Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jeremy Vine - people are morally obliged to downsize and free up property

668 replies

JoanThursday1972 · 14/04/2023 12:17

Currently have this on the radio. Suggestion is that people are not entitled to remain in and live in the house that they have bought and paid for. That they should downsize and free this up for more deserving occupants, ie families.

This is surely a personal choice and not an obligation? Anyone is entitled to live in a house they have bought, regardless of size.

OP posts:
Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 14:25

I was confused by your ridiculous leap. I never said that you should have to down size from social housing nor did I imply that. You are the proof that common sense and brains are two different things. Social housing should be for those with the greatest need and should be the most subsidised. They don't have to become ghettos. Once people are back on their feet they should move to reasonably price private rentals or buy to free up social housing for people with the greatest need/ who are more vulnerable. Some people will always need social housing because of their personal situation but many wont. The government should have a duty to ensure there is adequate social housing stock and that that there are affordable rents in the private sector available. Do you have a problem with those who have the greatest need being prioritised by the government for housing?

clopper · 15/04/2023 14:25

comptesse
retirement complexes which allow for residents to live completely independently in their own apartments whilst they are relatively able, but then able to access on site support gradually as they need it, and then ultimately live in care if they end up needing that.

This is what my parents have done. They moved out of choice before they became more frail and other people had to make choices for them. They have such a great active social life with people of their own age. I would definitely do this at an older age if I get the chance.

Jonei · 15/04/2023 14:18

We are talking about houses that people own and pay for themselves here. On what basis is the government going to intervene to say ‘no. You aren’t allowed to have that.’?

The government isnt going to dare try and do that. Along with trying to tax people so highly so highly they can no longer stay in the property that they have bought and paid for. Because that really is against the law.

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 14:09

@Socrateswasrightaboutvoting Proof that common sense and brains are two different things. You know damn well that you were saying there should be a time limit on people living in social housing. Sorry that its now unpalatable to you that what you were suggesting is a welfarised ambulance type service. Which will turn estates into ghettos. Ah but then people like you can have a group you can feel superior to.

YY @KimberleyClark no one would suggest they move. Have living proof that you have had sex without contraception and you wont be expected to move.

SquidwardBound · 15/04/2023 14:03

I’m pretty sure the British public won’t actually be up for that though. Not least because it would mean the ‘deserving’ families are all paying huge property taxes too.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 14:00

SquidwardBound · 15/04/2023 13:46

Where exactly are people planning to draw the line on ‘too much space’? Are people allowed a spare bedroom? What if they WFH and use it as an office?

What about the public rooms? Is it acceptable for people to have a dining room if there’s a kitchen table too? What about people with something as luxurious as a playroom?

Who is going to decide this shit?

We are talking about houses that people own and pay for themselves here. On what basis is the government going to intervene to say ‘no. You aren’t allowed to have that.’?

By taxing the hell out of you so that you can't afford to stay there and have to downsize to some miserable unsuitable accommodation and the home that you worked hard for goes to someone more 'deserving'. How dare you expect to enjoy the fruits of your labour, for which you have paid an insane amount of interest and have paid tax on the money to buy, and continue to pay tax (effectively a bedroom tax) for. <<sigh>>

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 13:48

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 13:45

@Socrateswasrightaboutvoting Then you have no right to moan about social housing estates becoming ghettos because that is the result when social housing becomes a welfarised ambulance type service.

Oh and as for hard working parents. Parenthood is a choice or it was the last time i checked.

I live in a ONE bedroom social housing flat and am childfree by choice. Might be a surprise to you but its not only the more well off who decide to remain child free I suppose you expect me to downsize to a garden shed.

I have no idea what you are talking about.

SquidwardBound · 15/04/2023 13:46

Where exactly are people planning to draw the line on ‘too much space’? Are people allowed a spare bedroom? What if they WFH and use it as an office?

What about the public rooms? Is it acceptable for people to have a dining room if there’s a kitchen table too? What about people with something as luxurious as a playroom?

Who is going to decide this shit?

We are talking about houses that people own and pay for themselves here. On what basis is the government going to intervene to say ‘no. You aren’t allowed to have that.’?

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 13:45

@Socrateswasrightaboutvoting Then you have no right to moan about social housing estates becoming ghettos because that is the result when social housing becomes a welfarised ambulance type service.

Oh and as for hard working parents. Parenthood is a choice or it was the last time i checked.

I live in a ONE bedroom social housing flat and am childfree by choice. Might be a surprise to you but its not only the more well off who decide to remain child free I suppose you expect me to downsize to a garden shed.

