Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jeremy Vine - people are morally obliged to downsize and free up property

668 replies

JoanThursday1972 · 14/04/2023 12:17

Currently have this on the radio. Suggestion is that people are not entitled to remain in and live in the house that they have bought and paid for. That they should downsize and free this up for more deserving occupants, ie families.

This is surely a personal choice and not an obligation? Anyone is entitled to live in a house they have bought, regardless of size.

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 16/04/2023 19:20

I will be totally honest- I think plenty of older couples still want space and gardens etc because in all honesty they don't want to be trapped with a grumpy bugger for long periods of time in a small space and with few rooms- !

diflasu · 16/04/2023 19:14

What's the point of spacious living room, unless you hugely entertain.

Proven* *very useful to fit the hospital bed downstairs and the hoist currently needed and the walking frame that and downstairs loo meant my parent has managed to leave hospital and stay in their own home.

My DGP I think made the space because they did enjoy entertaining well into their late 80s.

Our current house has a two rooms that could be knocked though - and many on estate have - but with five of us having two smaller downstairs rooms works very well for us. IL have similar with with wall removed and draw curtains across in winter but like the space rest of the year especially now retired and in the house much more.

lljkk · 16/04/2023 19:04

Thread is about downsizing after the (now adult) children have moved out, so why need a large living room after adult children moved out.

Swiftbushome · 16/04/2023 18:56

Well if you have a family then there's space for the kids to play while one parent is for example doing the ironing and the other is watching the TV? Makes sense to me. If love a big loving room

lljkk · 16/04/2023 18:49

What's the point of spacious living room, unless you hugely entertain. It's just empty space to heat, otherwise.

Nice view, cute garden, natural light, I understand merits of those. But ... big living room? Why.

Whisper23 · 16/04/2023 18:44

@Swiftbushome it's not that I think it's fine for a couple and 2 kids to live in an overcrowded house, more that I think it's not my responsibility to make sure they're adequately housed.

Swiftbushome · 16/04/2023 18:37

God this thread is so depressing. Of course people are under no obligation to move from their homes that they bought with their own money, but the attitude that they are horrified at even the thought of living with a bedroom plus a spare and a slightly smaller lounge plus maybe a smaller garden. And that they could not possibly entertain the indignity of living like that, but thinking it's totally fine for a couple and their 2 kids to live in the exact same property (but with twice the people) and that's totally fine, is something else.

PleaseJustText · 16/04/2023 17:12

If you put a minimum price on the filters you tend to find the houses with more square footage regardless of bedrooms. When we started house hunting we found a perfect 2-bed house with loads of living space downstairs and a massive garden. Sadly the seller took it off the market and we haven't found anything like it. Our search is still set to a price bracket without a limit on bedrooms.

Crikeyalmighty · 16/04/2023 15:52

@LolaSmiles Yep you are so right- we nearly didn't look at our current very lovely rental house as I had my Rightmove set to4 beds, as although only 2 of us now at home my H uses a ton of space for work which usually means we need 2 smaller bedrooms , plus a guest room, plus 1 for us- whereas our house now is 3 proper doubles (1 of which we use as a store room as has all built in wardrobes plus room for luggage, Xmas tree, cost tracks etc, plus a big lounge, big kitchen , conservatory and a totally converted garage joined to house, with power, proper central heating, light, patio doors etc- that he uses for work - and they correctly marketed it as a 3 bedder- luckily the agent knew what we were after and called me - I advise anyone not to just go on bedrooms , but look at floor plans or square footage etc- most agents oversell, but in our case the agent could easily have sold it as a 4 bedder

LolaSmiles · 16/04/2023 15:29

We do seem to sell on bedroom numbers not total square footage like I think the USA does and I agree it why IL and DP didn't end up moving because they didn't want less living space downstairs
We found that when house hunting.
Lots of properties were awkwardly extended to get an extra bedroom that wasn't usable, or a second reception room was added downstairs and the house was marketed as a 5/6 bedroomed house with the mark up

Really they were badly extended houses by people with limited budgets who focused more on the £££ they thought would come their way by being able to argue it's a 5 bedroom house.

Square footage would be a much better way of selling in my opinion and it would lend itself more to people making sensible renovations for their space/budget too.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 16/04/2023 15:28

Londre · 16/04/2023 14:24

Nope. This is my forever home, privately owned and only DH & I live in our home which has four bedrooms (the cat also has one - does that count as “occupied”?)

I have checked with our feline over-lord, aka CatBastard, who is currently in his bedroom, and he says it definitely counts as occupied, @Londre.

Crikeyalmighty · 16/04/2023 15:20

@SquidwardBound Yep my FIL has exactly the same issue -apart from the fact he doesn't like where it is- it was very much chosen by his partner to be bear get family, who has since died.

He isn't keen on the idea of buying a flat- due to leaseholds- I think he would sell up and rent one though 'if' he could get the security- but rentals through the specialists like McCarthy stone are extortionate! And standard private rentals - well you don't wont to be doing multiple moves in your 80s!!

I think some retired complexes but built to rent , low rise and with no service charges to tenants would actually do really well. Slightly higher rents to reflect getting windows cleaned, gardens tended, lifts maintained etc reflected in price but no need for 'care' etc or vast lounges and all the stuff that create £800 a month service charges in many if these owner occupied complexes

Small Bungalows are really not easy to find in good order in some areas- and hence are often very overpriced

diflasu · 16/04/2023 15:11

my parents decided not to downsize because what they were looking for - fewer bedrooms but with a spacious living room and large kitchen/diner - is not that easy to find.

One set of DGP lived in a house like that - huge downstairs space but two upstairs bedrooms not that large either- they did the layout planning in 60s when they still had two teens at home and it was their forever house.

It was sold after their deaths - I think with a view of doing up and selling on in a few years which did happen- first thing done was roof reconfiguration/layout to squeeze another bedroom in.

We do seem to sell on bedroom numbers not total square footage like I think the USA does and I agree it why IL and DP didn't end up moving because they didn't want less living space downstairs.

SquidwardBound · 16/04/2023 14:57

There really isn’t an abundance of the kind of housing downsizers would be looking for in this country.

my parents decided not to downsize because what they were looking for - fewer bedrooms but with a spacious living room and large kitchen/diner - is not that easy to find. Especially when you factor in that they would have to completely redecorate something and their furniture may not fit the smaller space. Added to that is the loss of the garden they’ve been tending for 35 years and the location and community they’ve been a part of for 45 years.

Small houses in the uk tend to be small in every way. People who’ve lived in houses for 45 years (or 75 even) don’t necessarily want to live in a block of flats with all that comes with that. The thought of moving to an old person specific development does not appeal to a lot of people in any way.

There have to be much better options to make all the upheaval of moving and setting up a new home worthwhile. Demonising a generation of people because they haven’t conveniently vacated the homes you want to have instead is unfair.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 16/04/2023 14:56

Starchipenterprise · 14/04/2023 13:30

The term 'Boomer' is unacceptable - reporting this.

It's not so much the term but that it is used as an insult - and by people who don't have the intelligence to realise that just because someone is of a particular age group it doesn't mean they have been in the fortunate economic position to have made financial gains due to previous housing markets - and nor does everyone of that age have a 'gold plated pension'.

DannyZukosSmile · 16/04/2023 14:53

Getting a bit tired of the same old tired attack on the 'boomers' to be honest. Not EVERY boomer had it 'easy' and had everything handed to them on a plate, but even if some of them did, so what? There are so many bitter, jealous people on here who are begrudging people having what they have worked all their lives for. It's pathetic, and tragic, at the same time. (I am NOT a boomer by the way!)

Saw a tweet on Twitter earlier from a guy called Alex Groundwater, that speaks volumes. Everyone and anyone who has any chances or opportunities will take them. If someone said to you now 'you can get a £200,000 house for £40,000,' or 'a £300,000 house for £60,000,' would you think even for a second 'no I'll give it a miss, coz it it may affect future generations down the line?' Would you fuck! You would take the opportunity. Do not lie, you WOULD.

And would you give up a lovely roomy home that is in a lovely area, and that you have spent 1000s of pounds on, that is near your friends/family/workplace etc, so another family with an extra member or two can have it? LOL, NO YOU WOULD NOT. Whether you were an owner OR someone renting a social housing home.

So much ludicrous hypocrisy from (some) millennials (and a few Gen Z.) They always bang on about 'the boomers...' taking sooo much from them (allegedly!) but in reality, the vast majority of 'boomers' have never done a thing wrong.

The bitterness and jealousy is so real on here (and on other platforms.) So much nastiness aimed at a generation who did nothing wrong, just made the best of the opportunities given to them. As I said, don't tell me you wouldn't all do the same, because you bastard well WOULD! Shame on some people for the way they talk about their parents and grandparents. Disgusting. As I said, THIS (on Twitter) speaks volumes...

Alex Groundwater on Twitter: "I have yet to meet a member of my parents’ generation (boomers) who deliberately set out to ‘screw the kids’. Likewise any members of GenX. Every generation takes advantage of all available opportunities to secure their family’s future! That’s human nature 🤷🏼‍♂️" / Twitter

https://twitter.com/alexgroundwater/status/1647387058808258560

Glasshalffullorempty · 16/04/2023 14:48

What someone else might deem ‘adequate’ for a family might not be the same what I feel is necessary. Our house is big but was bought before we had our unexpected last child so we will be moving. Others could have more children in the house we are in now. Not my problem.

JenniferBooth · 16/04/2023 14:24

Here they demolished a whole row of bungalows. The only thing they needed was new bathrooms and kitchens. But no..........demolished and replaced with flats.

Londre · 16/04/2023 14:24

Nope. This is my forever home, privately owned and only DH & I live in our home which has four bedrooms (the cat also has one - does that count as “occupied”?)

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 16/04/2023 14:19

Not sure that this makes sense - don't we have a shortage of affordable 2-3 bed homes - rather than the larger properties that retired people may be 'rattling around' in? Particularly if someone has bought a large family home when houses were cheaper - if they now decide to downsize to release equity for retirement then they are competing for the smaller starter size homes .

rwalker · 16/04/2023 14:12

My mums on her own now in a big house
found on for her so we worked it out
the money it would cost here to move would fund the difference in running new downsized house and here current big house for at least 9 years
shes 84 so staying put

Crikeyalmighty · 16/04/2023 14:06

@JenniferBooth I totally agree- my son is on £36k and can't even look at shared ownership in London unless he gets a partner (hes24) whereas he could easily afford a £750 flat (he pays more than this now) - it's basically totally ruling out most single people in London and quite a few other places too by making them all shared ownership and based on ludicrously high valuations.

JenniferBooth · 16/04/2023 13:54

We need proper community housing. Like Somerford Grove which had different dwellings built for everyone at all different stages of their lives.

This problem goes further back than 1980
The 1953 White Paper stipulated the continuing of promotion by all possible means the building of houses for owner occupation.

In 1954 private housebuilders were freed from the obligation to secure building licences one of the main ways by which local authority housing had been prioritised in the immediate post war years.

The big change came with the 1954 Housing Act which required that future council efforts be concentrated on redevelopment RATHER THAN general needs.

Where we are now is the result of decades of changes going further back than 1980.

JenniferBooth · 16/04/2023 13:52

From an older thread. four years ago

The Elephant and Castle neighbourhood is being physically, socially and ethnically transformed. This started with the demolition of the Heygate estate, a classic for stigmatised perceptions of council housing and the people who live in it. As the local 35% Campaign has meticulously documented, a succession of promises to Heygate residents were broken to arrive at a situation where 1,214 council homes were demolished, to be replaced with 2,704 new homes, of which only 82 (3%) are for social rent. The HA partner was London and Quadrant. To be eligible for the cheapest one-bedroom home built by them on the Heygate site, people needed a minimum household income of £57,500. The average household income in that part of Southwark is £24,324

It is NOT the fault of social housing tenants already living in social housing that this is happening. Whats really sickening is that people KNOW developers AND housing associations are doing this but STILL want to blame social housing tenants and move them around like chess pieces. Do the fucking maths. 1,214 council homes demolished and replaced with 82 for social rent.

This is not down to social housing tenants yet they are expected to pay the price!

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 16/04/2023 13:39

user1471538283 · 16/04/2023 12:43

Again this just deflects away from the fact that home owners in the main are not the problem. I know very few that have huge houses. My DGM did but that was left over from when housing was affordable.

The problem in my city is inhabitable houses that the council has ignored for years. By doing them up we would have a healthy social housing stock.

People won't be told though. It much easier to blame someone in a bigger house than the government.

Swipe left for the next trending thread