Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jeremy Vine - people are morally obliged to downsize and free up property

668 replies

JoanThursday1972 · 14/04/2023 12:17

Currently have this on the radio. Suggestion is that people are not entitled to remain in and live in the house that they have bought and paid for. That they should downsize and free this up for more deserving occupants, ie families.

This is surely a personal choice and not an obligation? Anyone is entitled to live in a house they have bought, regardless of size.

OP posts:
DyslexicPoster · 15/04/2023 20:28

If you taxed under occupancy in private ownership, where is the incentive to better yourself? When the kids leave home I would decide my assets up on a forced downsize if a house I worked hard to own. There wouldn't be much incentive for me to keep on working hard. In fact I wouldn't pay off the mortgage. There wouldn't be the incentive too.

Blossomtoes · 15/04/2023 20:10

Zipps · 15/04/2023 18:39

tailinthejam
"Selling your home to downsize, and then spending the money (or giving it to family) is frowned upon"
By who? Certain posters on MN? Because that is exactly what we have done and are early retiring and merrily spending the equity that was left over ie our own money 🤑.
Regards your solicitor comment, when we made our will, we had a lengthy and very helpful discussion with our solicitors regarding avoiding care home fees and IHT.

By local authorities which assess financial entitlement to residential care. They can and do go back decades and, according to our solicitor, there’s no foolproof way round it. We think it only right that we should pay care home fees if necessary so we weren’t interested anyway.

Changechangechanging · 15/04/2023 20:01

Ridiculous to have one person living in a 4 bedroom house.We should be taxing this type of situation much more heavily so that it incentivises people to move to an appropriate dwelling

Then you need to guarantee people that there will be a suitable property to down size to eg. without stairs, a lift in communal areas, use of well kept gardens....and you also need to make sure that such accommodation is affordable and exists in areas that people want to move to. I am.in my 50s and have begun looking but so far haven't seen anything that represents value for money and which is located somewhere I want to live. The sheer cost of moving with a legal fees, stamp duty etc is a huge issue even if suitable property is available.

larry55 · 15/04/2023 19:25

We down sized from a 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 3 storey Edwardian house in the S.E. and moved to a 3 bedroom detached house in the S.W. We were able to adapt our new home with equity from the sale of our large house so we now have a walk in shower instead of a bath, a downstairs loo and have converted the kitchen dining room into a separate dining room so that if the worst happens we could make the dining room into a bedroom. We also have a straight staircase so we could install a stair lift. We have looked for a bungalow in the area but this would cost us much more than we would get for selling this house.

We would not like to move from this area as our daughter lives near by and we look after our grandson so that she can work.

We were fortunate to be able to do this when we retired but it was a big decision to leave our friends and family to move to a completely new area which a lot of older people would not want to do.

ArcticSkewer · 15/04/2023 19:23

proppy · 15/04/2023 18:50

Regards your solicitor comment, when we made our will, we had a lengthy and very helpful discussion with our solicitors regarding avoiding care home fees and IHT.

why is everyone so desperate to avoid care home fees? Aren't you scared by what the provision will look like when you may need it?

Have you had any experience with care homes? You can pay a fortune and still get absolutely appalling care, can't complain about it, have basically no rights at all. Or you can be council funded - same, same.

proppy · 15/04/2023 18:50

Regards your solicitor comment, when we made our will, we had a lengthy and very helpful discussion with our solicitors regarding avoiding care home fees and IHT.

why is everyone so desperate to avoid care home fees? Aren't you scared by what the provision will look like when you may need it?

Zipps · 15/04/2023 18:39

tailinthejam
"Selling your home to downsize, and then spending the money (or giving it to family) is frowned upon"
By who? Certain posters on MN? Because that is exactly what we have done and are early retiring and merrily spending the equity that was left over ie our own money 🤑.
Regards your solicitor comment, when we made our will, we had a lengthy and very helpful discussion with our solicitors regarding avoiding care home fees and IHT.

tailinthejam · 15/04/2023 17:31

DeeHellem · 15/04/2023 14:33

Still don't understand the relevance of your Wills comment in relation to downsizing.