KimberleyClark · 15/04/2023 13:30

Lots of people with kids have more space than they need. I have a relative who lives with partner and one child in a three storey, five bedroom two bathroom Victorian townhouse, but I bet no one would suggest they move to a three bed semi.

JudgeJ · 15/04/2023 13:13

Tax on assets should be increased and on income reduced. Especially inheritance tax which is a bit of a joke really.

So those who have worked hard, saved money and provided their family with a good home should be responsible for funding the benefit recipients? The reason that so many of we boomers are where we are today is because we lived within our means and that included procreating.

MavisMcMinty · 15/04/2023 13:12

When my Mum died my Dad talked about selling their lovely 4-bed house “so another family can enjoy it”. I pointed out he’ll still need 3 bedrooms - one for him, one for his study, and one for me/my brother/anyone else coming to stay.

More importantly, he’d miss the community of the cul-de-sac he lives in, where everyone knows everyone else and looks out for one another. My Mum had dementia and was always disappearing, trying to get “home” to Ireland from their house in Hertfordshire - the whole street used to mount impromptu search parties. Most streets in modern Britain aren’t like that.

He was persuaded not to move!

(It’s also recommended that we don’t make life-changing decisions within a year of bereavement.)

JudgeJ · 15/04/2023 13:08

WarmWinterSun · 14/04/2023 21:15

Just to add- I live on a nice street with: one elderly woman in a 6 bedroom house, one elderly woman in a 4 bedroom house, one couple in a five bedroom house, one man in a 5 bedroom house, one couple in a 5 bedroom house, and two other families in 4-5 bedroom houses. It’s like this in all the nice parts of my city with mostly elderly couples or widows/widowers living in the larger houses. The families I know with school ages children are crammed into very modest and small homes. It makes me really angry.

Can these people who pop out sprogs regularly afford to buy the aforementioned properties or do they expect to get them for almost nothing from these awful people?

JudgeJ · 15/04/2023 13:03

you’ll only get them out by taxing them out. Ie a bedroom tax for private properties

You do realise that council tax is partially predicated on bedrooms and hence they're already contributing towards local facilities?

LemonPledge555 · 15/04/2023 13:02

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 15/04/2023 12:12

Im with you... I think he really believes that he haa in 'in depth discussion'...

In reality... The depth of a shallow puddle!

I used to just listen along and ignore most of it, it was interesting at times. Then one day he did a piece about something I happen to know a lot about, and I realised what an absolute waste of space he and the show are. It wasn’t balanced at all and it made me think about all the other shit he and his callers and “experts” have quoted, and gradually I just stopped listening to his show. And now I have dumped radio 2 completely 😂

ifIwerenotanandroid · 15/04/2023 12:58

Sarahconnor1 · 14/04/2023 21:19

Of course they should downsize (although I have sympathy for the lack of suitable housing). They are an utterly selfish generation.

But if there is no suitable housing, where are they going to downsize to. Its easy to give 'boomers' a kicking for all societies ills but they can't move if there is nowhere for them to move to.

This 'call them boomers, then we can demonise them as selfish & having had it easy all their lives' is rubbish & dangerous. From my viewpoint, younger adults fall for it through ignorance of the past.

Don't they realise that this is how things have always been? In the 1960s & 70s I knew personally, or was aware of, plenty of people living on their own or as a couple in houses, bungalows or apartments which today would be characterised as being too big for their needs. One old lady I knew lived in a modest terrace house but only used the ground floor due to a health condition. Some people were in houses they'd raised their family in. Other people were simply wealthy enough to buy whatever they wanted.

And so what? It's a free country. This is the way it's always been. And there's always been talk of a housing shortage.

We bought our house in the 1980s. We're still here, just the two of us, same as it ever was. It still suits our needs. But suddenly we're 'utterly selfish'.

And far from having it easy all our lives, neither my husband nor I inherited anything or had any help financially from our families or from anyone else. What we've got, we worked for, starting out with precisely, literally, nothing. My family were so appalling that they made me homeless when I was recovering from a serious illness. I had to shift for myself & get a job & somewhere to live when I should have been convalescing. If that's the sort of luxury life these offensive young adults envy, they can have it.

What younger adults today are seeing is those of us who survived the vagaries of life & managed to get what we wanted through our own hard graft. They don't see the graft, because they weren't alive then. They don't understand people's lives, or social history. They're easy to manipulate by governments who like to divide & conquer. Previously it's been benefit scroungers, the disabled, refugees & immigrants who've been 'the enemy' who are doing you down. Now it's the older generation. Don't fall for it.

notacooldad · 15/04/2023 12:26

Im on the verge of up sizing. The kids have left home. Ive always wanted a large detached wuth a ig garden. Ive got more spare money han ive ever had so its now or never. There will be just me and Dh.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 12:20

GasPanic · 15/04/2023 11:27

This really.

Cash should flow towards people who work hard and are productive in society not people who sit on assets.

Tax on assets should be increased and on income reduced. Especially inheritance tax which is a bit of a joke really.

People aren't sitting on assets when it's their only home. Everyone needs a place to live - you either rent or buy. Taxing income is the fairest system - Why should someone be penalised for spending money on bricks and mortar, furniture tradesmen, and gardeners, rather than the handbags and holidays. This country is in the state it is in because of a lack of critical thinking skills and an attitude of entitlement to the fruits of other peoples labour.

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 15/04/2023 12:16

DemelzaandRoss · 14/04/2023 12:50

My owned property, my choice.
As far as I know the UK is still a reasonably democratic country.
Nobody has any right to force me to downsize.
Naturally, being a country of free speech also, people are entitled to their own opinions.
My own opinion is that it is not morally wrong. Houses are homes, not investments. I have free will to do what is best for myself & my family. There is no place for state intervention.

I draw the opposite conclusion. Housing policy shouldn’t be pushed onto the individual conscience. It won’t work.
We need a national strategy because the situation for the young is rather desperate.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 15/04/2023 12:12

LemonPledge555 · 14/04/2023 14:28

YABU firstly for listening to that antagonistic and inflammatory AWFUL man who generally knows piss all detail of what he’s talking about.

Secondly YABU for even considering it’s enforceable.

We are a family of 3 in a 4 bed house that’s on the large side. We use all the rooms. Do we need to sell up?

absolute claptrap and BBCR2 sadly scraping the bottom of the barrel for segments for JV. I’ve stopped listening to R2 and threads like this make me glad o have.

Im with you... I think he really believes that he haa in 'in depth discussion'...

In reality... The depth of a shallow puddle!

Whisper23 · 15/04/2023 12:08

Cash should flow towards people who work hard and are productive in society not people who sit on assets. Tax on assets should be increased and on income reduced. Especially inheritance tax which is a bit of a joke really

So once people reach a certain age they should be punished with higher taxes for no longer being "productive" in society? Despite having "worked hard" and paid income tax throughout their working life? Reckon you'll feel differently about that one you reach that age.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 15/04/2023 11:58

I find it such a weird idea to "just" downsize. I spent at least 20k on the garden so it would be exactly what I want it to be, all building work on the house is done with the idea in mind that we want good quality (so the dearer option) because we want to stay in this house. It's not like you can get the same quality by downsizing, you'd have to start over! Oh, and since covid our extra bedrooms are offices... that did come in handy when we were told to stay away from other people.

Exactly!

DorritLittle · 15/04/2023 11:43

My mum lives in a large house. Living there she feels surrounded by nice memories. We can all stay when we visit. She is ten minutes from a High Street, station and buses. She has an active life because of this.

She has actually looked around for a smaller house within her budget, but she can’t find anything in such a handy location that she would also want to live in.

Why should she feel morally obliged to move somewhere less convenient?

SquidwardBound · 15/04/2023 11:28

I actually think it would be better to have far more emphasis in the tax system on income. Fewer of the taxes that come out of already taxes income, and which have a disproportionate affect on lower earners.

And target taxes at the points where people have gained wealth. Stamp duty, for example, should really be paid by the seller rather than the buyer, and may be more sensibly calculated as a percentage the increase in house price since they bought it to this point of sale. It is ludicrous that the buyer is the one being taxed.

GasPanic · 15/04/2023 11:27

proppy · 15/04/2023 10:28

I phrased it badly as i'm in rush. I believe there should be more balance in the tax system, as in there is too much weighted on income. I can see where care workers may be less then thrilled that they work for a shitty wage, can't afford secure housing but the person they are helping gets to pass on 1m of housing wealth or more if they have navigated the system but gets care, gets to retire earlier & gets free prescriptions etc. Those things are not going to be available for todays workers at the same age. We need a functioning health care system, social care system, emergency support etc. Everyone is going to need to pay more & because of the population dynamic shift it's not sustainable to target just workers.

This really.

Cash should flow towards people who work hard and are productive in society not people who sit on assets.

Tax on assets should be increased and on income reduced. Especially inheritance tax which is a bit of a joke really.