasn't left a cultural legacy. And WASP was more salient as an identity earlier last century. Remember Larry David pretending to be a WASP in Curb to get into a country club - 'I'm a Moose. And an Elk'. The Mid-West has a strong Germany heritage, though people don't often define as German-American - the wars made a difference there. But American Christmas & a good deal of the classical music world has been influenced by German American cultural practice.

What counts - only linguistic or physical difference? Why should somebody on the internet get to say over the person themselves? What would you count as authentic? Biden is attached to Irish poetry and history, visits frequently, has built friendships and connections with extended family and takes a special interest in the region of one of his ancestors. Why not do this if you could?

There are times when it would be good not to recycle tropes, whatever the satire/intended meaning/valid criticism blah blah blah justification after the fact. A little bit of political stress and whooops, the political cartoons start to get a bit tropey. There have been too many examples over the past few years. I guess there might be a perception among some British that this is just punching up, because 'America'. But it isn't, and it reflects badly on British political culture.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 20:44

belleager · 15/04/2023 20:36

All politics works this way. Everybody rolls out the red carpet for state visits. And we try to nurture existing bonds where possible. No guarantees, but we'd hardly be slamming the door in the man's face!

Britain has done a lot of door slamming in recent years.

Politics is the art of the possible - you welcome opportunities as they come.

tbh, it's another reason why that Times cartoon and cries of Biden 'hating' Britain are so silly. It's not going to do British diplomacy any favours to be seen as immature and thoughtless.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 20:41

belleager · 15/04/2023 20:36

All politics works this way. Everybody rolls out the red carpet for state visits. And we try to nurture existing bonds where possible. No guarantees, but we'd hardly be slamming the door in the man's face!

Britain has done a lot of door slamming in recent years.

Politics is the art of the possible - you welcome opportunities as they come.

Exactly - and Ireland enjoys a lot of soft power in relation to the USA. St Patrick's Day is celebrated in the White House every year, and Irish politicians attend. For a small nation, it gives pretty enviable access to power. Biden has accepted an invitation from King Charles to visit the UK in the near future.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 20:38

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 20:24

The whole thing is so pathetically needy. Like the UK thinking we have a special relationship with the US. No we don't. They will ditch us when they feel like it. What makes the Irish think they are any different?

Well, there's a pretty long history of the USA being sympathetic to Ireland, eg in terms of likening American independence to the fight for Irish independence. Biden alluded to this in his speech about the American Declaration of Independence including: 'The history of the present King of Great Britain is a history of repeated injuries and usurpations, all having in direct object the establishment of an absolute Tyranny over these States.'

belleager · 15/04/2023 20:36

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 20:24

The whole thing is so pathetically needy. Like the UK thinking we have a special relationship with the US. No we don't. They will ditch us when they feel like it. What makes the Irish think they are any different?

All politics works this way. Everybody rolls out the red carpet for state visits. And we try to nurture existing bonds where possible. No guarantees, but we'd hardly be slamming the door in the man's face!

Britain has done a lot of door slamming in recent years.

Politics is the art of the possible - you welcome opportunities as they come.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 20:35

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:43

Ok, wrong word, not 'interpretation', your presentation of the findings of research carried out but my point is 'youth' in my experience is not as concerned with differences, in fact that is why they are so profoundly shocked by racism, sexism, homophobia and general hostility based on prejudice.

Not sure what you mean - difference isn't always about prejudice.
My teenage nephews in London were certainly shocked by having potatoes thrown at them in school when they described themselves as Irish.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 20:24

The whole thing is so pathetically needy. Like the UK thinking we have a special relationship with the US. No we don't. They will ditch us when they feel like it. What makes the Irish think they are any different?

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 20:14

I’m sorry I didn’t mean to exclude people of Irish heritage in the uk
@Fimat really? Didn't you? Why didn't you notice us? Are you not aware of us? We are next door rather than three thousand miles away. Or are Irish American presidents more glamorous?

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 20:12

I'm not sure it helps with the vote either @whatchaos . After all the vast majority of Irish Americans live in states that always vote Democrat anyway? Although Biden himself is in a 'swingy' state.

You point about the passports tickled me. I bet the Brexiloons don't feel a bit cringe about applying for their Irish passports.

' Wad some Power the giftie gie us
Tae see oursells as ithers see us'

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 19:58

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 19:39

It's just weird. Betrays a loss of confidence within the establishment perhaps?

His visit seems to have touched a raw nerve in a way that just didn't happen with visits by other US presidents. I don't recall any ridicule of Obama when he visited Ireland. And his links are far more tenuous.

Or Clinton for that matter. Perhaps this is the start of the Murdoch Empire's campaign to re-elect Trump? But that's just me trying to make sense of it. I'm no psychiatrist.

Super peevish attitude, comes across as insecure, touchy and maybe a bit envious of Irish soft power and US investment in Ireland, particularly post-Brexit as well as the mess in NI being partly down to Tories getting into bed with the DUP in the last parliament.