What's CGT got to do with it?

Downsizing and spending your wealth is very different from downsizing to gift it away.

Still don't understand? Never mind.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/04/2023 15:50

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 15:37

The housing manager sat in our living room back in 2017 and told us there was absolutely no adapted housing available.

i let out an adapted flat that was my GPs. When my Nana went into a care home someone we know asked if we’d consider renting it as she’d been told she’d have a year wait for adapted housing. She was a tenant for several years. When she moved the housing officer asked if we’d consider someone else “short term”. They were a tenant for nigh on 9 years.

We’re now on the fourth round of the local council saying “we’d like to buy the property” but I have no doubt it’ll fall through again - every time we go through it, they agree the price, and then they say “sorry budget doesn’t allow”.

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 15:37

The housing manager sat in our living room back in 2017 and told us there was absolutely no adapted housing available.

megletthesecond · 15/04/2023 15:33

There's no point downsizing if there's no potential space for a wet room, stairlift, ramp access to front door and back garden and a spare room for a carer / family to stay. Larger homes can accommodate these adaptations.

Lionoso · 15/04/2023 15:27

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/04/2023 15:22

There isn't much point in downsizing to another double storey house.

So many new builds have super narrow stairs or curved stairs as well which doesn’t help.

When DH’s granny downsized she did move into a double storey place, but it had a lovely wide straight staircase and a stairlift was an easy option if needed.

I’ve beeb viewing houses with his aunt recently and there’s been none that would work (she’s not needing it but was thinking ahead).

Yes really narrow stairs or tiny landings that you would struggle to put a stair lift in. Also very narrow room dimensions that would make it tricky to manoeuvre a wheelchair in.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 15/04/2023 15:22

There isn't much point in downsizing to another double storey house.

So many new builds have super narrow stairs or curved stairs as well which doesn’t help.

When DH’s granny downsized she did move into a double storey place, but it had a lovely wide straight staircase and a stairlift was an easy option if needed.

I’ve beeb viewing houses with his aunt recently and there’s been none that would work (she’s not needing it but was thinking ahead).

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 15:22

Well i dont know about anyone else but i wouldnt be spunking money on decorating a place i would be forced to move out of a couple of years later

Busybody2022 · 15/04/2023 15:17

No they shouldn't and neither should council/HA tenants which is a very unpopular opinion.

Jonei · 15/04/2023 15:13

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 14:28

A mansion tax has been mooted by political parties previously and universities have been commissioned to investigate how a wealth tax might work, where wealth might include the value of the home you live in as well any pensions, savings and any other assets.

They might be exploring how it might work. But it needs to fit within the law. And charging people to live in their properties that they already own will not fit into that.

Lionoso · 15/04/2023 15:08

I have a chronic health condition that will worsen with time. I have been looking for a bungalow that will suit me when I get older. I have been looking for a long time now. There just aren't any. Old existing ones are bought at way over reasonable prices due to the demand for them. And despite loads of new housing estates being built near me, there are zero bungalows being built.

There isn't much point in downsizing to another double storey house.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 14:52

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 14:36

@Socrateswasrightaboutvoting

www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-rise-and-fall-of-council-housing-56139the welfarisation of council housing.

By John Boughton the author of Municipal Dreams The Rise and fall of Council Housing

In the 1980s, residualisation may have been a partly unintended consequence of housing policies pursued with varying ideological intent.

