Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jeremy Vine - people are morally obliged to downsize and free up property

668 replies

JoanThursday1972 · 14/04/2023 12:17

Currently have this on the radio. Suggestion is that people are not entitled to remain in and live in the house that they have bought and paid for. That they should downsize and free this up for more deserving occupants, ie families.

This is surely a personal choice and not an obligation? Anyone is entitled to live in a house they have bought, regardless of size.

OP posts:
JingleBellez · 14/04/2023 14:19

Aye, that's gonna fly...

diflasu · 14/04/2023 14:18

pollykitty · 14/04/2023 14:08

The real issue leading to this ‘debate’ is that the UK housing market has not kept pace with population needs, not only in terms of numbers of houses but quality and property sizes. This is 100% the fault of government who prioritize greedy developers and not social needs. Of course no one should feel morally obligated to downsize. There can be all sorts of reasons why someone wants to stay put and that’s fair enough. We actually downsized 5 years ago and are
much happier in a smaller property but it’s our choice.

I've seen a fair bit along these line on you tube recently - with idea that it has started to get noticed by editors and politicians as the effects started to go up the social economic ladder and hit their kids and GC.

It's still very hard to build new properties - lots of local opposition - but I think they've started to think about younger adults spending large amount of their income on rent and heating and now food and how that means less disposable income and how that's impacting the economy. Also more retired people who didn't mange to buy needing government help with rent increasing in numbers - it's also contributing to lowering birth rates - job shortages in some areas.

I think decades of this and the resulting impact are starting to be noticed.

ZeroPlastic · 14/04/2023 14:17

Probably already been said by one approach would be to offer downsizers the option to move without paying stamp duty.

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/04/2023 14:15

Frabbits · 14/04/2023 12:33

Putting aside the obvious economic/ social mobility problems, he's not really wrong.

If you have a family struggling in a 2 bed house who are unable to get something bigger because there is a lack of supply caused by larger houses being occupied by say elderly couples with 3 spare rooms then yes, there is an argument that the right thing to do is for the elderly couple to sell up and free up the family sized property.

As someone else has already pointed out, there is a lack of suitable smaller properties for elderly people. Bungalows are in very short supply, making the demand and price high. I live in a coastal town with a high proportion of retired people and there has been a lot of new building going on here (3 sites being developed as I write) - not a single bungalow on any of them.

As a result, most older people who can afford to 'develop' their homes to be more suitable for them in their older age, e.g. by extending, putting in downstairs bathrooms and so on.

If there is a desire for older people to 'downsize', there needs to be targets set for developers to build suitable, affordable homes for them alongside the mega houses they tend to prefer building.

Timesawastin · 14/04/2023 14:14

TheMarzipanDildo · 14/04/2023 13:12

My favourite bit was when Jeremy said “there used to be a bungalow near me. People laughed at it, but maybe bungalows are the answer?”

Has the man never left central London?! Can’t move for bungalows in N Wales.

Yes, we should all downsize to a 2 bed bungalow. Which where e I live will cost me another 20% on the price of my small family house with on street parking and a downstairs bathroom. 30% if you include stamp duty and moving costs.

Sallyh87 · 14/04/2023 14:12

I have just moved from a flat to a much bigger three bed house. I look forward to downsizing in 20 / 25 years as cleaning a whole house is a pain in the ass!

No, obviously people shouldn’t feel the need to downsize. However, I think the government should make some effort to make it more appealing to do so. Some kind of stamp duty relief, ensuring the appropriate smaller properties are built etc etc.

BellePeppa · 14/04/2023 14:12

The thing that puts me off moving is the expense and stress involved in selling and buying. The sheer enormity of dealing with the contents of a large house to move to a smaller one and all the costs involved means I’ll only move when my head can cope with all that and not to appease strangers who think I ought to move.

Porkandbeans1 · 14/04/2023 14:12

CAJIE · 14/04/2023 14:05

Lot of ageism here.A kind of suggesting that one should quietly fade away.Also many younger boomers don't own.Try getting millenials not to.constantly blame rathet than seeing the bigger picture.Ok blamers.Also some ageist ads encouraging older people tp release equity.Patronising and infantalising.
Do people have a god given right to family houses and capitalist family consunption when the world is as it is? Imho families are the basis of extreme selfishness.Years ago my dad tried to sell the family house to a charitable organisation which catered for .homeless people with depression and alcoholism.The nimbys went mad and the cruel judgemental comments really struck me as a young person.Yes there were security issues which needed addressing but the society were v vigilant.Dad backed down.

No one is obliged to move.

Your post is also incredibly ageist. The oldest millennials are 42, I'm in that group, had my child young and they are now off at uni. I'm not blaming anyone for anything. I own property and have done well in life.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 14/04/2023 14:12

Jonei · 14/04/2023 13:58

Yes.

Why?

Thelnebriati · 14/04/2023 14:10

I don't think people are morally obliged to downsize and free up property.
I do think help should be available for people who want to but face difficulties.
I also think that supplying adequate social housing should be a priority.

RedToothBrush · 14/04/2023 14:10

pollykitty · 14/04/2023 14:08

The real issue leading to this ‘debate’ is that the UK housing market has not kept pace with population needs, not only in terms of numbers of houses but quality and property sizes. This is 100% the fault of government who prioritize greedy developers and not social needs. Of course no one should feel morally obligated to downsize. There can be all sorts of reasons why someone wants to stay put and that’s fair enough. We actually downsized 5 years ago and are
much happier in a smaller property but it’s our choice.

This.

Builders kept building executive homes no one can afford.

They did first time buyer properties under duress.

What was neglected was the smaller family home across the board. This is where all the pressure in the system is.

Inyournightgarden · 14/04/2023 14:10

icanneverthinkofnc · 14/04/2023 12:32

Council tenants do pay rent, you know. Just not to pay landlords mortgages. The problem is the lack of them.
Incidentally, we did downsize because it was beneficial for us.
The problems faced by young people finding and paying for housing also mean tenants' offspring end up boomeranging in the same way others do.

They pay rent but stupidly low, have absolute security and have houses updated and maintained at zero cost to them on a regular basis, I know lots of people in council houses who could easily buy or rent privately but refuse to because they have it so easy

Timesawastin · 14/04/2023 14:09

Frabbits · 14/04/2023 12:33

Putting aside the obvious economic/ social mobility problems, he's not really wrong.

If you have a family struggling in a 2 bed house who are unable to get something bigger because there is a lack of supply caused by larger houses being occupied by say elderly couples with 3 spare rooms then yes, there is an argument that the right thing to do is for the elderly couple to sell up and free up the family sized property.

For the price of a much smaller property I assume you mean? Then they can move into a little flat for cash and everyone can attack them for pushing up the prices of starter homes.

pollykitty · 14/04/2023 14:08

The real issue leading to this ‘debate’ is that the UK housing market has not kept pace with population needs, not only in terms of numbers of houses but quality and property sizes. This is 100% the fault of government who prioritize greedy developers and not social needs. Of course no one should feel morally obligated to downsize. There can be all sorts of reasons why someone wants to stay put and that’s fair enough. We actually downsized 5 years ago and are
much happier in a smaller property but it’s our choice.

RedToothBrush · 14/04/2023 14:07

How does 'moral obligation' translate into 'who foots the removal and renovation bills' for council housing?

RedToothBrush · 14/04/2023 14:05

How does that work in the private sector?

Annie and Fred live in a 5 bed detatched in the Home Counties. Its worth £900k.

Sidney and Gertie have 2 kids. They live in a 2 bed and can't afford to buy a £900k house.

If Annie and Fred decide to downsize to a 2 bed, they are putting MORE pressure on demand for 2 beds. This makes it harder for Mabel and John who have just had a baby to move from their 1 bed.

The LA will not allow planning for the 5 bed detached to be split into smaller properties citing too much pressure on the road network and setting a precident for nearby properties. Local Nimbys support this action.

Local Nimbys also do not wish to allow the building of a council estate on brown fields site next door. Again citing too much additional traffic.