Many US presidents have visited Ireland the year before re-election, not sure it helps with the American voters but can't hurt.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:43

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 19:34

I'm not interpreting anything, just reporting on lots of studies which demonstrate there's historically been a difference in the USA and UK with second, third generation (etc.) Irish ethnicity (explainer: it's one of my areas of research). I'd say that it has been changing in the USA as neighbourhoods are less ethnically specific in many cities now other than maybe for the first generation of certain migrant groups.

Ok, wrong word, not 'interpretation', your presentation of the findings of research carried out but my point is 'youth' in my experience is not as concerned with differences, in fact that is why they are so profoundly shocked by racism, sexism, homophobia and general hostility based on prejudice.

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 19:39

It's just weird. Betrays a loss of confidence within the establishment perhaps?

His visit seems to have touched a raw nerve in a way that just didn't happen with visits by other US presidents. I don't recall any ridicule of Obama when he visited Ireland. And his links are far more tenuous.

Or Clinton for that matter. Perhaps this is the start of the Murdoch Empire's campaign to re-elect Trump? But that's just me trying to make sense of it. I'm no psychiatrist.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 19:34

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:25

I know it is a recognised ethnicity but the indifference is probably a reflection of their youth and that it being a fight of their forefathers rather than your interpretation of it which would categorically not feature on their radar, it doesn't even feature on my DH's radar and he is 41!

I'm not interpreting anything, just reporting on lots of studies which demonstrate there's historically been a difference in the USA and UK with second, third generation (etc.) Irish ethnicity (explainer: it's one of my areas of research). I'd say that it has been changing in the USA as neighbourhoods are less ethnically specific in many cities now other than maybe for the first generation of certain migrant groups.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:25

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 19:16

That might be the case for your DCs but white Irish is a recognised ethnicity in the UK - it was introduced as a category on the census and other official records in 2001.

There have been a number of studies about how, while Irish-Americanism is 'passed down' as an identity, it's not the case in the UK so much with Irish-British, with studies showing that 'ethnic switching' from Irish to white British typically happening in the second generation. So basically USA and Britain have different histories of people identifying themselves as Irish or not. Some sociologists have characterised this as partly due to historic and maybe residual anti-Irishness in Britain but also white privilege. In general, Irish people have been more welcomed historically in the USA (well since later 19C) so Irish identity has more positive associations there.

Having lived for many years in both the UK and the USA, I have to say that this tallies with my experience in terms of anti-Irishness in the UK and pro-Irishness in the USA.

I know it is a recognised ethnicity but the indifference is probably a reflection of their youth and that it being a fight of their forefathers rather than your interpretation of it which would categorically not feature on their radar, it doesn't even feature on my DH's radar and he is 41!

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 19:16

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 18:59

Well authenticity matters for the point of this discussion as that is literally what The Times are satirising- Biden's presents of being Irish. My DC have a very Irish Surname unlike 'Biden' but they have no awareness of this being different, they are just from a country that happens to be named England. Tbf as southerners they don't relate to large parts of the country they belong to just like their friends and I think that level of indifference is probably a good thing.

That might be the case for your DCs but white Irish is a recognised ethnicity in the UK - it was introduced as a category on the census and other official records in 2001.

There have been a number of studies about how, while Irish-Americanism is 'passed down' as an identity, it's not the case in the UK so much with Irish-British, with studies showing that 'ethnic switching' from Irish to white British typically happening in the second generation. So basically USA and Britain have different histories of people identifying themselves as Irish or not. Some sociologists have characterised this as partly due to historic and maybe residual anti-Irishness in Britain but also white privilege. In general, Irish people have been more welcomed historically in the USA (well since later 19C) so Irish identity has more positive associations there.

Having lived for many years in both the UK and the USA, I have to say that this tallies with my experience in terms of anti-Irishness in the UK and pro-Irishness in the USA.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 19:00

Presentation not 'prensents'.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 18:59

Jewel1968 · 15/04/2023 18:44

@Goldenbear but why does it matter if he wants the whole world to know how he identifies?

Well authenticity matters for the point of this discussion as that is literally what The Times are satirising- Biden's presents of being Irish. My DC have a very Irish Surname unlike 'Biden' but they have no awareness of this being different, they are just from a country that happens to be named England. Tbf as southerners they don't relate to large parts of the country they belong to just like their friends and I think that level of indifference is probably a good thing.

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 18:53

Fimat · 15/04/2023 18:28

I’m sorry I didn’t mean to exclude people
of Irish heritage in the uk. My point was more about why certain media outlets were horrified about the slip up. I personally feel those outlets don’t have the right to be outraged about it as the Black and Tans brutally attacked Irish people not the other way around

Anyway. I personally loved the whole visit. I absolutely think being Irish American can be its own category same as Italian American, Asian American etc
They are absolutely welcome here to retrace their roots. The more the merrier.

I found the whole visit warm, dignified, hopeful and I was especially moved when coincidentally the priest who gave Beau Bidens his last rites was stationed to the church Biden visited . That was such a powerful reunion and connection.

I don’t imagine that bit of humanity got as much press in the UK.

Biden is due to make another state visit to the UK soon and I really don’t think our press will be so disdainful and immature.

I agree that it was a good visit - slightly messy between a couple of verbal slip-ups, Biden being late to almost every event and the sarky attitudes of so many British journalists.

But I think that in general Irish people do feel a connection to the diaspora, and it was pretty amazing to see Biden giving his speech at St Muredach's Cathedral in Ballina which his great-great-great-grandfather supplied bricks to in 1827, and as this article says "helped buy tickets for himself and his family to sail to America decades later in 1851."

I think tbh most Irish people are mildly bemused at Americans describing themselves as 'Irish' but understand that it's context-specific and of importance to many people's sense of identity. We generally take it in good humour and as not that big a deal, all the 'but he's not Irish' comments on this thread are 🙄. Given the historically huge rate of emigration from Ireland, Irish identity (as opposed to citizenship) is pretty elastic and I'd rather Biden and other Irish Americans' celebration of their identity far more than British leave-voters unseemly scramble for passports post-Brexit.

In Pictures: Ballina puts on a show as Biden enjoys emotional trip to Mayo

Joe Biden ended his trip with a speech at St Muredach’s Cathedral in Ballina.

https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-41117212.html

Jewel1968 · 15/04/2023 18:44

@Goldenbear but why does it matter if he wants the whole world to know how he identifies?

Fimat · 15/04/2023 18:28

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 14:27

1910s is a bit vague.

@DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry I do apologise. That was vague of me. I didn't think anyone else would be interested in my family history. For anyone who is, my father was born in Killarney in 1918. His father was in London, having left his pregnant wife and three children to get a job in the docks. It was known as a "ticket" and was much prized. The jobs were controlled by family ties and Irish family members already living in London had got it for him. It was a very good reason for leaving Ireland where secure work was harder to find.

Sometime after my father's birth, I think it was 1919 but forgive me for being vague on the details because my dad is no longer available for consultation, my grandfather sent for his wife and children. So they didn't have direct experience of the Black and Tans but they had family still living in Ireland who did. That would be my great grandparents and great aunts and uncles and people like that. Not my grandparents as I said. That was what's known as a slip of the tongue.

That's why I said to @Fimat that British people or people living in Britain of Irish descent, whatever you like to call us, would know who the Black and Tans were. There are quite a lot of us dotted around, especially in English cities like London and Liverpool and thereabouts whose forebears never made it to America.

I also know who the All Blacks are even though I've never been to a rugby match or indeed, New Zealand. Because I'm not interested in rugby I couldn't tell you if Ireland was doing better than England. Are they? If so, that's nice for Irish rugby fans.

Though I am of Irish descent, I'm not Irish and neither is Joe Biden. Though on the Biden Scale of Irishness, I'm a bit more Irish than him. But it's not a competition. He can be proud of his Irish heritage and talk about it as much as he likes. I'm truly happy for him. It's just unfortunate when he makes mistakes. It's funny though. I agree, the cartoon wasn't.

I’m sorry I didn’t mean to exclude people
of Irish heritage in the uk. My point was more about why certain media outlets were horrified about the slip up. I personally feel those outlets don’t have the right to be outraged about it as the Black and Tans brutally attacked Irish people not the other way around

Anyway. I personally loved the whole visit. I absolutely think being Irish American can be its own category same as Italian American, Asian American etc
They are absolutely welcome here to retrace their roots. The more the merrier.

I found the whole visit warm, dignified, hopeful and I was especially moved when coincidentally the priest who gave Beau Bidens his last rites was stationed to the church Biden visited . That was such a powerful reunion and connection.

I don’t imagine that bit of humanity got as much press in the UK.

Biden is due to make another state visit to the UK soon and I really don’t think our press will be so disdainful and immature.

lljkk · 15/04/2023 18:14

Joe Biden isn't really Irish, though, is he?

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 17:51

HouseByTheSeaside · 15/04/2023 17:22

I agree.

Except, it isn't just his business as he wants the whole world to know (literally) and for it to be everyone's business!

HouseByTheSeaside · 15/04/2023 17:22

Jewel1968 · 15/04/2023 10:02

Identity is complex. Why are people so bothered about Biden describing himself as Irish. Criticise him for his politics by all means but why criticise him for how he identifies? Why do people feel they can tell him (or anyone) how they should identify?

My kids are mixed race (their father is Black) and they routinely get asked "where are you from" followed by "where are you really from". They are not immediately seen as British. Their identity is their business just like Biden's identity is his business.

I agree.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 16:33

Sorry for any misunderstanding - you said he isn't Irish, and I said he is in terms of what 'Irish' means in the context of the Irish-American diaspora, Irish being shorthand for of Irish descent and raised in an Irish-American milieu.

@whatchaos no need to apologise. But Biden isn't Irish. If he was he couldn't be President of the United States.