Since 2010, and more so since the return of single-party Conservative government in 2015, we’ve seen something further: welfarisation – ‘a conception of social housing as a very small, highly residualised sector catering only for the very poorest, and those with additional social “vulnerabilities”, on a short-term “ambulance” basis

So the conservatives are doing something similar, very badly. That's a shocker - Not! IME it's something which could be planned and executed well as part of a much larger solution for tackling the effects of poverty and improving outcomes. Just because it is being done badly at the moment doesn't mean that it can't be done well. I would like to see well thought out solutions for a change not sticking plasters or distraction strategies which pit one section of the public against another.

pigsDOfly · 15/04/2023 14:47

Thesharkradar · 15/04/2023 14:38

@pigsDOfly
Things like clothes and cars can't be compared to property, partly due to the way in which property appreciates in value whereas clothes and cars (with the exception of a few vintage examples) do not

@Thesharkradar

I wasn't comparing them, I was making a somewhat 'tongue in cheek' observation that if someone buys something it belongs to them and they need feel no obligation or pressure to give it up because someone else might want it.

Thesharkradar · 15/04/2023 14:38

@pigsDOfly
Things like clothes and cars can't be compared to property, partly due to the way in which property appreciates in value whereas clothes and cars (with the exception of a few vintage examples) do not

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 14:36

@Socrateswasrightaboutvoting

www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-rise-and-fall-of-council-housing-56139the welfarisation of council housing.

By John Boughton the author of Municipal Dreams The Rise and fall of Council Housing

In the 1980s, residualisation may have been a partly unintended consequence of housing policies pursued with varying ideological intent.

Since 2010, and more so since the return of single-party Conservative government in 2015, we’ve seen something further: welfarisation – ‘a conception of social housing as a very small, highly residualised sector catering only for the very poorest, and those with additional social “vulnerabilities”, on a short-term “ambulance” basis

The Rise and Fall of Council Housing

To mark its paperback release, we are republishing an extract from acclaimed history book Municipal Dreams: the rise and fall of council housing. Here, author John Boughton explains how council housing became ’welfarised’

https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-rise-and-fall-of-council-housing-56139

Thesharkradar · 15/04/2023 14:36

This is a big, complex and very thorny issue 😬

pigsDOfly · 15/04/2023 14:36

It's a odd concept that someone who has bought and paid for something, ie their own home, should be required to move out and sell it to a, younger, different sort of family, who is all probability couldn't afford it anyway, because in someone's view 'that's only fair'.

We're not in a communist country, no one can take legally acquired property from anyone.

Where do we draw the line here.

I drive a car that has seating for another four people but there is only one of me. Should I be required to sell it and buy a smaller car, perhaps a two seater, because surely, I don't need to drive around with that much space behind me and there might very well be a family with three children who is finding it hard to fit all their car seats in the back of their current car and there would be room in mine.

Do we limit the amount of clothes anyone can own, because you can only wear one outfit at a time, and those trousers might be needed by someone more deserving or someone they would fit better.

If someone buys a home they're entitled to live in it until they die. They have no moral or social obligation to give it up for anyone else to live in and if it's falling apart when they die, so be it. It's their home, bought with their own money.

DeeHellem · 15/04/2023 14:33

tailinthejam · 15/04/2023 11:14

We are currently in a situation where DH and I are re-jigging our wills, and rearranging who owns what (including a proportion of an inherited property). We had a meeting with a solicitor the other day, who went into all sorts of details regarding the best way to redistribute our assets to minimise how much in the way of care home fees could be taken in future. We are in our 60's and from what the solicitor said, it is far from straightforward. Selling your home to downsize, and then spending the money (or giving it to family) is frowned upon, and can be considered to be an intentional deprivation of assets.

Still don't understand the relevance of your Wills comment in relation to downsizing.

What's CGT got to do with it?

Downsizing and spending your wealth is very different from downsizing to gift it away.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 14:28

Jonei · 15/04/2023 14:18

We are talking about houses that people own and pay for themselves here. On what basis is the government going to intervene to say ‘no. You aren’t allowed to have that.’?

The government isnt going to dare try and do that. Along with trying to tax people so highly so highly they can no longer stay in the property that they have bought and paid for. Because that really is against the law.

A mansion tax has been mooted by political parties previously and universities have been commissioned to investigate how a wealth tax might work, where wealth might include the value of the home you live in as well any pensions, savings and any other assets.