Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the Peter Brookes cartoon of Joe Biden in the Times is pretty offensive towards Irish people?

262 replies

Hedwigharlot · 14/04/2023 13:42

The cartoon depicts him dressed as a leprechaun. It's like a depiction of Irish people from a Punch Magazine in the 19th century. Who thought it was appropriate? And why are the British media working themselves up into such a jealous frenzy over Biden coming to Ireland? Very poor behaviour.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
limitedperiodonly · 16/04/2023 19:38

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 16/04/2023 19:24

The EU is the third largest economy in the world, just after China, and Ireland is a member of the EU.

I don't dispute that. I didn't want to leave the EU but by a slim majority I had to. Everyone has to put up with things their fellow citizens vote for. What's your point?

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 16/04/2023 19:24

The EU is the third largest economy in the world, just after China, and Ireland is a member of the EU.

limitedperiodonly · 16/04/2023 18:01

@DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry I take your points but Ireland is a junior partner in their relationship to the USA. In what way is it not? Everyone is, apart from China. There is no shame in accepting that. You play the hand you are dealt and Ireland are doing it better than Britain at the moment.

As a country of immigrants who had a black President I'd also welcome a President of Chinese descent, but only as an abstract. Whoever is President of the United States doesn't affect me on a personal level. Even I was a US citizen, the fact he looked like me and shared the same faith and ethnic background wouldn't mean we thought the same things.

belleager · 16/04/2023 17:48

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 16/04/2023 17:38

I'd love to think the USA would elect a Chinese President, but given the carry-on about Obama, and that Biden is only the second Catholic ever, I don't think that's going to happen.

The relevance of Brexit is that although Ireland is a small country, albeit one that punches above its weight economically and diplomatically, it is also a member of the EU, and that is not a junior partner in its relationship with America.

Yes. And the whole notion that Ireland cannot benefit as a junior partner in a relationship makes no sense anyway. Ireland has benefited as smaller partner in trade with the UK, the EU, and the US for years. Small economies have their own advantages in these relationships - e.g. less need to prioritise a home manufacturing or extraction base.

Nobody in Ireland thinks that because Biden identifies as Irish, he will safeguard Ireland's interests forever. But a small economy cam position itself well to work with partners for mutual benefit.

I think that a lot of what the UK was sold around Brexit was about being bigger than the competition, not mutual benefit through cooperation. Junior partners have a range of options once they understand this. I think small countries are aware that they must be internationally facing. That doesn't mean reliant on any one power. I don't understand why so many posters on these threads feel the need to warn us that America will always prioritise America. We understand that. This is a business relationship!

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 16/04/2023 17:38

I'd love to think the USA would elect a Chinese President, but given the carry-on about Obama, and that Biden is only the second Catholic ever, I don't think that's going to happen.

The relevance of Brexit is that although Ireland is a small country, albeit one that punches above its weight economically and diplomatically, it is also a member of the EU, and that is not a junior partner in its relationship with America.

limitedperiodonly · 16/04/2023 17:27

whatchaos · 16/04/2023 00:40

Happy to explain - both my nephews won scholarships to an English public school, said they were Irish and then had potatoes thrown at them and nasty comments made in class about ireland

That's terrible. Clear racism and probably classism too. What did the school do about it? Has it been sorted out? Do your nephews still attend? Bullying is persistent and quite often schools want to brush it under the carpet for their image and also because they side with the bullies.

About my other comments. Like everyone, they can only ever be my own take on things. I have absolutely no ill will towards Ireland. I'm sure most Irish people realise as I do, that a weaker country can only ever be a very junior partner in their dealings with a stronger one and will be dropped at any moment.

The jibes about Brexit and Britain having no idea about Northern Ireland don't apply to me. I voted to Remain, and though not an expert, could see how having a land border with the EU coupled with that particular situation would be a problem. But they didn't ask me, did they? Having your government ride roughshod over you is a universal experience and we have to get on with it.

It's nice for Joe Biden to be able to talk about his Irish ancestry. And safe. Like Britain, Ireland is not a superpower. If he was of Chinese descent he might not make so much of it and make visits to the homeland of his forebears. Or if he did, it would be on a more formal basis.

Again, I don't blame Biden for this. We do what we can, which includes looking good to a home audience, or avoiding looking bad.

I can't remember who brought up the concept of soft power. I don't think it works. I believe it is a sop to keep us quiet about all sorts of abuses of power by more powerful people in our governments and others in a "you don't know what's doing on behind the scenes" kind of way.

In the specific context of Britain it's: "the Queen was really sad when we got rid of the Royal Yacht Britannia and of course it's okay for the Royal Family to squirrel away fabulous riches from foreign governments" kind of way. I entirely accept that it is a problem for the British people to solve and I don't think it the outcome will be what I want. That is my tragedy but this exists in other countries too in different ways. Or do you not agree?

whatchaos · 16/04/2023 10:21

ncfaily · 15/04/2023 22:42

America would like a more secure Atlantic for sure.

Yes, and although Ireland is a neutral country American planes were allowed refuel in Shannon on their way to the war in Iraq (there were protests)

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 16/04/2023 08:08

Ireland's relationship with America is partly down to long standing family ties, but also to Irish politicians, diplomats and business people working their socks off to build and maintain it.

Ireland is one of the top foreign direct investors in the USA - the country has a population of ca 5 million compared with the UK's 67 million, but our fdi in America is 50% of the UK's. Add in Germany, France and the rest of the EU and the UK is completely overshadowed. 'special relationship'? nah - 'those yanks love our monarch' really doesn't mean much.

whatchaos · 16/04/2023 00:40

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 21:16

So if push comes to shove @whatchaos what side do you think the US is going to come down on? Ireland is not important. The UK is not important. US presidents can use us to indulge their fantasies but come election time they are going to go for American votes and they'd run a mile from the suggestion they were influenced by outsiders.

That's how it should be. I'd be horrified if I discovered Rishi Sunak was favouring India over British interests because of family ties. I don't think that, btw. I have no idea about his views on India because he doesn't make a thing of them.

Re your anecdote about your nephews being pelted with potatoes. Can you expand? That sounds awful. I have lived in England above cover as a person of Irish descent all my nearly 60-year-old life and no one has ever made a spud joke much less thrown one. I can tell you about other insults, mainly about being thick and tarmacking or buying fertiliser for explosives but never about potatoes. Like references to the Black and Tans it's bit old. Is this a revival your nephews have identified?

Happy to explain - both my nephews won scholarships to an English public school, said they were Irish and then had potatoes thrown at them and nasty comments made in class about ireland

ncfaily · 15/04/2023 23:22

It's sad. The UK couldn't sort out its long-term economy and get ex-mining areas turned around, fund proper transport infrastructure, build some houses. It had decades after deindustrialisation to get sorted. But slid into Brexit instead, a coalition of thieves plus instant gratifiers wanting a sugar rush of saying no to free movement.

It's not looking well on it at the moment. Everything looks a bit decayed at the moment where I live - which is fine, the will of the people etc, entirely valid to choose to be poorer but have a sense of whatever it is.

But, there are implications for political stability in Ireland. Britain is often a good international citizen but it has some blind spots. A couple of years ago a colleague was spouting 'why should one small country be telling us what to do' online. I don't know, because there is a global community perhaps, and it's in Britain's interests to work well with its international partners.

Fimat · 15/04/2023 22:55

Chulainn · 15/04/2023 21:11

What I don't understand is why people are still making excuses for this depiction of Biden and his Irishness. Many Irish people on this thread have said they find it offensive. Instead of many accepting that, it seems there are loads of people excusing the offence by telling us that Biden isn't Irish, we shouldn't be offended, they aren't offended, we are misunderstanding what the cartoon is really about etc.

Whether anyone in the UK of Irish origin feels as Irish as Biden is irrelevant. He feels a deep connection to Ireland, exemplified by his trip to Mayo. He visited a hospice that is named for his son Beau, where he himself turned the sod when it was being built. He met, by accident not design, the priest who gave Beau his last rites. He was at a church one of his distant grandfathers helped build. It seemed like yesterday was very personal to Biden for many reasons, all connected to his family and Ireland.

We can speculate forever if Irish Americans should claim to feel Irish and there will be views on both sides. However, can we all please agree that this cartoon should not have been published as it has offended many Irish people (on and off this thread). Irish people should not have to explain why we are offended. It should be accepted. Arguing against that is offensive in itself.

Everything you’ve written here x1000000
Its just bizarre how offended people are.
I’m irish, my passport is Irish Joe Biden is American, his passport is American but he identifies as Irish American . So what???? That’s part of his family, their traditions and their stories that been handed down generation after generation. What’s the problem??

it just feels the problem is because it’s Ireland!
I’ve always seen the UK as a neighbour have many friends from there but something has shifted lately and this visit has highlighted it …

ncfaily · 15/04/2023 22:42

America would like a more secure Atlantic for sure.

Fimat · 15/04/2023 22:41

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 20:14

I’m sorry I didn’t mean to exclude people of Irish heritage in the uk
@Fimat really? Didn't you? Why didn't you notice us? Are you not aware of us? We are next door rather than three thousand miles away. Or are Irish American presidents more glamorous?

Wow…why so dramatic. I was talking generally about British Media. It’s been shown on here and obviously because of Brexit that the vast majority of English people have very knowledge of Irish history. If they really understood the complexities of NI then Brexit would not have happened. That was my point.
You’re taking my remarks extremely personally.
I’ve also had plenty of relations emigrate to the uk. Of course I know about the Irish diaspora there but I assumed wrongly that they’d know I wasn’t including them when I talk about British ignorance to the Black and Tans!

Abhannmor · 15/04/2023 22:25

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 20:24

The whole thing is so pathetically needy. Like the UK thinking we have a special relationship with the US. No we don't. They will ditch us when they feel like it. What makes the Irish think they are any different?

I think you are a bit confused. Nobody in Ireland is labouring under the misapprehension that we have a Special Relationship with the USA.

Stop projecting - as the yoof put it nowadays.

belleager · 15/04/2023 22:13

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 21:58

I'm always told how Britain has great soft power manifested in Queen Elizabeth II and now her son, Charles III. From where I'm sitting as a British subject I think the whole family are a bunch of freeloaders and it doesn't do me any good. Am I misguided? What soft power do you think Ireland enjoys that the US wouldn't pull in an instant if it suited them?

I don't know about the Queen - suspect she did add to Britain's soft power, and the Royal Family does, but it's up to British people whether they think that's worthwhile

You are right. America does not owe Ireland anything and should prioritise its own interests. Biden certainly will prioritise American interests. America knows that. There is no contradiction. If you look at Biden's speeches, they're partly about what makes Ireland a good place for American investment (and what doesn't). Irish soft power is a nice foundation for continuous cooperation, planning and investment. No guarantees. Very obviously worth continued attention as something beneficial to both countries. (Or we could say sorry, don't believe you, go and talk to Britain - no wait, Brexit - umm, France? Why would we do that?)

SpuytenDuyvil · 15/04/2023 22:02

PP saying that no Americans call themselves English-Americans is sort of true, unless they actually come from England. After all, we fought a revolt against the colonizers, i.e., the English. In part, there is a warm feeling of alliance toward the Irish (about 10% of the US population has Irish ancestry) since they are considered underdogs in perpetual rebellion against the English. And there is religion; Catholic immigrants (Irish, Italian, Polish, French, Spanish, etc.) were not accepted by the WASPs and were considered lower-class, so the underdog feeling exists there, too. That cartoon is rude.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 21:58

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 20:41

Exactly - and Ireland enjoys a lot of soft power in relation to the USA. St Patrick's Day is celebrated in the White House every year, and Irish politicians attend. For a small nation, it gives pretty enviable access to power. Biden has accepted an invitation from King Charles to visit the UK in the near future.

I'm always told how Britain has great soft power manifested in Queen Elizabeth II and now her son, Charles III. From where I'm sitting as a British subject I think the whole family are a bunch of freeloaders and it doesn't do me any good. Am I misguided? What soft power do you think Ireland enjoys that the US wouldn't pull in an instant if it suited them?

Chulainn · 15/04/2023 21:33

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 21:23

What I don't understand is why people are still making excuses for this depiction of Biden and his Irishness.

@Chulainn are they? I don't like the cartoon but Joe Biden isn't Irish, is he? If he was, he wouldn't be President of the USA, would he?

He considers his Irish heritage as important to him. Nobody has any right to say he can't feel like that, whether they understand it or not, or whether it's how they'd feel or not. Irrespective of that, the cartoon is offensive, which is the point of this thread.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 21:30

Oops, in the context of the Ireland conflict , the difference between the British and the Irish is not a good thing. Which part of London was that? That is unbelievably terrible! Tbf my DC just have an Irish surname they are not Irish, due to having a 16 year old and 12 year old, I am around teenagers quite a bit, I also do some work in a secondary school and we have not had Irish racism incidents. My eldest reads the news but that is a rarity amongst his peers, he certainly wouldn't know the significance of the potato. He asked my Dad about Ireland due to curiosity and whether he wants to study History A level and prior to my Dad's explanation he didn't know anything. My Dad was in The Hilton when the IRA bombed it so the conversation started from that point as a result of that tale.

belleager · 15/04/2023 21:25

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 21:23

What I don't understand is why people are still making excuses for this depiction of Biden and his Irishness.

@Chulainn are they? I don't like the cartoon but Joe Biden isn't Irish, is he? If he was, he wouldn't be President of the USA, would he?

He could be president of the US with dual citizenship in fact. He's not an Irish citizen, though. He's a man with a strong Irish heritage.

What's your point? I don't get it. Depicting Irishness this way is offensive whether Biden or anyone else is Irish or not.

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 21:23

What I don't understand is why people are still making excuses for this depiction of Biden and his Irishness.

@Chulainn are they? I don't like the cartoon but Joe Biden isn't Irish, is he? If he was, he wouldn't be President of the USA, would he?

belleager · 15/04/2023 21:22

Coolhwip · 15/04/2023 21:12

I agree the cartoon is offensive. I hope the people who are saying the Bidencartoon is racist stood in solidarity with Muslims who were offended by the cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed.

I would, yes. But that doesn't make this cartoon more or less offensive. People are entitled to find it offensive without being involved in other debates.

Goldenbear · 15/04/2023 21:21

whatchaos · 15/04/2023 20:35

Not sure what you mean - difference isn't always about prejudice.
My teenage nephews in London were certainly shocked by having potatoes thrown at them in school when they described themselves as Irish.

But in the conte

limitedperiodonly · 15/04/2023 21:16

So if push comes to shove @whatchaos what side do you think the US is going to come down on? Ireland is not important. The UK is not important. US presidents can use us to indulge their fantasies but come election time they are going to go for American votes and they'd run a mile from the suggestion they were influenced by outsiders.

That's how it should be. I'd be horrified if I discovered Rishi Sunak was favouring India over British interests because of family ties. I don't think that, btw. I have no idea about his views on India because he doesn't make a thing of them.

Re your anecdote about your nephews being pelted with potatoes. Can you expand? That sounds awful. I have lived in England above cover as a person of Irish descent all my nearly 60-year-old life and no one has ever made a spud joke much less thrown one. I can tell you about other insults, mainly about being thick and tarmacking or buying fertiliser for explosives but never about potatoes. Like references to the Black and Tans it's bit old. Is this a revival your nephews have identified?

Coolhwip · 15/04/2023 21:12

DandyMandy · 14/04/2023 15:03

This website itself is extremely anti-Irish yet it never gets called out on here. People would be outraged if a cartoon like that was aimed at blacks and Asians, but of course it's okay because Irish people are white. The British are whipping themselves up into a frenzy because they're obsessed with the Irish and always have been.

I agree the cartoon is offensive. I hope the people who are saying the Bidencartoon is racist stood in solidarity with Muslims who were offended by the cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed.