Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jeremy Vine - people are morally obliged to downsize and free up property

668 replies

JoanThursday1972 · 14/04/2023 12:17

Currently have this on the radio. Suggestion is that people are not entitled to remain in and live in the house that they have bought and paid for. That they should downsize and free this up for more deserving occupants, ie families.

This is surely a personal choice and not an obligation? Anyone is entitled to live in a house they have bought, regardless of size.

OP posts:
ElsieMc · 14/04/2023 13:54

I am in a large 4 bed detached house in big grounds, but my grandsons live with me so rooms are all used at present. But we do want to downsize so I find the implied criticism somewhat hard to take.

Last year we had our house for sale. It was expensive but not as expensive as many similar and we did take the lower of three valuations. Viewers felt it was not modernised enough. By this they wanted different room configuration ie large kitchen diner whereas ours is a vicarage and has separate kitchen, dining room and utility. It has a large living room and also a smaller living room typical of vicarage layout. The family viewers were complaining they hated their newbuild homes, the quality was poor but wanted to replicate the same home here.

I also felt awkward that the price was outside what many younger families could afford not to mention the added expenses of a larger property. It is a house that would be great for a large family.

We did take on board complaints about modernisation and have had a new central heating system put in alongside new oil tank. Undoubtedly it will still not be enough.

I dont know what the answer is here. We looked at smaller homes but they were as expensive as ours for much less tbh.

BoomerCormorant · 14/04/2023 13:54

Perhaps Jeremy would think we should downsize our belongings as well.
One knife fork spoon plate and mug each and a chair to sit on. 2 blankets.

Howpo · 14/04/2023 13:54

Downsizing etc does not fix the rental market, which is a disaster zone.

Even if we built far more houses, the bottom line is many people cannot afford to buy, they have to rent & atm, renters can't save and are struggling with very high rents plus landlords are selling up and issuing eviction orders.

Affordable new build HA properties in Plymouth are 300k for a 3 bed, avg wage in Plymouth is 26k.

Rents are around £850 to 1.1k per month and there are hardly any houses available, 100s of section 21 's have been issued in Plymouth recently.

Govt is sitting on its hands, the solution is to build 100s of '000s of council houses, not fiddling at the edges and forcing people to downsize.

Timeforachangeisitnot · 14/04/2023 13:52

proppy · 14/04/2023 12:49

Why is the stamp duty for those downsizing (who likely have lots of equity) more prohibitive than those trying to move up the ladder?

It’s not that it is more prohibitive , it’s that is an unnecessary expense - I have a home that I am happy in, with a modest garden, near amenities.

DH and I are looking at improvements which would mean we could live on the ground floor if we were unable to use the stairs ( hopefully a long way off) vs moving.

Said improvements are less costly than stamp duty, legal fees etc. So unless a smaller home which we prefer becomes available, why would we move ?

5128gap · 14/04/2023 13:51

ifIwerenotanandroid · 14/04/2023 13:20

I take it (hope) this is sarcastic, but didn't a Labour government start making noises about forcing people with large gardens to have a house built in their garden? Thankfully there was a general election & they were voted out before it happened.

Do you mean the proposal to allow councils to compulsorily purchase land that was otherwise left vacant and derelict? Often an eyesore in the local area? I'm not aware of any proposal to build in people's actual gardens, but prepared to be corrected if you can point me to the source of the information.

BoomerCormorant · 14/04/2023 13:51

Whoever you are. Please don't 'report as offensive' the term Boomer. The classification Baby Boom is given to a definite measurable ie factual rise in birthrate directly after WW2.
I am an early boomer, Father early med discharge from Army.
I'll do my own getting indignant and having a rant Thank you very Much

Orangetapemeasure · 14/04/2023 13:51

There is no motivation for this. DM lives alone in the 4 bed detached family home with an acre garden. I would estimate that at least 1/2 if not 2/3 of the properties her village are 3+ bedrooms , 1800sq feet and occupied by retired couples or single people. DM has zero intention of moving (is mid 70s). Neighbours on both sides of us are 80+ singles living in 2000sqft + houses with big gardens. Maintenance is minimal. When the fence blew down on one side they said that all their money was tied up in the house and they couldnt afford to replace it. They could go halves- so the choice was go halves or no fence. Inside the same house they have no central heating, use an Emersion for hot water (once a week shower) and haven’t done anything for at least 30 years. They’ll sell it to some poor sucker for £700k who will need to take it back to the bricks. I think they bought it for £20k. She has mentioned downsizing but wants to downsize ‘to a detached cottage with a large garden’. I want to scream ‘No. you are 85. You need to downsize to a bungalow with a patio’. What do these people think???
you’ll only get them out by taxing them out. Ie a bedroom tax for private properties.

IcedBananas · 14/04/2023 13:51

He’s not saying you don’t have the right to the property though is he? He’s saying morally can you justify staying in a big house on your own if there’s a huge shortage of family sized homes. We have families locally desperate for homes and ultimately having to move kids out of schools and relocate while retired people own the majority of the 3 or 4 bed homes. If you look at the big picture it’s hard to disagree that something has gone wrong somewhere. The question is how do we fix it?

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 14/04/2023 13:50

GreenwichOrTwicks · 14/04/2023 13:14

The problem is that this country houses are considered investments but don’t attract the tax of other investments so totally skewing the landscape.
Ridiculous to have one person living in a 4 bedroom house.
We should be taxing this type of situation much more heavily so that it incentivises people to move to an appropriate dwelling.

Primary properties only - The money is taxed as you earn it. You pay stamp duty (tax) and other legal fees when you buy your home, if it is over a certain level. You pay council tax for the privilege of living in your home. By the time you have finished paying for your house you have paid x time the amount of the original mortgage. How is that not enough tax? After 25-30 years of paying a mortgage people should be taxed out of their homes or forced to give them up for someone more 'deserving'?

pigsDOfly · 14/04/2023 13:48

proppy · 14/04/2023 13:37

I had no idea boomer was considered offensive! What should that generation be called?

The use of the term 'baby boomers' in itself is not offensive, it's the ageist, offensive way in which 'boomer' has been used in this thread.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 14/04/2023 13:47

MrsMcisaCt · 14/04/2023 13:46

Jeremy is just hosting a debate on this topic, it's not his personal view. The title of this thread makes it sound like its his view, but it was just a debate on his programme.

Fair enough - didn't hear the programme as I was working.

MrsMcisaCt · 14/04/2023 13:46

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 14/04/2023 13:32

So offer incentives, then, Jeremy - e.g. reduced stamp duty for downsizers. Often it's not the idea of living in a smaller house that is offputting, but the hassle and upheaval of moving - you need to incentivise it.

Jeremy is just hosting a debate on this topic, it's not his personal view. The title of this thread makes it sound like its his view, but it was just a debate on his programme.

caringcarer · 14/04/2023 13:46

Tell this to DH. He stubbornly refuses to let us downsize. My son will move out into his own house at the end of this month. Then there will be just DH, me and Foster son rattling around in a 6 bedroom house with 4 bathrooms. I want to downsize to 3 bedrooms, still leaving us a guest room but he absolutely refuses. I know we are going to have a falling out about it.

Crikeyalmighty · 14/04/2023 13:45

Problem is a lack of suitable things to downsize too in areas that retired people actually would choose to live- my FIL would like to move from his detached 3 bed chalet bungalow in the south east to a 2 bed detached one level one nearer to us in Bath- there are very very few and the odd ones there are are often in poor Nick and overpriced for what they are- he doesn't want a flat due to the 'leasehold aspect- he has a big issue with this given that the Uk seems like the Wild West in being able to charge vast amounts out the blue for repairs and there are few suitable share of freehold flats and he doesn't want a retirement flat due to worrying about them being hard to sell and huge service charges- personally I think he should rent a good modern flat but older people in the UK just don't tend to have that 'apartment' mindset

Goldbar · 14/04/2023 13:45

Well, it's not helpful if you have 2 people rumbling around in a 4/5 bed house and families of 6 stuck in 2 bedroom flats.

That said, it's hardly a moral issue.

Doesn't the problem usually resolve itself eventually anyway? Either people die and their houses are sold as part of their estate, or they need care and the houses are sold to cover the costs?

And adult children are often at home for a period nowadays anyway so under-occupation isn't such an issue.

So you're really only talking about the period of early old age between adult children becoming totally independent and needing to downsize for health reasons/ the house being sold to meet care needs.

Finalstar · 14/04/2023 13:44

I lived in a flat before moving to my current home - never again. I don't want to deal with a leasehold managing agency (and their costs), neighbour noise and no private outside space.

I would happily downsize to a bungalow when the time comes, but there are so few available with decent space - and what is available tends to be very expensive.

Sarvanga38 · 14/04/2023 13:43

Just about every bungalow in this area has been/is being knocked down and being replaced with multiple houses, so there certainly won't be many of those available.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 14/04/2023 13:42

I don’t agree with this but I do think holiday homes are extremely selfish. They are a waste of housing and ruin communities.

Sarvanga38 · 14/04/2023 13:42

There are two of us in a large four bedroom house, never had children. I reckon by the time my husband hits 70, the large garden will be becoming a stretch to cope with and I have it in mind that we would look to move then, not necessarily being set on any particular area.

Certainly in this area (South East) I would echo previous posters who have said that there is nothing smaller and appealing that would actually cost much less - and many would cost more - which seems bizarre but is true.

I don't think that anyone should be forced or morally obligated to downsize, but I do think that it would be personally advantageous to many older people living in overly large houses to down-size, while they are still young enough to integrate in to a new community and before it is too traumatic to do so. This just isn't going to happen without the right properties available, though.

Removal of stamp duty for down-sizers is certainly a good thought to incentivise, although fully agree that with most down-sizers moving from mortgage-free properties, it is a mental block rather than a financial one.

Spendonsend · 14/04/2023 13:41

Flats tend to be spacious, but the fear of flats is noise from neighbours after you are used to detached, worries about any maintenance costs rising, worries about the lack of lift or lift breaking, wanting some private outdoor space to sit and bbq, lack of storage if you have bikes, camping equipment etc.

Its why the idea of a bungalow is popular but they arent cheaper.

Terraces solve outdoor space, but are often smaller than flats and still have stairs and noise.

I cant see why people would downsize unless they needed to financially.

diflasu · 14/04/2023 13:41

Sarahconnor1 · 14/04/2023 12:25

Down sizing cost money. Stamp duty, legal fees, estate agent fees.

Often the properties to downsize to aren't suitable for older people, bungalows are few and expensive.

It's no wonder people don't want to downsize

This - both my DP and IL looked.

The "extra space" is probably used more now than every before because they are in the house so much more than when they worked.

There was a money box program on Radio 4 ages ago where they had a few callers who had downsized regretting it as when everything was paid out included unexpected work on new house they really didn't have much freed up money and had had a lot of hassle and worry.

Finalstar · 14/04/2023 13:41

Before finger-pointing at people in "under occupied" houses, these bright sparks could start instead with holiday homes, buy to let and Air BnBs....

Frabbits · 14/04/2023 13:39

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 14/04/2023 13:37

If he is proposing it, yes it is directly relevant. If he is just presenting the topic for debate and being devils advocate, then not relevant.

It's the second one. He's a talk show host, hosting debates is literally his job.

BankMum · 14/04/2023 13:39

It's an interesting question but to my mind totally misdirected. Second homes / holiday lets are surely the obvious target for a 'moral obligation' to sell up? I live in a very desirable village location with a high % of retirees and holiday homes. Of my nearest neighbours 1 is a family, 2 are holiday lets and 3 big houses with elderly inhabitants. I would 1000x rather see the holiday homes sold to families to live in rather than the older residents kicked out before they're ready and it would do more good.

Frabbits · 14/04/2023 13:39

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 14/04/2023 13:33

It's ok for Jeremy and his millions, he can afford to downsize to an exclusive retirement village with a boules green, sound proof apartments, private gardens or terraces and concierge service. Stupid idea which does nothing to address the real issue.

  1. JV is hosting a debate. It's not his personal idea.

  2. It's not necessarily a stupid idea.

There are plenty of families out there who would need to move to bigger houses but can't due to the costs of doing so and/or unavailability of suitable properties.

Likewise there are plenty of people in houses which really are too big for their needs and can't afford to heat/run/maintain them but are also unable to move due to the costs of doing so and/or unavailability of suitable properties.

So a scheme which puts these groups of people together would, on the face of it, help quite a deal.