CAJIE · 14/04/2023 14:05

Lot of ageism here.A kind of suggesting that one should quietly fade away.Also many younger boomers don't own.Try getting millenials not to.constantly blame rathet than seeing the bigger picture.Ok blamers.Also some ageist ads encouraging older people tp release equity.Patronising and infantalising.
Do people have a god given right to family houses and capitalist family consunption when the world is as it is? Imho families are the basis of extreme selfishness.Years ago my dad tried to sell the family house to a charitable organisation which catered for .homeless people with depression and alcoholism.The nimbys went mad and the cruel judgemental comments really struck me as a young person.Yes there were security issues which needed addressing but the society were v vigilant.Dad backed down.

No one is obliged to move.

neilyoungismyhero · 14/04/2023 14:04

ComtesseDeSpair · 14/04/2023 13:02

Yes, part of the problem is that too many British people think of apartment living as second rate and only what you do if you can’t afford a house. Because of this, and because land is expensive in the UK, developers build mostly houses, and because of land scarcity this results in undersized, boxy homes with often almost completely uselessly sized gardens and no storage space - not much good for young families.

We could build solid, spacious, soundprooofed, generously proportioned apartment blocks - for people of all ages and family sizes - with communal garden and play areas, laundries, gyms, work spaces and other services, as is more the norm and popular in many other cities around the world. It would be a much more effective use of land and home footprints could be much bigger - suiting families but with facilities also suiting people at all life stages.

A relative lived in a 1 bed flat. It was lovely, spacious kitchen nice bedroom, decent bathroom. To get to it on the 6th floor there were 2 options...a lift where people had pissed/vomited and beat the shit out of the panels or a staircase covered in piss and vomit. Either option stunk to high heaven and the access route to the flats was covered in detritus you had to pick your way over. Completely vile and awful. I certainly wouldn't want to live in a place like that. Some people seem to have no pride in their surroundings.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 14/04/2023 14:03

I agree with comtesse on page 1 - this all needs to be part of a larger conversation about aging well, amenities needed, suitability of housing, and there needs to be some acknowledgement that often when people want to "do the right thing" and move to somewhere smaller and more manageable it's nowhere to be had / the stamp duty and relative cost is too high. There's enough scope for government meddling there, but no appetite it seems.

KittyAlfred · 14/04/2023 14:03

Broadbeachshallow · 14/04/2023 12:46

Where doe JV live?

You realise he chairs a discussion programme? He’s not putting forward his own beliefs.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 14/04/2023 14:02

My mum sold her family home to move closer to us a couple of years ago. She'd lived there a few years after my dad died but realised she was struggling with the garden. Despite a massive enclosed garden and 4 big bedrooms, it was bought by a single woman in her 50s. Should she have been barred from buying it?

Also she really struggled to find something near us because of air bnbs. She ended up in a massive bungalow that footprintwise was very similar to the house she left.

Jl2014 · 14/04/2023 14:01

Perhaps those with 2nd homes should be encouraged to free those up for families before expecting people to sell up their main home.

Jonei · 14/04/2023 13:58

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 14/04/2023 13:50

Primary properties only - The money is taxed as you earn it. You pay stamp duty (tax) and other legal fees when you buy your home, if it is over a certain level. You pay council tax for the privilege of living in your home. By the time you have finished paying for your house you have paid x time the amount of the original mortgage. How is that not enough tax? After 25-30 years of paying a mortgage people should be taxed out of their homes or forced to give them up for someone more 'deserving'?

Yes.

latetothefisting · 14/04/2023 13:56

There aren't many 1 bed houses though so should single people have to live in flats regardless of whether they'd prefer or afford houses?

Also why is it always bedrooms that are the issue- nobody complains or is taxed if a house has too many bathrooms or a conservatory or utility or whatever but these are still rooms in excess of what is needed for bare minimum housing!

We technically have more bedrooms than people but I wfh full time so the extra room is an office which is pretty much needed - why should I downsize into a smaller house and have to lose space in the kitchen or wherever I need to set up 3 screens with a lack of privacy (against all guidance which stresses the importance of a permanent set up that you can close the door on if at all possible) when I can afford a spare room?

TeaAndTwoTa · 14/04/2023 13:56

Jokers! Maybe start with the 30 bedroom plus houses or estates first? Bet JRM has a few spare bedrooms - sure he’d be happy to lead the way and downsize 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread